CO snow lines are stabilised by the vertical transport of volatiles 2015 CO snow lines are stabilised by the vertical transport of volatiles – B
Alfie Robinson, James E. Owen, Richard A. Booth · 2026
Read CO snow lines are stabilised by the vertical transport of volatiles 2015 CO snow lines are stabilised by the vertical transport of volatiles – B by Alfie Robinson, James E. Owen, Richard A. Booth (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30157.txt.
Introduction
Alfie Robinson, James Owen, and Richard Booth ask whether the carbon monoxide snow line in planet forming discs is stable. Below a threshold temperature, carbon monoxide freezes onto dust grains. The boundary between ice and vapor is called the snow line. Earlier one-dimensional models suggested the boundary might oscillate unstably. The team tests that idea with vertical structure included.
Their disc evolution code gains a new ice-vapor chemistry solver. Including vertical structure does produce two stable equilibrium solutions. The snow surface can sit in either of two steady states. Yet evolving simulations never enter the predicted limit cycle. The two-dimensional snow surface shape prevents the oscillation. Vertical transport of volatiles also stabilizes the boundary. Snow line motion from this instability should be transient and random. Steady thermal evolution still reshapes the surface over time.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alfie Robinson, James E. Owen, Richard A. Booth |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 86 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30157
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
CO snow lines are stabilised by the vertical transport of volatiles 2015 CO snow lines are stabilised by the vertical transport of volatiles – B Alfie Robinson, James E. Owen, Richard A. Booth Abstract Volatile evolution in protoplanetary discs determines the compositional evolution of forming planets. Below their sublimation temperatures, volatiles freeze out from the vapour phase onto dust grains in the disc and transition to being dynamically-coupled to the dust component as opposed to the gas. The boundary between the ice and vapour phases is referred to as the snow line, when thought of as the mid-plane radius at which the phase transition occurs, or the snow surface, when viewed as a 2D (radial and vertical) structure in the disc. We investigate whether the CO snow line (and therefore snow surface) is thermally unstable and therefore liable to changes in its location during disc evolution using the disc evolution code cuDisc , to which we have added an ice-vapour chemistry solver. We find that the instability does lead to there being two steady-state stable equilibrium solutions for the snow surface when including the vertical structure. However, in dynamically-evolving simulations, the disc does not enter a limit-cycle — as seen in previous 1D models — due to the shape of the 2D snow surface and the vertical transport of volatiles. We therefore expect that dynamically evolution of snow lines due to instability is limited to transient, stochastic events rather than oscillatory behaviour with a regular period. However, we also expect the snow surface to evolve substantially during the disc lifetime solely due to changes in the thermal structure driven by evolution of the dust spatial structure and grain-size distribution — this we will explore in future models. 1 Introduction The initial composition of young planets is set by the solid and gaseous material that they accrete whilst forming in their host protoplanetary discs. In these discs, most of the important chemical elements are found in the form of simple molecules that are volatile at the temperatures and pressures found in such environments — e.g. H 2 O, CO 2 , CO, N 2 and CH 4 , amongst others (see 41 ; 65 , for recent reviews of disc chemistry) . These molecules can therefore either be in the vapour phase or frozen-out onto the surfaces of dust grains at a certain location in the disc; the contour that marks the transition between the vapour and ice phase is referred to as the snow surface whilst the mid-plane radial location of this surface is called the snow line. The location of the snow line and the shape of the snow surface are set by the temperature structure of the disc, the binding energy of the volatile to the grain surfaces and the vapour pressure of the volatile. Understanding these features of discs is vital for explaining planet formation. As snow lines lie at different radii for each volatile, the compositions of the gas and dust components of the disc — and therefore important quantities such as the C/O ratio — are functions of disc location ( 42 ) . Also, the dynamics of the ice and vapour phase volatiles are very different, as the ice-phase volatiles are coupled to the radially-drifting dust rather than the slowly-evolving gas. Such a difference means that composition is also a function of time ( 57 ; 17 ; 13 ; 12 , see e.g.) . We also know that CO is depleted compared to the ISM abundance in many discs, primarily inferred from CO gas masses that suggest dust-to-gas ratios larger than those of the ISM ( 2 ; 39 ) . Inclusion of dust growth and dynamics alongside chemistry when modelling the CO snow line ( 27 ; 13 ; 30 ; 29 ; 12 ; 45 ; 61 , see) has indicated that these processes play a crucial role in CO depletion. More recently, JWST observations have suggested that low-mass stars ( <0.3~\mathrm{M}_{\odot} ) have high C/O ratios in the inner disc ( 58 ; 3 ; 28 ; 33 ) in contrast to seemingly oxygen-rich higher mass stars ( 49 ; 60 , see e.g.) . Insight into this differentiation requires comprehensive modelling of both chemistry and dust processes; using 1D models that combine volatile molecule chemistry with dust and gas transport, 53 ; 52 show that the C/O ratio in the inner disc regions is a time-dependent function of both chemical and dynamical timescales. To understand the spatial structure, abundance and temporal evolution of molecules in discs, we therefore evidently need models of dust evolution that are coupled to the disc chemistry. CO in particular is an important molecule to study. It has a high interstellar abundance ( 4 ) , both making it very important for outer disc chemistry and amenable to observation across multiple isotopologues (e.g. 12 CO, 13 CO, C 18 O, C 17 O; see 38 ; 2 ; 11 ; 31 ). For typical discs around solar-mass stars, the mid-plane CO snow line lies in the outer disc, at radii of >\sim 20 au ( 42 , see e.g.) . This means that it lies in a region of the disc where the temperature is governed by absorption and re-processing of stellar light by dust grains. In the aforementioned models, the disc thermal structure is not self-consistently coupled to the evolving dust and volatile distribution, and is usually held constant. As the CO snow line (and snow surface) is exponentially sensitive to the disc thermal structure, any evolution of the disc temperature due to changes in the dust population should have profound impacts on the molecular layout of the disc. As a case in point, 43 produced a model of CO evolution that included dust dynamics and coupled the disc thermal structure to the dust and CO ice distributions; their results suggested that the snow line can be unstable to thermal perturbations, leading to rapid radial movement of the mid-plane CO snow line. All of this points to the case that self-consistent modelling of the disc temperature structure alongside dust evolution and chemistry is vital for correctly modelling the evolution of molecules in discs. In this paper, we study the CO snow line — and snow surface — in two dimensions (radial and vertical), coupling the disc thermodynamics to the time-dependent evolution of the dust and ice in the disc. To do this, we use the protoplanetary disc evolution code cuDisc ( 47 ) , adding to the base model ice-vapour chemistry and ice opacities, all of which allows us to study the CO snow line in a thermodynamically-coupled, vertically-resolved disc. With this updated model, we build upon the work done studying the CO snow line instability in 1D by 43 by including the vertical dimension and a detailed model of the evolving grain-size distribution; in this paper, we discuss the effect that these inclusions have on the nature of the snow line instability. 2 Methods We use cuDisc ( 47 ) , a protoplanetary disc code that simulates dust evolution in the 2D R-Z plane for axisymmetric discs and couples this evolving dust population to the thermal structure of the disc through solving the