A Decision-Making Framework for New Member Integration in Renewable Energy Communities under Prospect Theory
Louise Sadoine, Thomas Brihaye, Zacharie De Grève · 2026
Read A Decision-Making Framework for New Member Integration in Renewable Energy Communities under Prospect Theory by Louise Sadoine, Thomas Brihaye, Zacharie De Grève (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-30083.txt.
Introduction
Louise Sadoine, Thomas Brihaye, and Zacharie De Grève tackle a neglected question for renewable energy communities. These local groups share home-grown power among their members. Admitting a new member affects investments, pricing, and daily operations. Long-term choices and short-term scheduling pull in different directions. The authors build one framework that handles both horizons.
Long-term decisions are modeled as a finite extensive-form game. Short-term day-ahead scheduling becomes a generalized Nash equilibrium problem. Members differ in what they want, and their rationality is bounded. Prospect theory captures that boundedness, including reference point effects. The framework is applied to two groups of five members each. Eleven candidate users and several choice setups are tested. Results show decision order shapes the joint outcomes noticeably. What members value, and the prospect theory settings, matter as well.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Louise Sadoine, Thomas Brihaye, Zacharie De Grève |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 79 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30083
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Decision-Making Framework for New Member Integration in Renewable Energy Communities under Prospect Theory Louise Sadoine, Thomas Brihaye, Zacharie De Grève Abstract This paper introduces an original approach to an underexplored issue: the integration of a new member into an existing renewable energy community. The problem involves actions with both long-term consequences, such as investment and local pricing, and short-term operational ones, such as daily energy and financial flow management. Long-term decision-making is modeled using finite extensive-form game theory, while short-term day-ahead scheduling decisions are formulated as a generalized Nash equilibrium problem. This framework explicitly accounts for heterogeneous stakeholder preferences and bounded rationality, modeled through prospect theory. The proposed approach is flexible and general, making it applicable to various objectives and decision-making contexts in the evolving landscape of renewable energy communities. It is applied to two communities with five members, eleven candidate users, multiple preference configurations and a comparison with heuristic metrics from the literature is also addressed. The model also exhibits that equilibrium outcomes and stakeholder behavior are influenced by the order of decisions, their preference criteria, and prospect theory parameters particularly the reference point selection. 1 Introduction 1.1 Context Renewable energy communities ( REC s) are new collective actors of the energy system, which gather local consumers and prosumers into organized entities. They may engage in activities such as electricity generation, consumption, supply, storage, aggregation, commercial energy services, sharing and selling energy produced from members’ private or community-owned plants ( 31 ) . They allow their members to gather their energy resources and exchange locally generated renewable energy between participants. In this way, members do not depend solely on traditional wholesale/retail markets structure. Members are free to choose their electricity suppliers for consumption not covered locally and can sell production on conventional markets. Although RECs have attracted growing interest in recent years as an innovative contributor to the energy transition and to a prosumer-centric power system, their implementation has yet to overcome considerable challenges. This paper explores a crucial aspect that is still not widely studied in the literature: the integration of new members into an existing renewable energy community. The topic is especially relevant to the viability of RECs, which are called upon to expand by integrating members with various characteristics and objectives. European directives ( 12 ; 13 ) state that participation in a REC must be open and voluntary, based on transparent and non-discriminatory criteria. Similarly, any member wishing to leave the community has the right to a fair and non-discriminatory exit procedure. However, there are no further details concerning these procedures. The absence of common standards leaves a number of gray areas, which can give rise to uncertainties and concerns for RECs. More precisely, the impact of a user’s integration or exit on community dynamics is not fully anticipated in the literature. Indeed, entry and exit processes raise specific issues for the stability and efficiency of the REC: the arrival of a new user or the departure of a member can affect energy flows, costs, self-consumption and self-sufficiency rates, etc. In addition, the diversity of user profiles (in terms of consumption, production or flexibility) may require adjustments to strategies and recommendations for energy exchanges and consumption within the REC. To the best of our knowledge, the analysis of the dynamics of community members after a change in their composition (entry or exit), remains relatively unexplored in the literature. This lack of scientific references and regulations is a barrier to the expansion of RECs. 1.2 Related work 26 propose heuristic metrics based on community-level needs (generation, consumption, storage) to guide an existing REC to select new members or guide investment decisions. Their approach yields results close to optimization-based methods while offering better explainability and computational efficiency. 15 develops a community management model with fair revenue-sharing and exit clauses to find the optimal sizing of communities and to enhance cooperation. Users leaving the REC must pay a compensation that decreases over time, to mitigate the impact of their departure. These costs are calculated to ensure that other members do not suffer financial losses, thus guaranteeing economic stability for the REC. 30 consider entry and exit decisions within a bi-level optimization framework: the upper-level determines a new members based on prosumers’ preferences for cost and emission savings, while the lower-level maximizes REC’s collective welfare, through peer-to-peer trading. These studies highlight the importance of dynamic participation in RECs, but generally rely on heuristic or centralized optimization methods, without explicitly modeling strategic interactions, sequential decisions or behavioral diversity among stakeholders. This paper proposes an original approach to the New Member Integration Problem (NMIP) in an existing REC, where interactions between initial members and a potential newcomer are explicitly modeled. Beyond predefined energy profiles, the candidate may invest in additional generation or energy storage assets, though the focus remains on assessing the overall impact of integration, rather than evaluating specific investment scheme ( 4 ; 19 ; 38 , e.g.,) . We model the NMIP over a long-term ( LT ) planning horizon while accounting for its repercussions on short-term ( ST ) operations. The problem is formulated as a finite extensive-form game, which captures both strategic interactions and the dynamic nature of decision-making. The short-term day-ahead scheduling decisions are modeled as a Generalized Nash Equilibrium Problem ( GNEP ), following the framework developed in 35 . While extensive games have been used in power systems, particularly through Stackelberg formulations ( 22 ; 21 ; 39 ; 7 ; 5 ; 3 , e.g.,) , their application to the NMIP in RECs with demand-side management ( DSM ) schemes ( 35 ) remains innovative. Our framework incorporates heterogeneous stakeholder preferences and yields subgames perfect equilibria ( SPE s), providing robust plans of action by eliminating non-credible strategies. Standard REC models often assume that prosumers aim to minimize their total costs. However, end-users’ growing awareness of current energy and ecological priorities, as well as potential economic, social and environmental benefits that a REC can provide, calls for a broader perspectives. It is increasingly relevant to analyze equilibria when stakeholders show heterogeneous preferences. In this work, we study how the SPEs evolve when the REC and candidates adopt different long-term objectives. For simplicity and readability, our analysis focuses on five criteria, though the framework can accommodate additional objectives, such as those proposed in 25 ; 24 ; 27 . Most of the literature assume perfectly rational agents following the Expected Utility Theory (EUT) ( 44 ) , often with standard risk measures such as expected shortfall or conditional value-at-risk ( 1 ; 23 ; 43 ; 20 ) . However, empirical studies have shown that agent’s subjective perception and cognitive biases can significantly impact decision-making under uncertainty and, consequently, final outcomes ( 32 ) . The EUT fails to capture these effects and can not reliably predict actual individual behavior. As an alternative, 17 introduced Prospect Theory (PT) to describe the decision-making of bounded rational individuals under risk. This Nobel-prize-winning theory has already been applied to various problems in power systems. For instance, 45 and 11 examine the impact of non-rational behavior on energy management and DSM strategies over multiple time horizons, and 16 designs more effective energy policies taking into account