Nuclear equation-of-state at high density and multi-messenger astronomy: contribution of heavy-ion collisions
Arnaud Le Fèvre · 2026
Read Nuclear equation-of-state at high density and multi-messenger astronomy: contribution of heavy-ion collisions by Arnaud Le Fèvre (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-29588.txt.
Introduction
Le Fèvre reviews how heavy-ion collisions, smashing atomic nuclei together in the laboratory, constrain the nuclear equation of state at high density. That equation links pressure and density inside neutron stars, the densest objects known. Flow, the collective motion of particles produced in a collision, has proven a powerful observable for probing both symmetric and asymmetric nuclear matter.
Combining symmetry energy measurements with constraints on symmetric matter let researchers predict how pressure inside a neutron star grows with density. Those predictions agree with recent astronomical measurements from gravitational waves and pulsar observations, up to about two and a half times saturation density. A key subtlety is knowing which densities each measure actually probes. Future experiments at higher energy, such as ASY-EOS, should push the frontier further. Le Fèvre stresses that sound uncertainty estimates are essential for that progress.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Arnaud Le Fèvre |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.29588
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nuclear equation-of-state at high density and multi-messenger astronomy: contribution of heavy-ion collisions Arnaud Le Fèvre Abstract In the past decades, heavy-ion collisions (HIC) at intermediate energies have allowed to probe the nuclear equation-of-state (EoS) of both symmetric and asymmetric nuclear matter over a broad range of densities. In particular, flow has proven to be a powerful observable. Combining the symmetry energy and the symmetric nuclear matter constraints of the EoS from HIC allowed to predict a density dependence of the pressure in a neutron star, up to about 2.5 times saturation density ( n s a t n_{sat} ), which agrees with recent astronomical measurements deduced from gravitational waves and pulsar observations. So far, the accuracy from HIC expectations is comparable to the latter up to 1.5 n s a t n_{sat} . In these studies, a fundamental aspect is the determination of the profile of densities that are probed by experimental observables used to constrain the EoS. In the near future, new experiments like ASY-EOS performed at higher incident energy and with better accuracy will push further the frontier of the knowledge of the symmetry energy at higher density. These efforts cannot be conclusive without a reliable uncertainty determination, which is related to the reliability of transport model dependencies. Improvements and breakthroughs in transport model simulations and nuclear theory are therefore expected in a joint effort towards HIC contributions to the field of neutron-star physics, including the contribution of strangeness and of the QCD phase transition. keywords Nuclear matter equation-of-state, Symmetry energy, Heavy-ion collisions, Collective flows, Particle production, Neutron Stars, Transport models, QCD phase transition, Strangeness 1 Introduction The investigation of the nuclear matter equation-of-state (EoS) at high densities is an important subject in modern nuclear physics. It determines how nuclear matter behaves under conditions that differ from those found inside atomic nuclei and plays a significant role in phenomena such as heavy-ion collisions, neutron-star mergers, the determination of neutron-star mass–radius relations, and the modelling of supernova explosions. Our limited knowledge of the EoS is largely due to the challenges involved in solving the many-body problem when realistic nuclear interactions are considered. Over the past decades, both theoretical and experimental studies have led to substantial progress in describing the EoS for isospin-symmetric matter as well as for isospin-asymmetric matter (commonly referred to as the symmetry energy), particularly at densities above the saturation density (usually denoted n_{sat} or \rho_{0} ). In this article, we review selected investigations of the high-density behaviour of the EoS derived from heavy-ion collision experiments with incident energies ranging from several hundred MeV up to approximately 2 GeV per nucleon. We also summarise constraints on the EoS of isospin-symmetric matter obtained from analyses of kaon and pion production and from measurements of collective flow observables. For the symmetry energy, we discuss results obtained from studies of charged pion ratios and ratios of neutron-to-charged-particle elliptic flows. Furthermore, we describe how connections can be established between microscopic collisions (HIC), and macroscopic collisions like neutron-star mergers. In this context, estimates of neutron-star radii derived from heavy-ion collision results presented in this review are compared with astrophysical observations, including recent measurements enabled by gravitational-wave detections and X-ray satellite observations. A multi-source analysis combining theoretical calculations, astrophysical data, and heavy-ion collision results to constrain neutron-star radii is presented as an example of the important contribution of heavy-ion studies in the era of multi-messenger astronomy. Finally, we outline several future prospects and challenges from both experimental and theoretical perspectives. 2 Bridging heavy-ion collisions and neutron star mergers 2.1 The equation-of-state of nuclear matter The EoS describes the relation between binding energy E , density \rho , pressure P , temperature T and isospin asymmetry \delta=(\rho_{n}-\rho_{p})/\rho of infinite nuclear matter, where \rho_{n} and \rho_{p} are the neutron and proton densities, respectively 54 ; 15 . It is conventionally split into an isospin symmetric matter part, independent of \delta , and an isospin dependent term, expressed as a product of the symmetry energy (called also more academically ”asymmetry energy”) E_{sym}(\rho) , and the square of the isospin asymmetry parameter. For the case of T=0 : E(\rho,\delta)=E_{SNM}(\rho,\delta=0)+\delta^{2}E_{sym}(\rho)+o(\delta^{4}) (1) The symmetry energy quantifies the energy cost of converting protons into neutrons in nuclear matter. In thermodynamics, one derives the pressure from the energy per nucleon E/A the following way, at constant temperature: P=\rho^{2}\frac{\partial E/A}{\partial\rho}\biggr\rvert_{T=const} (2) In the field of the nuclear EoS, few key physical quantities are introduced to quantify the stiffness of the EoS. First, for SNM, the so-called incompressibility modulus: K_{0}=9\rho^{2}\frac{\partial^{2}E/A}{\partial^{2}\rho}\biggr\rvert_{\rho=\rho_{0}} (3) Second, for the symmetry energy, the slope of its density dependence at saturation density: L=3\rho_{0}\frac{\partial E_{sym}}{\partial\rho}\biggr\rvert_{\rho=\rho_{0}} (4) 2.2 Temperatures and densities According to transport models simulating HIC and numerical-relativity simulations of merging neutron star binaries 38 , temperature and density created in the fireball (also called ”participant”) in HIC at intermediate energies (few hundred to few GeV per nucleon incident energy) mimic the density and temperature conditions created in binary neutron star mergers, as illustrated in Figure 1 . Therefore, conditions of the EoS explored by both microscopic and macroscopic collisions are similar. In both cases, temperatures remain quite moderate in comparison with HIC at ultra-relativistic energies. Since neutron stars in equilibrium are essentially cold (i.e. close to zero temperature), constraining their EoS using HIC requires the extraction of the cold nuclear EoS. This, in turn, implies that the temperatures reached in such collisions should not exceed the regime where the interplay between thermal effects and the zero-temperature EoS becomes too complex. At moderate temperatures, transport models used to interpret heavy-ion data can still account for thermal contributions through the momentum dependence of the mean-field potentials, thereby allowing the underlying non-thermal (cold) component of the EoS to be constrained. Figure 1: Illustrations taken from 38 . Simulations of a binary neutron star merger at a post-merger time of t=6.34ms for the LS220-M132 binary (top panels) and of a gold on gold semi-central ( b=5fm ) collision at 1.5A GeV incident energy at t=15fm/c (bottom panels). Right and left panels show respectively the temperature and density (relative to the nuclear saturation density) distributions in the rotation plane of both objects. 2.3 Relation between squeeze-out in HIC and tidal deformability of neutron stars Other correspondencies between neutrons stars and nuclei, despite the vast difference in scale, can be found on the one side between the tidal polarizability (or deformability) of neutron stars and the squeeze-out amplitude of the fireball in HIC. Both are ruled on the first order by the stiffness of the EoS 42 ; 50 . The analysis of the detected gravitational waves (GW) generated by the collision of neutrons stars made it possible to determine the tidal deformability, \Lambda . This quantity characterizes how strongly a star’s mass distribution is deformed into a quadrupole shape by the gravitational influence of its companion and therefore depends on the EoS. Tidal effects leave measurable imprints on the gravitational-wave signal during the inspiral phase of binary neutron stars, enabling constraints on the EoS. In HIC at intermediate energies, in semi-central collisions, the participant region is highly compressed and flows afterwards preferentially perpendicular to the reaction plane, creating the so-called ”negative elliptic flow” which shows the strongest sensitivity to the stiffness