Adaptive AI Delegation under Uncertainty: A Bayesian Governance Policy for Sequential Decision Authority

Matthew Dixon · 2026

Read Adaptive AI Delegation under Uncertainty: A Bayesian Governance Policy for Sequential Decision Authority by Matthew Dixon (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-29406.txt.

Introduction

Dixon asks how much decision authority an organization should hand to artificial intelligence systems, and how that share should change as evidence improves or worsens. Current governance frameworks stress transparency, documentation, and oversight. They give little numeric guidance on when a manager should let a model decide alone. Dixon frames the problem for large language models and agentic systems working in high consequence settings.

He models delegation as a Governance-Aware Partially Observable Markov Decision Process. In that model, Bayesian inference, a method that updates beliefs as evidence arrives, tracks what is known. Sequential optimization then picks the right level of delegated authority at each step. Synthetic stress tests probe robustness when reported model confidence is wrong. Benchmarks against five fixed governance strategies follow. Sequential Bayesian governance performs best overall across mixed quality regimes, while simpler heuristics win only when conditions stay steady.

Catalog record

CREATORMatthew Dixon
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE108 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.29406

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Adaptive AI Delegation under Uncertainty: A Bayesian Governance Policy for Sequential Decision Authority Matthew Dixon Abstract Organizations increasingly use large language models and agentic AI systems to generate probabilistic assessments and candidate actions in high-consequence settings. This creates a managerial problem that is fundamentally different from prediction: how should organizations allocate decision authority to AI-generated recommendations as evidence quality, uncertainty, and organizational objectives evolve over time? Existing AI governance frameworks emphasize transparency, documentation, oversight, and regulatory compliance, but they provide limited quantitative guidance for dynamically allocating decision authority under uncertainty. To address this challenge, we formulate adaptive AI delegation as a Governance-Aware Partially Observable Markov Decision Process (POMDP) in which Bayesian inference estimates the informational state and sequential optimization determines the appropriate degree of delegated AI authority. The paper also develops a quantitative validation and benchmarking framework for governance policies. Synthetic stress tests, reported LLM-confidence robustness, forecast-accuracy validation, governance-appetite sensitivity, and fragile-AI early-warning experiments evaluate whether the proposed policy exhibits graceful degradation, robustness to confidence-only perturbations, adaptive delegation under improving evidence quality, and interpretable calibration of institutional conservatism. Finally, the Governance-Aware POMDP is benchmarked against five representative governance strategies operating under identical Bayesian beliefs, information, and governance objectives. The results show that while specialized heuristics remain effective under stationary operating conditions, sequential Bayesian governance provides the strongest general-purpose governance policy across heterogeneous AI-quality regimes by dynamically allocating organizational decision authority under uncertainty. Keywords: AI governance; adaptive delegation; Bayesian decision theory; POMDP; model validation; Belief-at-Risk; organizational decision making; human–AI governance. 1 Introduction Motivation. Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly embedded within organizational decision processes, supporting decisions in finance, healthcare, cybersecurity, manufacturing, supply-chain management, and other high-consequence domains. In many settings, AI systems no longer function solely as predictive models; instead, they operate as decision-support agents whose recommendations influence human judgment and organizational action. As organizations adopt increasingly capable foundation models and agentic AI systems, a central managerial challenge emerges: how should decision authority be allocated between AI-generated intelligence and established organizational decision processes when the reliability of AI is uncertain? Governance. Existing approaches to AI governance emphasize model validation, monitoring, documentation, transparency, explainability, regulatory compliance, and post-deployment oversight ( 23 ; 18 ; 24 ; 14 ) . Although these mechanisms are essential, they are largely static. Organizations repeatedly decide whether AI-generated recommendations should be accepted, moderated, or overridden as new evidence becomes available and operating conditions evolve. Governance therefore becomes a sequential organizational decision problem rather than a one-time certification exercise. The relevant managerial question is not simply whether an AI model is accurate on average, but how organizations should dynamically regulate the influence of AI-generated intelligence over time. Delegation. We argue that this challenge is fundamentally one of adaptive organizational delegation. Classical organizational theory distinguishes information acquisition from decision authority and emphasizes that organizations frequently separate these functions to improve decision quality ( 29 ; 16 ; 19 ; 1 ) . Bayesian decision theory similarly distinguishes inference from action by representing uncertainty through posterior beliefs that evolve as new information arrives ( 8 ; 26 ; 20 ) . Rather than allowing AI systems to determine organizational actions directly, organizations require a governance mechanism that continuously determines the appropriate degree of authority assigned to AI-generated intelligence. This mechanism should adapt to evolving evidence while preserving the ability to revert toward independently validated organizational knowledge whenever governance risk becomes sufficiently large. Research Questions. This paper addresses four related questions. First, how should organizations dynamically allocate decision authority between AI-generated intelligence and existing organizational decision processes? Second, how should uncertainty regarding AI reliability be represented and updated as new information becomes available? Third, can AI governance itself be formulated as a sequential optimization problem rather than as a collection of static validation rules? Fourth, does sequential Bayesian governance provide measurable organizational advantages relative to simpler governance mechanisms such as static delegation, confidence thresholds, Bayesian shrinkage, reliability-only delegation, and rule-based governance? Approach. To answer these questions, we formulate adaptive AI delegation as a Governance-Aware Partially Observable Markov Decision Process (POMDP). Bayesian filtering estimates posterior beliefs regarding the latent operating environment, while a governance policy maps those beliefs into delegated decision authority assigned to AI-generated recommendations. Unlike conventional POMDP applications, the optimization variable is not the operational decision itself but the degree of organizational authority assigned to AI-generated intelligence. Governance therefore becomes an adaptive organizational capability rather than a collection of manually specified confidence thresholds or approval rules. Benchmarking. A distinguishing feature of the paper is the development of a quantitative benchmarking framework for AI governance policies. Rather than evaluating the proposed Governance-Aware POMDP in isolation, we compare it against five representative governance mechanisms: Static Delegation, Confidence Threshold, Reliability-Only Delegation, Bayesian Shrinkage, and SR11-7 Style Governance. Every benchmark policy operates under the identical Bayesian filtering framework, identical information set, identical simulated environments, and identical governance objective. The policies differ only in how delegated AI authority is determined. This design isolates the incremental value of sequential governance from differences in forecasting models, Bayesian inference, or utility specification, providing a principled basis for comparing competing governance strategies. Contributions. This paper makes six principal contributions. First, it reframes AI governance as a dynamic organizational delegation problem in which governance itself becomes the object of sequential optimization rather than post hoc model validation. Second, it develops a parsimonious Bayesian framework that separates inference, validation, governance, and execution while representing organizational uncertainty through posterior beliefs. Third, it formulates a Governance-Aware POMDP that continuously regulates delegated AI authority as uncertainty evolves, replacing heuristic confidence thresholds with principled sequential optimization. Fourth, it establishes theoretical properties of the proposed governance framework, including existence of an optimal governance policy, belief-state sufficiency, monotone adaptation to governance risk, robustness to confidence-only perturbations, and adaptive delegation under improving evidence quality. Fifth, it introduces a comparative benchmarking methodology in which multiple governance policies are evaluated under identical Bayesian beliefs, information, and governance objectives. Finally, it validates the resulting governance architecture through synthetic experiments and historical market replay, demonstrating that adaptive Bayesian governance provides the strongest general-purpose governance policy across heterogeneous AI-quality regimes while remaining competitive in investment performance. Findings. The empirical results reveal an important distinction between specialized and adaptive governance policies. Bayesian Shrinkage performs best when AI quality is persistently poor because immediate contraction toward the validated reference process minimizes unnecessary AI exposure. However, the Governance-Aware POMDP achieves the highest governance utility across fragile, improving, and high-quality AI regimes, demonstrating that sequential governance becomes increasingly valuable as AI quality evolves over time. Rather than seeking to maximize AI utilization, the proposed framework dynamically allocates organizational authority according to Bayesian evidence quality, governance risk, and institutional objectives. Managerial Perspective. The proposed framework is intended to augment rather than replace human expertise. Governance decisions remain under organizational control, while AI contributes probabilistic information whose influence varies according to Bayesian evidence, statistical reliability, and governance risk. This perspective is particularly relevant in regulated industries, where organizations must justify not only individual decisions but also the governance processes through which those decisions are made. By embedding governance directly within sequential decision making, organizations can adapt continuously to changing evidence without relying on static approval rules or binary override mechanisms. Paper Organization. The remainder of the paper is organized as

Read the complete text