Simulation-Based Inference for Cluster Cosmology with Set-Based Neural Network Architectures
S. Zelmer, E. Bulbul, K. Lehman, S. Krippendorf, E. Artis, S. Grandis, N. Clerc, Z. Ding, L. Fiorino, V. Ghirardini, M. Kluge, N. Malavasi, A. Merloni, T. Mistele, K. Nandra, M. E. Ramos-Ceja, J. S. Sanders, F. Pacaud, A. von der Linden, J. Weller, and X. Zhang · 2026
Read Simulation-Based Inference for Cluster Cosmology with Set-Based Neural Network Architectures by S. Zelmer, E. Bulbul, K. Lehman, S. Krippendorf, E. Artis, S. Grandis, N. Clerc, Z. Ding, L. Fiorino, V. Ghirardini, M. Kluge, N. Malavasi, A. Merloni, T. Mistele, K. Nandra, M. E. Ramos-Ceja, J. S. Sanders, F. Pacaud, A. von der Linden, J. Weller, and X. Zhang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27439.txt.
Introduction
Zelmer leads a large collaboration building simulation-based inference for galaxy cluster cosmology, so that survey catalogues can be used at full strength. The eROSITA all-sky survey delivers record-size cluster samples. Their pipeline generates realistic mock samples through the survey selection function, calibrated on test suites. In 2026, a set-based neural network reads each cluster directly, and a masked flow turns its encoding into posterior densities for the parameters.
Input universes are recovered within the inferred uncertainties across the mock suite. Calibration tests pass, even with survey biases and scatter included. Matter density is constrained to about eleven percent and the fluctuation size to about four percent, averaged over samples matching the real sample size in the reported analysis. That precision rivals classic analyses using much larger samples.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S. Zelmer, E. Bulbul, K. Lehman, S. Krippendorf, E. Artis, S. Grandis, N. Clerc, Z. Ding, L. Fiorino, V. Ghirardini, M. Kluge, N. Malavasi, A. Merloni, T. Mistele, K. Nandra, M. E. Ramos-Ceja, J. S. Sanders, F. Pacaud, A. von der Linden, J. Weller, and X. Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27439
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Simulation-Based Inference for Cluster Cosmology with Set-Based Neural Network Architectures S. Zelmer, E. Bulbul, K. Lehman, S. Krippendorf, E. Artis, S. Grandis, N. Clerc, Z. Ding, L. Fiorino, V. Ghirardini, M. Kluge, N. Malavasi, A. Merloni, T. Mistele, K. Nandra, M. E. Ramos-Ceja, J. S. Sanders, F. Pacaud, A. von der Linden, J. Weller, and X. Zhang Abstract The unprecedented statistical power of galaxy cluster catalogs from the SRG (Spectrum Roentgen Gamma)/eROSITA All-Sky Survey provides a unique opportunity to place stringent constraints on cosmological models through measurements of structure growth. Fully exploiting the potential of these large X-ray-selected cluster samples, however, requires robust statistical frameworks that accurately connect observable quantities to the underlying cosmological parameters. We develop and implement a simulation-based inference (SBI) framework for cosmological parameter estimation using a realistic mock-generation pipeline calibrated on eRASS1 simulations. Synthetic galaxy cluster catalogs are propagated through the survey selection function to produce mock eRASS1 observations that reproduce the data’s statistical properties. At the core of the method lies a set-based neural network (i.e., a graph neural network operating on sets) that encodes information from individual clusters and is coupled to a masked autoregressive flow for flexible posterior density estimation. This approach enables the use of the full cluster-level information content without compressing the observables into binned summary statistics. Our framework recovers the input cosmologies within the inferred uncertainties, and passes simulation-based calibration tests (SBC) and TARP diagnostics, demonstrating robustness in the presence of realistic survey effects, including selection biases and intrinsic scatter in the scaling relations. We obtain mock constraints of 11.5 % on Ω m \Omega_{\mathrm{m}} and 4.4 % on σ 8 \sigma_{8} averaged over a suite of simulated cluster catalogs matching the effective sample size of the data set (of order 3,300 clusters). We achieve a precision comparable to that obtained with traditional MCMC analyses based on substantially larger cluster samples. The framework is readily extensible to more complex forward models and additional observables. This work highlights the potential of SBI methods for next-generation large-scale structure analyses with forthcoming X-ray cluster surveys. 1 Introduction Galaxy cluster abundances as a function of mass and redshift encode the growth of cosmic structure and are particularly sensitive to the matter density parameter, \Omega_{\mathrm{m}} , and the amplitude of matter fluctuations, often expressed as \sigma_{8} or a combination of both, S_{8} . Large, homogeneously selected samples of clusters therefore provide a powerful avenue for constraining cosmology and testing models of structure formation (see, e.g., 2 , 58 , 65 , 30 , 7 , 40 ( 40 hereafter), 38 , 9 , 17 ). The Spectrum-Roentgen-Gamma (SRG) mission, with its soft X-ray instrument eROSITA (extended ROentgen Survey with an Imaging Telescope Array), conducted the first imaging all-sky X-ray survey since ROSAT ( 93 ) , and with unprecedented depth ( 88 ; 75 ) . During the operation phase, eROSITA performed approximately 4.4 All-Sky Surveys between 2019 and 2022. Already, the first all-sky survey (eRASS1) has delivered a catalog containing 5,259 extent-selected galaxy clusters in the Western Galactic Hemisphere ( 21 ; 52 ) . This sample is complemented by the clusters in the point-source sample 12 , which represents the largest ICM-selected cluster sample currently available. A multitude of cosmological studies have been performed based on this catalog, including a main cosmological analysis ( 40 ) , investigations of the growth of structure and general relativity ( 7 ) , alternative f(R) gravity models ( 8 ) , constraints on ultra-light axion dark matter ( 98 ) , and cluster clustering analyses ( 85 ) . Furthermore, machine learning algorithms have previously been applied to eROSITA data to infer the masses of galaxy groups and clusters without assuming an underlying dark matter profile or hydrostatic equilibrium, and have been shown, based on hydrodynamical simulations, to accurately recover halo masses down to 10^{13} M ⊙ based on the hydrodynamical simulations ( 54 ) . Extracting cosmological constraints from such datasets requires accurate modeling of the survey selection function and high accuracy of observable–mass relations and their scatter, while fully exploiting the statistical power of the catalog ( 41 ) . Standard analyses have relied on Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods, which typically involve the numerical computation of the expected number density of observed clusters with a likelihood function (e.g. 16 ; 40 ; 29 ; 18 ). These approaches are primarily limited by the model complexity. Modeling effects include correlations among multiple observables, skewness in the distributions, complex scaling relations, and sample variance, which typically lead to a large number of nuisance parameters that must be integrated out numerically. Furthermore, the expansion in sample size, together with the increased volume of ancillary weak-lensing data employed in mass calibration, results in greater computational demands and, consequently, longer likelihood evaluation times. Finally, they usually involve an information loss inherent to data compression. A promising alternative is simulation-based inference (SBI; see 31 for a review), a likelihood-free approach that infers posterior distributions of model parameters directly from mock observations generated under forward simulations. In the context of cluster cosmology, SBI enables the use of the full information contained in individual clusters, while naturally incorporating survey selection effects and complex scaling relations. Neural density estimators, such as normalizing flows (e.g., masked autoregressive flows ( 70 ) ), offer a flexible way of approximating the posterior, provided suitable data embeddings are used. Since mock catalogs from cosmological forward models vary in the number of objects they contain, the corresponding SBI architecture must be able to process inputs of varying sizes. Consequently, some operation needs to be applied to the variable-dimensional data vector to standardize its dimensionality; the easiest choice is binning in the data space. In this work, we take a step further and present the first application of SBI to Bayesian cosmological inference for X-ray-selected galaxy clusters that does not require fixed input vector dimensions and can handle varying sample sizes. Using mock catalogs calibrated to the eRASS1 survey, we train a set-based embedding network that encodes individual cluster properties and passes them to a masked autoregressive flow for posterior estimation. The set-based neural network resembles a graph neural network (GNN) that operates on sets (i.e., graphs without edges). This allows us to use highly informative neural-informed summary statistics rather than naive compression techniques such as binning. We demonstrate, using realistic mock catalogs calibrated to the eRASS1 survey, that this method can recover Bayesian cosmological constraints consistent with established approaches, while providing a framework capable of scaling to future eROSITA data releases. This work focuses on methodological development and validation, while applications to observational survey data are deferred to follow-up work. This paper is structured as follows. Section 2 describes the simulated mock catalogs used in this work. Section 3 introduces our SBI framework, including the embedding network and density estimator. In Sect. 4 , we present the results of our cosmological inference and discuss the implications and robustness of our findings. Section 5 provides our conclusions and outlook. 2 Training data To train a neural network to infer cosmological and auxiliary parameters from eRASS1, we adopt a forward model that closely mirrors the survey (see Artis et al., in prep., 2026). The full parameter set used