The Second Law, Symmetry of Time Reversal and Thermodynamic Equilibrium in Superconductors.

Vladimir Kozhevnikov · 2026

Read The Second Law, Symmetry of Time Reversal and Thermodynamic Equilibrium in Superconductors. by Vladimir Kozhevnikov (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27628.txt.

Introduction

Vladimir Kozhevnikov asks how the second law of thermodynamics applies to superconductors. Superconductors carry current with no resistance at all. Kozhevnikov argues that this case has a real gap in understanding. His 2026 note revisits two basic ideas: equilibrium and reversibility. It keeps the special traits of superconductivity in view throughout.

He stresses three points. First, field strength plays the main role in forming magnetisation. Second, a sample in true equilibrium has zero entropy. Third, samples out of equilibrium carry two kinds of superconducting current. He then shows a key result. Time reversal symmetry, where equilibrium behaviour looks the same run forwards or backwards, follows from the second law itself here. That makes the symmetry a duty of equilibrium samples, not an extra guess. He also states the conditions needed to reach such equilibrium. The aim is to guide work on all kinds of superconducting materials.

Catalog record

CREATORVladimir Kozhevnikov
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27628

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Second Law, Symmetry of Time Reversal and Thermodynamic Equilibrium in Superconductors. Vladimir Kozhevnikov Abstract The Second law, universally applicable to all states of all sorts of matter and radiation, is undeniably the brightest jewel in the tiara of laws of thermodynamics; recall that the achievements of this law include the principle of least action, the atomistic structure of matter, the quantization of radiant heat, and much more. However, there is a significant gap in understanding the application of the Second law to magnetizing materials, especially to superconductors. This communication is targeted to fill the gap. The concepts of equilibrium and reversibility in thermodynamic processes are considered with particular attention to specifics of superconductivity. These include (1) the primary role of the field strength H in forming magnetization; (2) the zero entropy of samples in a state of thermodynamic equilibrium; and (3) two kinds of superconducting currents in samples out of equilibrium. As shown, time reversal symmetry in superconductors is a consequence of the Second law and, therefore, is a mandatory property of these materials in a state of equilibrium. Necessary conditions for achieving the latter are framed out. Awareness of these aspects is important for advancing research on superconductivity in all kinds of superconducting materials. . By the mid 1800s it became clear that the First fundamental principle of thermodynamics, or the First law, representing the energy conservation, was insufficient to explain the absence of time reversal symmetry (TRS) in thermal processes. The problem was solved by Clausius, who introduced the Second fundamental principle, or the Second law of thermodynamics Clausius-1867 , based on a previously unknown physical quantity that he named entropy, physical significance of which was first disclosed by Boltzmann Bolzmann . The law can be verbalized in various forms (see. e.g., Planck ; Planck_time reversal ; Fermi ). The shortest one, due to Planck Planck , reeds “The total change of the entropy \geqq 0”, where the inequality corresponds to irreversible thermodynamic processes and the equality refers to reversible ones. The Second law, originally formulated as a generalization of empirical facts, was rigorously justified by the methods of statistical thermodynamics Gibbs ; Schrodinger . The validity of the law has been proven for all sorts of matter in any aggregate state, homogeneous and inhomogeneous systems, and radiation Planck-radiation ; Planck_time reversal ; LL-StatPhys ; Callen ; the latest addition to this list is the information processing Parrondo . Overall, the Second law is a fundamental law of nature, which ‘‘will never be overthrown” (Einstein about thermodynamics 1 1 1 Complete quote: “A theory is the more impressive the greater the simplicity of its premises is, the more different kinds of things it relates, and the more extended is its area of applicability. Therefore the deep impression which classical thermodynamics made upon me. It is the only physical theory of universal content concerning which I am convinced that, within the framework of the applicability of its basic concepts, it will never be overthrown (for the special attention of those who are skeptical on principle)” Einstein . ). Yet, there is a significant gap in the understanding the Second law as it applies to magnetizing materials 2 2 2 Magnetizing materials are such whose magnetization vanishes in the absence of an external magnetic field. , especially to superconductors. The objective of this communication is to fill this gap. To begin, let us take a closer look at Planck’s interpretation of the Second law and revisit the concept of thermodynamic equilibrium in reversible processes, that is successions of equilibrium states with constant entropy. By definition, the equilibrium state of a statistical system is a state, whose properties are determined by the state parameters (e.g., volume, temperature, applied field, etc. ), regardless on the path by which the system is brought to that state. Consequently, the properties of systems in equilibrium are time indifferent and their entropy is the maximum of the accessible values in both reversible and irreversible processes. The difference between the two is that in the former, the permutation of the final and initial states, i.e., time reversal (TR), completely restores the initial state of the system, whereas in the latter this is not the case, due to the difference in the entropy of the initial and final states in irreversible processes. Thus, systems undergoing reversible processes possess TRS, whereas in irreversible processes this symmetry is absent. In other words, the concepts of reversibility and TRS are equivalent : both are valid only together and only in adiabatic processes Planck_time reversal . On the other hand, properties of statistical systems that are out of equilibrium are largely determined by transport processes caused by the exchange of mass, charge, energy, linear and angular momentums. Such systems have a “memory” of their recent history, meaning that in cyclical processes they exhibit hysteresis. For nonequilibrium systems, the Second law asserts that they monotonically evolve toward equilibrium and therefore do not possess TRS by definition. The above is of a universal nature and is well covered in textbooks on thermodynamics. However, in many publications of recent years, the authors claim to have observed breaking of TRS in superconductors. Since the entropy of superconductors is constant (zero), such claims contradict the Second law and, therefore, are unrealistic. At the same time, there are specific features concerning the Second law as applied to superconductors, which are insufficiently articulated in literature. Non-acquaintance with these features is a possible reason of statements similar to TRS breaking. These features are discussed below. 1. Time reversal symmetry in diamagnets. TRS rises no questions regarding electrically polarizing materials LL-electrodynamics , since polarization is unrelated to time. However, this is not the case for magnetizing materials because magnetization is caused by induced microscopic currents persistently circulating within the sample. Therefore, TR (the transformation t\rightarrow-t ) reverses direction of these currents 3 3 3 In the current-carrying systems, time reversal ( t\rightarrow-t ) is equivalent to reversal of the sign of charge carriers ( e\rightarrow-e ). and, accordingly, the direction of the magnetic moments caused by them. Hence, TR should reverse magnetization at the unchanged state parameters, which conflicts with the Second law. To sort out with this issue, we need to refresh the notions of induction B and intensity (or strength) H of the magnetic field, linked by the relationship \textbf{B}=\textbf{H}+4\pi\textbf{I} , where I is magnetization, magnetic moment per unite volume induced by the field. After Lorentz Lorentz , B is a mean field due to all microscopic currents in the sample. In turn, I is related to the field through the fundamental equation of induced magnetism Maxwell , which reads \textbf{I}=\chi\textbf{H}, (1) where \chi is the magnetic susceptibility or coefficient of induced magnetization. Therefore, the intensity H , also called the magnetizing force Maxwell , controls magnetization, that is, induces a magnetic moment in the microscopic units composing the sample. In other words, H is a mean field acting on a given microscopic unit; it does not include the field due to the unit in question, while B , the mean field due to all units, includes it. This seemingly minor difference between H and B fields inside the sample (outside \textbf{B}\equiv\textbf{H} ) leads to principally different boundary

Read the complete text