On a Class of Harko–Kovacs–Lobo Wormholes

R.Kh. Karimov, R.N. Izmailov, K.K. Nandi · 2026

Read On a Class of Harko–Kovacs–Lobo Wormholes by R.Kh. Karimov, R.N. Izmailov, K.K. Nandi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-29818.txt.

Introduction

Karimov, Izmailov, and Nandi study a family of wormholes proposed by Harko, Kovács, and Lobo. A wormhole is a hypothetical tunnel through spacetime, and this family is described by the throat size and a deviation parameter that keeps the throat open.

The authors work out the energy accounting of these wormholes and how the deviation parameter changes the tidal forces felt in a moving frame. They then apply an idea based on Fresnel coefficients, the numbers that say how light reflects, to ask how different outside observers would identify the object. The striking result is that an observer's position matters. There is a nonzero probability that the wormhole is identified as a black hole even when the parameter says it is a genuine wormhole.

Catalog record

CREATORR.Kh. Karimov, R.N. Izmailov, K.K. Nandi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.29818

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On a Class of Harko–Kovacs–Lobo Wormholes R.Kh. Karimov, R.N. Izmailov, K.K. Nandi Abstract The Harko, Kovács, and Lobo wormhole (HKLWH) metric contains two free parameters: one is the wormhole throat r 0 r_{0} , and the other is a dimensionless deviation parameter γ \gamma with values 0 < γ < 1 0<\gamma<1 , the latter ensuring the needed violation of the null energy condition at the throat. In this paper, we study the energetics of the HKLWH and the influence of γ \gamma on the tidal forces in the Lorentz-boosted frame. Finally, we apply a new concept, namely, the probabilistic identity of the object observed by different external observers in terms of the Fresnel coefficients derived by Tangherlini. The intriguing result is that observations can differ depending on the location of the observer, i.e., there is a nonzero probability that the HKLWH will be identified as a black hole even when γ ≠ 0 \gamma\neq 0 . I Introduction Wormholes (WHs) were conceived as a particle model by Einstein and Rosen (the well known Einstein–Rosen bridge) in 1935 Einstein 1935 . Ellis Ellis 1973 and Bronnikov Bronnikov 1973 , independently in 1973, found WH solutions threaded by an Einstein minimally coupled scalar field with a negative kinetic term in the Lagrangian. After the seminal work by Morris and Thorne in 1988 Morris 1988 , there was a revival of interest in the subject among the physics community. WHs are topological handles connecting two spacetimes that have not yet been ruled out by experiments. In fact, in the context of semiclassical quantum gravity, the minimal two-surface is not the horizon of a black hole (BH) but the throat of a WH Barthiere 2018 . The possibility of the appearance of Planck-sized WHs in quantum gravity is well discussed in the literature Nandi 2004 ; Roman 1986 . Moreover, there has been much work on the possibility of observationally distinguishing classical WHs from BHs by means of various diagnostics, such as an accretion disc, gravitational lensing, etc.; see, for example, Karimov 2019 ; Harko 2009 ; Tsukamoto 2017 ; Shaikh 2017 ; Shaikh 2018 ; Tsukamoto 2020 ; Tsukamoto 2020 ; Korolev 2020 ; Yusupova 2021 ; Stuchlik 2021 ; Paul 2021 ; Radinschi 2021 ; Alencar 2021 ; Bronnikov 2021 ; Fabris 2021 ; Jusufi 2022 ; Sokoliuk 2022 . The purpose of the present paper is to study the features of the HKLWH in reasonable detail, emphasizing the role of \gamma in various physical effects that include energetics, tidal effects, and most interestingly, the probabilistic identification of the type of the object as an outcome of probes by photons, i.e., we calculate the probability of the HKLWH being identified as a WH or a BH by different observers using probability flows of photons as probes. To achieve this, we adopt Tangherlini’s Tangherlini 1975 idea of the probabilistic scattering of photons, which is as follows. Classically, a photon motion is a regular deterministic wave propagation into an optical medium with reflection and transmission amplitudes; however, Tangherlini introduced an indeterministic condition instead of a deterministic one at the interface . The indeterminacy was introduced by assuming a hypothetical arrangement in which individual photons are incident on widely separated media at random intervals of time. As a consequence, the physical flow of energy into the medium cannot be associated with a physical flow of energy but some kind of probability flow associated with each photon. In other words, the Fresnel coefficients are determined in terms of a statistical ensemble average over a large number of replica media having the same index n —with one photon for each replica. Because of the assumed independence of collisions at the medium interface, the coefficients are the same for one photon as for N photons Tangherlini 1975 . The above ingenious idea of Tangherlini does not use Planck’s constant but an experimentally verified photon momentum increase in the refractive medium, namely, p^{\prime}=np , n\geq 1 . Equivalently, the de Broglie relation p^{\prime}\lambda^{\prime}=p\lambda= constant ( without Planck’s constant \hslash ), together with the well-known reduction in the wavelength \lambda^{\prime}=\lambda/n , then leads to p^{\prime}=np , which was used as a starting point by Tangherlini Tangherlini 1975 to derive the Fresnel coefficients R and T . Remarkably, the same Fresnel coefficients can also be deduced from the standard quantum mechanical treatment of the Schrödinger equation for a certain potential well, which reinforces the validity of the assumed probability flow in Tangherlini’s scheme. Loosely speaking, we can say that the scheme yields “quantum mechanics without quantum mechanics”. That is why Tangherlinini called his approach a “pre-quantal statistical formulation”. No information is reduced, and the new idea is that the photon motion into the medium is raised from the classical deterministic level to a so-called pre-quantal statistical flow of energy without Planck’s constant. For further explanation, see the original paper Tangherlini 1975 . The purpose of Tangherlini’s approach Tangherlini 1975 , as enumerated by the author himself, is that “The approach should be of value in further clarifying questions about the foundations of quantum mechanics as well as fundamental questions about the interaction of light and matter”. The expected outcome in the present study is that an external observer has the probability to observe the probed centrally gravitating object either as a BH or a WH, thus forming a two-point sample space. The indeterministic effect of Tangherlini’s approach is dictated only by the WH geometry, which subsumes the source energy distribution in the spirit of general relativity, no matter whether the source satisfies the energy conditions or not. A photon is propagating (in the statistical sense, as explained above) through the exterior energy-violating region of the HKLWH, portrayed as an “effective optical medium”. We make a similar hypothetical arrangement to that explained above but now involving a gravitational “effective optical medium” to probe the nature of the central object. If every photon is reflected back by the probed surface (implying R =1 , T=0 ), the observer sending the pulse would identify the surface to be a BH horizon with certainty. The ground for taking R =1 , T=0 as a hallmark of a BH is that these values follow directly from the conventional quantum mechanical treatment using the Schrödinger equation for a certain potential well Bohm 1951 . On the other hand, if all of the photons transmit through the surface, so that R =0 , T=1 , then the observer identifies the surface as a WH throat with certainty. If some photons are reflected and some transmitted, then depending on the value of \gamma and location of the observer, the latter is more likely to identify the object as a BH (if R>T) or a WH (if R<T ) in a large number of probes. Thus, for any \gamma\neq 0 , however tiny, the ( R,T ) values would differ leading correspondingly to the different outcomes in the two-point sample space (BH or WH). The essence of all this is that \gamma\neq 0 does not necessarily lead to the observation of a HKLWH but, statistically speaking, can also lead to a BH. To apply Tangherlini’s idea in gravity, we shall first portray the HKLWH spacetime as a gravitational “effective

Read the complete text