The Allee Effect in Compressible Flows

Jonathan Bauermann, Roberto Benzi, David R. Nelson, Federico Toschi · 2026

Read The Allee Effect in Compressible Flows by Jonathan Bauermann, Roberto Benzi, David R. Nelson, Federico Toschi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-28260.txt.

Introduction

Jonathan Bauermann, Roberto Benzi, David R. Nelson, and Federico Toschi study microbes drifting in thin layers at the ocean surface. Turbulence there squeezes and stretches the flow, making it effectively compressible, so patches of water gather microbes together or spread them apart while the microbes reproduce.

Bauermann and colleagues focus on populations with an Allee effect, where growth stalls unless enough individuals are present. They derive formulas that give the carrying capacity from the Allee strength in two limits of the Damköhler number, which compares the flow's turnover time with the growth rate. Simulations connect the two limits. When growth is slow relative to the flow, they find a largest Allee strength, set by flow statistics, beyond which the species dies out in strong turbulence.

Catalog record

CREATORJonathan Bauermann, Roberto Benzi, David R. Nelson, Federico Toschi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.28260

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Allee Effect in Compressible Flows Jonathan Bauermann, Roberto Benzi, David R. Nelson, Federico Toschi Abstract Microbes in marine environments are often confined to thin near-surface layers while being advected by turbulent flows. Because such constrained advection generates an effectively compressible flow, reproduction and transport interact in a nontrivial way. Here, we focus on populations whose growth is governed by an Allee effect and show that sinks and sources, generated by the compressible flow, have dramatic consequences for the survival of such species. We derive analytical expressions for the carrying capacity as a function of the Allee strength in the limit of small and large Damköhler number, which measures the product of the large eddy turnover time and the organism growth rate. Numerical simulations reveal how these two limits connect. In the limit of small Damköhler number, we find a maximal Allee strength, set by the statistics of the compressible flow, that leads to species extinction in fully developed turbulence. Introduction.— Microbial populations in oceans and lakes are constantly advected by turbulent flows. While these tiny organisms reproduce, they are simultaneously being transported, mixed, and dispersed across vast scales. In large lakes and the open ocean, the large eddy turnover time \tau_{\text{eddy}} (~ 10 days in the ocean Thorpe 2005 ; Vallis 2017 ) can exceed the typical doubling times of reproducing microbes \tau_{\text{rep}} (~ 12 – 24 hours for phytoplankton Eppley 1972 ) by more than an order of magnitude. The latter, however, is still much larger than the turnover time of the smallest eddies, \propto\sqrt{\eta/\epsilon} (~ 10 minutes in the ocean Thorpe 2005 ; Vallis 2017 ), where \eta is the viscosity of water and \epsilon is the energy dissipation rate. Thus, the biological time scale lies directly within the range over which the turbulent cascade is active, thereby setting the stage for a fascinating interplay between microbial reproduction and turbulent mixing d’Ovidio et al. 2010 . Furthermore, many of these microbes have evolved to localize near the surface (~ 10 – 100 m depth), in thin layers (~ 10 m width), where both light and nutrients are present Cullen 1982 ; Cullen 2015 . These layers are much thinner than the large length scales of the turbulent flow, effectively rendering the turbulent dynamics two-dimensional. However, when floater particles riding on a three-dimensional, incompressible turbulent flow are constrained to a two-dimensional interface, the resulting effective two-dimensional flow field is compressible Eckhardt and Schumacher 2001 ; Cressman and Goldburg 2003 ; De Pietro et al. 2015 . This effect can be quantified more generally by the dimensionless compressibility \kappa=\frac{\langle|\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{u}|^{2}\rangle}{\langle|\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{u}|^{2}\rangle+\langle|\nabla\times\boldsymbol{u}|^{2}\rangle}, (1) where \boldsymbol{u} is the effective two-dimensional flow field, and the brackets \langle\cdot\rangle represent a spatial average. For passive floaters on top of a turbulently stirred body of water, an effective compressibility of \kappa\approx 0.5 was reported Cressman and Goldburg 2003 , while in simulations of particles constrained to a thin layer within the bulk of isotropic, incompressible, three-dimensional flow one finds \kappa\approx 0.17 De Pietro et al. 2015 . Microbes in the ocean, however, are not merely passive tracers advected by effectively compressible flows, but are constantly reproducing. For well-mixed populations, in an incompressible flow field, the average density c is typically modeled by a first-order differential equation, i.e., dc/dt=\mu c\,p(c) , where \mu=1/\tau_{\text{rep}} and p(c) is the per-capita growth rate. For simple logistic growth, the per-capita growth decreases linearly with concentration due to competition, i.e., p(c)=1-c , where we rescale the population density to set c=1 as the carrying capacity of the well-mixed system. In previous work, the consequences of compressibility for populations with simple logistic growth were studied Benzi and Nelson 2009 ; Perlekar et al. 2010 ; Benzi et al. 2022 . Depending on the Damköhler number \mathrm{Da}=\tau_{\text{eddy}}/\tau_{\text{rep}} , the carrying capacity can be reduced dramatically, by up to 80\% of the saturation concentration. In this work, we are interested in the effects of compressibility on species for which reproduction is governed not only by competition but also by cooperation. Indeed, for many species, ranging from mammals and insects to microbes Allee 1931 ; Stephens et al. 1999 ; Courchamp et al. 2009 , an increase in the per-capita growth rate at low population density (in contrast to the monotonic decrease assumed by the logistic equation) has been reported, often stemming from cooperative effects between individuals. This phenomenon is known as the Allee effect and is modeled, in a minimal manner, by a quadratic form for the per-capita growth rate p(c)=(1-c)(c-a), (2) where a is the Allee strength. Depending on a , there are four interesting regimes: (i) a<-1 : p(c) is monotonically decreasing in the biologically relevant domain 0<c<1 , similar to logistic growth where p(c)=1-c ; (ii) -1<a<0 : p(c)>0 and has positive slope for c\gtrsim 0 , known as a weak Allee effect; (iii) 0<a<1 : p(c)<0 but has positive slope for c\gtrsim 0 , known as a strong Allee effect; (iv) a>1 : p(c)<0 in the relevant domain 0<c<1 , so that the population always goes extinct. Crucially, for a strong Allee effect, a critical population density c^{*}=a is necessary for growth, and below which, the well-mixed population goes extinct. In yeast cells ( S. cerevisiae ), for example, such a strong Allee effect was found due to a cooperative sucrose metabolism Gore et al. 2009 . More relevant in the context of this study, a strong Allee effect has also been reported for V. fischeri Kaul et al. 2016 , a widespread marine bacterium. Even without predation, an Allee effect was found, potentially stemming from a quorum sensing mechanism such that cells need to reach a certain density to switch on growth - promoting functions. The critical population density became higher, i.e., the Allee effect became stronger, in the presence of predation due to a bacterivore ( Cafeteria roenbergensis ), where at low densities, the individual risk of predation of a single bacterium is much bigger than at higher densities. Furthermore, in recent years, quorum sensing has been found in many marine bacteria Coolahan and Whalen 2025 . For example, sexual reproduction occurs during the natural bloom of a widespread, toxic single-celled alga ( Pseudo - nitzschia australis ) Prigent et al. 2025 . Both mechanisms provide motivation for inducing an Allee effect in these marine microbes. Dynamics.— We approximate microbes with an Allee effect confined to the upper layers of the ocean by a two-dimensional convection–diffusion equation in a compressible flow with local reproduction, \partial_{t}c+\boldsymbol{\nabla}\cdot(\boldsymbol{u}c)=D\nabla^{2}c+\mu c(1-c)(c-a), (3) where \boldsymbol{u}(\boldsymbol{x},t) is a two-dimensional compressible flow field and D is the diffusivity of the microbes. Reproduction follows the standard local form of the Allee effect, with Allee strength a and reproduction rate \mu=1/\tau_{\text{rep}} . Note that, in the absence of advection and for a strong Allee effect, i.e., 0<a<1 , this dynamics reduces to a deterministic version of model A in the classification of critical phenomena Hohenberg and Halperin 1977 , also known as the Allen–Cahn equation Allen and Cahn 1979 ; Evans et al. 1992 . This model describes the relaxation of a non-conserved order parameter and can be written as \partial_{t}c=-D\,\delta F/\delta c , with the free energy \displaystyle F=\int d\mathbf{x}\,\left[f(c)+|\nabla c|^{2}\right], (4) \displaystyle f(c)=\mu c^{2}\big(3c^{2}-4(1+a)c+6a\big)/(12D), (5) where f is

Read the complete text