Reading the Same Data Differently: Interpretive Labor Across System Boundaries in Electronic Monitoring CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Human-centered computing Ubiquitous and mobile computing CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI)

Yibo Meng*, Bingyi Liu, Zhiqi Gao, Shuai Ma, Hongyu Zhou · 2026

Read Reading the Same Data Differently: Interpretive Labor Across System Boundaries in Electronic Monitoring CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Human-centered computing Ubiquitous and mobile computing CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) by Yibo Meng*, Bingyi Liu, Zhiqi Gao, Shuai Ma, Hongyu Zhou (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27301.txt.

Introduction

Meng and colleagues examine how tracking data get read in opposite ways by the two sides of the corrections system. Ankle monitoring tracks supervised people through ankle devices, location rules, and status logs. Interviews cover twenty-six supervised people and twelve staff in China's community corrections system. Watched people see only outcomes, guessing system logic with little visibility into official interpretation. Staff rebuild conduct from murky traces using context, experience, and procedure in this poster study from 2026.

That structural divergence is named interpretive misalignment. Unequal access to data, context, and reasoning produces it. Behaviour adapts in response: probing, strategic compliance, over-compliance, disengagement, and contestation all appear. A stray signal can mean violation, device failure, or blind spot, with freedom riding on the reading. Steady sensing emerges as distributed reading work, not automatic enforcement. Designs that make data-to-decision paths legible and contestable are the authors' closing plea.

Catalog record

CREATORYibo Meng*, Bingyi Liu, Zhiqi Gao, Shuai Ma, Hongyu Zhou
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27301

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reading the Same Data Differently: Interpretive Labor Across System Boundaries in Electronic Monitoring CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Human-centered computing Ubiquitous and mobile computing CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) Yibo Meng*, Bingyi Liu, Zhiqi Gao, Shuai Ma, Hongyu Zhou Abstract . Electronic monitoring (EM) systems are increasingly used in community corrections to enforce spatial, temporal, and behavioral rules through continuous sensing. While prior work has examined EM as a criminal justice tool or as a mechanism for compliance, less is known about how sensed data become meaningful in everyday practice. This poster examines EM as a dual-sided sensing system in which supervised individuals and authorities reason about the same data stream from different positions. Based on semi-structured interviews with 26 supervised individuals and 12 authorities in China’s community corrections system, we show that supervised individuals infer system logic from outcomes with limited visibility into how data are interpreted, while authorities reconstruct behavior from ambiguous traces using contextual knowledge, professional experience, and institutional procedures. We call this structural divergence interpretive misalignment . It emerges from asymmetric access to data, context, and reasoning processes, and it shapes behavior through probing, strategic adaptation, over-compliance, disengagement, and contestation. We contribute a CSCW account of continuous sensing as distributed interpretive work and identify design opportunities for making data-to-decision processes more legible, contestable, and accountable across system sides. 1. Introduction Electronic monitoring (EM) systems use continuous sensing to supervise people under community-based correctional arrangements, translating everyday movement and activity through GPS ankle monitors, mobile reporting tools, geofences, and device-status logs into records that may trigger warnings, intervention, or sanction. We argue that EM should be understood not only as a criminal justice technology, but also as an intensified and highly consequential form of ubiquitous computing, where sensing is persistent, participation is compulsory, and interpretation can directly shape freedom, mobility, work, and family life ( 34 ; 1 ; 4 ; 39 ) . However, the traces produced by EM systems do not carry stable meanings on their own. A boundary crossing may be read as an intentional violation, but may also result from GPS drift, environmental interference, or an imprecisely defined legal boundary; similarly, a signal interruption may indicate device failure, a signal blind spot, or deliberate manipulation ( 15 ; 17 ; 33 ; 35 ) . What becomes consequential, therefore, is not only whether sensing is technically accurate, but how data traces are interpreted, contextualised, and connected to institutional action. This study examines how different actors construct meaning around the same continuous data stream. Supervised individuals typically begin from their own lived actions and try to infer how the system records, classifies, and judges them, whereas authorities begin from system-generated traces and work backward to reconstruct behaviour. These actors therefore reason in opposite directions, under unequal access to context, discretion, and each other’s interpretive processes. We investigate this dynamic through 38 semi-structured interviews in China’s community corrections system, where EM is used to supervise people serving non-custodial sentences. This poster contributes a dual-sided empirical account of how continuous sensing is understood by both monitored individuals and institutional reviewers, develops interpretive misalignment as a concept for explaining how actors can reasonably draw different meanings from the same data, and identifies design implications for CSCW systems that must support not only sensing accuracy, but also interpretive legibility, contestability, and accountability. 2. Related Work and Positioning 2.1. Electronic Monitoring as Continuous Sensing Electronic monitoring has often been evaluated through policy questions such as deterrence, compliance, recidivism, and alternatives to incarceration ( 4 ; 27 ; 7 ; 26 ) . CSCW and HCI research, however, invite a complementary view: EM can be understood as a continuous sensing environment in which data infrastructures reorganize everyday action, responsibility, and institutional interaction. Location-based systems already raise questions about what location records can prove, who is accountable for their interpretation, and how presence becomes administratively meaningful ( 33 ; 11 ; 32 ; 31 ) . EM makes these questions especially visible because participation is mandatory and the consequences of interpretation are immediate and high stakes. 2.2. Sensemaking Around Opaque Systems Prior work on algorithmic opacity shows that users develop folk theories and practical models for systems whose internal logic is only partially visible ( 29 ; 12 ; 16 ; 9 ) . Such work typically focuses on how users explain feeds, rankings, or algorithmic recommendations. In EM, sensemaking occurs under stronger constraints: users cannot simply opt out, and uncertain interpretations may produce sanctions. The system therefore becomes something users must learn, test, and anticipate in daily life. 2.3. Institutional Judgment and Distributed Interpretation Authorities also engage in sensemaking. Street-level bureaucracy scholarship shows that frontline actors apply discretion when formal rules meet incomplete information ( 18 ; 8 ; 19 ; 21 ) . CSCW and algorithmic accountability research further shows that human judgment is shaped by how data, categories, and decision-support systems organize work ( 14 ; 2 ; 5 ; 20 ) . Our study connects these perspectives by examining user-side and authority-side interpretation together. The central problem is not simply opacity for users or discretion for institutions, but how sensing systems distribute interpretive authority across actors. 3. Method We conducted a qualitative interview study with two participant groups in China’s community corrections system: 26 supervised individuals and 12 authorities. Supervised participants had at least three months of recent EM experience, while authorities had direct experience reviewing monitoring records, interpreting anomalies, or making intervention decisions. Participants were recruited through purposive and snowball sampling via community corrections channels, and varied in age, gender, education, occupation, and urban–rural background. Most supervised participants wore GPS ankle monitors; some also used mobile reporting tools, smart wristbands, alcohol sensors, or physiological sensors. Interviews lasted approximately 45–65 minutes and were conducted one-on-one, online or offline. Interviews with supervised individuals focused on daily restrictions, perceived system logic, mismatched records, uncertainty, coping strategies, and perceptions of authority judgment. To move beyond general attitudes, we asked participants to reconstruct concrete events, such as unexpected system records, moments of uncertainty about whether an action would be flagged, or situations where monitoring changed their routines. Interviews with authorities focused on data presentation, anomaly interpretation, contextual information, uncertainty management, risk assessment, and decisions about whether to observe, verify, warn, or escalate. We analyzed transcripts using iterative thematic analysis ( 6 ; 37 ; 36 ; 10 ) . Three researchers first independently coded a subset of transcripts and developed an initial codebook, including codes such as “GPS drift,” “hidden threshold,” “self-protection,” “trajectory-based judgment,” “risk category,” and “evidence conflict.” We then refined and applied the codebook across the full dataset, using constant comparison ( 13 ; 25 ; 38 ; 24 ) to identify patterns within and across the two participant groups. The analysis focused on how actors interpreted data, how their interpretations diverged, and how such divergence shaped action over time. 4. Results Our findings identify a dual-sided interpretive process. Supervised individuals and authorities make sense of the same monitoring system, but they do so through different starting points, different evidence, and different forms of visibility. 4.1. Supervised Individuals Build Practical Models of the System For supervised individuals, EM was experienced as a set of

Read the complete text