Investigating the System Configuration of Kepler-451 through Orbital Period Variations: Dynamical and Magnetic Interpretations

Huseyin Er, Aykut Ozdonmez, M. Emir Kenger, B. Batuhan Gurbulak, Ilham Nasiroglu, Murat Tekkesinoglu, Ergun Ege, Nazlı Karaman · 2026

Read Investigating the System Configuration of Kepler-451 through Orbital Period Variations: Dynamical and Magnetic Interpretations by Huseyin Er, Aykut Ozdonmez, M. Emir Kenger, B. Batuhan Gurbulak, Ilham Nasiroglu, Murat Tekkesinoglu, Ergun Ege, Nazlı Karaman (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26817.txt.

Introduction

Huseyin Er and seven colleagues investigate the Kepler-451 system through wobbles in its eclipse timing. Kepler-451 is an eclipsing binary star system. If unseen companions orbit the pair, their gravity shifts eclipse times in patterns over years. The team assembled observations spanning two decades, from ground and space. Two data sets were modelled with light-travel-time configurations hosting different numbers of companions.

One data set favoured a two-companion model; the other preferred three. The innermost signal in the second set sat below the systematic error level, so it may be an artefact. Magnetic activity on the stars was also tested as an explanation through the Applegate mechanism. Most signals exceeded the available magnetic energy budget. Removing the likely magnetic terms left configurations stable for at least ten million years.

Catalog record

CREATORHuseyin Er, Aykut Ozdonmez, M. Emir Kenger, B. Batuhan Gurbulak, Ilham Nasiroglu, Murat Tekkesinoglu, Ergun Ege, Nazlı Karaman
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26817

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Investigating the System Configuration of Kepler-451 through Orbital Period Variations: Dynamical and Magnetic Interpretations Huseyin Er, Aykut Ozdonmez, M. Emir Kenger, B. Batuhan Gurbulak, Ilham Nasiroglu, Murat Tekkesinoglu, Ergun Ege, Nazlı Karaman Abstract We present an analysis of eclipse timing variations in Kepler-451 using data spanning 2004–2024 from both ground- and space-based observations. Using two datasets, DS-A and DS-B, we constructed updated O − C O-C diagrams. By modeling both datasets with various LTT configurations, we tested for the presence of circumbinary companions. For DS-A, the two-companion model (LTT34) provides the best fit with RMS = 3.23 s and χ ν 2 = 1.23 \chi^{2}_{\nu}=1.23 , while inclusion a fifth body (LTT345) does not improve the fit (RMS = 3.24 s, χ ν 2 = 1.28 \chi^{2}_{\nu}=1.28 ). For DS-B, the three-companion model (LTT345) yields the best fit (RMS = 2.31 s, χ ν 2 = 1.01 \chi^{2}_{\nu}=1.01 ), although the semi-amplitude of the inner companion (1.34 s) is smaller than the systematic error (1.81 s), suggesting that it may originate from observational or calibration systematics. Applegate-mechanism tests indicate that most signals exceed the available energy budget, while the outer LTT terms in both datasets remain consistent with the Standard model and may have a magnetic origin. Removing these magnetic terms yields dynamically stable configurations for at least 10 7 10^{7} yr. These findings support the presence of a second-generation circumbinary planet at ∼ 3.4 \sim 3.4 AU around Kepler-451, while the origin of the remaining LTT signals remains uncertain. show][email protected] I Introduction Post-common-envelope binaries (PCEBs), which consist of a hot subdwarf B (sdB) star and a low-mass main-sequence companion in a close orbit, are important systems for studying binary evolution. The hot sdB components in these systems reside on the extreme horizontal branch of the Hertzsprung–Russell (H-R) diagram, burn helium in their cores, and retain only very thin hydrogen envelopes ( 28 ) . The tight orbital separations observed in these systems imply that they could not have maintained such configurations throughout their lifetimes, because the progenitor of the compact object would have engulfed its companion during the giant phase. Therefore, it is assumed that the system originated as a wider main-sequence binary with an orbital separation of about 1 AU. As the more massive component evolved into a giant, unstable mass transfer was triggered, leading to the formation of a common envelope (CE) surrounding both stars. The strong frictional drag forces within the CE cause the binary system to lose orbital energy and angular momentum. This leads the two stars to spiral inward. Once enough energy accumulated in the envelope, it was expelled from the system, leaving behind a binary consisting of the compact object and companion star ( 47 ; 64 ; 67 ; 53 ; 68 ; 27 ; 26 ) . Their short orbital periods and deep eclipses allow for the determination of eclipse timings with an accuracy of just a few seconds, enabling the detection of even minor variations in orbital periods. Such eclipse-timing variations (ETVs) have often been interpreted as evidence for the presence of a circumbinary planet ( 52 ; 7 ; 53 ; 6 ; 15 ; 46 ) . However, some ETV-based planetary architectures have been shown to be dynamically unstable or otherwise implausible ( 31 ) , so such interpretations should be treated with caution. Circumbinary planets have been reported around several post-common-envelope sdB binaries. 68 examined orbital period variations in thirteen sdB systems and detected significant variations in five of them. Many researchers have interpreted these evidence for additional massive bodies such as those proposed for HS 0705+6700, HS 2231+2441, NSVS 14256825, NY Vir, and HW Vir ( 55 ; 54 ; 6 ; 35 ; 42 ; 15 ; 14 ; 13 ) . 50 re-investigated seven post-common-envelope binaries (four of which are sdB systems: HW Vir, NY Vir, HS 0705+6700, and NSVS 14256825) and demonstrated that the majority of the previously proposed models failed to align with the new O – C diagrams, even over short intervals. More recently, 14 extended the O – C baseline of HS 0705+6700 to twenty-four years and modeled its period variations using linear, quadratic, and additional-body terms. They found that, although models with multiple closely spaced brown dwarfs could statistically fit the data, these configurations would be unstable on short timescales. In this context, Kepler-451 serves as a well-suited test case for these interpretations, given its well-studied nature and extensive observational coverage. The Kepler-451 system, also cataloged as 2MASS J1938+4603, KIC 9472174, TIC 271164763, 1SWASP J193832.60+460359.1, and NSVS 5629361, was first identified by 69 who classified it as an sdB+dM post-common-envelope binary with an orbital period of \sim 0.12576 days and component masses of M_{1}=0.48\pm 0.03\ M_{\odot} and M_{2}=0.12\pm 0.01\ M_{\odot} . The orbital period variations of Kepler‐451 have been the subject of numerous studies. Using Kepler photometry, 4 measured the Rømer delay, which causes eclipses to appear shifted depending on the orbital position of the star, and found that the secondary eclipse occurs about 2s behind the midpoint between the consecutive primary eclipses. 38 analyzed the multi-year SuperWASP archive for twelve post-common-envelope binary systems, including Kepler-451. By comparing the mid-eclipse times with a previously published ephemeris, they found no clear evidence of significant period variation in the system. Using Kepler photometry, 2 reported a periodic signal in the O-C diagram, attributing it to a tertiary companion orbiting at 0.92 AU with a period of 416 days and a minimum mass of \sim 1.9\ M_{Jup} . They also identified a significant long-term trend in the timing data that could indicate an evolutionary effect or the presence of other companions. Both 2 and 32 derived mid-eclipse times from prewhitened Kepler light curves. The studies differ primarily in their datasets (SC-only vs. LC+SC) and timing analysis procedures. 32 challenged the planetary interpretation by reanalyzing the Kepler-451 timing data with refined reduction techniques designed to mitigate the effects of sdB pulsations and to limit calibration/reduction systematics. In addition to the O-C analysis, 32 applied the binarogram method as an independent check. Neither approach recovered a significant modulation at the proposed \sim 416-day period, thereby rejecting the Jupiter-mass companion suggested by 2 . Subsequently, 3 reprocessed the timing data and confirmed a clear periodic ETV signal, supporting the initial detection. More recently, 17 performed a long-baseline analysis that revealed more complex eclipse-timing behavior in Kepler-451. By combining Kepler eclipse timings with additional years of ground-based monitoring and TESS observations, 17 detected multiple periodicities in the O-C curve. The originally reported modulation of \sim 416 days was refined to \sim 406 days with a modest eccentricity. Two further signals were identified: an inner companion with a period of \sim 43 days, present only in the Kepler residuals after a two-body model was fitted to the full O-C diagram, and an outer body with a cycle of \sim 1800 days. These variations were interpreted as evidence for a three-planet circumbinary system, with all three Jovian‐mass companions having comparable masses. In this work, we extend the eclipse‐timing baseline of Kepler‐451 with our new measurements to investigate whether its period variations arise from circumbinary companions or alternative mechanisms, with the ultimate aim of offering alternative solutions to orbital

Read the complete text