A geometric multimessenger consistency test of radiative and near-zone gravity with LISA and SKA

Bhooshan Gadre · 2026

Read A geometric multimessenger consistency test of radiative and near-zone gravity with LISA and SKA by Bhooshan Gadre (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26945.txt.

Introduction

Bhooshan Gadre proposes a consistency test of gravity using binaries seen by both radio telescopes and gravitational wave detectors. A compact binary pulsar's orbit tilt can be measured two ways. Radio timing gives it through the Shapiro delay, the slowing of pulses near the companion. Gravitational waves give it through the ratio of the signal's polarisation amplitudes. General relativity says both messengers must agree on the same geometry.

Gadre defines a residual: the radio value minus the wave value at a common epoch. Relativity predicts zero. A nonzero result would expose either hidden systematics or a real split between gravity's near-zone and radiative behaviour. Precision forecasts use a timing Fisher matrix and the expected sensitivity of the LISA space detector, with the Square Kilometre Array supplying radio timing. Conservative noise assumptions frame the estimates.

Catalog record

CREATORBhooshan Gadre
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26945

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A geometric multimessenger consistency test of radiative and near-zone gravity with LISA and SKA Bhooshan Gadre Abstract Compact binary pulsars observed both through precision radio timing and low-frequency gravitational waves offer a direct way to compare the same binary geometry with two independent messengers. We propose a multimessenger consistency test based on the orbital inclination, measured from the Shapiro-delay shape parameter in radio timing and from the tensor polarization amplitude ratio in the gravitational-wave signal. Defining the common-epoch residual ε ⁡ ( t 0 ) = s Shapiro ​ ( t 0 ) − s GW ​ ( t 0 ) \varepsilon(t_{0})=s_{\rm Shapiro}(t_{0})-s_{\rm GW}(t_{0}) , general relativity predicts ε = 0 \varepsilon=0 , while a nonzero value would indicate either an unmodeled systematic or a mismatch between the near-zone and radiative descriptions of gravity. We estimate the attainable precision on this quantity for representative LISA–SKA compact binary pulsars using a seven-parameter timing Fisher matrix and a sky-averaged LISA sensitivity curve including the Galactic foreground. We adopt a conservative radio baseline, σ TOA = 1 ​ μ ​ s \sigma_{\rm TOA}=1\,\mu{\rm s} and N eff = 10 4 N_{\rm eff}=10^{4} , intended to summarize radiometer noise, jitter, residual dispersion-measure and scattering effects, profile evolution, and cadence losses after wideband timing. For systems at d = 5 ​ kpc d=5\,{\rm kpc} observed for four years, we find σ ε ≃ 4 × 10 − 3 \sigma_{\varepsilon}\simeq 4\times 10^{-3} for a favorable double neutron star and σ ε ≃ 9 × 10 − 4 \sigma_{\varepsilon}\simeq 9\times 10^{-4} for a hypothetical pulsar–black-hole system. The former is the more robust astrophysical benchmark; the latter illustrates the reach if such a high-SNR chirping source is discovered. The useful cases remain limited mainly by gravitational-wave polarimetry, while radio timing supplies the near-zone reference measurement of the inclination. These results define a quantitative target for future joint Bayesian analyses of compact binary pulsars observed in both radio and gravitational waves. I Introduction Binary pulsars provide some of the most precise tests of gravity currently available. Radio timing probes the near-zone spacetime through pulse propagation effects, orbital dynamics, and post-Keplerian timing parameters 11 ; 27 ; 14 ; 18 ; 31 . The coming low-frequency gravitational-wave era adds a complementary view of the same systems. A subset of compact binary pulsars, especially short-period Galactic double neutron stars and possible pulsar–black-hole systems, should be observable both as radio pulsars timed with SKA-class precision and as slowly evolving low-frequency sources in LISA-like detectors 21 ; 20 ; 2 . LISA studies of Galactic binaries, verification binaries, and time-delay interferometry have already established the detector-response language needed to discuss such systems 8 ; 25 ; 7 ; 19 ; 3 . This opens up a multimessenger problem that is more interesting than parameter combination alone: the same binary geometry can be measured in two physically distinct ways. In this paper we focus on the orbital inclination \iota . In the gravitational-wave channel, \iota is inferred from the polarization content of the radiative field. In the radio channel, s=\sin\iota is inferred from the Shapiro delay experienced by pulses propagating through the companion’s gravitational potential. In general relativity these are simply different functions of the same angle. More generally they need not agree. A non-tensor contribution can bias the tensor-only polarization ratio used in the GW analysis, while a modified near-zone metric can bias the Shapiro-delay shape. The equality between s_{\rm GW} and s_{\rm Shapiro} is therefore a geometric cross-check between the radiative and near-zone sectors of the theory. The point is not that this test outperforms every existing binary-pulsar bound. It does not. The strongest scalar-tensor constraints from systems such as PSR J1738+0333 and the double pulsar rely on dipole-radiation and orbital-damping channels 14 ; 18 . The observable studied here probes something different: whether the inclination inferred from the radiative polarization geometry agrees with the inclination inferred from the near-zone metric. In that sense it is complementary to the usual \dot{P}_{b} tests, just as polarization, propagation, and generation tests are complementary within the broader GW tests-of-GR program 33 ; 31 ; 12 ; 24 . The credibility of this comparison depends on several practical issues. On the timing side, the Shapiro Fisher matrix must include the Roemer covariance and should be separated cleanly from assumptions about cadence and the effective amount of independent information. On the gravitational-wave side, the polarimetric inclination estimate must be used with due care, since it is only an analytic approximation to a full LISA inference problem. The Galactic foreground is anisotropic, and non-contemporaneous observations may be affected by secular changes in the projected orbit. Our aim here is to keep these issues explicit while still working with an analytic calculation that makes the basic scaling of the observable transparent. The paper is organized as follows. Section II places the observable in the context of existing binary-pulsar and GW tests. Section III defines the radiative and near-zone inclination measurements and the common-epoch residual. Section IV discusses phenomenological non-tensor leakage and the associated phase-coherence caveat. Section V develops the timing Fisher matrix, explains the treatment of cadence and effective timing weight, and summarizes omitted timing terms such as the Einstein delay. Section VI describes the LISA estimate and the way we bracket its unmodeled covariance. Section VII presents the benchmark results. Section VIII discusses cadence, Galactic confusion, chirping, precession, and common-epoch modeling. Section IX reports algebraic and numerical checks. Section X explains how the observable should be interpreted in specific theories, and Sec. XI outlines the corresponding Bayesian analysis. Appendices summarize the Takahashi–Seto scaling used here, the circular Shapiro identity, the seven-parameter timing derivatives, and reproducibility details. We use G=c=1 in analytic formulae unless SI units are displayed. II Relation to existing binary-pulsar and GW tests It is useful to separate three types of tests that are often grouped together. The first class consists of timing-only post-Keplerian tests. In those tests one measures several timing parameters, such as periastron advance, Einstein delay, Shapiro range and shape, and orbital decay, and asks whether a single pair of masses in a specified theory explains them. The second class consists of radiative tests, where the waveform phase, polarization, or propagation is compared with GR. The third class, to which the present paper belongs, compares two operational definitions of the same source geometry obtained from different sectors of the field. The inclination residual is not a stronger version of \dot{P}_{b} ; it is a different null relation. This distinction matters for interpreting numerical reach. A scalar-tensor theory with a light scalar can generate dipole radiation that is strongly constrained by \dot{P}_{b} . The same theory may generate much smaller changes in the tensor polarization ratio for a given binary orientation. It would therefore be misleading to rank the present observable solely by whether it improves the best scalar-tensor coupling bound. Its value is that it tests whether the radiative field and the near-zone metric encode the same inclination. This is the same logic that makes polarization tests interesting even when phase tests give stronger bounds in a specific model: the two observables probe different projections of theory space. The observable is also distinct from ordinary LISA–radio parameter combination. A joint fit that assumes

Read the complete text