Quantum anomalies from three-point on-shell bootstrap

Hiren Kakkad, Rémy Larue, Alexander Ochirov · 2026

Read Quantum anomalies from three-point on-shell bootstrap by Hiren Kakkad, Rémy Larue, Alexander Ochirov (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-28193.txt.

Introduction

Hiren Kakkad, Rémy Larue, and Alexander Ochirov derive quantum anomalies, places where a classical symmetry breaks once quantum effects enter, using a bootstrap approach. Instead of computing with a full theory, they start from scattering particles treated as on-shell, meaning every particle is real and physically allowed.

Working at the simplest level of three interacting particles, Kakkad and colleagues feed in only the classical symmetry and the symmetries of the effective action. Helicity spinors and on-shell versions of the discrete symmetries then fix the Weyl, chiral, diffeomorphism, and Lorentz anomalies up to overall constants. They recover the known conditions under which gauge anomalies cancel. They also find that the Weyl anomaly cannot involve Pontryagin densities, certain geometric terms one might have expected.

Catalog record

CREATORHiren Kakkad, Rémy Larue, Alexander Ochirov
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE73 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.28193

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum anomalies from three-point on-shell bootstrap Hiren Kakkad, Rémy Larue, Alexander Ochirov Abstract We bootstrap quantum anomalies using on-shell techniques in the simplest setting: at three points. The necessary field-theoretic input includes the local or global classical symmetry, which the anomaly may break, and the symmetries of the effective action — though not its explicit form. We use massless helicity spinors together with an on-shell representation of the discrete C, P, and T transformations. Our approach determines the Weyl, chiral (global and local), diffeomorphism, and Lorentz anomalies up to real constant prefactors. In particular, we recover gauge-anomaly cancelation conditions, as well as find that the Weyl anomaly should not involve Pontryagin densities. I Introduction Quantum anomalies are among the most robust statements in field theory: a classical symmetry of the action can fail to survive quantization, and when it does, there are significant formal and phenomenological consequences Ball 1989 ; Bertlmann 2005 ; Fujikawa and Suzuki 2004 . The most notorious example is the chiral anomaly, which governs the decay rate of the neutral pion through the Adler–Bell–Jackiw anomaly Adler 1969 ; Bell and Jackiw 1969 , puts strong constraints on the Standard Model (SM) and beyond the SM via the gauge-anomaly cancelation Bouchiat et al. 1972 ; Gross and Jackiw 1972 , and is related through the index theorem to the topology of the gauge group Atiyah and Singer 1968 ; Nielsen and Schroer 1977a ; Nielsen and Schroer 1977b ; Nielsen et al. 1977 ; Christensen and Duff 1979 ; Fujikawa 1979 ; Alvarez-Gaume and Ginsparg 1984 . Another well-known example is the Weyl anomaly Capper and Duff 1974 , which drives quantum vacuum effects, such as the Hawking radiation and the Casimir effect Christensen and Fulling 1977 ; Setare and Rezaeian 2000 ; Setare 2001 , puts constraints on string compactification Polyakov 1981 , and plays a central role in holography Henningson and Skenderis 1998 . That anomalies are tightly constrained by symmetry is not new. The Wess–Zumino consistency conditions Wess and Zumino 1971 and their cohomological realization Becchi et al. 1976 ; Bonora et al. 1983 ; Dubois-Violette et al. 1985 have long shown that the allowed anomalies are fixed by the gauge-group structure, largely independent of microscopic dynamics. What these approaches do not provide is a direct on-shell characterization of the anomalies, similar to the modern scattering-amplitude bootstrap Bern et al. 1994 ; Bern et al. 1995 ; Dixon 1996 ; Britto et al. 2005a ; Britto et al. 2005b ; Britto et al. 2005c ; Britto et al. 2005d ; Anastasiou et al. 2007 ; Forde 2007 ; Benincasa and Cachazo 2007 ; Giele et al. 2008 ; Badger et al. 2013 ; Badger et al. 2015 ; Badger et al. 2018 ; Abreu et al. 2018 ; Badger et al. 2019 ; Abreu et al. 2019 . Recent works Huang and McGady 2014 ; Chen et al. 2014 ; Accettulli Huber and De Angelis 2021 ; Alviani and Falkowski 2026 did probe gauge anomalies via a clash between unitarity and locality in 4- and higher-point scattering amplitudes, but without deciphering the anomaly structure itself. Besides, global anomalies, which do not jeopardize unitarity nor locality, have remained elusive. One may instead ask which 3-point on-shell structures are compatible with Lorentz invariance, discrete symmetries, and residual gauge freedom, and whether they can be determined without reference to an explicit action, a cohomological complex, or a regularization scheme. In this letter, we show that anomalies in four-dimensional quantum field theories (QFT) do admit such an on-shell description. Starting from anomalous Ward identities, we construct the most general 3-point form factors for the chiral, Weyl, diffeomorphism, and Lorentz anomalies consistent with (residual) gauge symmetries, discrete symmetries, and Bose symmetry. More precisely, we define the anomalies field-theoretically, without specifying the form of the action, and then bootstrap them directly on shell. Our assumptions are: (SYM) ​​ we only bootstrap anomalies for continuous transformations that are already classical symmetries; (EA) ​​ ​​effective action \Gamma encodes full quantum dynamics; (CPT) ​​ {\cal CPT} and global Lorentz invariance of \Gamma ; (CP) ​​ {\cal C} and {\cal P} invariance unless broken classically; (COV) ​​ anomalies may be expressed in a covariant form; (POL) ​​ on shell, nontrivial anomalies ( i.e. which cannot be renormalized away Bertlmann 2005 ) must correspond to polynomials in helicity spinors. Perhaps the most suspicious assumption (POL) ​​ may be argued from its subtle relationship with the covariance assumption (COV) ​​ . Indeed, the nonpolynomial form of 3-point amplitudes in gauge theory and gravity is known Arkani-Hamed and Kaplan 2008 to be related to their cubic vertices being incomplete in the sense that they are tied by covariance to the free action, as opposed to separate effective-field-theoretic (EFT) operators. We will provide even more arguments in favor of the polynomial assumption below. In this way, we will constrain the admissible spinor and tensor structures without any loop integration for each anomaly up to a real numerical coefficient, which depends on the microscopic details of the theory and is assumed to be nonzero. Our bootstrap reproduces the known gauge and gravitational anomalies, including the mixed sectors. The anomaly-cancelation conditions emerge as consistency requirements of the bootstrap, rather than properties imposed on a specific Lagrangian. The resulting 3-point structures provide the seed from which the full anomaly can be reconstructed. Our results prove that anomalies, like amplitudes, admit a description in terms of consistency rather than explicit loop calculations. II Gauge anomaly We start by bootstrapping anomalies in unitary gauge theories. The gauge transformation A_{\mu}\to UA_{\mu}U^{-1}+iU\partial_{\mu}U^{-1}/g , with U(x)=e^{ig\xi^{a}(x)t^{a}} , has the linear part \delta^{\text{g}}_{\xi}A^{a}_{\mu}=\partial_{\mu}\xi^{a}-gf^{abc}\xi^{b}A^{c}_{\mu}\eqqcolon D_{\mu}^{\text{adj}}\xi^{a}. (1) As per our assumption (EA) ​​ , a certain effective-action functional \Gamma[A,\varphi] fully describes the quantum dynamics of a gauge theory with matter transforming according to its, presently unspecified, gauge-group representation r : 1 1 1 The gauge-group generators in representation r may be chosen hermitian and normalized to \operatorname*{tr}(t_{r}^{a}t_{r}^{b})=C_{r}\delta^{ab} , with C_{\text{F}}=1/2 in the fundamental representation and C_{\text{A}}=N in the adjoint of {\rm SU}(N) . The anticommutation relations \{t_{r}^{a},t_{r}^{b}\}=d_{r}^{abc}t^{c}/C_{r}+\tilde{C}_{r}\delta^{ab} depend on r , as opposed to [t_{r}^{a},t_{r}^{b}]=if^{abc}t_{r}^{c} . For {\rm SU}(N) we have the standard relationship \tilde{C}_{r}=2C_{r}/\operatorname*{dim}(r) , whereas for the abelian case of U(1), we choose t^{1}=1 , d^{111}=2 and \tilde{C}=0 to avoid treating the abelian and nonabelian cases separately. \varphi\to U_{r}\varphi=\varphi+ig\xi^{a}t_{r}^{a}\varphi+{\cal O}(\xi^{2}) . Its gauge variation is \delta^{\text{g}}_{\xi}\Gamma[A,\varphi]=\!\int\!\mathrm{d}^{4}x\bigg[\frac{\delta\Gamma}{\delta A^{a}_{\mu}\!}D_{\mu}^{\text{adj}}\xi^{a}+ig\xi^{a}\frac{\delta\Gamma}{\delta\varphi}t_{r}^{a}\varphi\bigg]. (2) The gauge-anomaly functional may be defined as \!\!{\cal A}^{c}(z)[A,\varphi]\coloneqq-\frac{\delta(\delta^{\text{g}}_{\xi}\Gamma[A,\varphi])}{\delta\xi^{c}(z)}=D_{\mu}^{\text{adj}}\frac{\delta\Gamma}{\delta A^{c}_{\mu}\!}-ig\frac{\delta\Gamma}{\delta\varphi}t_{r}^{c}\varphi.\! (3) In order to probe this local functional at the lowest nontrivial order, we further differentiate this variation twice and obtain the anomaly’s 3-point function 2 2 2 We discard the bubbles to obtain the second line in eq. ( 4 ), because they do not contribute to on-shell anomaly amplitudes. \displaystyle{\cal A}_{\lambda\mu}^{abc}(x,y,z)\coloneqq \displaystyle\frac{\delta^{2}{\cal A}^{c}(z)[A,\varphi]}{\delta A^{a\lambda}(x)\delta A^{b\mu}(y)}\bigg|_{A=\varphi=0} (4) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{\partial~}{\partial z^{\nu}}\frac{\delta^{3}\Gamma[A,0]}{\delta A^{a\lambda}(x)\delta A^{b\mu}(y)\delta A_{\nu}^{c}(z)}\bigg|_{A=0}\!.\! In other words, the 3-point anomaly measures the failure of the Ward identity applied to the exact vertex. In view of our classical-symmetry assumption (SYM) ​​ , the right-hand side comes exclusively from loop corrections. In momentum space, the vertex factorizes onto the momentum-conserving delta function. We may then choose to put all three legs on shell by hand, contract the free indices with the

Read the complete text