Contact cosmetic surgery on Legendrian knots in integer homology sphere L L -spaces
Apratim Chakraborty, Swarup Kumar Das, Tanushree Shah · 2026
Read Contact cosmetic surgery on Legendrian knots in integer homology sphere L L -spaces by Apratim Chakraborty, Swarup Kumar Das, Tanushree Shah (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27485.txt.
Introduction
Chakraborty, Das, and Shah extend the contact cosmetic surgery question to Legendrian knots sitting in a broader class of three-manifolds. Cosmetic surgery asks whether two different surgeries on one knot can ever produce the same result; the contact version asks it for Legendrian knots with their contact structures. The setting is integer homology sphere L-spaces, manifolds whose Heegaard Floer homology is as small as possible. Techniques from the classical sphere case are adapted and refined, with Floer-theoretic constraints doing heavy lifting in this topology paper from 2026.
The contact cosmetic surgery conjecture is proven to hold for every non-trivial Legendrian knot in this setting. One family escapes the proof: Lagrangian slice knots, which remain a possible exception. Knot surgery rigidity survives the change of scenery. The exceptional family is small and geometrically constrained, a clear target for future work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Apratim Chakraborty, Swarup Kumar Das, Tanushree Shah |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27485
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Contact cosmetic surgery on Legendrian knots in integer homology sphere L L -spaces Apratim Chakraborty, Swarup Kumar Das, Tanushree Shah Abstract . We extend the study of contact cosmetic surgeries to Legendrian knots in integer homology sphere L L -spaces . We prove that the contact cosmetic surgery conjecture holds for all non-trivial Legendrian knots in this setting, with the possible exception of Lagrangian slice knots. Our argument adapts and refines techniques from the S 3 S^{3} case to the broader context of L L -spaces, incorporating constraints arising from Heegaard Floer theory. 1. Introduction In this paper, we establish that a contact analogue of the cosmetic surgery conjecture holds for Legendrian knots in integer homology sphere L -spaces, with the possible exception of a small and geometrically constrained family of knots. We begin by recalling the smooth cosmetic surgery conjecture in a general setting. Let K be a knot in a closed oriented 3 –manifold Y . Two surgeries Y_{K}(r) and Y_{K}(r^{\prime}) are called cosmetic if they are diffeomorphic, and truly cosmetic if they are orientation–preserving diffeomorphic. In the case Y=S^{3} , it is known that while cosmetic surgeries exist, the only known truly cosmetic surgeries occur on the unknot. The cosmetic surgery conjecture predicts that non-trivial knots admit no truly cosmetic surgeries. This conjecture has been extensively studied in S^{3} , particularly using Heegaard Floer homology and correction terms, and these results play an essential role in our arguments. We now turn to the contact setting. Let (Y,\xi) be a tight contact structure on an L -space integer homology sphere, and let L\subset(Y,\xi) be a Legendrian knot. Contact (r) –surgery on L is obtained by removing a standard neighborhood of L and gluing back a solid torus whose meridian has slope r+\text{tb}(L) , extending the contact structure over the torus as any tight contact structure. As in the case of S^{3} , when r\neq 1/n , there are generally multiple possible contact surgeries corresponding to a single smooth surgery coefficient. Two contact surgeries on L with distinct smooth coefficients are said to be cosmetic if the resulting contact manifolds are contactomorphic. Since contactomorphisms are orientation-preserving, we do not distinguish between cosmetic and truly cosmetic surgeries in the contact category. This leads to the following natural generalization of the cosmetic surgery conjecture to the contact setting. Conjecture 1.1 (Contact cosmetic surgery conjecture) . Let (Y,\xi) be an integer homology sphere. Any Legendrian knot in (Y,\xi) that is not smoothly an unknot admits no cosmetic contact surgeries. This conjecture is a natural extension of the smooth cosmetic surgery conjecture and is closely related to understanding the extent to which contact surgery descriptions of contact manifolds are unique. As a first step toward this problem, it is useful to isolate a class of knots for which the surgery behavior is more tractable and closely tied to the classical S^{3} setting. This leads to the notion of local knots, where the surgery problem effectively reduces to one in S^{3} . Local knots A knot K\subset Y is said to be local if it is contained in an embedded 3 –ball in Y . Equivalently, K determines a knot in S^{3} . In this situation, performing smooth r –surgery along K affects only the 3 –ball containing the knot, and the resulting manifold is diffeomorphic to Y\#S^{3}_{K}(r) , where S^{3}_{K}(r) denotes the manifold obtained by r –surgery on the corresponding knot in S^{3} . Remark 1.2 . In the case of local knots, the limiting conditions remain unchanged from the S^{3} setting, since the ambient manifold differs only by a connected sum. Thus, the contact manifolds obtained are of the form Y\#S^{3}_{K}(r) , and the analysis reduces to that in [ 7 ] . We now establish an obstruction to performing contact surgery on more general classes of knots in integer homology sphere L -spaces. The L -space condition imposes strong Floer-theoretic constraints, and these constraints allow us to adapt and refine arguments from the S^{3} case. Our main result establishes this conjecture for almost all Legendrian knots. Remark 1.3 . Throughout this paper, Y will denote an L -space integer homology 3 –sphere (ZHS 3 ). We fix once and for all a positively co-oriented tight contact structure \xi with nonvanishing Heegaard Floer contact invariant on Y and work in the contact manifold (Y,\xi) . One example to keep in mind is the Poincaré homology sphere -P^{3} equipped with a positively co-oriented tight contact structure arising as the boundary of its Stein filling. Theorem 1.4 . Let (Y,\xi) be a contact integer homology sphere L -space with non-trivial Heegaard Floer contact invariant. The contact cosmetic surgery conjecture holds for all non-trivial Legendrian knots in (Y,\xi) , except possibly for \pm 2 surgery on a Legendrian knot L whose smooth knot type K satisfies \tau_{Y}(K)=0,\quad g(K)=2,\quad\overline{\text{tb}}(K)=-1 . Here \tau_{Y}(K) denotes the Heegaard Floer smooth \tau –invariant of the knot in Y . The proof proceeds by constructing explicit contact (\pm 1) –surgery diagrams representing candidate cosmetic surgeries and comparing their d_{3} –invariants. The L -space hypothesis allows us to control correction terms and eliminate potential coincidences except in the narrow family described above. As in the S^{3} setting, when r\neq 1/n there may be multiple contact (r) –surgeries on a fixed Legendrian knot. This leads to two refinements of cosmetic behavior. We say two contact (r) –surgeries are weakly cosmetic if the resulting contact manifolds are contactomorphic, and strongly cosmetic if the resulting contact structures are isotopic. Since the smooth surgery coefficient is fixed, the underlying smooth manifold is canonically identified in this situation. Rather than formulating a precise conjecture in this direction, we ask: Question 1.5 . Which Legendrian knots in tight contact integer homology sphere L -spaces admit weakly-cosmetic or strongly-cosmetic surgeries? Remark 1.6 . We further analyze contact surgeries on Legendrian unknots in L -space homology spheres and observe a striking dichotomy: certain Legendrian unknots admit contact surgeries with no cosmetic counterparts, while in other cases a given contact surgery is contactomorphic to infinitely many distinct surgeries on the same knot. We establish several structural restrictions analogous to the S^{3} case. In particular, Floer-theoretic constraints coming from the L -space condition severely restrict the possibility of strongly-cosmetic surgeries for non-trivial knot types, especially for L -space knots realizing the maximal Thurston–Bennequin bound \text{tb}(L)=2\tau_{Y}(L)-1 . Ni–Wu showed that knots in S^{3} admitting truly cosmetic surgeries must have vanishing \tau -invariant [ 21 ] . We extend Ni–Wu’s result to integer homology sphere L -spaces . Theorem 1.7 . Let Y be an L -space integer homology sphere and K\subset Y a knot. If K admits truly cosmetic surgeries in Y —that is, there exist distinct slopes r_{1}\neq r_{2} with Y_{r_{1}}(K)\cong Y_{r_{2}}(K) as oriented 3 -manifolds—then the Ozsváth–Szabó knot Floer invariant \tau_{Y}(K)=0 . When Y is an integer homology L -space equipped with a contact structure \xi whose contact invariant is nontrivial, the smooth \tau -invariant \tau_{Y}(K) agrees with the contact \tau -invariant \tau_{\xi}(K) defined by Hedden [ 14 ] . Using the lower bound on \tau_{\xi}(K) , we then obtain the desired constraint on the maximal Thurston-Bennequin number. Hanselman [ 12 ] obtained further restrictions on knots in S^{3} admitting truly