"Why Put in This Much Effort?": How AI Availability Shapes Students’ Motivation in Introductory Programming Conference: Proceedings of the ACM Conference on International Computing Education Research Vol.1; August 11–14, 2026; Uppsala, Sweden Proceedings of the ACM Conference on International Computing Education Research Vol.1 (ICER 2026 Vol. 1), August 11–14, 2026, Uppsala, Sweden DOI: 10.1145/3765964.3811653 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2203-5/2026/08 CCS: Social and professional topics CS1 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI

Keith Tran, Colton Harper, Thomas Price · 2026

Read "Why Put in This Much Effort?": How AI Availability Shapes Students’ Motivation in Introductory Programming Conference: Proceedings of the ACM Conference on International Computing Education Research Vol.1; August 11–14, 2026; Uppsala, Sweden Proceedings of the ACM Conference on International Computing Education Research Vol.1 (ICER 2026 Vol. 1), August 11–14, 2026, Uppsala, Sweden DOI: 10.1145/3765964.3811653 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2203-5/2026/08 CCS: Social and professional topics CS1 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI by Keith Tran, Colton Harper, Thomas Price (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30480.txt.

Introduction

Keith Tran, Colton Harper, and Thomas Price interview programming students about what AI help does to their drive to practice. AI tools can complete introductory assignments in moments. Students then face a plain question: why struggle through them personally? Earlier work studied instructor policies and usage patterns. This study centers the students' own experience instead. Thirteen engineering majors in a MATLAB course were interviewed.

Each student had access to a course-specific AI chatbot. Situated Expectancy-Value Theory framed the analysis of their answers. Students wondered if their programming time was well spent. Some doubted the long-term usefulness of the skill itself. Satisfaction dropped when AI bypassed the productive struggle. Confidence often depended on AI being available nearby. Nearly all preferred learning through effort yet felt shortcut temptation. Some set explicit boundaries and reframed the tension successfully. Others used AI in ways conflicting with their own values.

Catalog record

CREATORKeith Tran, Colton Harper, Thomas Price
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30480

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

"Why Put in This Much Effort?": How AI Availability Shapes Students’ Motivation in Introductory Programming Conference: Proceedings of the ACM Conference on International Computing Education Research Vol.1; August 11–14, 2026; Uppsala, Sweden Proceedings of the ACM Conference on International Computing Education Research Vol.1 (ICER 2026 Vol. 1), August 11–14, 2026, Uppsala, Sweden DOI: 10.1145/3765964.3811653 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2203-5/2026/08 CCS: Social and professional topics CS1 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI Keith Tran, Colton Harper, Thomas Price Abstract . Background. When AI tools can easily complete programming assignments, students face a motivational question: why invest effort in completing them independently? While prior work has examined instructor policies and usage patterns, we focus on how students themselves experience and respond to AI availability, a perspective important for designing courses that sustain engagement with programming practice. Objectives. We investigate two research questions: (1) How do engineering students describe how AI availability shapes their motivation to put effort into programming assignments? (2) How do students navigate the tension between their expressed value for learning through effort and the constant availability of AI as an alternative to effort? Method. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 13 engineering majors in an introductory MATLAB course where students could use a course-specific AI chatbot. Using Situated Expectancy-Value Theory (SEVT) as an analytical framework, we examined how students described their expectancy, values, and costs in the context of AI availability. Findings. When AI could complete assignments quickly, students questioned whether their time on programming was well spent (cost), questioned the long-term usefulness of programming skill (utility value), reported less satisfaction when AI bypassed productive struggle (intrinsic value), and described confidence that depended on AI being available (expectancy). Nearly all students expressed a preference for learning through effort and a simultaneous temptation to take shortcuts with AI (sanctioned or otherwise). Some students managed this tension through reframing and explicit boundaries on AI use. Others used AI in ways they saw as conflicting with their own values. Implications. Our findings complicate the assumption that students need external constraints to protect their learning. Most students in our sample already valued independent effort but struggled to act on those values when AI offered a faster alternative. Students who managed the tension found motivation in the learning process itself, suggesting that course design may need to shift from valuing what students produce to supporting how they learn. † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Learning to program requires sustained effort. Students design solutions, write and test code, trace through logic to find errors, and iterate until something finally clicks. Research on the “doer effect” has established that students learn through this kind of active practice ( 35 ) , and these hands-on experiences are central to how students build genuine skill. Throughout this paper, we refer to generative AI tools that can produce working code from natural language prompts, such as ChatGPT, as AI . These tools can now solve most programming problems students encounter at the introductory level ( 53 ; 24 ; 5 ) , and when a working solution is available on demand, the value of sustained effort may feel less certain to students. Emerging evidence suggests this may create motivational challenges for students ( 5 ; 11 ) , but how AI availability shapes students’ motivation to engage with programming remains an open question. We can imagine students responding to easy access to AI tools in different ways. Some might feel discouraged, questioning why they should put effort into assignments when peers can get good grades using AI. Others may question the value of building programming skills when AI can produce working code effortlessly, a concern that extends to both current effort and future career relevance ( 22 ; 12 ) . Others might find that AI tools help them write or debug code more effectively ( 38 ; 17 ) . Still others may think very little about AI. These varied reactions ( 5 ) highlight that AI availability may shape motivation in ways that extend beyond whether students choose to use it, and may reveal existing motivations that were less apparent before a faster alternative was available. Understanding how students experience this situation matters for three reasons. First, motivation is a well-established predictor of persistence and learning in computing education ( 41 ; 20 ; 27 ) . If AI availability threatens students’ motivation to engage deeply with programming, the consequences may extend beyond any single assignment to students’ long-term learning and retention. Second, when motivation is low and AI provides an easy alternative, students may not do the work at all. Recent research suggests this is already happening. Stone ( 55 ) found that 41% of surveyed students reported using AI in ways explicitly banned, and other studies have documented students disabling pedagogical guardrails to access direct solutions ( 31 ) and shifts in academic integrity behaviors in the presence of generative AI ( 14 ) . Third, instructors need guidance navigating this landscape. Instructors currently face difficult choices about whether to ban AI entirely and risk students using it anyway, or allow it and wonder whether students are actually learning ( 36 ) . Making informed decisions requires understanding how students experience AI availability and what helps them stay engaged with the material. A growing body of research has explored the impact of generative AI on computing education ( 4 ; 48 ; 49 ; 7 ) . Much of this work has focused on what motivates students to use AI tools ( 42 ; 1 ; 50 ) , and a few studies have begun to examine the relationship between motivation and LLM use in programming ( 6 ) . However, less attention has been paid to how the constant awareness that AI can complete their work relates to students’ motivation to put effort into assignments themselves, regardless of whether they actually use these tools. We draw on Situated Expectancy-Value Theory (SEVT), which frames motivation as shaped by both individual beliefs and situation factors such as available alternatives ( 20 ) . Within SEVT, the perceived value and cost of an activity are not fixed but are constructed in the moment. This makes SEVT well suited for examining how the availability of AI, as a situational factor, may relate to how students experience the effort, value, and costs of their programming assignments. In this study, we investigated how engineering students described their motivation to put effort into their programming assignments in the context of AI availability. We focused on engineering majors specifically, as they are end-user programmers ( 34 ) for whom programming serves disciplinary engineering work rather than being the core professional skill they are training to develop. Prior work has argued that this distinction matters for motivation as non-majors form a distinct audience for introductory computing whose motivational goals should not be inferred from CS-major samples ( 26 ; 29 ) . We conducted semi-structured interviews with 13 engineering students in a required introductory MATLAB course where students could use a sanctioned, class-specific AI tool. Our analysis, guided by SEVT, examined how students described their motivation in the context of AI availability and whether their behavior aligned with their stated values around learning. We address the

Read the complete text