Spreading the Risk of Scalable Legal Services: The Role of Insurance in Expanding Access to Justice

Roee Amir, David Chriki, Harel Omer · 2026

Read Spreading the Risk of Scalable Legal Services: The Role of Insurance in Expanding Access to Justice by Roee Amir, David Chriki, Harel Omer (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-29598.txt.

Introduction

Amir, Chriki, and Omer argue that liability insurance could unlock artificial intelligence legal services while protecting users. Automated advice could widen access to justice, yet two barriers loom: catastrophic risk to a user from bad advice, and weak accountability when failures occur.

Current regulation leans on human oversight requirements, which raise costs and limit scale. Insurance, the authors propose, spreads risk across many users instead. Performance-based premiums would reward providers that improve quality. Their model sets clear risk thresholds, simpler compensation mechanisms, and ongoing performance monitoring. Rather than trying to eliminate every risk in advance, the framework manages risk directly. That, they argue, lets automated legal services scale while keeping robust user protections in place.

Catalog record

CREATORRoee Amir, David Chriki, Harel Omer
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.29598

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Spreading the Risk of Scalable Legal Services: The Role of Insurance in Expanding Access to Justice Roee Amir, David Chriki, Harel Omer Abstract Liability insurance for AI-powered legal services offers a promising solution to two critical barriers in using AI to expand access to justice: mitigating catastrophic risk to individual users from inadequate advice and ensuring meaningful accountability when failures occur. Existing accountability mechanisms face significant challenges: tort liability frameworks encounter barriers including judgment-proof providers and costly information asymmetries, while current regulatory approaches revolve around human oversight requirements, creating cost and scalability barriers which limit access to justice. This Article argues that an insurance-based framework offers a promising response to these challenges by distributing risks across users while establishing market-driven incentives for quality improvement through performance-based premiums. The Article proposes a comprehensive insurance model for AI legal services that establishes clear risk thresholds, streamlined compensation mechanisms, and continuous performance monitoring. Rather than attempting to eliminate all risks through restrictive ex-ante oversight requirements or relying on ineffective ex-post remedies, insurance enables efficient risk spreading while facilitating the scaling of automated legal services. This framework demonstrates how carefully structured insurance mechanisms can help realize AI’s transformative potential to democratize legal assistance while maintaining robust user protections through sophisticated risk management rather than direct oversight. [[email protected], ] *1 [[email protected], ] *2 [[email protected], ] *3 1 keywords Access to Justice ,Access to Justice ,AI Legal Services ,Liability Insurance ,Risk Management,Accountability,Legal Technology ,Consumer Protection,Risk Thresholds,Legal Innovation,Automated Legal Services ,Legal Risk Distribution,Insurance Mechanisms,Legal Service Automation,Market-Based Regulation,Insurance ,AI Accountability † † copyrightyear: 2024 † † copyright: Copyright for this paper by its authors. Use permitted under Creative Commons License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0). † † venue: AI for Access to Justice Workshop – Jurix 2024, Masaryk University, Brno, Czechia † † corresp: LL.M., Harvard Law School; M.D. Candidate, Hadassah-Hebrew University School of Medicine; former Research Fellow, Harvard Law School Program on Corporate Governance. † † corresp: JSM, Stanford Law School † † corresp: Senior Product Manager, Nvidia † † We are grateful to Nathan Hemmendinger, Yotam Berger, and the participants of the 2024 JURIX AI Conference at Stanford Law School for their insightful discussions, valuable suggestions, and thoughtful feedback on earlier versions of this paper. 1 Introduction Liability insurance for legal services powered by artificial intelligence (AI) offers a promising solution to two primary barriers in using AI to expand access to justice: mitigating the risk that individual users face catastrophic consequences from inadequate advice and ensuring accountability when such failures occur. While legal scholars, policymakers, bar associations, lawyers, and courts have emphasized responsible AI use — often advocating for limited scope or mandatory human oversight — these restrictions could severely constrain the technology’s capacity to democratize legal assistance. 1 1 1 A number of jurisdictions ban unauthorized practice of law in a manner that could effectively limit the ability of companies to provide legal advice without oversight of licensed lawyers. 7 4 . Even when the use of AI legal advisors is not strictly banned, courts have penalized unrepresented individuals for not correcting legal arguments in pleadings generated by generative AI, though the unrepresented individual does not possess the expertise to identify such errors 22 Insurance accomplishes these dual objectives by distributing potential losses across all users rather than concentrating risk on individuals, while simultaneously creating a reinforcing loop for accountability through performance-based premiums and deductibles that incentivize service providers to maintain high standards of accuracy. This approach preserves the transformative potential of AI legal services while protecting individual users and establishing clear financial consequences for inadequate performance. The emergence of AI-powered legal services presents an unprecedented opportunity to expand access to legal services. Through sophisticated language processing and generation capabilities, these tools automate key legal processes that have traditionally required human lawyers, empowering individuals to articulate claims, engage in better-informed settlement negotiations, and navigate legal disputes. Such systems promise to bridge systemic gaps in legal service delivery by reducing costs, enabling scalable solutions, and addressing long-standing disparities in access to justice. However, the transformative potential of AI is shadowed by significant risks. AI-generated legal advice can be flawed or misleading, potentially exposing users to severe adverse consequences. This risk warrants particular attention for two fundamental reasons. First, the technical complexity and opacity of AI systems often leaves users ill-equipped to assess the reliability of the guidance they receive or make informed decisions about using these services despite the risks involved. Second, when these tools fail, the burden falls disproportionately on individual users, while the system’s overall success in serving most users masks these failures. This statistical success may diminish providers’ incentives to improve accuracy or fully disclose limitations, even as their errors impose catastrophic losses on individual users—creating a stark accountability deficit that threatens to erode trust and limit adoption of these promising services. Both traditional accountability mechanisms and current regulatory frameworks seem inadequate to address these challenges. Traditional tort liability faces several fundamental barriers: the technical complexity and opacity of AI systems make causation and fault exceptionally difficult to establish, rendering potential claims prohibitively expensive to litigate and leading to systematic underenforcement. Even if users could successfully establish liability, AI-powered legal services present an acute judgment-proof problem, where potential damages from systematic errors could far exceed providers’ assets. Perhaps most critically, pursuing tort claims requires precisely the legal expertise and resources whose absence drives users to seek AI assistance in the first place. Meanwhile, current regulatory approaches focusing on mandatory human oversight of these technologies involve high costs and create scalability bottlenecks that undermine the technology’s potential to democratize legal assistance. This Article argues that liability insurance for AI-powered legal services offers a promising response to these challenges. Rather than attempting to eliminate all risks through constrictive regulatory measures or relying solely on traditional legal remedies poorly equipped to address AI systems’ unique characteristics, insurance enables efficient risk spreading while facilitating the scaling of automated legal services. The proposed insurance framework would operate on multiple levels to address current shortcomings: First, by distributing potential losses across all users, it protects individuals from catastrophic consequences while providing streamlined paths to compensation through predetermined mechanisms rather than complex litigation. Second, the framework creates market-driven accountability through performance-based premiums and deductibles, creating direct financial incentives for accuracy and reliability. This accountability would be reinforced by insurance providers’ own incentives to continuously monitor AI system performance against established risk thresholds, requiring services to maintain measurable standards of quality. This shift from direct oversight and case-by-case litigation to systematic risk management enables the development of scalable, accessible legal services without sacrificing user protection or stifling innovation. The analysis proceeds as follows. Beyond this introduction as Part 1 , Part 2 examines the transformative potential of AI-powered legal services, highlighting their promise to expand access to justice alongside the risks of flawed advice and inequitable outcomes. Part 3 addresses accountability deficiencies in AI systems, emphasizing challenges in fault attribution and the limitations of traditional tort liability and current regulatory frameworks focused on human oversight. Part 4 proposes liability insurance as a more effective framework for managing AI risks, detailing its ability to redistribute liability, incentivize system improvements through dynamic premiums, and align innovation with user protection. It contemplates

Read the complete text