The Role of Scintillation in Detecting HI Absorption in FRB Spectra

Om Gupta, Pawan Kumar, Paz Beniamini, Edward L. Robinson · 2026

Read The Role of Scintillation in Detecting HI Absorption in FRB Spectra by Om Gupta, Pawan Kumar, Paz Beniamini, Edward L. Robinson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-28314.txt.

Introduction

Om Gupta, Pawan Kumar, Paz Beniamini, and Edward L. Robinson ask whether a long-predicted spectral feature could ever be seen in fast radio bursts, millisecond flashes from deep space. As a burst passes through neutral hydrogen, the gas should absorb at the famous twenty-one-centimeter line, but detector noise is not the only obstacle.

Gupta and colleagues model scintillation, the twinkling imposed when the burst crosses a thin scattering screen. Absorption stays detectable in a bright, scintillation-dominated spectrum when the twinkling's frequency scale differs clearly from the line's width. Repeating bursts help, provided they arrive far enough apart for the twinkling to reshuffle. One famous repeater's sightline may cross a Milky Way molecular cloud. Even so, current telescopes would need over a thousand stacked bursts for a firm detection.

Catalog record

CREATOROm Gupta, Pawan Kumar, Paz Beniamini, Edward L. Robinson
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.28314

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Role of Scintillation in Detecting HI Absorption in FRB Spectra Om Gupta, Pawan Kumar, Paz Beniamini, Edward L. Robinson Abstract The 21-cm absorption line of neutral hydrogen has been a long hypothesized observational feature of the spectra of Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs). The difficulties associated with detector noise in extracting HI absorption have been previously studied. We test the role that scintillation plays in the HI absorption line’s detectability, and characterize the regimes where a realistic FRB may yield the 21-cm line. We build an efficient model to simulate diffractive scintillation arising from FRB passage through a thin scattering screen. We find that the absorption profile is detectable in a scintillation-dominated high signal-to-noise spectrum if the scintillation decorrelation bandwidth differs significantly in scale from the width of the absorption profile. Active repeaters also enable favorable conditions as the absorption signal improves when repeat bursts are stacked. Repeat bursts must be separated in time by more than the diffractive scintillation timescale, otherwise flux modulations with frequency are correlated. By cross-referencing repeating FRB positions with an observational catalog of Milky Way molecular clouds detected in CO, we find that the sightline to FRB 20180916B may intersect a Galactic molecular cloud. For currently operating and planned sensitive telescopes, the presence of both scintillation and noise requires ≳ 1000 \gtrsim 1000 bursts to be stacked to detect the HI absorption line at a 5 ​ σ 5\sigma significance. Improvement in detector sensitivities will help probe HI clouds intersected by FRBs in the host or intervening galaxies, or in high-redshift minihalos. show][email protected] I Introduction Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) are highly energetic radio signals that are typically extragalactic in origin. They are detected ubiquitously across the sky and have been observed between 110 MHz - 8 GHz. The 21-cm (or 1.4 GHz) hyperfine transition of neutral hydrogen is one of the most well-known features of radio astronomy, which is seen both in emission as well as in absorption against background radio sources. Because FRBs are detected in the radio-band, the signals may pass through structures containing neutral hydrogen, located somewhere along the sight-line. Whether HI is observed in emission or absorption depends on the background radio signal. Since typical brightness temperatures for FRBs are 10^{36} K, HI hyperfine transitions will leave an absorption imprint on the FRB spectrum. There are a large number of molecular clouds, primarily in the disc of the Milky Way, which host cold HI gas along with molecular hydrogen ( 10 ) . Similarly, FRB host galaxies exhibit diverse properties in their HI content and distribution ( 13 , and references therein), as well as in their molecular gas content, as traced by CO ( 16 ; 7 ; 18 ) . Although, the focus of these studies is on the properties and kinematics of HI and H 2 in the whole of the galaxy. Pulsars have been used to detect HI absorption for decades (e.g., 1 ; 43 ; 44 ; 21 ). The possibility of FRBs being used to detect HI absorption imprinted on their spectra, was first discussed by 11 . Like that study, our primary focus will be on cold HI gas in the Milky Way, the host galaxy and intervening galaxies, as the source of HI absorption. Detectable HI absorption in FRB host galaxies can directly yield the redshift of the host without the need for localization ( 28 ) . However, with significantly high localization precision and optical follow-up studies, obtaining redshifts for host galaxies nowadays is relatively easier, for both repeaters and non-repeaters. FRBs can serve as alternate probes of neutral hydrogen in our own galaxy for low latitude sightlines which effectively intersect one or more molecular cloud regions in the Milky Way disk. But the more unique opportunity is that the pencil-beam FRB sightline can probe the chemical features of individual cold gas clouds in different galaxies on a sub-cloud transverse scale. Even though, as we show later, the fraction of random sightlines intersecting cold HI clouds in a galaxy is low, usable cases can be found within the rapidly growing FRB population. Furthermore, it may prove useful for high redshift applications in the future, such as in detecting a high-redshift forest of HI absorption lines arising from neutral hydrogen structures called minihalos ( 12 ) . I.1 Neutral Hydrogen Absorption HI is an abundant species in molecular cloud halos, and is observed with large optical depths in surveys (e.g. 39 ), which find neutral hydrogen column densities upwards of 10^{21}\rm cm^{-2} . The hydrogen column densities are typically defined in these surveys as: N_{\rm HI}=1.82\times 10^{18}\frac{T_{\rm spin}}{1\;\rm K}\int\tau(v)\frac{dv}{1\;\rm km\,s^{-1}}{\rm cm^{-2}} (1) Here, T_{\rm spin} is the spin temperature of the gas, assumed to be constant throughout the molecular cloud, and \tau(v) is the optical depth as a function of line-of-sight velocity v (or equivalently as a function of frequency). There are certain caveats to this estimate. Although Eq. ( 1 ) is formally general, in practice we measure the brightness temperature rather than the optical depth directly. As a result, applying this expression requires the optically thin approximation. However, this assumption is often violated, as optical depths \tau\gtrsim 1 are commonly observed in such clouds. Consequently, the inferred column densities should be regarded as lower limits. Alternatively, we can use the hyperfine level-splitting calculations to define the optical depth at line center: \tau_{0}=0.31\Big[\frac{N_{\rm HI}}{10^{21}\,{\rm cm^{-2}}}\Big]\Big[\frac{10\,{\rm kms^{-1}}}{b}\Big]\Big[\frac{10^{2}\,{\rm K}}{T_{\rm spin}}\Big], (2) where, b is the velocity broadening of the optical depth profile. The broadening seen in molecular clouds is often much larger than the calculated thermal broadening, and is attributed to turbulent motions within the cloud. 17 found that b=\sqrt{2}\sigma_{v}=1.2\,{\rm km\,s^{-1}}\Big(\frac{d}{1\,{\rm pc}}\Big)^{0.65} (3) where d is the size of the molecular cloud. The frequency dependence of the absorption is given by the Voigt profile (see e.g., 40 ), and the full-width half maximum (FWHM) of the absorption profile \approx 2\sqrt{\ln 2}(b/c)\nu_{0}\approx(9.5\;{\rm kHz})(d/1\,{\rm pc})^{0.65} . II Scintillation As FRBs pass through the ionized material in the ISM of the Milky Way, they are scattered due to the changes in the density of gas clumps along their path. The wavefront gets distorted as the electric field vectors at different points accumulate different phase shifts. Furthermore, this phase shifting is frequency dependent, due to which the electric field vectors adding up to constitute the signal at the observer’s location within the time resolution of the detector create a scintillation pattern in which the flux varies with frequency. Scintillation is a common phenomenon observed in the radio for Galactic point sources such as pulsars, and for extragalactic point sources like FRBs ( 30 ; 9 ) . It is also a very powerful tool which can tell us about FRB physics ( 3 ; 24 ; 32 ) , the host galaxy and Milky Way ISM properties, and the source-screen-observer geometries ( 41 ; 37 ; 42 ) . Even though, scintillation arises from the inhomogeneity of the electron distribution and its temporal change in a 3D volume, its properties can be typically encapsulated by modeling a thin scattering screen. For FRBs, the electrons which contribute to scintillation/scattering are usually mostly concentrated in the Milky Way and the host galaxy, for which separate scattering screens must be invoked

Read the complete text