Stochastic Variability of Binary Accretion

Akhil Nair, Jonathan Zrake · 2026

Read Stochastic Variability of Binary Accretion by Akhil Nair, Jonathan Zrake (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-28499.txt.

Introduction

Akhil Nair and Jonathan Zrake listen to how a pair of black holes eats. An unequal-mass binary wrapped in a circumbinary gas disk feeds two smaller minidisks, and the total accretion rate flickers. Using very high-resolution two-dimensional simulations, the pair measure the flicker's power spectrum, hunting for a fingerprint that could reveal hidden supermassive black hole binaries.

The continuum spectrum is a broken power law: flat at low frequencies, then falling steeply past a break at about five times the orbital frequency. Nair and Zrake trace the shape to gas delivery behaving as a damped random walk, filtered again by each minidisk. Oversized numerical sinks manufacture fake high-frequency spikes, they warn. The shape resembles ordinary active-galaxy variability, raising the conjecture that binarity is widespread, though pulsar timing may rule that out.

Catalog record

CREATORAkhil Nair, Jonathan Zrake
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.28499

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Stochastic Variability of Binary Accretion Akhil Nair, Jonathan Zrake Abstract We measure the power spectral density (PSD) of the accretion rate time series in an unequal mass ( q = 0.2 q=0.2 ) binary surrounded by a circumbinary gas disk, using very high-resolution 2D hydrodynamics simulations. Our aim is to identify new signposts of supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries in active galactic nuclei (AGN), based on the shape of the continuum PSD, to complement well-studied line features in the PSD (periodicities). We find that the continuum PSD is a broken power-law, transitioning from flat (white noise) to a slope of − 4 -4 at a break frequency generically ∼ 5 \sim 5 times the binary orbital frequency. This form is expected when (a) delivery of gas from the circumbinary disk to the individual “minidisks” is a damped random walk with correlation time equal to binary orbital period and (b) the minidisks function as low-pass filters acting at the Kepler frequency of the outer edge of the smaller black hole’s minidisk; we show numerical evidence for both. The broken power-law PSD is attained in a limit where the secondary black hole is much smaller than its minidisk, realized numerically by a sufficiently small “sink” region; larger sinks lead to excess high-frequency noise seen as accretion rate spikes, and we argue these should be regarded as artificial when the black holes themselves are smaller than the sink regions. The broken power-law PSD is reminiscent of stochastic variability in ordinary AGN, inviting the conjecture that canonical AGN variability could result from widespread binarity, however pulsar timing experiments may exclude this possibility. show][email protected] I Introduction Supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries are an expected consequence of hierarchical galaxy formation. When two massive galaxies merge, gravitational torques channel gas and stars toward the nuclear region ( 36 ) , and the central black holes sink toward a common center through dynamical friction and stellar scattering, eventually forming a gravitationally bound pair ( 5 ; 37 ) . These systems are expected to be common at sub-parsec separations, and their study stands to significantly increase understanding of cosmic structure formation, the environments of galactic centers, and the production of low-frequency gravitational waves now evidenced by pulsar timing arrays ( 1 ) . Yet they remain observationally elusive. Sub-parsec binaries cannot be spatially resolved with current instruments, and the most widely pursued temporal signpost, quasi-periodic flux modulation at or near the binary orbital frequency ( 10 ; 29 ; 12 ) , is complicated by the intrinsically stochastic nature of AGN light curves ( 34 ; 52 ; 40 ) . Apparent periodicity must be carefully distinguished from red noise fluctuations ( 54 ; 57 ) , and periodicity searches are limited to orbital periods sufficiently shorter than the survey baseline, typically of order a decade, which excludes the vast majority of the expected sub-parsec population ( 24 , e.g.) , whose orbital periods extend to 10^{3}\,\mathrm{yr} . Moreover, even for binaries within the accessible period range, periodogram recovery rates drop dramatically for the non-sinusoidal (e.g. sawtooth) pulse shapes predicted by hydrodynamic simulations ( 30 ) . These limitations motivate theoretical exploration of temporal signposts of binary SMBH pairs, beyond periodic brightness variations of the host nucleus. Gas accretion in binary systems is inherently variable and intermittent, including on timescales much shorter than the binary orbital period. This raises the possibility that binary AGN could exhibit stochastic variability signatures with a distinct character from that of single AGN. In this paper we use hydrodynamics simulations to quantify the stochastic variability of black hole mass accretion rates arising uniquely from the chaotic circumbinary gas flows. We focus on sub-orbital timescales, aiming to identify a signpost of long-period SMBH binaries that could be revealed in high-cadence optical surveys such as the Vera C. Rubin Observatory LSST ( 25 ) . Specifically, we measure the overall amplitude and shape of the continuum 1 1 1 By “continuum” we mean the part of the PSD aside from periodicities (which would then be analogous to “lines” in an emission spectrum). Throughout this paper “accretion rate” refers to the joint time series \dot{M}_{1,2} of both the primary and secondary components. part of the accretion rate power spectral density (PSD): does it exhibit power-law scaling in frequency? Are there characteristic break frequencies? What is the rms variability on timescales much shorter than the orbital period? We hope to reveal ways in which the continuum PSD differs from the canonical red-noise spectrum of AGN ( 31 ; 26 ) . The literature contains numerous studies based on simulations of binary accretion to characterize quasi-periodic features of the accretion rate time series. For nearly equal mass circular binaries, the dominant low-frequency modulation is the “lump”, an m=1 overdensity at the inner edge of the circumbinary disk that orbits at \sim 0.2\,\Omega_{\rm bin} ( 32 ; 47 ; 21 ; 19 ; 16 ; 14 ) . Power at the orbital frequency and its harmonics is also present, varying in amplitude with mass ratio. Quasi-periodic variability has also been seen in 3D GRMHD simulations associated with “sloshing” mass exchange between the minidisks at frequencies near the binary orbital period ( 4 ) , and 2D simulations show that the minidisks themselves can develop eccentricity and collide with one another at roughly the orbital period ( 56 ) . In eccentric prograde binaries with e\gtrsim 0.1 , the dominant modulation occurs at the binary orbital frequency ( 60 ; 18 ; 55 ; 17 ) . In contrast, the continuum of the PSD remains largely uncharacterized, particularly at super-orbital frequencies, thus novel measurements can be made within a simple physical setup. For our simulations in this first study on the subject, we assume the disk is thin and the dynamics are predominantly coplanar. We use a locally isothermal equation of state with orbital Mach number \mathcal{M}=10 . This comes at the expense of being unable to compute emission spectra; we thus use accretion rates onto the component black holes as proxies for bolometric luminosity, which we believe is reasonable given that in a thin, radiatively efficient disk the thermal emission is expected to roughly track \dot{M} , especially at photon energies at and above optical-UV ( 55 , e.g.) . Disk internal stresses, nominally associated with unresolved MHD turbulence, are modeled using the Shakura-Sunyaev \alpha prescription ( \alpha=0.01 ). We exclude magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), isolating the variability signal induced by binary accretion from variability associated with temporal fluctuations of the MRI stresses ( 31 ) . In this paper we also systematically explore the role of sink size , a parameter that determines the inner truncation radii of the minidisks. Sink size can be loosely interpreted as the radii of the black holes’ innermost stable circular orbits (ISCOs). For a binary system where the separation a is much greater than the gravitational radius r_{g}\equiv GM_{\rm bin}/c^{2} (with M_{\rm bin} denoting the binary mass throughout), computational feasibility may require the numerical sink size to be significantly larger than the physical ISCO size, in which case the sink size must be regarded as a numerical parameter; its choice might thus influence measurements such as the component accretion rate time series. We characterize

Read the complete text