A&A community survey on the future of scientific publishing

João Alves, Arūnas Kučinskas, Charlotte Van Rooyen, Marc Audard, Pierre-Alain Duc, David Elbaz, Thierry Forveille, Laszlo L. Kiss, Tiago Pereira, Eva Villaver · 2026

Read A&A community survey on the future of scientific publishing by João Alves, Arūnas Kučinskas, Charlotte Van Rooyen, Marc Audard, Pierre-Alain Duc, David Elbaz, Thierry Forveille, Laszlo L. Kiss, Tiago Pereira, Eva Villaver (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27447.txt.

Introduction

Alves leads the report of a community survey on the future of scientific publishing, commissioned in 2026 by the journal Astronomy and Astrophysics. Publishing is being reshaped by open access, artificial intelligence, and demands for transparency and equity, while article volume strains editors and reviewers. The survey went to nearly twenty-nine thousand of the journal's authors and drew close to three thousand responses from sixty-nine countries. Questions covered journal choice, peer review, open access, research evaluation, and AI's role.

Quality and reputation dominate where researchers choose to publish, with cost second. The top peer review worry is reviewer expertise and fairness, not speed. Citation counts still matter, but many want broader, more qualitative impact measures. Most prefer public or institutional funding for open access. Views on AI split sharply: help with administration and language is welcome, autonomous decisions or generated content are firmly rejected.

Catalog record

CREATORJoão Alves, Arūnas Kučinskas, Charlotte Van Rooyen, Marc Audard, Pierre-Alain Duc, David Elbaz, Thierry Forveille, Laszlo L. Kiss, Tiago Pereira, Eva Villaver
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27447

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A&A community survey on the future of scientific publishing João Alves, Arūnas Kučinskas, Charlotte Van Rooyen, Marc Audard, Pierre-Alain Duc, David Elbaz, Thierry Forveille, Laszlo L. Kiss, Tiago Pereira, Eva Villaver Abstract Scientific publishing is undergoing major change, driven by a shift toward open access (OA), the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), and growing demands for transparency, reproducibility, and equity. At the same time, rapid growth in article output strains editors and reviewers and means that metrics and speed can eclipse quality and rigor. To better understand how the community is responding, Astronomy & Astrophysics (A&A) commissioned the A&A Survey on Trends and Challenges in Scientific Publishing, which documents community opinion on journal choice, peer review, OA, research evaluation, and the role of AI, with the goal of informing future editorial policies and the wider conversation on sustainable, ethical, and equitable scientific communication. Distributed online in May 2025 to 28 787 A 28\,787\text{\,}\mathrm{A} &A authors and co-authors, the 13-question survey drew 2944 r 2944\text{\,}\mathrm{r} esponses from 69 countries by its closing date. Quantitative answers were analyzed through frequency distributions, and roughly 3000 f 3000\text{\,}\mathrm{f} ree-text comments were grouped into recurring themes. The responses were clear. Journal quality and reputation are the most decisive factors in deciding where to publish, followed by cost. The principal worry about peer review is reviewer expertise and fairness rather than speed. Citation counts are still an important consideration, but many respondents want broader, more qualitative measures of impact. The majority of them prefer public or institutional funding for OA, and views on AI are polarized, with widespread acceptance of administrative and language assistance but firm opposition to autonomous decision-making or content generation. Integrity, credibility, and fairness are common themes in every section of the responses. Overall, the survey portrays an engaged community that values quality over speed, fairness over profit, and human oversight over automation, providing A&A with clear insight into community preference and a solid framework for shaping future policies on OA, peer review, and the responsible integration of AI. Credibility over speed, fairness over profit, human judgment over automation 1 Introduction Journals are shifting from subscription-based access, where content is available only to paying institutions or individuals, to open access (OA) models that make research freely available, as in the case of Astronomy & Astrophysics (A&A). At the same time, metrics to evaluate careers in most countries, as well as AI ( 9 ) , are reshaping how researchers communicate and assess scientific work. The pressure to move beyond narrow metrics has prompted community responses such as the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment ( 3 ) , the Leiden Manifesto ( 4 ) , and the Agreement on Reforming Research Assessment ( 1 ) . As one of the major journals in the field, A&A plays a leading role in this changing environment. Established as a nonprofit community-owned publication, “a Journal for astronomers by astronomers,” A&A has always aimed to balance scientific excellence with accessibility and fairness. Because publishing practices evolve rapidly, the journal needs to have regular dialogue with its authors. In May 2025, A&A launched the Survey on Trends and Challenges in Scientific Publishing, targeting its broad base of authors and co-authors. The survey aimed to gauge attitudes toward journal selection, peer review, research evaluation, OA, and the integration of AI into publishing workflows. The response was impressive: 2944\text{\,}\mathrm{p} articipants from 69 countries provided quantitative ratings and extensive free-text comments. The resulting dataset offers one of the most comprehensive contemporary snapshots of researchers’ perspectives on scientific publishing in astronomy. Beyond statistical trends, the richness of the almost 3000\text{\,}\mathrm{f} ree-text comments reveals the values that guide the community: a commitment to integrity, fairness, and responsible research communication. A preliminary analysis of the survey data was presented at the Annual Meeting of the European Astronomical Society in Cork in June 2025. This Editorial presents and interprets the main results of the survey, drawing on both the quantitative responses to the survey questions and the qualitative insights provided through free-form comments by individual A&A authors. This lets us report not only what the community thinks, but the reasoning behind it. Figure 1: Cumulative number of responses over time. The survey opened on 20 May 2025 and closed on 16 June 2025. Reminder emails at the end of May and just before the survey closed on 16 June 2025 produced visible increases in participation. 2 Survey design and participation 2.1 Objectives and structure The A&A Survey on Trends and Challenges in Scientific Publishing was designed to gather broad, quantitative, and qualitative feedback from the journal’s author community on key aspects of scientific publishing. The questionnaire addressed 13 topics grouped into five thematic areas: 1. Journal selection criteria; 2. The peer-review process; 3. Evaluation of research impact; 4. OA and funding models; 5. The role of AI in publishing. Each thematic block consisted of multiple-choice questions using a five-point scale (from “least important” = 1 to “most important” = 5) and open text fields for comments. These qualitative responses were later coded by theme to complement the statistical analysis. The A&A Survey on Trends and Challenges in Scientific Publishing aimed to capture the collective experience and expectations of the community rather than test predefined hypotheses. In this sense, it was exploratory and intended to guide A&A’s editorial and strategic decisions on policy, communication, and future directions. Figure 2: Geographic distribution of respondents to the A&A Survey on Trends and Challenges in Scientific Publishing. The survey reached participants in 69 countries, with the highest representation in Europe but substantial participation worldwide. The questionnaire was distributed on 20 May 2025 to 28\,787\text{\,}\mathrm{A} &A authors and co-authors from the previous three years, using EDP Sciences’ email distribution platform. The survey closed on 16 June 2025, at which time 2944\text{\,}\mathrm{r} esponses had been recorded. To put this level of participation into perspective and considering that the A&A community is mostly from A&A sponsor countries, this number is comparable to roughly half the membership of the European Astronomical Society and a quarter of that of the International Astronomical Union, providing a useful sense of scale relative to the active astronomy community. The substantial response rate suggests genuine interest across the community in the development and future of A&A and its role in scientific publishing. The response timeline (see Fig. 1 ) shows a strong initial surge after the announcement, with distinct secondary peaks after the reminder emails were sent at the end of May and just before the closing date. This pattern indicates that the initial communication channels reached a large portion of the target audience effectively, while reminders increased participation by prompting those who had not yet responded. The respondents represent 69 countries (see Fig. 2 ), which confirms the international character of A&A. The highest participation came from Europe, followed by North America and Asia, with approximately a third (29%) of all responses from non-sponsor countries. 2.2 Career stages and demographics The respondents represent all stages of an academic career, from PhD students and postdocs to senior researchers and emeritus scientists. The breakdown between junior and senior researchers is roughly balanced (PhD students and postdocs, 42%; mid-career and senior scientists, 55%). A smaller fraction of them are retired

Read the complete text