Deuterated water and the formation of the satellites of Uranus
Michael E. Brown, Matthew Belyakov, Swaroop Chandra, M. Ryleigh Davis, Merritt McDowell, Ashma Pandya, Kevin T. Trinh, Samantha K. Trumbo · 2026
Read Deuterated water and the formation of the satellites of Uranus by Michael E. Brown, Matthew Belyakov, Swaroop Chandra, M. Ryleigh Davis, Merritt McDowell, Ashma Pandya, Kevin T. Trinh, Samantha K. Trumbo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-29674.txt.
Introduction
Brown leads a team measuring the deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio in the water ice of Uranus's five regular satellites. Uranus is tilted on its side, and its satellites share that extreme tilt, yet how they formed remains uncertain. Candidate pathways include formation from impact debris and reaccretion from a massive ring.
Using the James Webb Space Telescope, the team finds a ratio almost five times the value found for Uranus itself and similar to values measured in comets. Deuterium is the heavy form of hydrogen, so the ratio fingerprints the water's origin. That enrichment is inconsistent with any scenario where much Uranian material entered the satellites. Models requiring heavy mixing in an impact-derived vapour disk are therefore excluded. The data instead fit formation from material that stayed largely separate from Uranus. Miranda, the innermost satellite, shows a slightly higher ratio still.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael E. Brown, Matthew Belyakov, Swaroop Chandra, M. Ryleigh Davis, Merritt McDowell, Ashma Pandya, Kevin T. Trinh, Samantha K. Trumbo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.29674
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Deuterated water and the formation of the satellites of Uranus Michael E. Brown, Matthew Belyakov, Swaroop Chandra, M. Ryleigh Davis, Merritt McDowell, Ashma Pandya, Kevin T. Trinh, Samantha K. Trumbo Abstract The satellites of Uranus orbit in a low‑eccentricity, equatorial plane that is tilted by 98 ∘ relative to the solar system—a geometry that mirrors Uranus’s extreme axial tilt. Although a giant impact could have tipped Uranus, how the satellites came to share this orientation remains uncertain. Proposed formation pathways include primordial accretion followed by reorientation, formation from debris generated by the tilting impact, and reaccretion from a massive ring produced by the tidal disruption of passing bodies from the outer solar system. Current observations do not discriminate among these scenarios. Using the James Webb Space Telescope, we measured the deuterium‑to‑hydrogen (D/H) ratio in the water ice of the five regular satellites of Uranus. We find an average D/H ratio of 2.1 ± 0.2 × 10 − 4 2.1\pm 0.2\times 10^{-4} , nearly five times higher than that of Uranus and comparable to values measured in comets. This enrichment is inconsistent with any formation scenario in which substantial Uranian material was incorporated into the satellites, thereby excluding models that require significant mixing in an impact‑derived vapor disk. The observed D/H ratios are instead compatible with models in which the satellites accreted from material that remained largely separate from Uranus, such as debris from a disrupted pre‑existing satellite system or from a tidally captured outer solar system body. The innermost regular satellite, Miranda, exhibits a marginally elevated D/H ratio (2.8 σ \sigma above the average of the outer satellites), potentially indicating a distinct formation history or source of water and offering an important clue for distinguishing among competing models. www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.2519276123 † † lead-author: Brown † † author-contributions: MEB conceived the project, analyzed the data, and wrote the manuscript. MB and MRD obtained and reduced the Miranda data. CS, MEB, and AP obtained and analyzed the laboratory data. All authors discussed results and implications and provided feedback on the manuscript. † † author-declaration: The authors declare that they have no competing interests. † † corresponding-author: 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: [email protected] \dropcap All giant planets in our solar system have satellites, but each system has unique properties suggesting individual formation pathways. The four large Galilean satellites of Jupiter seem the most straightforward to explain, as they appear to have formed in a circumplanetary disk in some ways analogous to the formation of the planets in the circumsolar disk lunine_formation_1982 ; Peale_origin_1999 ; Canup_formation_2002 ; Canup_common_2006 . Saturn, with its rings, series of mid-sized moons, and single large satellite is more complicated, but a combination of satellite formation, destruction, re-accretion from the rings, and fast tidal migration to their present positions appears a promising scenario Canup_origin_2010 ; Charnoz_accretion_2011 ; asphaug_late_2013 ; blanc_understanding_2025 . Neptune is the only giant planet with no regular satellite system, instead hosting the massive Triton which appears to be a captured body from the outer solar system goldreich_neptunes_1989 ; banfield_dynamical_1992 ; agnor_neptunes_2006 ; rufu_tritons_2017 . Of the giant planet satellite systems, the origin of that orbiting Uranus remains the least understood. Uranus has a series of 5 regular satellites, ranging in diameter from nearly 470 km (the inner satellite Miranda) to almost 1700 km (the outer pair Titania and Oberon), with a total mass approximately 10 -4 times that of Uranus. The central pair, Ariel and Umbriel, are about 1160 km in diameter. These regular satellites all orbit in a prograde sense in the equatorial plane of Uranus, but the planet itself has an obliquity of nearly 98 degrees. The source of this unexpected tilt is unknown. An ancient giant impact is often taken to be the cause safronov_sizes_1966 ; morbidelli_explaining_2012 ; ida_uranian_2020 ; salmon_co-accretion_2022 , but alternative non-impact possibilities exist, such as those involving spin-orbit interactions between Uranus and primordial satellites saillenfest_tilting_2022 ; rogoszinski_tilting_2020 . Whatever the cause of the tilt, either the orbital plane of the satellites must have re-oriented at the same time as Uranus, the satellites must have been formed by the event itself, or the satellites formed subsequent to the event. The available data do not point to an obvious favorite among the multiple possibilities. Isotopic measurements offer a potentially powerful means of distinguishing between these scenarios. Decades of laboratory, theoretical, observational, and modeling work have sought to use measurements of the ratio of deuterium to hydrogen (hereafter the D/H ratio) across and beyond the solar system as a proxy for understanding protoplanetary disk temperature and dynamics, inferring the path of water into the inner solar system, and tracing the inheritance of unprocessed ices from the interstellar medium into the planetary system furuya_water_2017 ; yang_dh_2013 ; albertsson_chemodynamical_2014 . Such measurements have been instrumental in trying to understand such diverse topics as the delivery of water to the Earth, the accretion of solid material into Uranus and Neptune, and the provenance of the ices incorporated into comets albertsson_chemodynamical_2014 ; lis_terrestrial_2019 ; bockelee-morvan_cometary_2015 . The D/H ratio can be used to trace similar processes in the formation of the Uranian satellites, and different scenarios for the formation of the satellites can lead to large differences in predicted D/H ratios. The D/H ratio of Uranus has been measured to be (4.4 \pm 0.4)\times 10^{-5} feuchtgruber_dh_2013 (about twice the solar value), presumably reflecting a mixture of protostellar H 2 carrying the solar D/H ratio, and outer solar system ices with elevated values, while comets from the outer solar system have measured D/H values that range from 1.6 to 6.5 \times 10^{-4} bockelee-morvan_cometary_2015 ; biver_isotopic_2016 ; lis_terrestrial_2019 ; muller_high_2022 , between 4 and 15 times higher than that of Uranus. Depending on the source material, the D/H of the Uranian satellites could plausibly fall anywhere within this range. Observations from the Cassini spacecraft and the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) have shown that deuterated water can be detected in the reflectance spectrum of the icy satellites of Saturn clark_isotopic_2019 ; hedman_waterice_2024 ; brown_deuterated_2025 via a spectroscopic absorption at about 4.14 µm caused by the O-D stretch fundamental (analogous to the well-known 3 µm O-H stretch fundamental). Here, we analyze similar JWST observations of the major regular satellites of Uranus in an attempt to identify the O-D stretch, quantify the D/H ratios on these satellites, and constrain the origin of the satellite system. Figure 1: JWST near-infrared reflectance spectra of the leading and trailing hemispheres of the Uranian satellite Ariel cartwright_revealing_2024 The overall structure of the spectra is dominated by the 3 µm O-H stretch absorption from H 2 O and the broad 4.5 µm H 2 O combination band. At smaller scales, the 3.1 µm Fresnel reflectance peak can be seen. The region beyond 4 µm has multiple features due to CO 2 , particularly on the leading hemisphere, including the 4.26 µm \nu_{3} asymmetric stretch absorption, a reflectance peak at 4.22 µm and multiple weaker absorption features at longer wavelengths. A small absorption at 4.14 µm is coincident with the expected fundamental O-D stretch feature of deuterated water, but is also in a spectral region potentially containing absorption due to CO 2 ; the strength of the 4.14 µm feature does not appear to change