On the Effects of Decentralized Moderation on Network Robustness and Information Diffusion in Mastodon Preprint: APS/123-QED
Beatriz Arregui-García, Lucio La Cava, Anees Baqir, Andrea Tagarelli, Riccardo Gallotti, Sandro Meloni · 2026
Read On the Effects of Decentralized Moderation on Network Robustness and Information Diffusion in Mastodon Preprint: APS/123-QED by Beatriz Arregui-García, Lucio La Cava, Anees Baqir, Andrea Tagarelli, Riccardo Gallotti, Sandro Meloni (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-27149.txt.
Introduction
Arregui and colleagues examine how scattered moderation shapes Mastodon, the social network split across thousands of self-governed servers. The team builds a signed, directed, time-changing network from one year of records. Follows form positive links, while daily block actions form negative ones. Big questions follow: does constant local blocking destabilise the whole, and how does news then spread in this analysis of 2026?
Despite nonstop moderation, the structure stays strikingly stable over the year. Link patterns and degree shapes persist, and averaged transitions settle near Markovian balance over middle time scales. A marked split appears between instances that mostly ban and those mostly banned. Information starting in the banning minority spreads more efficiently, inside and outward. Flow in the reverse direction stays fragile. Echo chambers emerge even in a globally balanced network, and stricter spread rules strengthen them.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Beatriz Arregui-García, Lucio La Cava, Anees Baqir, Andrea Tagarelli, Riccardo Gallotti, Sandro Meloni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.27149
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Effects of Decentralized Moderation on Network Robustness and Information Diffusion in Mastodon Preprint: APS/123-QED Beatriz Arregui-García, Lucio La Cava, Anees Baqir, Andrea Tagarelli, Riccardo Gallotti, Sandro Meloni Abstract Decentralized online social networks such as Mastodon distribute moderation power across thousands of independently governed servers, raising fundamental questions about how local block decisions shape global structure and information flow. In this paper, we analyze Mastodon at the instance level by constructing a signed, directed, temporal network in which positive edges aggregate inter-instance follow relationships and negative edges encode daily block actions. Using one year of data, we show that despite continuous moderation activity and changing roles among instances, the network exhibits strong structural stability: signed dyadic motifs and degree distributions display highly persistent dynamics, and aggregated transition matrices satisfy Markovian equilibrium conditions over intermediate time scales. Building on the marked asymmetry between instances that predominantly issue bans and those that are mostly banned, we then study information diffusion on the positive network via a hybrid contagion model that combines simple contagion within groups and complex contagion across groups. We find that information originating in the minority of moderating instances spreads more efficiently, both internally and toward the majority, while the opposite direction is fragile and sensitive to contagion parameters. Echo-chamber effects emerge even in a globally balanced signed network and become stronger under stricter contagion conditions. Together, these results show that decentralized moderation in Mastodon generates a stable macroscopic configuration that both structures and constrains information exchange, effectively isolating norm-violating domains without centralized control. I Introduction Over the past two decades, online social networks (OSNs) have become essential infrastructures for communication, information exchange, and social organization 26 ; 3 ; 32 ; 29 . The scale at which millions of users—and increasingly, automated agents—participate in these environments generates complex, coordinated behavior 12 that can pose significant risks to public health or electoral integrity 15 ; 5 ; 18 . A wide range of harmful content, including misinformation, harassment, hate speech, and coordinated manipulation, can spread rapidly across densely connected systems, often outpacing mechanisms designed to detect or counteract it 25 ; 42 ; 22 . Studies across multiple platforms have shown that online communities can evolve into echo chambers, where selective exposure, homophily, and social reinforcement jointly amplify extreme or misleading content 11 ; 8 ; 10 . Mainstream platforms have responded with various content-moderation strategies, ranging from algorithmic filtering and fact-checking to the permanent removal of offending accounts—a practice known as deplatforming 21 ; 20 ; 35 . While deplatforming can effectively reduce the immediate reach of harmful content 40 , it can also generate unintended consequences: banned users often migrate to alternative platforms, where they may form ideologically homogeneous communities and continue their activities with diminished oversight 1 ; 19 . These dynamics highlight a fundamental dilemma of centralized moderation: it can limit harmful exposure within a platform, but may simultaneously fragment public discourse and accelerate the proliferation of less-regulated spaces 30 . As concerns about centralized governance grow, decentralized online social networks (DOSNs) have attracted increasing attention as an alternative paradigm. The structural properties of these networks have been studied with work focusing on the growth dynamics and backbone of the instance network 23 , and on how user communities are distributed across instances 6 ; 37 . In platforms such as Mastodon, content hosting, user data, and moderation responsibilities are distributed across independently operated servers—known as instances—interconnected through open protocols such as ActivityPub 36 . Rather than a single corporation enforcing uniform rules, each instance defines its own moderation policies, community norms, and governance practices. This federated design promises greater user autonomy, transparency, and resilience by eliminating a single point of control and enabling communities to self-organize according to their values 2 ; 39 ; 4 . A growing body of research has examined moderation in the Fediverse, predominantly through qualitative methods. Interview-based studies have explored the challenges faced by instance administrators and moderators, including the labor involved in moderation 38 and the use of community-level blocklists 31 ; 43 . Other qualitative work has examined the political dimensions of federated governance 16 , the formal rules adopted by Mastodon instances 34 , and how governance structures and moderation priorities evolve as communities grow 33 . Quantitative research remains comparatively limited. Existing studies include an analysis of defederation events, showing that blocking reduces activity on targeted servers without significantly affecting post toxicity 9 , using LLMs for automating community rule compliance 24 , and a federated graph-learning framework for detecting toxic conversations across instances while preserving data locality 27 . Despite growing attention to DOSNs, the mechanisms by which decentralized moderation shapes collective structure and information flow remain poorly understood. It remains unclear whether federated systems—subject to continuous, heterogeneous moderation activity—can settle into stable macroscopic configurations, or whether they exhibit persistent structural flux. While recent work has identified equilibrium-like properties in offline social ties 17 , comparable analyses in digital environments are scarce. Research on online networks has largely focused on growth mechanisms such as preferential attachment 28 or bursty edge dynamics 14 , rather than on the possibility of stationary regimes. This question is especially pertinent in Mastodon, where moderation does not merely regulate behavior but actively rewires the network: instances can block others, severing communication channels and reshaping the system’s topology. Moreover, structural features of signed networks—such as patterns of trust and distrust—have been shown to generate echo chambers and polarization even in the absence of algorithmic filtering 41 , raising the further question of whether moderation boundaries shape not only network structure but also the efficiency and directionality of information transmission. We address both questions: whether decentralized moderation produces a stable macroscopic configuration, and whether that stable structure leaves a fingerprint on what information reaches whom. In this paper, we investigate how decentralized moderation shapes the structural stability and information flows of Mastodon’s inter-instance network over one year of observation. We combine two large-scale datasets: a snapshot of inter-instance follow relationships and a daily record of instance-level domain blocks spanning August 2023 to July 2024. Representing the system as a signed, directed, temporal network—where positive edges encode social connectivity and negative edges encode moderation decisions—we show that, despite continuous moderation activity and evolving participant identities, the network’s edge configurations and degree distributions display strong temporal persistence, satisfying equilibrium conditions at mesoscopic temporal scales. Building on the structural asymmetry between instances that predominantly issue bans and those that are primarily targeted, we then simulate information diffusion using a hybrid contagion model that combines simple contagion within groups (moderators and banned instances) and complex contagion across group boundaries. We find that information originating in the minority of moderating instances spreads more efficiently—both internally and toward the majority—while the reverse direction is fragile and sensitive to contagion parameters. Echo-chamber effects emerge even in a globally balanced signed network and intensify under stricter contagion conditions. Together, these results show that decentralized moderation in Mastodon generates a stable macroscopic configuration that both structures and constrains information exchange, effectively isolating norm-violating domains without centralized control. II Network Description Figure 1: Moderation activity in the Mastodon social network: Panel A shows the total number of bans registered across instances