UV completion of 2D Ising CFT: a golden E 8 E_{8} massless S S -matrix

Changrim Ahn †, Minkyoo Kim ♯,♭ · 2026

Read UV completion of 2D Ising CFT: a golden E 8 E_{8} massless S S -matrix by Changrim Ahn †, Minkyoo Kim ♯,♭ (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-28783.txt.

Introduction

Ahn and Kim classify the possible high-energy completions of the two-dimensional Ising model, a classic lattice model of magnetism, viewed as a conformal field theory. A completion means a fuller theory at short distances that settles into the Ising behaviour at larger scales. They solve bootstrap equations, consistency conditions that any scattering description must satisfy, for massless particles moving left and right.

For the version carrying the exceptional E8 symmetry pattern, they find exactly four completions. The four arise from a family of deformations, among them a golden flow not known before, whose short-distance fixed point is a coset theory built from a simple symmetry group. A shared Fibonacci and E8 structure runs through the adjacency patterns and the period patterns of the system across all scales, so the symmetry persists from the shortest distances to the largest.

Catalog record

CREATORChangrim Ahn †, Minkyoo Kim ♯,♭
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.28783

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

UV completion of 2D Ising CFT: a golden E 8 E_{8} massless S S -matrix Changrim Ahn †, Minkyoo Kim ♯,♭ Abstract We present a full classification of UV complete QFTs that RG flow to the 2D Ising CFT by solving the bootstrap equations for massless right–left S S -matrices. For the Ising model with E 8 E_{8} spectrum we find exactly four completions, arising from higher- T ​ T ¯ T\bar{T} -type deformations, including a previously unknown “golden flow” whose UV fixed point is a diagonal s ​ u ​ ( 2 ) su(2) coset CFT ( c = 25 / 14 c=25/14 ) along Δ rel = 2 / 7 \Delta_{\rm rel}=2/7 . A universal Fibonacci/ E 8 E_{8} structure governs the R–L adjacency matrices and the Y Y -system periods, so that the E 8 E_{8} symmetry persists across all RG scales. I Introduction The two-dimensional (2D) Ising conformal field theory (CFT) is one of the most fundamental building blocks of string theories as well as many other applications. Our prime goal is to find a complete list of UV CFTs and deformations which RG flow into the 2D Ising CFT in terms of concrete S -matrices based on the integrability. For this purpose, we need to find all exact S -matrices which can describe the Ising CFT in the IR limit and irrelevant deformations. A systematic approach was proposed in AhnLeClair2022 where the RG flows are constructed by S -matrices between massless particles describing the IR theory. In the massless limit, the excitations split into right (R) and left (L) movers. The right–right (R–R) and left–left (L–L) S -matrix amplitudes are the same as those of the massively deformed IR CFT. Deforming an integrable field theory by the irrelevant fields built from the higher T\bar{T} -type conserved charges generates CDD-like scalar factors in the massive S -matrices SmirnovZam ; CNST . These factors contribute the right–left (R–L) and left–right (L–R) S -matrices in the massless limit AhnLeClair2022 . Thermodynamic Bethe ansatz (TBA) equations derived from these amplitudes identify UV complete theories connected to the IR CFT by the RG flows. The 2D Ising CFT can maintain integrability upon two particular deformations. Deformed by the energy operator, this is described by a massive free Majorana fermion. Using this simple S -matrix, one can still compute various interesting correlation functions. The other deformation is obtained by the magnetic spin operator. This integrable field theory is given by the Zamolodchikov’s celebrated S -matrix with eight self-conjugate particles, whose masses are given by the Perron-Frobenius eigenvector of the E_{8} symmetry Zam1989 . Some of these excitations have been experimentally observed with a golden mass ratio m_{2}/m_{1}=2\cos(\pi/5)=\varphi Coldea2010 . The Ising CFT is thus described by two distinct massless theories, the free-fermion one and the E_{8} one, recovered as the massless (conformal) limits of the two massive deformations. For the free-fermion one with the (R–R) and (L–L) S -matrices -1 , the R–L S -matrices that generate RG flows into the tricritical Ising CFT with c=7/10 alyosha or N=1 supersymmetric CFTs with c=3/2 akrz ; andre have been previously found. Our main interest is to represent the Isng CFT as a scattering theory of the eight particles in the massless limit m_{1}\to 0 while maintaining the mass ratios m_{a}/m_{1} , which are proportional to the E_{8} Perron-Frobenius eigenvector elements. While the (R–R) and (L–L) amplitudes are the same as Zamolodchikov’s S -matrix, explicit expressions of the (R–L) and (L–R) S -matrices have been missing. Although a previous study found three UV completions—diagonal, minimal, and saturated—without explicit S -matrices, complete analysis of the RG flows is not available AhnLeClair2022 . For the minimal case, a conjectured TBA proposed in ravanini remains unproven. Our result in this letter provides not only explicit S -matrices and TBAs for these three cases but also discovers one additional UV completion, the “golden”. We also find a universal relation based on the E_{8} symmetry that connects all these four. For a full classification, we need to find complete solutions of the massless bootstrap equations which have been used in A_{n} scattering theories Ahn2025 . As a summary, we (i) construct the finite positive R–L amplitudes satisfying the bootstrap and saturation bound which generate not only the three UV completions but also the new “golden” solution; (ii) derive its TBA/ Y -system by inversion relations and read off the UV central charge and the relevant deforming field; (iii) identify the golden UV candidate as the diagonal coset (su(2)_{5}\times su(2)_{5})/su(2)_{10} from this TBA data and its \Delta=2/7 operator content, checked against the genuine affine-branching spectrum; and (iv) check the relevant massless Y -system periods by exact integer/tropical Y -pattern computations. Table 1: Complete R–L amplitude tables of the minimal and golden completions ( a\leq b , S_{ba}=S_{ab} ), S_{ab}=\prod_{p}[p]^{\,n_{ab}(p)} with the shorthand [p]\equiv F_{p}(\theta) for compactness. The exponents define the matrices n(p) used below. minimal golden minimal golden S_{11} [1][11] [7][13] S_{36} [5][7]^{2}[9][11][13]^{2}[15] [1][3][5][7]^{2}[9]^{2}[11]^{3}[13]^{3}[15] S_{12} [7][13] [1][7][11][13] S_{37} [3][5][7][9]^{2}[11]^{2}[13]^{2}[15] [3][5]^{2}[7]^{2}[9]^{3}[11]^{3}[13]^{3}[15]^{2} S_{13} [2][10][12] [6][8][12][14] S_{38} [4][6]^{2}[8]^{2}[10]^{2}[12]^{2}[14]^{3} [2][4]^{2}[6]^{2}[8]^{3}[10]^{4}[12]^{4}[14]^{4} S_{14} [6][10][14] [4][8][10][12][14] S_{44} [1][5][7][9][11]^{2}[13][15] [3][5][7]^{2}[9]^{2}[11]^{2}[13]^{3}[15] S_{15} [3][9][11][13] [5][7][9][11][13][15] S_{45} [4][6][8]^{2}[10][12]^{2}[14]^{2} [2][4][6]^{2}[8]^{2}[10]^{3}[12]^{3}[14]^{3} S_{16} [6][8][12][14] [2][6][8][10][12]^{2}[14] S_{46} [3][5][7][9]^{2}[11]^{2}[13]^{2}[15] [3][5]^{2}[7]^{2}[9]^{3}[11]^{3}[13]^{3}[15]^{2} S_{17} [4][8][10][12][14] [4][6][8][10]^{2}[12][14]^{2} S_{47} [3][5][7]^{2}[9]^{2}[11]^{2}[13]^{3}[15] [1][3][5]^{2}[7]^{3}[9]^{3}[11]^{4}[13]^{4}[15]^{2} S_{18} [5][7][9][11][13][15] [3][5][7][9]^{2}[11]^{2}[13]^{2}[15] S_{48} [2][4][6]^{2}[8]^{2}[10]^{3}[12]^{3}[14]^{3} [2][4]^{2}[6]^{3}[8]^{4}[10]^{4}[12]^{5}[14]^{5} S_{22} [1][7][11][13] [1][7]^{2}[11][13]^{2} S_{55} [1][3][5][7][9]^{2}[11]^{3}[13]^{2}[15] [3][5]^{2}[7]^{3}[9]^{3}[11]^{3}[13]^{4}[15]^{2} S_{23} [6][8][12][14] [2][6][8][10][12]^{2}[14] S_{56} [4][6]^{2}[8]^{2}[10]^{2}[12]^{2}[14]^{3} [2][4]^{2}[6]^{2}[8]^{3}[10]^{4}[12]^{4}[14]^{4} S_{24} [4][8][10][12][14] [4][6][8][10]^{2}[12][14]^{2} S_{57} [2][4][6]^{2}[8]^{2}[10]^{3}[12]^{3}[14]^{3} [2][4]^{2}[6]^{3}[8]^{4}[10]^{4}[12]^{5}[14]^{5} S_{25} [5][7][9][11][13][15] [3][5][7][9]^{2}[11]^{2}[13]^{2}[15] S_{58} [3][5]^{2}[7]^{3}[9]^{3}[11]^{3}[13]^{4}[15]^{2} [1][3]^{2}[5]^{3}[7]^{4}[9]^{5}[11]^{6}[13]^{6}[15]^{3} S_{26} [2][6][8][10][12]^{2}[14] [2][6]^{2}[8]^{2}[10][12]^{3}[14]^{2} S_{66} [1][3][5][7]^{2}[9]^{2}[11]^{3}[13]^{3}[15] [1][3][5]^{2}[7]^{4}[9]^{3}[11]^{4}[13]^{5}[15]^{2} S_{27} [4][6][8][10]^{2}[12][14]^{2} [4]^{2}[6][8]^{2}[10]^{3}[12]^{2}[14]^{3} S_{67} [3][5]^{2}[7]^{2}[9]^{3}[11]^{3}[13]^{3}[15]^{2} [3]^{2}[5]^{3}[7]^{3}[9]^{5}[11]^{5}[13]^{5}[15]^{3} S_{28} [3][5][7][9]^{2}[11]^{2}[13]^{2}[15] [3][5]^{2}[7]^{2}[9]^{3}[11]^{3}[13]^{3}[15]^{2} S_{68} [2][4]^{2}[6]^{2}[8]^{3}[10]^{4}[12]^{4}[14]^{4} [2][4]^{3}[6]^{4}[8]^{5}[10]^{6}[12]^{6}[14]^{7} S_{33} [1][3][9][11]^{2}[13] [5][7]^{2}[9][11][13]^{2}[15] S_{77} [1][3][5]^{2}[7]^{3}[9]^{3}[11]^{4}[13]^{4}[15]^{2} [1][3]^{2}[5]^{3}[7]^{5}[9]^{5}[11]^{6}[13]^{7}[15]^{3} S_{34} [5][7][9][11][13][15] [3][5][7][9]^{2}[11]^{2}[13]^{2}[15] S_{78} [2][4]^{2}[6]^{3}[8]^{4}[10]^{4}[12]^{5}[14]^{5} [2]^{2}[4]^{3}[6]^{5}[8]^{6}[10]^{7}[12]^{8}[14]^{8} S_{35} [2][4][8][10]^{2}[12]^{2}[14] [4][6]^{2}[8]^{2}[10]^{2}[12]^{2}[14]^{3} S_{88} [1][3]^{2}[5]^{3}[7]^{4}[9]^{5}[11]^{6}[13]^{6}[15]^{3} [1][3]^{3}[5]^{5}[7]^{7}[9]^{8}[11]^{9}[13]^{10}[15]^{5} II New solutions of the bootstrap The elementary CDD block can be expressed with F_{p}(\theta)\equiv\frac{\sinh\theta-i\sin(\pi p/30)}{\sinh\theta+i\sin(\pi p/30)},\qquad p\in\mathbb{Z}. (1) Each block is crossing-unitary, F_{p}(\theta)F_{p}(\theta+i\pi)=1 , and pole-free in the physical strip. Using F_{30-p}=F_{p} , F_{-p}=F_{p}^{-1} , F_{0}=F_{30}=1 , F_{p+60}=F_{p} , we can express every S -matrix element as a product of each F_{p} ( p=1,\cdots,15) with non-negative integer power n_{ab}(p) , S_{ab}=\prod_{p=1}^{15}F_{p}^{\,n_{ab}(p)} . Therefore, the (R–L) scatterings S_{ab} are essentially encoded in these exponents n_{ab}(p) . We find all possible solutions n_{ab} from the bootstrap equations along the following three steps. (1) Fix S_{11} . The self-fusion A_{1}A_{1}\to A_{1} gives the first bootstrap equation S_{11}(\theta)=S_{11}\left(\theta+\frac{i\pi}{3}\right)S_{11}\left(\theta-\frac{i\pi}{3}\right). (2) Each solution of this provides a seed to construct all other amplitudes. The saturation bound below limits the seeds to at most four F_{p} blocks. The new solutions already appear at two blocks: after full directed propagation, pole-free positivity, and the saturation bound, the surviving two-block seeds are the minimal F_{1}F_{11} and the new golden F_{7}F_{13} , while the saturated solution is the entrywise square (F_{1}F_{11})^{2} . The diagonal completion requires no search: its R–L amplitudes are the inverses of the massive E_{8} amplitudes, S^{\rm diag}_{ab}=\big(S^{E_{8}}_{ab}\big)^{-1} , which are pole-free in the physical strip and solve the same fusing equations, giving the seed F_{2}F_{10}F_{12} . (2) Generate all amplitudes from S_{11} . Each heavier particle is a bound state reached by an equal-mass fusion A_{a}A_{a}\to A_{c} , realized as a shift with the fusion angle \overline{u}^{a}_{ac} ; A_{1}A_{1}\to A_{2,3} with m=6,1 ; A_{2}A_{2}\to A_{4,5,6} with m=7,4,1 ; A_{3}A_{3}\to A_{7} with m=2 ; and A_{4}A_{4}\to A_{8} with m=1 (the complete fusion angle table is in the SM SM

Read the complete text