When Does Personality Composition Matter for Multi-Agent LLM Teams?

Aryan Keluskar, Amrita Bhattacharjee & Huan Liu · 2026

Read When Does Personality Composition Matter for Multi-Agent LLM Teams? by Aryan Keluskar, Amrita Bhattacharjee & Huan Liu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27443.txt.

Introduction

Keluskar, Bhattacharjee, and Liu test whether the traits assigned to language model agents change how well a team performs, not just how it talks. Prior work showed low-agreeableness prompts turn agents adversarial and high-agreeableness prompts turn them cooperative. The team varies team makeup across frontier models in three domains: structured coding, open-ended research collaboration, and competitive bargaining. Style and outcomes are measured separately, so talk and results cannot be confused, in a multi-agent study appearing in 2026.

Personality effects hinge on task structure. In coding, low agreeableness shifts tone dramatically yet milestone completion barely moves. In open-ended collaboration and bargaining, the same tweak badly degrades performance. Designers of agent teams therefore cannot treat makeup as cosmetic everywhere. Where work is loosely structured, team makeup is a performance lever; where goals are explicit, it mostly changes tone. The limits of such tuning are mapped alongside its power.

Catalog record

CREATORAryan Keluskar, Amrita Bhattacharjee & Huan Liu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27443

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When Does Personality Composition Matter for Multi-Agent LLM Teams? Aryan Keluskar, Amrita Bhattacharjee & Huan Liu Abstract Personality prompting shapes how large language models communicate, yet whether these behavioral shifts affect objective task outcomes remains under-explored. Prior work shows that agents prompted with low agreeableness produce adversarial language, while those prompted with high agreeableness become cooperative, but the relationship between communication style and task performance has not been systematically examined across multiple domains. In this work, we investigate whether personality composition matters for multi-agent team performance by manipulating personality traits across frontier LLMs on three task domains: structured coding, open-ended research collaboration, and competitive bargaining. We find that personality effects depend critically on task structure. In coding tasks, low agreeableness leads to large communication shifts that have little effect on milestone completion. In open-ended collaboration and bargaining, the same manipulation substantially degrades performance. We discuss implications for multi-agent system design and the limits of personality manipulation. 1 Introduction Multi-agent LLM systems have rapidly progressed from research prototypes to mass-market products. Claude Code, the most-used AI coding tool as of early 2026 ( 20 ) , orchestrates teams of sub-agents that communicate directly with each other, claim tasks from shared lists, and coordinate without human intermediation ( 1 ) . Similar multi-agent architectures appear in OpenAI Codex, Google ADK, and frameworks like AutoGen ( 28 ) , MetaGPT ( 10 ) , LangGraph and CrewAI. As these systems mature, a natural question from organizational psychology arises: does the personality composition of an agent team matter for task performance? Consider a team of coding agents collaborating on a software project. If one agent is prompted to be disagreeable and adversarial, it produces hostile communication, challenges its teammates’ proposals, and refuses to acknowledge their contributions but it could also help the accuracy by forcing other agents to think and rationalize their decisions further and prevent premature convergence of ideas ( 17 ) . Prior work demonstrates that personality prompting shapes how agents communicate . LLMs prompted with high agreeableness produce warmer, more cooperative language, while those prompted with low agreeableness become adversarial ( 26 ; 8 ; 13 ) . These shifts have been documented across multiple models and personality dimensions ( 22 ; 32 ) . However, whether communication shifts cascade to objective task outcomes remains unknown. The relationship between communication style and task performance is an empirical question that prior work has not addressed systematically across task domains. Organizational psychology provides relevant framing. Person-environment fit theory ( 15 ) predicts that employee traits help when they match situational demands and hurt when they conflict. For instance, agreeableness benefits collaborative teams but harms competitive negotiators ( 5 ; 23 ) . However, personality effects in LLM teams raise a distinct question that human team research does not address: can structured task outputs buffer against personality-induced process degradation? Coding tasks produce artifacts with formal constraints (syntax rules, type systems, functional specifications), while research tasks produce unconstrained natural-language output. If the structured nature of the output medium constrains convergence independently of communication quality, personality effects which degrade outcomes in open-ended collaboration may be inert when task structure compensates for dysfunctional communication (Figure 1 ). To investigate this phenomenon in multi-agentic systems, we systematically evaluate personality effects across three task domains using popular frontier LLMs. We focus primarily on homogeneous-personality teams to isolate the task-structure effect, but we also take a first step toward the heterogeneous scenario above with a single-challenger pilot that asks whether one low-agreeableness agent in an otherwise cooperative team can reduce the rate of premature-convergence. Low-agreeableness prompt Large communication shift \varphi:\;0.44\to 0.93 (all models, all domains) Structured output code: syntax, types, functional specs Outcome buffered milestones hold near baseline Unstructured output research ideas, negotiation offers Outcome exposed research & agreement degrade sharply Figure 1: Artifact-mediated buffering. Low agreeableness shifts communication the same way in every domain ( \varphi{:}\,0.44\to 0.93 ), but whether that shift reaches objective outcomes depends on the output medium. A code file must satisfy syntactic and semantic constraints regardless of how the agents communicated, so its outcomes stay near baseline (top). Unstructured text has no such constraints, and the same degradation passes through to the outcome (bottom). 2 Related Work 2.1 Organizational Psychology Big Five is the dominant taxonomy of personality traits in psychology ( 19 ) . It organizes personality along five broad dimensions: openness (intellectual curiosity vs. conventionality), conscientiousness (organization vs. carelessness), extraversion (sociability vs. reserve), agreeableness (cooperation vs. antagonism), and neuroticism (emotional volatility vs. stability). 9 operationalized the Big Five through sets of bipolar adjective pairs. Each dimension is captured by pairs that anchor its low and high poles (e.g., for agreeableness: unkind–kind, cold–warm, harsh–lenient). Our work draws on person-environment fit theory ( 15 ) , which predicts that performance improves when individual traits align with situational demands and degrades when they conflict. Meta-analyses on team composition and the Big Five ( 5 ; 23 ) show that team minimum agreeableness predicts performance and that agreeableness variability hurts it. We test these patterns computationally and extend them with a distinction between structured and unstructured output media that is absent from the organizational psychology literature, where tasks rarely impose the formal constraints that code introduces. 2.2 Personality in LLMs Recent work has established that LLMs exhibit stable personality traits ( 25 ) . 26 showed that these traits can be reliably shaped through prompting using Goldberg bipolar adjective pairs. 8 connect Big Five configurations to task performance in multi-agent debate, and 11 find that agreeableness increases concession rates in negotiation agents. However, none of these studies test whether personality effects generalize across task domains or separate process-level communication shifts from objective outcome effects. We extend this foundation by evaluating the same trait across three task domains, showing that it produces fundamentally different outcomes depending on task structure. 2.3 Multi-Agent LLM Collaboration Multi-agent LLM collaboration has advanced through both frameworks and benchmarks. CAMEL ( 16 ) introduced role-playing communication between agents. AutoGen ( 28 ) provides a conversation-based framework for orchestrating multiple agents. MetaGPT ( 10 ) and ChatDev ( 24 ) apply multi-agent architectures to software development with structured role assignments. AgentVerse ( 7 ) studies emergent behaviors in multi-agent groups. On the benchmarking side, MultiAgentBench ( 31 ) provides tasks with milestone-based evaluation; Collab-Overcooked ( 27 ) tests constrained collaborative cooking requiring explicit coordination; HiddenBench ( 17 ) studies collective reasoning under distributed information. M3-BENCH ( 30 ) introduces process-aware evaluation revealing inconsistencies between process and outcome metrics, a phenomenon we observe directly as behavioral–outcome dissociation. SWE-Bench ( 14 ) and HumanEval ( 6 ) evaluate code generation but focus on single-agent settings. Industry efforts ( 1 ) similarly optimize architectural coordination without considering personality as a design parameter. 3 Methodology We investigate whether injecting varying personality traits into the model during inference by adding personality specific traits in system prompt affects objective task outcomes in multi-agent LLM teams, and if so, whether the effects generalize across task domains. Our methodology centers on answering three research questions: • RQ1: Does personality prompting affect task outcomes, or does it shift communication style without changing objective performance? • RQ2: Do personality effects generalize across task domains? •

Read the complete text