Beyond Objects
Daniel Jackson · 2026
Read Beyond Objects by Daniel Jackson (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27258.txt.
Introduction
Jackson argues that object orientation, the organising idea behind decades of software design, rests on a flawed split. The founding principle assigns each system function to objects mirroring individuals in the problem domain. Jackson contends that carving functionality along those lines is neither natural nor straightforward. Later methods tried to patch the resulting fragmentation and conflation of functions. Those troubles, he argues, were inevitable consequences of the founding principle itself in this essay from 2026, written for a memorial volume honouring Jean-Raymond Abrial.
An easier path starts by abandoning object orientation altogether. The alternative decouples problem-domain individuals from the modules that partition functionality. Historical discussion reaches back to Abrial's 1974 data semantics work, an early abstract model of objects and relations. That model, Jackson suggests, already hinted the object structure was the wrong path. Software specification and design gain a cleaner foundation when functions are partitioned on their own terms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniel Jackson |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27258
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Beyond Objects Daniel Jackson Abstract A core principle of object orientation—that the functionality of a system can be partitioned amongst objects that correspond to individuals in the problem domain—has influenced how software has been specified, designed and implemented for more than fifty years. Later developments in software engineering sought to build on this principle. But in fact this partitioning is neither natural nor straightforward, and the problems that these later developments sought to mitigate—the fragmentation and conflation of functionality—were often, in fact, the inevitable consequences of this founding principle. An easier path to addressing these problems therefore starts by going back, abandoning object orientation, and replacing it with an alternative approach that decouples the individuals of the problem domain from the modules that partition functionality. To appear, Gedenkenschrift for Jean-Raymond Abrial, Springer Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Volume 16750. 1 Historical Preamble In 1974, Jean-Raymond Abrial presented a paper entitled Data Semantics at an IFIP Working Conference on Data Base Management [ 2 ] . That paper came to be viewed as a seminal contribution to the theory of object orientation. Simula 67 [ 18 ] , which was almost a decade old at that point, had introduced the key ideas of object-oriented programming, but only as an execution mechanism, and there was little understanding of objects as semantic entities independent of their implementation. Abrial’s paper offered an abstract model of objects connected by relations, forming a bridge between the nascent world of object orientation and the relational data model that Codd had introduced a few years earlier [ 13 ] . Chen’s entity relationship model would build on Abrial’s model, and become the standard semantic view of relational data [ 12 ] . In Abrial’s model, the state of a system is a collection of relations over object identities. These relations were global; there was no scoping or module structure. From the perspective of later developments in object orientation, this made Abrial’s contribution suspect. Why did he not adopt the compelling object structuring that was already available in languages like Simula? Abrial seemed to realize that object-oriented structuring was not the right path to a more modular definition of behavior and state. In his subsequent work on Z [ 1 ] (and later B [ 3 ] ), he continued to view state relationally. Both Z and B offered structuring mechanisms for large specifications, with Z being particularly flexible in supporting a separation of concerns (exploited in work on view-based specification [ 32 , 5 , 19 , 22 ] , which anticipates some of the ideas of this paper). B was more traditional than Z in this respect, but a proposal [ 51 ] for adding event synchronization [ 29 ] to Event-B [ 4 ] results in a language very similar to that described here. Surprisingly, the researchers who developed modularity mechanisms for Z and B seem to have had rather limited goals—primarily easing the tasks of specification and verification. Papers and books about formal methods tend not to be concerned about the modularity of software, except insofar as it impacts the difficulty of constructing a one-time proof of correctness. This seems to be a missed opportunity. In this paper, some classical ideas of abstract modeling from the field of formal methods—in particular relational states, events as state predicates, and event synchronization—are used to organize software in a new way that aligns with recent trends in industrial software development but offers improved separation of concerns and a more direct correspondence between problem domain and computational elements. Seeds of these ideas can be found in early formal methods work. A 1987 specification of the CAVIAR reservation system by Bill Flinn and Ib Holm Sorensen that was included in Ian Hayes’s case study collection [ 27 ] proposed a parameterized module feature for Z, which it illustrated with a generic reservation module that could be applied (in different variants) to different kinds of resources (such as hotel rooms, conference rooms, and minibus seats). This specification inspired later work by Ian Hayes and Luke Wildman on modularity mechanisms for specification libraries [ 26 ] . As the CAVIAR acknowledgments explain, these modularity ideas came from the original 1981 version of the specification, whose author was none other than Jean-Raymond Abrial himself. 2 Introduction On September 30, 1991, the cover of Business Week [ 11 ] depicted a cartoon baby happily clicking away on a computer keyboard under the caption “Software Made Simple.” The article inside explained: Instead of microchips, the software revolution will be built on so-called objects—simple, self-contained, reliable software components. Perhaps a revolution was indeed built on objects. Whether they provided reliability is hard to judge. But simple and self-contained? That objects would turn out not to be—and this paper will explain why. In the conventional reading of the history of software engineering, object-oriented programming is one of its major successes. Following its invention more than 50 years ago, it has been widely applied in many successful systems. The technical challenges of designing and implementing object-oriented languages have been largely solved, and stable programming practices are reflected in well known patterns. At the same time, the fundamental problems of software development have not gone away. Code is still hard to write and hard to read (and in many respects much harder than it was 30 years ago), and making the smallest changes to a large software system is still extremely challenging. While paying lip service to modularity, developers continue to entangle their code with couplings, with the popularity of the term ‘dependency hell’ attesting to the pain this causes. The advent of LLM-based coding promises to reduce dramatically the amount of human effort involved in programming. But code generated by LLMs follows the same practices that got human coders into trouble, and the use of LLMs seems poised to amass vast piles of technical debt—code that is fragile, unpredictable and near unmaintainable. A brighter future, for human and LLM developers alike, is possible if we are prepared to reconsider the paradigms and assumptions that led us to this point. Many researchers and practitioners assume that object orientation was a major step forward, and that we simply need to refine and augment it with further advances. But many of the problems that currently plague software development are the direct and inevitable consequences of object orientation itself. The seeds of our contemporary problems were planted so long ago that a careful analysis will be needed to identify them and to trace their influence. Object orientation is not a single idea, but a complex of ideas that have merged together in the popular conception of object-oriented programming. By disentangling these distinct notions and motivations that have become conflated over the years, we will be able to understand object orientation better and expose opportunities to use a subset rather than being committed to the entire package. One particular principle, which brings two influential ideas together, has been the cause of many of our problems. It can be dropped without abandoning object-oriented programming in its entirety. But because this principle guides the high-level organization of most software systems today, it will need to be replaced by a different principle that achieves the intended