Fault tolerant computation of the static structure factor and finite size effects Preprint: APS/123-QED
Rishabh Bhardwaj, Alexander Reed Muñoz, Travis E. Jones, John Golden · 2026
Read Fault tolerant computation of the static structure factor and finite size effects Preprint: APS/123-QED by Rishabh Bhardwaj, Alexander Reed Muñoz, Travis E. Jones, John Golden (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27734.txt.
Introduction
Quantum computers may one day compute material energies beyond classical reach. Their answers come from finite simulation cells, though. Real material properties live in the infinite-size limit. Rishabh Bhardwaj and three colleagues tackle the leading finite-size correction in 2026. After twist averaging cuts one-body shell effects, the main leftover error comes from slow density fluctuations. Those are encoded in the static structure factor at small momentum.
The team builds a fault-tolerant post-processing strategy around that factor. They state its operator in a Bloch-orbital basis. A block encoding is built through the density operator. An amplified Hadamard test estimates the ground-state value. Adaptive searches, in global and local forms, locate the fitting window for the correction. The added cost stays below the cost of the energy routine. The approach replaces repeated energy runs on larger cells with measurements of the correlations that control the error.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rishabh Bhardwaj, Alexander Reed Muñoz, Travis E. Jones, John Golden |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 113 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27734
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fault tolerant computation of the static structure factor and finite size effects Preprint: APS/123-QED Rishabh Bhardwaj, Alexander Reed Muñoz, Travis E. Jones, John Golden Abstract Fault-tolerant quantum algorithms offer a promising pathway for estimating the ground-state energies of periodic materials that are beyond the practical reach of classical electronic-structure methods. A remaining challenge is finite-size mitigation: quantum algorithms evaluate a finite supercell or finite Brillouin-zone mesh, while materials properties are defined in the thermodynamic limit. In this work we develop a quantum post-processing strategy for the leading two-body finite-size correction. After one-body shell effects are reduced by twist averaging, the dominant residual error is controlled by long-wavelength density fluctuations, which are encoded in the small-momentum static structure factor S ( 𝐪 ) S(\mathbf{q}) . We formulate the corresponding operator in a Bloch-orbital basis, construct its block encoding through the density operator, and estimate its ground-state expectation value using an amplified Hadamard test. We also introduce adaptive global and local binary search procedures for identifying the infrared fitting window used to reconstruct the two-body finite size error correction. The resulting cost remains subleading relative to the main ground-state energy estimation routine: the structure-factor correction has leading 𝒪 ( N b N k ) 3 \mathcal{O}(N_{b}N_{k})^{3} dependence on the Bloch-orbital basis size, avoids the large plane-wave prefactor of full Hamiltonian simulation, and requires only 𝒪 ( N b N k ) \mathcal{O}(N_{b}N_{k}) logical qubits. This provides a fault-tolerant alternative to down-sampling, replacing repeated energy calculations on larger cells with targeted measurements of the infrared density correlations that control the finite-size effects. I Introduction Computing ground-state energies of interacting electrons is among the most compelling applications of fault-tolerant quantum computers 26 ; 20 ; 18 ; 6 ; 42 . Over the past decade, quantum algorithms for electronic structure have evolved into increasingly practical workflows built on block encodings, qubitization, and quantum phase estimation (QPE) 4 ; 25 ; 32 ; 41 ; 22 ; 5 . For extended periodic systems, these methods offer a route to materials regimes where classical approximations struggle, including correlated metals, transition-metal oxides, warm dense matter, and other systems in which long-range screening, strong correlation, and finite-size convergence must be controlled simultaneously. A central obstacle in applying these algorithms to solids is that a quantum simulation does not give the ground state energy in the thermodynamic limit, E_{\infty} directly. One instead computes the energy of a finite supercell, or equivalently a discrete Brillouin-zone (BZ) mesh, and then removes the resulting finite-size error in classical post-processing. This error has two principal components. The first is a one-body shell error arising from the discrete sampling of single-particle states. This error is especially pronounced in metals, where an accurate description of the BZ is required because the electronic structure is highly sensitive to states near the Fermi surface. The second is a two-body error arising from the distortion of long-wavelength Coulomb correlations in a finite periodic cell. In classical and quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) calculations, the one-body component is commonly reduced by twist averaging , first introduced in Refs. 40 ; 28 . The two-body contribution is commonly addressed using one of two common strategies: down-sampling over a hierarchy of cell sizes or k -meshes 45 ; 47 ; 49 ; 22 and corrections based on the small-momentum behavior of the static structure factor (SSF) 21 . Down-sampling is more systematic, but it is expensive: it requires repeating the underlying energy calculation on progressively larger supercells or denser k -meshes. Starting from the coarsest calculation, one successively adds finite-size increments from neighboring levels of the hierarchy to estimate the thermodynamic-limit energy. If the largest required cubic mesh is size L , this procedure requires 2L+1 separate energy evaluations. In the fault-tolerant setting this overhead is especially costly, because ground-state energy estimation is already the dominant quantum primitive. Figure 1: Schematic overview of finite-size mitigation as a quantum post-processing task of the quantum workflow of E_{\infty} estimation. A finite periodic cell and trial state are supplied as input to a fault-tolerant ground-state energy-estimation routine, which produces finite-cell energies for different twists. Rather than reaching the thermodynamic limit by repeating the full energy calculation on a hierarchy of larger supercells or denser meshes, the post-processing stage combines twist averaging with targeted measurements of the small-momentum SSF. These long-wavelength density correlations determine the leading residual two-body finite-size correction, yielding the corrected thermodynamic-limit estimate. The corrected energy can then be used in downstream materials workflows such as equations of state, phase diagrams, and materials-property prediction. The SSF provides a more targeted route to the long-wavelength physics. It measures density–density correlations in momentum space and enters the two-body energy through Coulomb-induced density fluctuations. Since the Coulomb kernel strongly weights small momenta, the dominant residual two-body finite-size error is controlled by the infrared behavior of the SSF. This is why structure-factor corrections are so useful in QMC. In practice, however, extracting the low-momentum behavior from classical QMC can be delicate: the fermion sign problem restricts the accessible system sizes precisely in metallic and extreme-condition regimes, where finite-size effects are most important 52 ; 31 ; 16 ; 2 . In our work we address this post-processing stage of fault-tolerant materials simulation: how to remove finite-size errors once a finite-cell ground-state energy has been obtained. The broader workflow still requires state preparation and ground-state energy estimation, and we assume access to a trial state with non-negligible overlap with the ground state. Our focus is the finite-size correction, which has so far largely remained outside the quantum workflow. Existing approaches repeat the full energy-estimation routine across a hierarchy of larger supercells or denser k -meshes 23 ; 41 ; 22 . We replace this repeated use of the most expensive routine with a fault-tolerant computation of low-momentum samples of the SSF, from which the leading two-body finite-size correction can be reconstructed directly. The resulting strategy combines twist averaging for one-body shell effects with a quantum evaluation of the low-momentum SSF for the residual two-body correction. In this way, reaching the thermodynamic-limit is tied directly to the long-wavelength density correlations that control the finite-size bias, rather than to repeated ground-state energy calculations on larger simulation cells. This distinction is especially important for metallic and extreme-condition materials, where dense k -space resolution can otherwise amplify quantum resource estimates. Figure 1 gives a pictorial description of this procedure. Our work makes three main contributions: 1. We provide a fault-tolerant procedure for estimating SSF using an amplified Hadamard test, together with adaptive global and local binary search protocols for extracting the infrared structure-factor data that enter the finite-size correction. 2. We define the SSF operator, whose expectation value with respect to the ground state yields SSF. We express it in a Bloch-orbital basis, and construct its block encoding. This representation preserves crystal-momentum structure. 3. We provide exact circuit architecture and the resulting resource estimates in the form of Toffoli and qubit count. We further show that the finite-size correction remains subleading relative to the main ground-state energy estimation routine. The correction has leading Toffoli scaling proportional to (N_{b}N_{k})^{3} , but avoids the large plane-wave prefactor appearing in full Hamiltonian simulation 41 ; 5 ; 22 ; its logical-qubit