Direct Causation in International Humanitarian Law and the Challenge of AI-Mediated Civilian Cyber Operations

Alice Saito, Harold Godsoe, Phan Xuan Tan · 2026

Read Direct Causation in International Humanitarian Law and the Challenge of AI-Mediated Civilian Cyber Operations by Alice Saito, Harold Godsoe, Phan Xuan Tan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-29175.txt.

Introduction

Saito, Godsoe and Tan examine a gap in international humanitarian law opened by civilians using autonomous AI cyber systems. The law protects civilians unless they take direct part in hostilities. The Red Cross's 2009 guidance tests this with three criteria, one being direct causation: harm must follow in one causal step from the act.

That standard, the authors argue, fails for AI-mediated operations. When a civilian fields an autonomous multi-agent cyber system, harm comes from system decisions made after the human disengages. It is not one causal step away. The fallback integral-part test also fails, because it assumes downstream human contributors whose conduct can be classified. The framework thus treats such deployments as indirect participation, against its own purpose. The authors identify goal-specification granularity, how detailed the human's instructions are, as the hidden pivot of the test. They classify operations on a five-level spectrum.

Catalog record

CREATORAlice Saito, Harold Godsoe, Phan Xuan Tan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.29175

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Direct Causation in International Humanitarian Law and the Challenge of AI-Mediated Civilian Cyber Operations Alice Saito, Harold Godsoe, Phan Xuan Tan Abstract International humanitarian law protects civilians from direct attack unless and for such time as they take direct part in hostilities, with the ICRC’s 2009 Interpretive Guidance operationalising this rule through a three-criterion cumulative test. This paper argues that AI-mediated civilian cyber operations challenge the direct causation element of this test in a structurally specific way: when a civilian deploys an autonomous multi-agent cyber system of the kind recently demonstrated in offensive AI research, the “one causal step” standard fails because harm is produced by system-generated decisions made after human disengagement, and the integral-part requirement does not extend because it presupposes downstream human contributors whose conduct can be independently classified. The framework therefore defaults to treating such deployments as indirect participation, in tension with its purpose of capturing civilians who personally take part in hostilities. Beyond the doctrinal analysis, this paper identifies goal-specification granularity as the property on which the integral-part test’s concreteness component implicitly turns, classifies AI-mediated operations along a five-level spectrum, and argues that existing technical AI governance instruments do not log or report this property. 1 Introduction The principle of distinction is the requirement that parties to an armed conflict distinguish at all times between civilians and combatants and direct attacks only against the latter. This is one of the foundational rules of international humanitarian law. As 12 observes, this principle is “right at the centre of international humanitarian law” and the material from which many of its rules are made. The direct participation in hostilities doctrine is the mechanism through which distinction operates for individual civilians: civilians are protected from direct attack unless and for such time as they take a direct part in hostilities (AP I, Art. 51(3); AP II, Art. 13(3)). When the doctrine functions well, it provides a shared classification scheme through which parties with deeply conflicting interests can coordinate on restraint. Each side refrains from targeting civilians in the expectation that the other side will do the same, and the classification of who counts as a civilian participant is stable enough to sustain this coordination even under conditions of distrust. This paper shows that a specific class of AI-mediated cyber conduct breaks this coordination by severing the causal link the doctrine relies on to identify participants, and it isolates the measurable system property responsible for the break. The ICRC’s 2009 Interpretive Guidance ( 13 ) operationalises the DPH rule through a three-criterion cumulative test: threshold of harm, direct causation, and belligerent nexus. The threshold of harm concerns the act’s likely effects; the belligerent nexus concerns its purpose in supporting one party against another. This paper focuses exclusively on the direct causation criterion, the requirement that a sufficiently close causal link exist between the civilian’s act and the resulting harm. The choice to focus on direct causation reflects the structural importance of this element: where the threshold of harm and belligerent nexus criteria are concerned with the character and purpose of an act, direct causation is concerned with the relationship between the civilian’s act and the harm it produces. This relationship is where AI-mediated cyber operations create the most distinctive doctrinal pressure. This paper argues that AI-mediated civilian cyber operations, as emerging in the Russia–Ukraine conflict and foreshadowed by recent offensive AI research, are actively challenging the direct causation element of the DPH framework. The argument proceeds through three scenarios spanning a range of human causal involvement: an actor using a language model to draft attack tools, a hacktivist running an agentic exploitation framework under per-action human approval, and a hacktivist deploying an autonomous multi-agent exploitation system after configuration only. The first two cases fit within the framework’s existing logic. The third does not: the “one causal step” standard fails, the integral-part requirement does not extend across the human–machine boundary, and the framework’s default classification places the conduct alongside scientific research and weapons production, a result substantively in tension with the framework’s purpose. The direct causation strain carries a further consequence. Because the framework cannot identify the participatory act, the “for such time as” temporal boundary has nothing to anchor on and breaks down in turn. The underlying source of the strain is structural: the framework’s doctrinal tools all presuppose identifiable human actors downstream of the civilian’s act whose conduct the framework can classify, and AI-mediated cyber operations remove those actors. This paper does not attempt a full treatment of the threshold of harm, belligerent nexus, or possible governance proposals. Those issues are left for further work. The paper makes three contributions. First, a doctrinal analysis showing that the direct causation element of DPH fails in a structurally specific way for autonomous multi-agent deployments. Second, identification of goal-specification granularity, how much of the operative decision-making is fixed at the moment the human configures and launches the system, as the property on which the integral-part test’s concreteness component implicitly depends. Third, an assessment of existing technical AI governance instruments against this property, showing that none log or report it even though downstream legal classification requires it. Beyond the doctrinal analysis, this work localises precisely where the doctrine requires updating as autonomous systems proliferate: the concreteness component of the integral-part test cannot function without a measure of how much operative content the human fixed at configuration. The remainder of the paper is organised as follows. Section 2 presents the IHL legal framework and Section 3 presents the empirical context of civilian cyber participation and AI capabilities in offensive cyber. Section 4 describes three scenarios of AI-mediated civilian cyber conduct. Section 5 applies the direct causation framework to these scenarios and identifies the structural strain. Section 6 introduces goal-specification granularity as a measurement construct and assesses existing technical AI governance instruments against it. Section 7 discusses consequences for the principle of distinction. Section 8 concludes. 2 The Legal Framework 2.1 The Principle of Distinction and the DPH Exception Under international humanitarian law (IHL), the body of law governing armed conflicts, civilians are protected from direct attack unless and for such time as they take a direct part in hostilities (AP I, Art. 51(3); AP II, Art. 13(3)). The principle of distinction is the requirement that parties to an armed conflict distinguish at all times between combatants and civilians, and can only directly attack combatants. This is one of the foundational rules of IHL, and the protection of civilians from direct attack is its central operational consequence. The Direct Participation in Hostilities (DPH) doctrine is the mechanism through which IHL determines when an individual civilian forfeits this protection. Two definitions are prerequisites to applying this framework. The first is hostilities, defined as the collective resort by parties to a conflict to means and methods of injuring the enemy ( 13 , p. 43) . The second is direct participation, which refers to the specific involvement of an individual in acts of hostility, as distinct from the general conduct of war. 2.2 The ICRC Three-Criterion Test The ICRC’s Interpretive Guidance ( 13 ) operationalised this provision into a three-part cumulative test. The first constitutive element is the threshold of harm. The act must be likely to adversely

Read the complete text