The Contagion Tensor: A Framework for Measuring Output-Distribution Coupling in Multi-Agent LLM Systems —and Auditing the Claims It Enables
Zewen Liu · 2026
Read The Contagion Tensor: A Framework for Measuring Output-Distribution Coupling in Multi-Agent LLM Systems —and Auditing the Claims It Enables by Zewen Liu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-28839.txt.
Introduction
Liu introduces a measurement framework for tracking how the outputs of many interacting language models influence each other. His Contagion Tensor records how output distributions couple across three axes: modalities such as text and image, the agents involved, and time steps. From it he derives the Coupling Amplification Factor, a unitless ratio comparing coupling under a test condition against a baseline, reported with bootstrap confidence intervals.
Four variants measure network, cross-modal, temporal and full-axis coupling. In simulations, an apparent super-linear image effect largely vanished when the image perturbation module was switched off, showing the ablation could separate real coupling from design artefacts. Real tests through commercial model services told a mixed story. With uniform personas, text coupling sat near baseline in both model families tested, while mixed personas pushed toward convergence. On one model, real vision input produced clearly stronger coupling than text, matching the simulation's prediction.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zewen Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.28839
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Contagion Tensor: A Framework for Measuring Output-Distribution Coupling in Multi-Agent LLM Systems —and Auditing the Claims It Enables Zewen Liu Abstract We introduce the Contagion Tensor ( 𝔗 ∈ ℝ M × N × T \mathfrak{T}\in\mathbb{R}^{M\times N\times T} ), a measurement framework for quantifying how large language model (LLM) output distributions couple across modalities ( M M ), agents ( N N ), and time steps ( T T ). From the tensor we derive the Coupling Amplification Factor (CAF), a family of ratio-based metrics that share the form CAF = 𝔼 [ 𝔗 condition ] / 𝔼 [ 𝔗 baseline ] \text{CAF}=\mathbb{E}[\mathfrak{T}_{\text{condition}}]/\mathbb{E}[\mathfrak{T}_{\text{baseline}}] . CAF provides a unitless, baseline-referenced measurement with bootstrap confidence intervals, applicable to any multi-agent configuration for which agent output distributions can be discretized. We instantiate CAF in four variants—network ( CAF net \text{CAF}_{\text{net}} ), cross-modal ( CAF cross \text{CAF}_{\text{cross}} ), temporal ( CAF temp \text{CAF}_{\text{temp}} ), and full-axis reference ( CAF base \text{CAF}_{\text{base}} )—each replacing a previously conflicting Γ \Gamma symbol from prior work. The strongest variant ( CAF base \text{CAF}_{\text{base}} ) is evaluated in a complete 2 × 2 × 2 2\times 2\times 2 block-orthogonal simulation design with a modality-specific ablation. The ablation reveals that an apparent image-condition super-linear effect ( CAF = 1.40 \text{CAF}=1.40 ) collapses to sub-linear ( CAF = 0.87 \text{CAF}=0.87 ) when the image perturbation module is disabled, a shift of − 0.53 -0.53 with zero effect on text conditions. We supplement the simulation with real-API experiments across two model families: DeepSeek-Chat ( R = 30 R=30 , both uniform and diverse personas) and GPT-4o-mini ( R = 15 R=15 , within-model, real vision). Under uniform personas, text-only BOUNDARY_SYNC produces CAF ≈ 1.0 \text{CAF}\approx 1.0 in both models. Diverse personas drive convergence (CAF = 0.88). A within-model comparison on GPT-4o-mini reveals: C3 (text) CAF = 1.02 \text{CAF}=1.02 vs. C5 (real vision, R = 30 R=30 ) CAF = 1.72 \text{CAF}=1.72 [1.700, 1.733], Δ = + 0.70 \Delta=+0.70 , validating the simulation’s super-linear image-condition prediction. Of 11 conditions, 5 have been tested on real APIs and 6 remain unverified. Our contribution is two-layered: (1) at the measurement-instrument level, the CAF family—a baseline-referenced, unitless ratio that makes output-distribution coupling quantitatively falsifiable for the first time; and (2) at the methodology level, a transferable ablation protocol that any modular multi-agent simulator can adopt to distinguish genuine coupling effects from design artifacts. The framework, the protocol, and the audit together provide the tools and standards the field currently lacks. 1 Introduction When multiple LLMs interact—as chatbot ensembles, retrieval-augmented systems, or agent-based social simulations—their output distributions evolve through repeated exchange. A bias in one agent can propagate across the network, coupling outputs in ways that single-model benchmarks cannot capture [ 1 , 2 ] . Yet the community lacks a reusable measurement framework for this phenomenon. We have single-model bias probes (BBQ [ 5 ] , StereoSet [ 6 ] ) and qualitative multi-agent case studies [ 1 ] , but no principled metric to answer questions like: how much does adding a second modality amplify coupling? Does memory increase temporal persistence? Can a calibration run on conditions A–D guarantee valid measurements on conditions E–H? This paper provides the metric, the measurement protocol, and the audit. The framework. We define the Contagion Tensor \mathfrak{T}\in\mathbb{R}^{M\times N\times T} , where each cell \mathfrak{T}[m,n,t]=\operatorname{D}_{\text{JS}}(w_{n,t}^{m}\|w_{0}) is the Jensen-Shannon divergence of an agent’s output distribution from a uniform reference. From the tensor we derive the Coupling Amplification Factor (CAF), a family of ratio-based metrics that all share the same form—condition over baseline—but differ in which axis they perturb (Table 1 ). This unification replaces four conflicting \Gamma symbols across our prior work with a single notation. The strongest case. We instantiate \text{CAF}_{\text{base}} in a 2\times 2\times 2 full-factorial simulation (modality \times agent-count \times timestep-count). Under default parameters, image conditions appear super-linear ( \text{CAF}_{\text{image}}=1.40 ) while text conditions are sub-linear ( \text{CAF}_{\text{text}}=0.84 )—superficially, a modality-driven bifurcation. We then disable the single module that differentiates image from text in the simulator. All four image conditions collapse from super-linear to sub-linear ( \Delta=-0.53 ); text conditions are untouched. The “bifurcation” is an artifact. The audit. We compile a verification completeness table (Table 11 ), reporting the empirical status of every CAF variant. Of 11 conditions, 5 have been tested on real APIs across two model families with functional BOUNDARY_SYNC communication and controlled personas (C3u and C8u at R=15 , C3d at R=30 , C5 at R=30 ). Under these controlled conditions, both C3 and C8u converge to \text{CAF}\approx 1.0 , indicating that functional BOUNDARY_SYNC communication alone—without persona diversity—does not measurably alter output-distribution coupling relative to isolation. The previously reported sign reversal (C3 from 0.877 to 3.300 at R=5 ) was a small-sample noise artefact. We document this resolution not to minimize the earlier gap but to demonstrate that CAF, when measured at adequate repetitions with controlled confounds, converges to the theory-expected value. What this paper is. It is two things at different levels. At the measurement-instrument level, it is a framework that makes output-distribution coupling quantitatively falsifiable for the first time. At the methodology level, it is a transferable ablation protocol that any modular multi-agent simulator can adopt to distinguish genuine coupling effects from design artifacts. It is not a claim of emergent behavior. It is built on the premise that making a phenomenon measurable—and providing the tools to audit those measurements—is a scientific contribution, even when the first measurements reveal more about the instruments than about the phenomenon. 2 Related Work Multi-agent LLM systems. Generative agents [ 1 ] , multi-agent debate [ 3 ] , and negotiation [ 4 ] demonstrate emergent social dynamics but measure task performance, not output-distribution coupling. Frameworks including MetaGPT [ 23 ] , CAMEL [ 24 ] , and AutoGen [ 25 ] provide engineering infrastructure for multi-agent workflows but offer no standardized coupling metric. Agent-based modeling textbooks provide simulation methodology [ 11 ] but no coupling metric. Our CAF is orthogonal: it quantifies how much outputs couple, independent of task success. LLM bias evaluation. Single-model bias probes—BBQ [ 5 ] , StereoSet [ 6 ] , Winogender [ 7 ] , and broader safety benchmarks [ 2 ] —measure static distributional disparities. Information-theoretic diversity measures for text generation [ 8 ] quantify output variety but not inter-agent coupling. CAF fills the gap between single-model bias measurement and multi-agent dynamics. Simulation artifact detection. Verification and validation of simulation models has a long history [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] . Standard protocols (ODD [ 12 ] ) require design documentation but do not prescribe module-specific ablation. Our modality-ablation protocol provides a concrete, transferable procedure applicable to any multi-agent LLM simulator with independently toggleable modules. Network contagion and spectral methods. Threshold models [ 13 ] and spectral epidemiology [ 14 ] model propagation in networks. JSD has been used as a divergence measure in multi-agent settings [ 15 ] but not as the basis for a coupling ratio. \text{CAF}_{\text{net}} bridges spectral radius to distributional coupling via a mean-field mapping (see §4.2, Table 1 ). Multi-agent coupling metrics. Several recent frameworks target dynamics and coupling in multi-agent LLM systems from complementary angles. CASPIAN monitors causal