Forward-modelling the Tolman and distance-duality tests with IllustrisTNG 2026 Forward-modelling the Tolman and distance-duality tests with IllustrisTNG – References

Harry Desmond, Tariq Yasin, Richard Stiskalek, Sebastian von Hausegger · 2026

Read Forward-modelling the Tolman and distance-duality tests with IllustrisTNG 2026 Forward-modelling the Tolman and distance-duality tests with IllustrisTNG – References by Harry Desmond, Tariq Yasin, Richard Stiskalek, Sebastian von Hausegger (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27182.txt.

Introduction

Desmond and colleagues test two classic checks of cosmic expansion inside a simulated universe. The Tolman test watches how galaxy surface brightness fades with redshift, meaning distance in cosmic time. The distance-duality test compares two kinds of distance measures that expanding space links tightly. Recent observations look flatter than standard cosmology expects, fuelling non-expanding claims. Forward modelling inside the IllustrisTNG simulation asks whether ordinary galaxy evolution explains the signals, in a study appearing in 2026.

A mock survey selection, trained on real survey data, mimics how observed galaxies get chosen. Relevant galaxy change compresses into one power-law exponent for luminosity density over redshift. The simulation's value is roughly enough to explain both test signals within standard cosmology. A small leftover gap for the radio test hints radio galaxies evolve slightly more strongly. Exotic cosmology is not needed; selection and evolution do the explanatory work.

Catalog record

CREATORHarry Desmond, Tariq Yasin, Richard Stiskalek, Sebastian von Hausegger
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27182

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Forward-modelling the Tolman and distance-duality tests with IllustrisTNG 2026 Forward-modelling the Tolman and distance-duality tests with IllustrisTNG – References Harry Desmond, Tariq Yasin, Richard Stiskalek, Sebastian von Hausegger Abstract The Tolman surface-brightness test and the angular-size distance-duality test are two complementary probes of the same underlying relation between luminosity and angular-diameter distance, D L = ( 1 + z ) 2 ​ D A D_{L}=(1+z)^{2}D_{A} , as holds in any metric theory of gravity where photon number is conserved. Both tests have recently delivered a priori surprising signals: JWST/ASTRODEEP measurements yield a surface brightness scaling with redshift much flatter than the expected value, and ultracompact radio sources also appear to follow a flatter D L / D A D_{L}/D_{A} scaling with redshift. These results have been suggested to support non-expanding cosmologies, however they are also sensitive to astrophysical and instrumental effects. We test whether these results indicate genuine departures from standard cosmology by forward-modelling observed surface-brightness evolution in the IllustrisTNG cosmological hydrodynamical simulation, with an empirical mock-spectroscopic selection trained on ASTRODEEP. We show that the astrophysical evolution relevant for both tests may be effectively parametrised as a single power-law exponent for the luminosity density as a function of redshift, for which the simulation gives γ = 2.23 ± 0.20 \gamma=2.23\pm 0.20 across realistic aperture conventions. This value is approximately sufficient to explain both the Tolman and distance-duality signals within standard cosmology and galaxy formation physics, with a small discrepancy for the latter suggesting that radio AGN evolve slightly more strongly than bright galaxies. 1 Introduction The redshift–distance relation is a fundamental relation in cosmology. In any metric theory of gravity that conserves photon number along null geodesics, luminosity and angular-diameter distances are linked by the Etherington relation D_{L}=(1+z)^{2}D_{A} ( Etherington 1933 ) . This relation is geometric in origin and so is independent of the gravitational field equations and hence the dynamics of the expansion; it can therefore be used as an unambiguous test that the Universe permits a metric description ( Ellis 2007 ) . Two operational tests of this prediction have a long history. The first is the Tolman surface-brightness (SB) test ( Tolman 1930 ; Tolman 1934 ) : for a non-evolving extended source the bolometric SB should fall as I_{\rm SB}\propto(1+z)^{-4} , while a measurement at fixed observer-frame frequency in a single broad band gives I_{\rm SB}^{\rm obs}\propto(1+z)^{-(3+\alpha_{\rm SED})} with \alpha_{\rm SED} the rest-frame spectral energy distribution (SED) slope of the source. The second is the angular-size–redshift relation for non-evolving compact sources ( Kapahi 1987 ; Gurvits 1994 ; Gurvits et al. 1999 ; Jackson & Jannetta 2006 ; Cao et al. 2017 ) : an object of fixed rest-frame physical size has a redshift-dependent angular size that, combined with a flux measurement, can be reduced to the duality ratio D_{L}/D_{A} (hereafter the distance-duality relation, DDR). Cluster Sunyaev–Zel’dovich measurements ( Holanda et al. 2010 , e.g.) and strong-lensing Einstein-radius and velocity-dispersion measurements ( Liao et al. 2016 , e.g.) provide further independent handles (see also Bassett & Kunz 2004 and Uzan et al. 2004 for early introductions to these tests). Both tests have very recently produced results seemingly threatening to standard cosmology. Tsymbal et al. 2026 report observed-frame Tolman redshift scaling of I_{\rm SB}\propto(1+z)^{-1.3} from the ASTRODEEP-JWST catalogue ( Merlin et al. 2024 ) , which they compare primarily with the bolometric Tolman expectation I_{\rm SB}\propto(1+z)^{-4} . Because our forward model works with observed broad-band flux densities, we use below the corresponding specific-flux prediction I_{\rm SB}^{\rm obs}\propto(1+z)^{-(3+\alpha_{\rm SED})} ; for our fiducial \alpha_{\rm SED}=0.3 this is still much steeper than the measured slope. 1 1 1 In fact, Tsymbal et al. 2026 also work with a broad-band flux, making the relevant reference slope -3-\alpha_{\text{SED}} rather than -4. We return to this issue in Sec. 5 . Li 2023 combines the JJ2.29 ( Jackson & Jannetta 2006 ) and GKF5.0 ( Gurvits et al. 1999 ) ultracompact-radio samples to construct an empirical D_{L}/D_{A}(z) , and finds that this closely matches D_{L}=(1+z)D_{A} . Such findings could be framed as evidence for a non-expanding cosmology in which tired-light models provide a mechanism to generate redshifts ( Lerner 2018 ; Lopez-Corredoira 2014 , e.g.) ; for simplicity we refer to these simply as “non-expanding” or “non-exp.” models hereafter. Alternatively they may also be indicative of strong evolution of the source populations within standard Friedmann–Robertson–Walker (FRW) cosmology, or simply as artefacts of photometric systematics. Source evolution has been considered in the classical Tolman setting, where the measured passive luminosity evolution of, e.g., cluster ellipticals accounts for the shortfall of the recovered exponent from its bolometric value ( Pahre et al. 1996 ; Lubin & Sandage 2001c ) , and has been revisited recently in a JWST-era volume Tolman test ( Conselice et al. 2026 ) . What has not been done is a forward-model calibration of the intrinsic-evolution exponent itself in a \Lambda CDM galaxy-formation simulation, propagated through both the surface-brightness and the distance-duality inferences jointly. That is the goal of this paper. It is important to realise that while the fundamental redshift scaling D_{L}=(1+z)^{2}D_{A} arises purely from metric geometry, measuring either distance through a population of sources and hence reconstructing this relation empirically requires a model for the intrinsic luminosity (in the case of D_{L} ) and intrinsic physical size (in the case of D_{A} ) of those sources at each redshift. Unless dealing with a standard candle or ruler this has to be done by modelling the redshift evolution of the population, and any unmodelled redshift evolution in the population’s intrinsic luminosity or size can bias the inferred D_{L} or D_{A} . This is the mechanism by which a population of sources can appear to fail the distance-duality test while in fact obeying the conventional relation, as has been appreciated in the literature (e.g. Lopez-Corredoira 2014 ; Lerner 2018 ). It is in fact the mechanism we find to be at play. Although the Tolman surface brightness test and the angular-size distance duality test both depend on the sources’ D_{L} and D_{A} , they are conventionally treated as independent. Indeed they do respond to different intrinsic quantities: the Tolman observable measures projected luminosity density (with A_{\text{phys}} the rest-frame source area on the sky), \Sigma_{L}\equiv L/A_{\rm phys} , whereas the Li 2023 distance-duality reduction uses volumetric luminosity density, \rho_{L}\equiv L/V (with V the rest-frame source volume). Their redshift-evolution exponents therefore need not coincide a priori . A central question for the forward model is therefore whether a realistic \Lambda CDM galaxy population nevertheless links these two evolutions strongly enough to place the tests on a common physical footing, which we answer here in the affirmative. To test whether the intrinsic evolution necessary to reproduce the Tolman and distance-duality data is an expectation of \Lambda CDM we interrogate the state-of-the-art IllustrisTNG-100 simulation (hereafter TNG) ( Springel et al. 2018 ; Pillepich et al. 2018b ; Nelson et al. 2018 ; Naiman et al. 2018 ; Marinacci et al. 2018 ) , taking mock HST and JWST imaging from the MAST archive ( Nelson et al. 2019 ; Vogelsberger et al. 2020 ; Snyder et al. 2023 ) and applying a single empirical spectroscopic-selection model trained on ASTRODEEP. We measure the Tolman

Read the complete text