When May I Help You? On The Effect of Proactivity on Group Human-Robot Collaboration
Thomas Vitry, Vanessa Maeder, Kieran Edgeworth, Asihati Hazaiti, Doga Deniz Ates, Connor Gäde, Jan-Gerrit Habekost, Dennis Becker, Stefan Wermter · 2026
Read When May I Help You? On The Effect of Proactivity on Group Human-Robot Collaboration by Thomas Vitry, Vanessa Maeder, Kieran Edgeworth, Asihati Hazaiti, Doga Deniz Ates, Connor Gäde, Jan-Gerrit Habekost, Dennis Becker, Stefan Wermter (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-28469.txt.
Introduction
Thomas Vitry and eight colleagues ask when a robot should speak up. In group work, a proactive robot can offer help at the right moment, or can interrupt, split attention, and wreck turn-taking. A reactive robot protects human control but may watch a team struggle past chances to assist.
Vitry's team placed pairs of participants in a collaborative escape room with a humanoid robot, either reactive, answering only when addressed, or proactive, listening continuously and re-initiating on its own. The proactive robot multiplied interaction frequency, yet the reactive groups finished with a descriptively higher success rate, about ninety-three percent against seventy-one. Prior experience mattered: participants seasoned with language models solved early puzzles faster with the reactive robot, and robot experience and introversion reshaped how each style was judged.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thomas Vitry, Vanessa Maeder, Kieran Edgeworth, Asihati Hazaiti, Doga Deniz Ates, Connor Gäde, Jan-Gerrit Habekost, Dennis Becker, Stefan Wermter |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.28469
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
When May I Help You? On The Effect of Proactivity on Group Human-Robot Collaboration Thomas Vitry, Vanessa Maeder, Kieran Edgeworth, Asihati Hazaiti, Doga Deniz Ates, Connor Gäde, Jan-Gerrit Habekost, Dennis Becker, Stefan Wermter Abstract Robot initiative is a central challenge in multi-party human-robot collaboration. A robot that contributes without being addressed may provide timely support, but it may also disrupt coordination, divide attention, or interrupt turn-taking; a robot that waits to be addressed may preserve human control, but it may also miss opportunities to assist. We investigate this design challenge in a collaborative escape room in which pairs of participants work with a humanoid robot under either a reactive interaction model, where the robot responds only when addressed, or a proactive model, where it listens continuously, contributes autonomously, and periodically re-initiates interaction. We evaluate both models using puzzle-solving performance, interaction frequency, and participant ratings on the Godspeed and RoSAS scales. The proactive model substantially increases interaction frequency, whereas the reactive model shows a descriptively higher overall success rate (92.86% vs. 71.42%). The strongest differences emerge when prior experience and personality are taken into account: participants with LLM experience solve the early puzzles faster in the reactive condition, and participants with prior robot experience show modified evaluations of proactive and reactive interaction as do introverted participants. These findings demonstrate that the effects of robot initiative are simultaneously shaped by users’ prior experience, personality traits and more generally by the needs of the group. I Introduction As robots take on more collaborative roles, their contributions to an interaction depend on what they do, when they act, and how they act [ 15 , 16 ] . In shared activities, successful human-robot interaction depends on both joint task completion and the robot contributing at appropriate moments without disrupting coordination between partners. These challenges become especially important in multi-party settings, where a robot must balance helpfulness with the risk of interrupting or distracting human collaborators [ 16 , 26 ] . These coordination demands make robot initiative a central challenge in collaborative human-robot interaction [ 15 , 16 ] . A robot that waits to be addressed may preserve human control, but it may also miss opportunities to support the task. A robot that contributes on its own may help maintain progress, but it may also interrupt, overstep, or change how the interaction is experienced [ 33 , 27 , 18 ] . This tension becomes even more apparent for language-enabled robots, whose contributions are conveyed not only through physical action but also through language and dialogue, making them more visible as both task support and social behavior [ 6 , 1 , 2 ] . The central research question in this work is how a robot should participate in multi-party collaboration: by following a reactive interaction style and waiting to be addressed, or by taking a more proactive role and contributing on its own. This question is investigated in a collaborative escape room scenario in which pairs of participants interact with a humanoid robot assistant under time pressure and a shared goal, creating repeated opportunities for the robot either to wait for explicit requests or to contribute autonomously. Specifically, this study compares a reactive interaction model, in which the robot responds only when explicitly addressed, with a proactive model, in which it continuously listens, contributes more autonomously, and periodically re-initiates interaction. The study assesses how these interaction styles affect task performance, interaction behavior, and social perception of the robot. In doing so, it provides an empirical comparison of proactive and reactive interaction styles for a language-enabled robot in a multi-party cooperative human-robot setting and introduces a collaborative escape room setup for examining the effects of robot initiative in an interaction involving a human pair and a robot. II Background Human-robot interaction research increasingly examines robots as tools and collaborative partners whose timing, communication, and social behavior shape the quality of joint activities. In shared tasks, interaction quality depends on more than task completion alone; perceived fluency, coordination, and the robot’s ability to participate appropriately in a multi-person interaction are also central to user experience [ 15 , 16 , 26 ] . The interaction model, therefore becomes a key design variable in collaborative scenarios, especially when robots must balance helpful initiative with respect for human control. In addition to behavior, the social perception of these robot partners is also affected by the Uncanny Valley. According to this theory, the more a robot resembles a human, the more people feel warmer toward it; however, when the resemblance reaches a very high level, the imperfect small details of the robot create a feeling of discomfort or unease in people [ 23 ] . While it was previously thought that there was only one valley, new research shows that there may actually be two uncanny valleys. In particular, users can feel uncomfortable even at much lower levels of similarity when the robot’s appearance and social behavior do not match [ 20 ] . A main aspect of robot behavior in collaborative interaction is whether the robot takes initiative proactively or responds reactively. Prior work suggests that proactive support can assist task progression by anticipating user needs and taking initiative, but its effects are not uniformly positive [ 27 , 17 , 14 ] . Proactive behavior can improve coordination and reduce idle time. However, it also alters expectations regarding autonomy, assistance, and the division of control [ 33 , 18 ] . Its value therefore depends on the task context and users interpretation of it, rather than being universally beneficial [ 16 , 33 , 18 ] . This is relevant in collaborative team-based tasks, where timely support should not undermine the human partner’s sense of agency. Further work shows that individuals evaluate robots both socially and instrumentally. Social categorization can already shape these perceptions, as robots framed as in-group members are anthropomorphized more strongly and evaluated more positively [ 21 ] . Robot personality, gaze, facial expression, and conversation style further shape perceived likability, trust, engagement, and performance in interactions [ 11 , 6 , 25 ] . Personality cues can affect preference and trust, while gaze and facial expressions influence collaboration and perceived intelligence [ 3 , 22 , 12 ] . With language-enabled robots, these distinctions become even more important, as robot behavior is expressed through action timing and also through language, dialogue structure, and, in some systems, personality-consistent responses [ 13 , 6 , 1 ] . In parallel, LLMs can be grounded in robot capabilities and executable skills, enabling long-horizon embodied action from natural-language instructions [ 2 ] . These developments suggest that robots are increasingly experienced both as physical team members and as language-enabled social partners. Game-based and escape room-like settings provide a useful testbed for studying human-robot interaction under time pressure, coordination demands, and dialogue-rich collaboration. They have been used to examine engagement and collaborative dynamics in structured interactive tasks [ 10 , 25 , 7 ] . Prior research in these settings also examines trust, emotion, and interactional cues, including affective influences on performance and the effects of robot facial expressions and gaze in collaborative interaction [ 14 , 12 ] . However, much of this work tends