Hidden-ordered Dirac fermions
Bitan Roy · 2026
Read Hidden-ordered Dirac fermions by Bitan Roy (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27368.txt.
Introduction
Roy proposes a new species of Dirac fermion whose order hides from ordinary probes. Standard Dirac materials pair a kinetic term with one masslike operator that anticommutes with it. Adding a second, independent anticommuting masslike operator yields what he calls hidden-ordered Dirac fermions. The spectrum stays linear in any spatial dimension, with a renormalised Fermi velocity. In the theory paper of 2026, phase diagrams change because the hidden order commutes differently with candidate insulating orders.
Insulating transitions get pushed to stronger coupling than in ordinary Dirac systems. Whether the hidden-ordered phase survives near criticality depends on the algebra between its order parameter and the insulating one. Concrete lattice models realise the construction, giving simulators a target. The proposal enlarges the known taxonomy of Dirac matter. Hidden order becomes a tunable axis rather than a curiosity. Experimental signatures are left as a challenge for lattice realisations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bitan Roy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27368
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Hidden-ordered Dirac fermions Bitan Roy Abstract I propose a Hermitian extension of the Lorentz-symmetric Dirac theory by complementing the associated Hamiltonian with another masslike anticommuting Dirac operator. The resulting theory manifests the iconic linear energy-momentum relationship in any dimension ( d d ) and hence the emergent nodal quasiparticle excitations are named hidden-ordered Dirac fermions , which are symmetry protected and their responses are analogous to those in original Dirac systems, however, in terms of a renormalized (due to the hidden ordering) Fermi velocity. Typically, such a hidden ordering pushes any quantum phase transition into an insulation toward even stronger coupling in any d > 1 d>1 . However, depending on the internal algebra between the candidate insulating order parameter and masslike Dirac operator, the hidden-ordering may survive or disappear near the corresponding itinerant quantum critical point. I construct lattice models for such hidden-ordered massless Dirac fermions and outline promising platforms (numerical and experimental) to test these predictions. Introduction . Linear energy-momentum relationship is critical to ensure the Lorentz symmetry in the Dirac theory Dirac:1 ; Dirac:2 . Furthermore, the discrete charge conjugation ( {\mathcal{C}} ), parity or inversion ( {\mathcal{P}} ), and time-reversal ( {\mathcal{T}} ) symmetries restrict the associated Dirac Hamiltonian for relativistic fermions to its canonical form peskin . Specifically, the Dirac theory permits two quantities that transform as scalars under the Lorentz transformation; (a) the Dirac Hamiltonian that is linear in momentum and (b) a constant mass terms. Both of them are accompanied by appropriate \gamma matrices, which mutually anticommute. In terms of such Lorentz-Dirac scalars, here I propose a Lorentz-symmetric Hermitian extension of the Dirac Hamiltonian for massless quasi-relativistic excitations that continues to display the hallmark linear energy-momentum relation in any dimension ( d ). Construction . The Dirac Hamiltonian for quasi-relativistic fermions with the Fermi velocity v_{{}_{\rm F}} takes the universal form H_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k})=v_{{}_{\rm F}}\left(\Gamma_{j}k_{j}\right) , where j=1,\cdots d and a summation over repeated indices is assumed. The Hermitian \Gamma matrices satisfy the anticommuting Clifford algebra \{\Gamma_{j},\Gamma_{k}\}=2\delta_{jk} , where \delta_{jk} is the Kronecker delta symbol, yielding the energy spectra \pm E_{{\bm{k}}} manifesting the linear energy-momentum relation E_{{\bm{k}}}=v_{{}_{\rm F}}|\bm{k}| . The dimensionality and explicit representation of the \Gamma matrices depend on d and microscopic details, about which more in a moment. In this language, any Dirac mass is represented by a Hermitian matrix M , satisfying \{M,\Gamma_{j}\}=0 for any j and M^{2}=\Gamma_{0} (identity matrix). In terms of these two ingredients, I propose the following Lorentz invariant extended Dirac operator ~H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k})=H_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k})+i\alpha MH_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k}), (1) where \alpha is a dimensionless quantity. The energy spectra of H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) are \pm E_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) with E_{\rm HO}(\bm{k})=v_{{}_{\rm F}}\sqrt{1+\alpha^{2}}|\bm{k}| . Therefore, H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) continues to display the characteristic linear energy-momentum relation in terms of a renormalized Fermi velocity v^{\rm R}_{{}_{\rm F}}=v_{{}_{\rm F}}\sqrt{1+\alpha^{2}} , despite containing a mass matrix ( M ) therein which typically stems from ordering, devoid of some discrete and/or continuous symmetries. So, I name such nodal quasi-relativistic excitations hidden-ordered Dirac fermions (HODF) and showcase the outcomes, summarized below. In monolayer graphene (a planar Dirac system), it is conceivable to find gapless superconducting phases with pairing amplitude \alpha for which the effective single-particle Bogoliubov de-Gennes Hamiltonian takes the form of H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) Roy-Herbut-2010:PRB ; Uchoa-CastroNeto-2007:PRL . Key results . The Hamiltonian for HODF is unitarily equivalent to a scaled Dirac Hamiltonian according to H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k})=e^{iM\theta/2}\>\left\{\sqrt{1+\alpha^{2}}\;H_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k})\right\}\>e^{-iM\theta/2}, (2) where \theta=\tan^{-1}(\alpha) . The gapless nature of such HODF is shown to be symmetry protected, despite H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) containing a symmetry-breaking mass matrix ( M ). Thermodynamic, transport, and elastic responses of massless HODF show the same power-law scaling as the original Dirac systems, however, in terms of v^{\rm R}_{{}_{\rm F}} . The enhanced Fermi velocity yielding a larger band width defers any spontaneous symmetry breaking in hidden-ordered Dirac systems toward a stronger coupling in comparison to that in conventional Dirac systems. Here, this outcome is shown by considering only mass orders that are represented by matrices ( N ) that fully anticommute with H_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k}) . However, the quantum critical phenomena in the close proximity to mass orderings crucially depend on the internal algebra between the candidate mass order matrix N and the mass matrix appearing in H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) , namely M . When [N,M]=0 , thus the ordered phase earns the name commuting class mass (CCM), the parameter associated with the hidden-ordering ( \alpha ) remains marginal . If, on the other hand, \{N,M\}=0 , for which the ordered phase is coined anticommuting class mass (ACM), the parameter \alpha becomes marginally irrelevant near such ordering. Alternatively, the hidden-ordering disappears near the ACM ordering. Next these results are discussed in detail. Symmetry protection . In d=2 the minimal representation of pseudo-spin Dirac fermions in any lattice-based spinless system (such as graphene) is four and the \Gamma matrices appearing in H_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k}) are four-dimensional. Without loss of generality, I choose \Gamma_{1} and \Gamma_{2} to be purely imaginary okubo , for which {\mathcal{T}}={\mathcal{K}} , where {\mathcal{K}} is the complex conjugation, such that {\mathcal{T}}^{2}=+1 , as it should be for spinless fermions. The (antiunitary) particle-hole symmetry is generated by {\mathcal{C}}={\bm{\Gamma}}{\mathcal{K}} , where {\bm{\Gamma}}\in\{\Gamma_{3},\Gamma_{4},\Gamma_{5},\Gamma_{12}\} with \Gamma_{jk}=i\Gamma_{j}\Gamma_{k} . Note that {\bm{\Gamma}} is the set of matrices that fully anticommute with H_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k}) and thus represents all the mass orders. I choose \Gamma_{3} , \Gamma_{4} , and \Gamma_{5} to be purely real and \{\Gamma_{j}\} with j=1,\cdots,5 constitute the set of maximal five mutually anticommuting four-dimensional Hermitian matrices. The unitary particle-hole or sublattice symmetry is generated by {\mathcal{S}}={\bm{\Gamma}} . The generators of rotational symmetry about the z axis is \Gamma_{12} . In addition, the two-dimensional Dirac Hamiltonian also enjoys a SU(2) chiral symmetry, generated by \{\Gamma_{34},\Gamma_{45},\Gamma_{53}\} . Hence, the triplet mass \{\Gamma_{3},\Gamma_{4},\Gamma_{5}\} breaks (preserves) the chiral (time-reversal) symmetry, while the signlet mass \Gamma_{12} preserves (breaks) the chiral (time-reversal) symmetry graphenemicroscopic:1 ; graphenemicroscopic:2 . So, it is sufficient to choose M=\Gamma_{3} and \Gamma_{12} in Eq. ( 1 ) to establish symmetry protection of nodal HODF in d=2 . With the former choice of M , H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) lacks the {\mathcal{T}} symmetry, but possesses particle-hole symmetries, generated by {\mathcal{C}}=\Gamma_{4}{\mathcal{K}},\Gamma_{5}{\mathcal{K}} and {\mathcal{S}}=\Gamma_{3},\Gamma_{12} , besides the rotational symmetry, and a reduced U(1) chiral symmetry under \Gamma_{45} . As shown in the Supplemental Material (SM), residual symmetries of H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) are sufficient to forbid the nucleation of any fermion bilinear SM . By contrast, when M=\Gamma_{12} , H_{\rm HO}(\bm{k}) possesses identical symmetries as H_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k}) . Hence, formation of finite vacuum expectation value of any fermionic bilinear must be associated with the breakdown of some symmetry of the noninteracting system. Therefore, a collection of HODF in two spatial dimensions is always symmetry protected. In d=3 , I choose three four-dimensional \Gamma matrices ( \Gamma_{1} , \Gamma_{2} , and \Gamma_{3} ) appearing in H_{\rm Dir}(\bm{k}) to be purely real. The time-reversal operator is then {\mathcal{T}}=\Gamma_{4}{\mathcal{K}} or \Gamma_{5}{\mathcal{K}} . For either choice {\mathcal{T}}^{2}=-1 as it should be, since a four-component Dirac theory in d=3 involves relativistic spin-1/2 fermions with strong spin-orbit coupling Dirac:1 ; Dirac:2 ; peskin . The particle-hole symmetries are generated by {\mathcal{C}}=\Gamma_{45}{\mathcal{K}} or {\mathcal{K}} and {\mathcal{S}}=\Gamma_{4} or \Gamma_{5} . The parity or inversion, under which \bm{r}\to-\bm{r} and \bm{k}\to-\bm{k} , is generated by {\mathcal{P}}=\Gamma_{4} or \Gamma_{5} . The three-dimensional Dirac Hamiltonian