The Maximum Initial Mass

Dario Izzo and Giacomo Acciarini · 2026

Read The Maximum Initial Mass by Dario Izzo and Giacomo Acciarini (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-29289.txt.

Introduction

Izzo and Acciarini give a neglected spacecraft problem its own formal treatment: the maximum initial mass problem. Mission design usually fixes a spacecraft's starting mass and minimises time or propellant for a low-thrust transfer. This problem inverts the question: given the transfer and its flight time, what is the largest starting mass that can still complete it? The quantity summarises thrust, efficiency and boundary conditions in one number.

Working in Pontryagin's optimal control framework, they derive the necessary conditions. In the nondegenerate case, the best throttle setting is simply full-on, and thrust direction follows a primer-vector law. Their central theorem shows minimum-time solutions are exactly maximum-initial-mass solutions over the same flight time, and conversely. They also show the problem yields a smooth homotopy path to multi-revolution transfers, exposing the funnel-shaped landscape of time-optimal solutions in a worked example.

Catalog record

CREATORDario Izzo and Giacomo Acciarini
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.29289

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Maximum Initial Mass Dario Izzo and Giacomo Acciarini Abstract Introduction L ow-thrust optimal control problems are most often formulated either as minimum-propellant (or, equivalently, maximum-final-mass) or minimum-time transfers, and these two problem classes underpin the majority of contemporary work in astrodynamics and spacecraft guidance. In interplanetary mission design, time- and fuel-optimal low-thrust problems are routinely employed not only to construct feasible flight trajectories, but also as building blocks for exploring the global structure of the transfer landscape via homotopy methods [ 18 , 11 , 12 , 17 ] , parametric sweeps, and reachability studies [ 2 , 19 , 3 ] . Across this broad literature, time and propellant emerge as the canonical performance indices around which methods, theory, and intuition have been built. They drive homotopy-based algorithms that connect simple reference solutions to complex, high-fidelity transfers; they parameterize reachability analyses; and they provide training data for surrogate models that emulate optimal guidance policies at negligible online cost. Minimum-time low-thrust problems, in particular, have been the natural backbone for the construction of probability-one homotopy schemes that guarantee convergence to optimal solutions under broad conditions [ 11 ] , and they have inspired a variety of continuation strategies in thrust, boundary conditions, and complexity in the dynamics [ 17 , 18 ] . Despite the pervasive role of low-thrust analysis in preliminary mission design, the structurally related maximum-initial-mass problem has instead received comparatively little explicit attention. Informally, this problem seeks, for a fixed transfer geometry and final state, the largest initial mass from which a low-thrust spacecraft can accomplish the transfer subject to its dynamical and operational constraints. Conceptually, it inverts the usual “given initial mass, minimize time/propellant” viewpoint and instead asks “given time of flight, maximise initial mass”. During the Global Trajectory Optimization Competitions (GTOCs), this perspective started to emerge: in one edition, the team from JPL introduced and exploited an approximation to the maximum-initial-mass solution, valid for sufficiently short arcs, that later became known and systematically analyzed under the acronym MIMA [ 5 ] . That approximation proved instrumental in designing a highly complex coordinated multi-rendezvous mission, and it suggests that the underlying optimal-control formulation could also be valuable more generally for mission design Subsequent work, including contributions by the present authors, has begun to leverage this idea numerically, even if the problem itself has rarely been formalized and studied on its own terms. Neural surrogate models of the maximum-initial-mass map have been constructed to rapidly assess the feasibility and performance of large sets of asteroid mining scenarios [ 1 , 6 ] , while related constructs have been proposed for solar sailing applications and low-thrust reachability envelopes [ 2 ] . In these studies, the maximum-initial-mass quantity appears as a natural scalar summary of the reachable set for a specified transfer, encoding in a single number the combined effect of thrust, specific impulse, and boundary conditions. Yet, its optimal-control structure, its Hamiltonian, costate behavior, and relation to the classical time-optimal problem, has so far been exposed mostly through numerical evidence rather than a dedicated analytical treatment. This work argues that the maximum-initial-mass problem deserves to be elevated to a first-class optimal control formulation in low-thrust trajectory design. Building on insights that originated from competitive trajectory design at the GTOC and were later used in the context of preliminary mission analysis, the paper formally introduces the maximum-initial-mass optimal control problem, characterizes its relationship to the more familiar minimum-time low-thrust problem, and highlights the specific advantages that follow from adopting this formulation as a design primitive. As a further result, we use the derivation of the necessary conditions to clarify a common misunderstanding in the indirect formulation of time-optimal problems, specifically regarding the transversality condition. Finally, we show that the maximum-initial-mass problem admits a natural homotopy path to multi-revolution transfers. This path can be exploited to reveal the rich solution landscape that arises in such cases and to provide a fundamentally different perspective from thrust-continuation-based approaches. By making the maximum-initial-mass formulation explicit and clarifying its links to the established minimum-time framework, as well as its differences and advantages, the paper aims to provide a foundational step toward systematic use of maximum-initial-mass optimal control in low-thrust mission design. The maximum initial mass problem Consider the low-thrust dynamics, \dot{\bm{x}}=\bm{f}(\bm{x})+c_{1}\bm{B}(\bm{x})\frac{u}{m}\hat{\bm{i}},\qquad\dot{m}=-\frac{c_{1}}{c_{2}}u, (1) where \bm{x} is the state vector, such as Cartesian, modified equinoctial elements, or any other coordinate representation, u\in[0,1] is the throttle, \hat{\bm{i}} is the thrust direction with \|\hat{\bm{i}}\|=1 , and c_{1} , c_{2} are constants related to maximum thrust and specific impulse. The maximum-initial-mass problem consists in finding the control histories u(t) and \hat{\bm{i}}(t) that transfer the system from \bm{x}(t_{0})=\bm{x}_{0} to \bm{x}(t_{f})=\bm{x_{f}} while maximizing the initial mass m(t_{0}) , with fixed transfer time t_{f}-t_{0} . To investigate its mathematical structure and explain its favorable numerical properties, we begin from the Pontryagin Minimum Principle and derive the corresponding first-order necessary conditions. We formulate the problem in the normal form of the principle, following [ 8 ] , by setting \lambda_{0}=1 (this is the constant that multiplies the objective). This fixes the multiplier normalization and excludes abnormal extremals [ 8 ] . Let us introduce the Meyer-form cost functional, converting the maximization into an equivalent minimization, J=-m(t_{0}), (2) where the Hamiltonian is \mathcal{H}(\bm{x},m,\bm{\lambda},\lambda_{m},u,\hat{\bm{i}})=\bm{\lambda}^{T}\left[\bm{f}(\bm{x})+c_{1}\bm{B}(\bm{x})\frac{u}{m}\hat{\bm{i}}\right]-\lambda_{m}\frac{c_{1}}{c_{2}}u. (3) According to the Pontryagin Maximum Principle in minimum form, the optimal controls satisfy (u^{*},\hat{\bm{i}}^{*})=\operatorname{argmin}_{u\in[0,1],\,\|\hat{\bm{i}}\|=1}\mathcal{H}(\bm{x},m,\bm{\lambda},\lambda_{m},u,\hat{\bm{i}}) (4) at each instant along the optimal trajectory. Minimization with respect to the thrust direction gives \hat{\bm{i}}^{*}=-\frac{\bm{B}(\bm{x})^{T}\bm{\lambda}}{\|\bm{B}(\bm{x})^{T}\bm{\lambda}\|}. (5) Substituting this expression into the Hamiltonian yields a reduced Hamiltonian affine in u , \mathcal{H}=\bm{\lambda}^{T}\bm{f}(\bm{x})+c_{1}u\left(-\frac{1}{m}\|\bm{B}(\bm{x})^{T}\bm{\lambda}\|-\frac{\lambda_{m}}{c_{2}}\right). (6) Therefore, introducing a switching function S=-\frac{1}{m}\|\bm{B}(\bm{x})^{T}\bm{\lambda}\|-\frac{\lambda_{m}}{c_{2}}, (7) the optimal throttle is u^{*}=\begin{cases}1,&S<0,\\ 0,&S>0.\end{cases} (8) To determine the sign of S , consider the mass costate equation. Since \dot{\lambda}_{m}=-\partial\mathcal{H}/\partial m , substitution of the optimal thrust direction gives \dot{\lambda}_{m}=\bm{\lambda}^{T}\left[c_{1}\bm{B}(\bm{x})\frac{u}{m^{2}}\hat{\bm{i}}^{*}\right]=-\frac{c_{1}u}{m^{2}}\|\bm{B}(\bm{x})^{T}\bm{\lambda}\|\leq 0. (9) Hence \lambda_{m}(t) is non-increasing along the optimal trajectory. The transversality condition at the initial time is \lambda_{m}(t_{0})=-\frac{dJ}{dm}=1>0 , while at the final time \lambda_{m}(t_{f})=0 and therefore \lambda_{m}(t)\geq 0 for all t\in[t_{0},t_{f}] . In particular since m>0 , c_{2}>0 , and \|\bm{B}(\bm{x})^{T}\bm{\lambda}\|\geq 0 , it follows from Eq.( 7 ) that in the nondegenerate case, one has in fact S<0 and thus, necessarily the optimal throttle is u^{*}=1 and does not exhibit a discontinuous bang-bang structure, making the problem well-suited for numerical solutions. It is indeed the case that both direct and indirect methods converge rapidly to the solution allowing the creation of large databases of optimal trajectories in short times, a property largely utilized in [ 1 , 6 , 2 ] . Considering indirect methods, a shooting-based method will then guess values for the initial mass and co-states and integrate numerically the augmented dynamics trying to solve for the following shooting function 1 1 1 The exact details of the shooting function will change depending on the actual boundary manifolds considered for which transversality conditions may apply. Here we show the case of a fixed starting state \bm{x_{0}} and fixed final state \bm{x_{f}} . : F(\bm{\lambda}_{0},m_{0})=[\bm{x}(t_{f})-\bm{x}_{f},\lambda_{m}(t_{f})]=\bm{0} (10) which is a well-posed root finding problem, with seven equations and seven unknowns. Minimum time problem To later demonstrate the strong relationship of the maximum-initial-mass problem to the minimum-time problem we now consider the classical minimum-time low-thrust trajectory optimization problem, under the

Read the complete text