Bank Earnings, Credit Supply & the Macroeconomy Evidence from Canada

Santiago Camara, Sanaa Latif · 2026

Read Bank Earnings, Credit Supply & the Macroeconomy Evidence from Canada by Santiago Camara, Sanaa Latif (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30381.txt.

Introduction

Santiago Camara and Sanaa Latif trace how news about Canadian bank profits moves the whole economy. Banks' balance sheets can amplify or dampen business cycles. When bank net worth rises, credit supply expands. Borrowing spreads fall as lending gets easier. The hard part is isolating that credit-supply news. Stock prices react to many kinds of information at once.

The authors build high-frequency shocks from earnings announcement days. Six large Canadian banks anchor the identification strategy. Co-movement with corporate spreads purges contaminating information from raw surprises. The cleaned shocks are then traced through the economy. Favorable shocks lower corporate spreads, as the model predicts. Bank values and broader equity prices rise together. The Canadian dollar appreciates after such shocks. Real activity increases over the medium run. Results hold across specifications, samples, and extra outcomes.

Catalog record

CREATORSantiago Camara, Sanaa Latif
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE126 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
RIGHTSCC0
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30381

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bank Earnings, Credit Supply & the Macroeconomy Evidence from Canada Santiago Camara, Sanaa Latif Abstract This paper studies whether news about banks’ balance sheets propagates to aggregate financial conditions and macroeconomic activity. We construct high-frequency Canadian bank net-worth shocks using stock-price reactions around earnings announcements of the six large Canadian banks. Guided by a model in which higher intermediary net worth expands credit supply and lowers borrowing spreads, we use the co-movement between bank equity prices and Canadian corporate spreads to purge raw bank equity surprises from contaminating information. Favorable purged credit-supply bank net-worth shocks lower corporate spreads, raise bank valuations and broader equity prices, appreciate the Canadian dollar, and increase real activity over the medium run. The results are robust across specifications, samples, and additional outcomes, and suggest that bank earnings news is macroeconomically relevant in concentrated banking systems. Keywords: Bank net worth; credit supply shocks; financial intermediation; earnings announcements; high-frequency identification; corporate spreads; local projections; Canada. JEL Codes: E32, E44, E51, G14, G21, C32. 1 Introduction What role do banks play in aggregate fluctuations? A large theoretical literature argues that shocks to intermediary balance sheets can affect credit supply, asset prices, and real activity. When intermediaries lose net worth, their ability to expand balance sheets deteriorates, lending spreads increase, and credit to the real economy contracts. Conversely, improvements in intermediary net worth can ease borrowing conditions and stimulate activity. These mechanisms are central to theories of financial amplification and macroeconomic crises [ 6 , 5 , 19 , 7 , 12 ] . Yet empirically identifying shocks to bank net worth, and tracing their aggregate effects, remains challenging. Bank equity prices respond to many sources of information, including news about banks’ own lending capacity, expected loan demand, borrower fundamentals, aggregate macroeconomic conditions, risk premia, and monetary policy. The central empirical problem is therefore to isolate the component of changes in bank valuations that can be interpreted as credit-supply news. This paper constructs high-frequency Canadian bank net-worth shocks using stock-price reactions around the earnings announcements of the six large Canadian banks. The empirical strategy builds on the insight of 23 , who use earnings-announcement windows of large U.S. financial intermediaries to identify high-frequency financial shocks. Earnings announcements are useful for identification because they are predetermined, bank-specific events that reveal information about bank profitability, future net worth, and lending capacity. Around these events, stock-price movements provide a direct market-based measure of the news released about the intermediary. We adapt this idea to the Canadian setting and use it to study the macroeconomic consequences of bank net-worth shocks. Canada is an especially useful setting for this question. The Canadian banking sector is highly concentrated and dominated by a small number of large institutions. Earnings news about Royal Bank of Canada, Toronto-Dominion Bank, Bank of Montreal, Bank of Nova Scotia, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce, and National Bank of Canada therefore represents news about a quantitatively important part of the domestic intermediation sector. This feature distinguishes the Canadian setting from the U.S. banking system. While the U.S. financial sector is larger, intermediation is substantially more fragmented across banks, nonbanks, broker-dealers, and capital-market institutions. By contrast, large Canadian banks account for a central share of domestic financial intermediation and have been studied as a distinctive banking system relative to the United States [ 2 ] . Their scale, concentration, and resilience are also emphasized in work comparing Canadian banks to international banking systems, especially around the global financial crisis [ 24 ] . This institutional structure makes Canada a natural environment in which to ask whether news about large banks’ balance sheets has aggregate effects on borrowing conditions and macroeconomic activity. The Canadian setting is also important because Canada is a small open economy exposed to global financial and trade shocks. Recent work shows that international monetary disturbances can affect the Canadian economy through both financial conditions and trade linkages. 1 1 1 A first example is 25 and 26 , which present evidence on the international spillovers of US monetary policy in the Canadian economy. Second, [ 8 ] shows that monetary policy shocks from the European Central Bank have significant financial and trade linkages with the Canadian economy. This paper studies a complementary domestic source of variation in financial outcomes: news about Canadian banks’ balance sheets. By focusing on bank earnings announcements, we isolate shocks originating in the domestic intermediation sector and ask whether they propagate to Canadian corporate spreads, asset prices, real activity, and prices. Our empirical approach closely follows 23 , but adapts their high-frequency earnings-announcement strategy to the Canadian setting and to a more explicitly macroeconomic question. The first difference is practical. While their baseline identification uses narrow intraday windows around U.S. financial intermediaries’ earnings announcements, our implementation uses timing-adjusted daily event windows, reflecting the availability of Canadian bank equity prices and Canadian corporate spread data. For each earnings release, we use the Bloomberg earnings-release timestamp to define the relevant stock-price reaction: previous close to announcement-day open for pre-market releases, open to close for intraday releases, and announcement-day close to next-day open for post-market releases. This preserves the central logic of the high-frequency design, isolating the market reaction around predetermined earnings-news events, while adapting the event window to the Canadian data environment. The second difference is substantive. Whereas 23 focus primarily on financial-market and cross-sectional firm-level transmission, our analysis uses the identified shocks to study aggregate macroeconomic propagation in Canada. We estimate the dynamic responses of Canadian corporate spreads, bank valuations, equity prices, exchange rates, monetary policy, real activity, prices, sectoral output, and labor market outcomes. The paper begins with a simple theoretical framework that motivates this identification strategy. Financial intermediaries face costly balance-sheet expansion because external equity issuance is costly, and they compete strategically in the loan market. In this environment, an increase in intermediary net worth lowers the marginal cost of supplying loans, expands credit supply, reduces equilibrium lending spreads, and raises bank equity valuations. The model delivers a clear empirical implication: favorable news about banks’ net worth should raise bank stock prices and lower corporate borrowing spreads. This implication guides the construction of the purged credit-supply component of bank equity surprises. We construct the shocks using Bloomberg data from 2002:Q4 to 2026:Q1. We focus on earnings releases for the Canadian-listed tickers of the six large Canadian banks. We first show that earnings announcements are information events. Announcement days feature substantially larger absolute and squared stock-price movements than non-announcement days, and timing-adjusted event-window stock-price reactions are strongly positively related to Bloomberg earnings surprises. We then aggregate bank-level stock-price reactions using lagged quarterly market-capitalization shares. The use of lagged weights ensures that larger banks receive greater weight in the aggregate surprise while avoiding mechanical effects of the announcement-window price reaction. The raw weighted bank equity surprise is informative, but it is not yet a clean credit-supply shock. Positive bank earnings news may reflect an improvement in banks’ balance-sheet strength and lending capacity, but it may also reflect contaminating information about expected loan demand, borrower fundamentals, aggregate conditions, or risk premia. To purge this contamination, we use the model’s key empirical implication: favorable credit-supply news should raise bank equity valuations and lower corporate borrowing spreads. We therefore identify

Read the complete text