Testing the prevalence of hydrogen-silicate miscibility in young sub-Neptunes

James G. Rogers, Hilke E. Schlichting · 2026

Read Testing the prevalence of hydrogen-silicate miscibility in young sub-Neptunes by James G. Rogers, Hilke E. Schlichting (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30644.txt.

Introduction

James Rogers and Hilke Schlichting ask whether young sub-Neptune planets mix hydrogen into their rocky interiors. Sub-Neptunes are planets larger than Earth but smaller than Neptune. If hydrogen and silicate rock are miscible, meaning they blend into one fluid, a planet can hide most of its hydrogen inside, safe from being blown away by its star. That storage would change how the planet cools and shrinks.

The pair model miscibility together with stellar-driven atmospheric escape. For roughly the first hundred million years, planets keep most hydrogen in their interiors. As escape strips the envelope, fresh hydrogen seeps out of the interior, refilling it and slowing contraction. Their models still match young planet observations from the TESS telescope. They also design a population test using slower contraction, and estimate that seventy to one hundred observed young sub-Neptunes would settle how common mixing is.

Catalog record

CREATORJames G. Rogers, Hilke E. Schlichting
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30644

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Testing the prevalence of hydrogen-silicate miscibility in young sub-Neptunes James G. Rogers, Hilke E. Schlichting Abstract Hydrogen-silicate miscibility can significantly alter the interior structure and thermal evolution of sub-Neptunes. We consider the interplay between this miscibility and stellar-driven atmospheric escape. We find that, for the first ∼ 100 \sim 100 Myrs, sub-Neptunes store most of their hydrogen content within their miscible interiors, protecting it from escape. As hydrogen is removed from the top of the atmosphere, more hydrogen is exsolved from the miscible interior, resupplying the envelope mass and delaying the planet’s contraction when compared with models that do not account for miscibility. Regardless of miscibility, atmospheric escape reproduces the young planet observations from TESS , and we highlight the emergence of the primordial Neptune desert at short orbital periods. We construct a population-level test for the prevalence of miscible sub-Neptunes which exploits their slower radial contraction. We find that ∼ 70 − 100 \sim 70-100 observed young sub-Neptunes with ages ≲ 100 \lesssim 100 Myrs are required to answer this question. I Introduction Observations of young exoplanets are extremely valuable for our understanding of planet formation. Planets can retain the imprints of their formation history during the first \sim 10-100 Myr of life, before being sculpted by complex evolutionary processes that mask these signatures over the following \sim Gyr of evolution where typical observations occur. The value in amassing young planet observations is particularly important for the population of low mass ( \lesssim 20M_{\oplus} ), close-in exoplanets (periods \lesssim 100 days) referred to as super-Earths and sub-Neptunes. Such planets are thought to be the most common class of planet in our galaxy ( 5 ; 17 ; 51 , e.g.) . After \sim 1-10 Gyr of evolution, super-Earths and sub-Neptunes are observed to form a bimodal size distribution, often referred to as the radius valley, with peaks at \sim 1.5R_{\oplus} and \sim 2.4R_{\oplus} , respectively ( 18 ; 64 ; 4 ; 52 ; 26 , e.g.) . It is widely believed that the radius valley is a product of atmospheric escape, with the proximity of some planets to their host stars leading to hydrodynamic outflows of their hydrogen-dominated atmospheres. This mass loss is capable of stripping some young sub-Neptunes of their primordial envelope to form the population of super-Earths ( 48 ; 34 ; 21 ; 23 , e.g.) . This theory is supported by observations of escaping hydrogen/helium exospheres from sub-Neptunes ( 12 ; 35 , e.g.) as well as bulk density measurements which show super-Earths to be consistent with bare, rocky planets and sub-Neptunes to be consistent with hosting hydrogen-dominated envelopes ( 67 ; 28 , e.g.) . Planet evolution, particularly in the absence of atmospheric escape, is convergent: different initial conditions can evolve to the same state after billions of years. A planet with an initially higher entropy cools and contracts more rapidly, meaning it reaches the same thermodynamic state as a planet that started with lower entropy. This fact makes inferring the initial properties of mature planets challenging. However, young planets allow these degeneracies to be broken. Several observational studies have shown that young super-Earths or sub-Neptunes with ages \lesssim 100 Myrs are larger than their evolved counterparts, in some cases similar to the size of gas giants ( \sim 10R_{\oplus} ) although with substantially lower masses ( 15 ; 8 ; 63 ; 1 ; 62 ; 9 ; 33 , e.g.) . Since these planets are still hot from formation, one can infer their initial entropy ( 50 ) or their envelope mean molecular weight ( 58 ) . In this study, we utilise young transiting exoplanets to test the prevalence of hydrogen-silicate miscibility in sub-Neptunes. Recent studies have shown that hydrogen and silicate melt can become miscible at the thermodynamic temperatures ( \gtrsim 4000 K) and pressures ( \sim GPa) relevant to the interiors of sub-Neptunes, ( 70 ; 19 , e.g.) . This implies that hydrogen and silicate combine to form a homogeneous super-critical miscible interior that exsolves (releases) hydrogen into the planet’s immiscible envelope over time ( 57 ) . This is contrary to previous frameworks which have assumed discrete planetary layers with or without gas dissolution in a magma ocean. 57 showed that miscibility affects the thermal evolution of sub-Neptunes, with significant implications for young planets. Here, we couple an evolving interior structure framework for miscible sub-Neptunes with atmospheric escape models to predict how and where to find such planets in the young planet population. II Method We simulate sub-Neptune evolution with an interior structure model based on that of 57 . We provide a brief summary here, in addition to details on model upgrades, but point the interested reader to this latter study for more information. II.1 Interior structure model The interior structure framework of 57 assumes spherically-symmetric 1 -D planetary models in hydrostatic and thermochemical equilibrium. It solves the following equations for radial, pressure and temperature structure: \frac{\partial r}{\partial m}=\frac{1}{4\pi r^{2}\rho}, (1) \frac{\partial P}{\partial m}=-\frac{Gm}{4\pi r^{4}}, (2) \frac{\partial T}{\partial m}=-\frac{Gm}{4\pi r^{4}}\frac{T}{P}\nabla, (3) where m is the mass contained within radius r , \rho is the density, P is the pressure, T is the temperature, G is the gravitational constant and \nabla\equiv\partial\ln T/\partial\ln P is the temperature gradient and depends on the material properties. In practice, these equations are solved using an adaptive step RK45 shooting method with an outer boundary condition such that P(m=M_{\text{p}})=0.1 bar and T(m=M_{\text{p}})=T_{\text{eq}} , where M_{\text{p}} is the planet mass and T_{\text{eq}} is the planet equilibrium temperature (assuming zero Bond albedo), which are both free parameters of the model. To account for hydrogen-silicate miscibility, the model utilises the binodal surface derived from the H 2 -MgSiO 3 density functional theory (DFT) molecular dynamics simulations from 19 . In regions of the planet with temperatures and pressures greater than the binodal surface, hydrogen and silicate melt are miscible and combine to form a supercritical fluid. At temperatures and pressures below the binodal surface, hydrogen and silicate melt exist in two distinct phases: gas, such as H 2 , SiO, etc., and melt, such as MgSiO 3 melt with dissolved H 2 . To account for the mixing of hydrogen and silicate in the miscible interior, we follow the best-fit to DFT results from 70 , in which the density of the uncompressed H 2 -MgSiO 3 mixture is given by: \rho_{\text{mix},0}=(x_{\text{H}_{2}}\mu_{\text{H}_{2}}+x_{\text{sil}}\mu_{\text{sil}})\,\bigg(x_{\text{H}_{2}}\frac{\rho_{\text{H}_{2},0}}{\mu_{\text{H}_{2}}}+x_{\text{sil}}\frac{\rho_{\text{sil},0}}{\mu_{\text{sil}}}\bigg), (4) where \rho_{\text{H}_{2},0} and \rho_{\text{sil},0} are the uncompressed densities of pure hydrogen and silicate. Unlike in 57 , we use the 68 Vinet fit to the updated 37 equation of state for MgSiO 3 melt. For hydrogen, we again use the equation of state from 7 . These equation of state tables are also used to compute adiabatic temperature gradients, which are used in Equation 3 in convective regions of the planet. We assume the entire miscible interior is convective, facilitating a constant hydrogen concentration throughout the interior (although this concentration can vary with time). In the immiscible envelope, heat can be transported via convection, conduction and radiative diffusion. We use the moist adiabat from 22 (their Equation 1) to account for condensible silicate gas species and rain-out (which we assume is instantaneous). Additionally, we account for convection inhibition due to mean

Read the complete text