Comments on the paper “Eliminating beam-induced depolarizing effects in the hydrogen jet target for high-precision proton beam polarimetry at the Electron-Ion Collider Rathmann et al. 2026 ”

A. A. Poblaguev · 2026

Read Comments on the paper “Eliminating beam-induced depolarizing effects in the hydrogen jet target for high-precision proton beam polarimetry at the Electron-Ion Collider Rathmann et al. 2026 ” by A. A. Poblaguev (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30672.txt.

Introduction

A Comment by A. A. Poblaguev reviews a 2026 analysis by Rathmann and colleagues. Rathmann's team studied beam-induced depolarisation at the Electron-Ion Collider. The collider measures beam polarisation with a polarised hydrogen jet, long used at RHIC. Rathmann's team claimed the jet would lose polarisation at the new collider under the older facility's holding field.

Poblaguev argues that several key assumptions behind that claim are wrong or flawed. He questions a photon emission threshold. He also questions Fermi's Golden Rule for coherent hyperfine transitions, the reading of power broadening as a real linewidth increase, and the handling of spatial magnetic fields. A consistent treatment using the Schrödinger equation, he shows, makes the chances of beam-induced depolarisation tiny. The predicted large effects, he concludes, are artifacts of the method, not physics.

Catalog record

CREATORA. A. Poblaguev
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30672

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comments on the paper “Eliminating beam-induced depolarizing effects in the hydrogen jet target for high-precision proton beam polarimetry at the Electron-Ion Collider Rathmann et al. 2026 ” A. A. Poblaguev Abstract A critical review of the methodology used in F. Rathmann et al. , Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 29, 021001 (2026), to evaluate beam-induced depolarization of the Atomic Polarized Hydrogen Gas Jet (HJET) target at the Electron–Ion Collider (EIC) is presented. It is shown that several key assumptions underlying that analysis—including the introduction of a photon emission threshold, the application of Fermi’s Golden Rule to coherent hyperfine transitions, the interpretation of power broadening as a physical linewidth increase, and the treatment of spatial magnetic fields—are either incorrect or internally inconsistent. As a consequence, the predicted large depolarization effects are demonstrated to be artifacts of the adopted methodology rather than genuine physical phenomena. A consistent quantum-mechanical treatment based on the time-dependent Schrödinger equation shows that beam-induced depolarization probabilities at the EIC are negligibly small. For more than two decades, the Atomic Polarized Hydrogen Gas Jet Target (HJET) Zelenski et al. 2005 ; Poblaguev et al. 2020 has been successfully used in the RHIC Spin Program for absolute calibration of the proton beam polarization. However, operation of the HJET at the Electron–Ion Collider (EIC) requires additional consideration owing to the significantly more stringent requirements on systematic uncertainties in beam polarization measurements, as well as the approximately threefold increase in the average beam current and the nearly order-of-magnitude reduction in both bunch spacing and bunch length. An evaluation of possible beam-induced depolarization Ackerstaff et al. 1999 of the jet target at the EIC was initiated in Ref. Rathmann et al. 2026 , where it was claimed that the jet target would be unavoidably depolarized at the EIC if operated at the 120 mT holding field used at RHIC. In the present Comment, we argue that this conclusion is not supported by a consistent quantum-mechanical analysis. Beam-induced depolarization may arise from the time-dependent magnetic field generated by the bunched proton beam. Assuming a Gaussian longitudinal bunch density, the temporal dependence of the induced magnetic field at a radius r from the beam axis can be approximated as B_{\text{ind}}(r,t)=B_{\text{pk}}(r)\sum_{k=-\infty}^{\infty}\exp\!\left[-\frac{(t-k\tau_{b})^{2}}{2\sigma_{t}^{2}}\right], (1) where for the EIC flattop \sigma_{t}=0.2\,\text{ns} , \tau_{b}=10.027\,\text{ns} , and the peak value of the bunch-induced field B_{\text{pk}}(r) reaches its maximum B_{m}=3.03\,\text{mT} at r_{m}=1.04\,\text{mm} Rathmann et al. 2026 . Since B_{\text{ind}} is periodic in time, it can be expanded into harmonic components: \displaystyle B_{\text{ind}}(r,t) \displaystyle=\frac{\sqrt{2\pi}\sigma_{t}}{\tau_{b}}B_{m}F_{B}(r) \displaystyle\times\left[1+\sum_{\eta=1}^{\infty}2\,e^{-(\omega_{\eta}\sigma_{t})^{2}/2}\cos(\omega_{\eta}t)\right], (2) where \omega_{\eta}=2\pi\eta f_{b} , f_{b}=\tau_{b}^{-1}=90.683\,\text{MHz} , and the radial dependence F_{B}(r)=F(r)/F(r_{m})\leq 1 is expressed in terms of F(r) defined in Eq. (45) of Rathmann et al. 2026 . The normalization factor \sqrt{2\pi}\sigma_{t}/\tau_{b} ensures that the zeroth harmonic equals the time-averaged value of B_{\text{ind}}(r,t) . The equivalence of the two representations of B_{\text{ind}}(r,t) , ( 1 ) and ( 2 ), can be readily verified by direct numerical calculation. The amplitude of the \eta -th harmonic is therefore B_{1}^{(\eta)}(r)=B_{m}F_{B}(r)e^{-2\pi^{2}\eta^{2}\sigma_{t}^{2}f_{b}^{2}}\leq 0.136\,\text{mT}. (3) Since all harmonics are coherent for t=0 , B_{1}^{(0)}(r)+\sum_{\eta=1}^{\infty}{2B_{1}^{(\eta)}(r)}=B_{m}F_{B}(r)\leq B_{m}. (4) It is well known (see, e.g., Ref. Rathmann et al. 2026 ) that, in a static holding field {\boldsymbol{B}}_{\text{hold}} , the ground state of the hydrogen atom is described by a four-level hyperfine system with eigenstates |i\rangle and eigenvalues E_{i} of the time-independent Hamiltonian H_{0}(B_{\text{hold}}) . In the presence of a time-dependent perturbation H_{1}(t) , the atomic wave function may be written Landau and Lifshitz 1977 as \Psi(t)=\sum_{k}a_{k}(t)\,|k\rangle e^{-iE_{k}t/\hbar}, (5) and the Schrödinger equation leads to i\hbar\frac{da_{k}(t)}{dt}=\sum_{n}{\cal M}_{kn}(t)\,a_{n}(t)\,e^{i\omega_{kn}t}, (6) where {\cal M}_{kn}(t)=\langle k|H_{1}(t)|n\rangle and \omega_{kn}=(E_{k}-E_{n})/\hbar . For a single harmonic \omega=2\pi\eta f_{b} from Eq. ( 2 ), {\cal M}_{kn}(t)=\hbar\omega_{R}^{(kn)}\cos(\omega t),\quad\omega_{R}^{(kn)}=-2\mu_{e}B_{1}^{(\eta)}S_{kn}, (7) where \mu_{e}=-14.012\,\text{MHz/mT} is the electron magnetic moment. The values of the spin-dependent factors S_{kn} in {\cal M}_{kn}(t) Beijers 2005 ; Poblaguev 2026 depend on whether the oscillating field is parallel ( \sigma ) or perpendicular ( \pi ) to {\boldsymbol{B}}_{\text{hold}} , and on the mixing angle \theta , defined by \tan(2\theta)=B_{c}/B_{\text{hold}} , where B_{c}=50.7\,\text{mT} Rathmann et al. 2026 , S_{kn}^{\pi}=\begin{pmatrix}0&\sin\theta&0&\cos\theta\\ \sin\theta&0&\cos\theta&0\\ 0&\cos\theta&0&-\sin\theta\\ \cos\theta&0&-\sin\theta&0\end{pmatrix}, (8) S_{kn}^{\sigma}=\begin{pmatrix}1&0&0&0\\ 0&\cos{2\theta}&0&-\sin{2\theta}\\ 0&0&-1&0\\ 0&-\sin{2\theta}&0&-\cos{2\theta}\end{pmatrix}. (9) The physical role of the diagonal terms in S_{ij}^{\sigma} is transparent. For a stationary state |i\rangle , the wave function evolves as \exp(-iE_{i}t/\hbar) . The longitudinal component of the beam-induced magnetic field modifies the energy E_{i} and thus alters the phase evolution. At the matrix-element level, this effect is encoded in the diagonal elements of S_{ij}^{\sigma} , which represent field-induced shifts of the stationary state energies. To analyze the behavior of the system in the vicinity of a resonant transition, consider a two-level subsystem \{ij\} initially prepared in state |i\rangle , with a_{i}(0)=1 and a_{j}(0)=0 . For small detuning, |\Delta\omega|=|\omega-\omega_{ij}|\ll|\omega_{ij}| , and for short interaction times t\ll|\Delta\omega|^{-1} (but still much larger than |2\omega_{ij}|^{-1} ), one finds a_{j}(t)=-i\frac{\omega_{R}}{2}\int_{0}^{t}dt^{\prime}\left(e^{-i\Delta\omega t^{\prime}}+e^{-i2\omega_{ij}t^{\prime}}\right)\approx-i\frac{\omega_{R}t}{2}. (10) For longer interaction times, both transitions |i\rangle\leftrightarrow|j\rangle must be treated consistently, which leads to the well-known result Rabi 1937 a_{j}(t)=-i\,\frac{\omega_{R}}{\Omega}\sin\!\left(\frac{\Omega t}{2}\right),\qquad\Omega=\sqrt{\omega_{R}^{2}+\Delta\omega^{2}}. (11) This expression is fully consistent with Eq. ( 10 ) in the limit of short times t\ll 1/\Omega . The corresponding transition probability is \Pi_{ij}=|a_{j}(t)|^{2}=\frac{\omega_{R}^{2}}{\Omega^{2}}\sin^{2}\!\left(\frac{\Omega t}{2}\right), (12) which, for nonzero detuning, may appear as an effective broadening of the transition line. However, this effect arises purely from coherent interference and does not correspond to any physical smearing or modification of the atomic energy levels themselves. For specified matrix elements and initial conditions a_{n}(0) , Eq. ( 6 ) can be solved exactly, for example, by numerical integration. In Ref. Poblaguev 2026 it was shown that, for EIC flattop operation and the potentially resonant transitions \{ij\}=\{13\},\,\{14\},\,\{23\},\,\{24\} , \langle\omega_{R}^{\{ij\}}(t)\rangle\tau_{\text{int}}/2\ll 1 (see Eq. ( 10 )) due to the exponential suppression ( 3 ) of B_{1}^{(\eta)} at high harmonic numbers and the small total resonant interaction time \tau_{\text{int}} . Consequently, the corresponding matrix elements can be neglected, {\cal M}_{ij}\to 0 , on the right-hand side of Eq. ( 6 ), and the four-level system reduces to two independent subsystems, \{12\} and \{34\} , which considerably simplifies the integration. Including the time dependence of \omega_{R}(t) and the detuning \Delta\omega(t) along the atomic trajectory, it was found that the beam-induced depolarization at the EIC flattop is negligible, \lesssim 10^{-4} . The methodology used in Ref. Rathmann et al. 2026 does not account for the dynamical evolution described by Eq. ( 6 ). Instead, an atom-track-averaged Rabi frequency f_{R}=\omega_{R}/2\pi was employed. Although Eq. ( 2 ) can be obtained by inverse Fourier transformation directly from Eq. (19) of Ref. Rathmann et al. 2026 , it was not explicitly used in that analysis. Moreover, the oscillation amplitudes (and hence the Rabi frequencies) were incorrectly evaluated there. For example, using Eq. (37) of Ref. Rathmann et al. 2026 and L_{\text{int}}=30.6\,\text{mm} , one can readily evaluate the track-averaged oscillation amplitude as \langle B_{1}^{(\eta)}\rangle\approx 0.18\,B_{1}^{(\eta)}\leq 25\,\mu\text{T}. (13) However, Fig. 16 of Ref. Rathmann et al. 2026 shows \langle B_{1}^{(0)}\rangle\approx 1500\,\mu\text{T} . Furthermore, if the reported 6th harmonic amplitude of 1174\,\mu\text{T} were correct, the sum of only the first seven harmonics, according to Eq. ( 4 ), would exceed 15.3\,\text{mT} , already far larger than the peak field of 3.03\,\text{mT} . Thus, the Rabi frequency was overestimated by approximately a factor of 60, and the depolarization probability by roughly a factor of 3600 when approximation ( 10

Read the complete text