From Holst to Carroll Gravity, a Hamiltonian point of view

J. Fernando Barbero G, Juan Margalef-Bentabol, Valle Varo, Eduardo J.S. Villaseñor · 2026

Read From Holst to Carroll Gravity, a Hamiltonian point of view by J. Fernando Barbero G, Juan Margalef-Bentabol, Valle Varo, Eduardo J.S. Villaseñor (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26799.txt.

Introduction

J. Fernando Barbero G, Juan Margalef-Bentabol, Valle Varo, and Eduardo J.S. Villaseñor analyse Carroll gravity from a Hamiltonian standpoint. Carroll gravity is the ultra-relativistic limit where light cones collapse to lines. It helps study flat spacetime edges, black hole horizons, and some condensed matter systems. The authors start from the Holst action, the form of general relativity suited to modern variable choices.

They derive the most general Carroll-invariant theory obtainable that way. Cartan geometry tools guide the analysis. The full constraint structure and gauge symmetries are identified. The Hamiltonian vector fields are written out explicitly. New Ashtekar-like variables are introduced for the magnetic regime of the theory. An analogue of the time gauge used in general relativity's Hamiltonian form is also discussed in detail.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. Fernando Barbero G, Juan Margalef-Bentabol, Valle Varo, Eduardo J.S. Villaseñor
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE244 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26799

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

From Holst to Carroll Gravity, a Hamiltonian point of view J. Fernando Barbero G, Juan Margalef-Bentabol, Valle Varo, Eduardo J.S. Villaseñor Abstract The Carrollian regime of gravity provides a useful ultrarelativistic framework for studying asymptotically flat spacetimes, horizon dynamics, and condensed matter systems. In this paper, we present a comprehensive Hamiltonian analysis of the most general Carroll-invariant Lagrangian that can be derived from the Holst action. To guide the analysis, Cartan geometry tools are used. We identify the full constraint structure of the theory, characterize its gauge symmetries, obtain the explicit form of the Hamiltonian vector fields and introduce Ashtekar-like variables for the magnetic Carrollian regime. We also discuss in detail an analog of the time gauge employed in the Hamiltonian analysis of the Holst action for general relativity. June 30, 2026 Key Words: Carrollian gravity; Group contractions; Gravitational actions. 1 Introduction The Carrollian limit of gravitational theories provides an interesting setting to study a number of problems related to general relativity (GR) and cosmology such as the study of black hole horizons [ 1 ] and asymptotic null infinity [ 2 ] . It also finds interesting applications in other parts of physics [ 3 ] . Many of these applications take advantage of the fact that in the Carrollian limit light cones degenerate into curves and, hence, the nature of causality in Carrollian spacetimes is somewhat simplified (although, arguably, it is changed in a rather non-trivial fashion). From a mathematical perspective, the main idea in the Carrollian setting is to introduce a contraction of the Poincaré algebra within the gravitational models at hand along the lines first proposed by Lévy-Leblond [ 4 ] and Sen Gupta [ 5 ] . In recent years there has been a renewed interest to understand the intricacies of the dynamics of the electric and magnetic sectors of Carrollian theories [ 6 ] and extend their applications (see recent papers, such as [ 8 , 7 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] , for comprehensive lists of references). The purpose of this paper is to study in detail the Hamiltonian formulation for the most general Carrollian gravitational Lagrangian derivable from the Holst action [ 12 ] for GR. This Lagrangian is the sum of the Carrollian gauge-invariant 4-forms given in [ 13 ] (see also [ 14 ] ). One application of the results that we present here is to provide relevant toy models for the canonical quantization of gravity. In fact, for the action discussed in this work, we will find that the phase space is related to the one corresponding to the Ashtekar formulation for GR [ 15 , 16 ] . The only significant difference between the Hamiltonian formulation presented here and the standard Hamiltonian formulation for Lorentzian gravity in terms of real Ashtekar variables is the form of the Hamiltonian constraint: whereas in the case of GR this constraint can be written as the combination of two terms, one involving the curvature of the Ashtekar connection and the other the curvature of the spin connection built with the triads, in the Carrollian case only the last term is present. This is a simplification of sorts that may enable the canonical quantization of the action discussed here. We would like to point out that the present work is not the first one to study the Hamiltonian formulation of a Carrollian gravity. For example, the equivalence between the magnetic Carrollian limit of Einstein gravity and the Carrollian theory of gravity was established in [ 6 ] by using Hamiltonian techniques. Also, in [ 17 ] the author performs a Hamiltonian analysis of the Carrollian limit of the Cartan-Palatini action for GR the action discussed in [ 14 ] by following a line of thought similar to the one presented in [ 18 ] (in particular, relying on the use of a quadratic constraint) and taking a limit. There are several well-established methods to deal with singular (constrained) Lagrangian systems and obtain the corresponding Hamiltonian formulations. The best known of them is due to Dirac [ 19 ] . If followed to the letter, it always gives a Hamiltonian picture of dynamics equivalent to the one given from the action through the Euler-Lagrange equations. However, the implementation of the procedure is often tricky, in particular, the resolution of the equations that determine the undetermined multipliers introduced in the definition of the total Hamiltonian. If these equations are not solved, it is possible to miss constraints and arrive at incorrect results. A nagging feature of the approach followed in [ 18 ] is the substitution of primary constraints linear in momenta by a quadratic one which is then used to define the total Hamiltonian. The reason for this is rather obscure but is probably justified by the appearance of dynamical objects in the primary constraints that are interpreted as Lagrange multipliers and, for this reason, considered (incorrectly) as non-dynamical objects. Another unnatural feature of the mentioned approach is that, instead of working with the natural variables in which the Cartan-Palatini action is written (a coframe and an spin connection) it uses a frame field. This unnecessarily complicates the form of the action and makes all the computations significantly harder. The approach we follow here is different in spirit on several grounds. First, because we consider the most general Carrollian Lagrangian derivable from the Holst action (see [ 13 ] ), including a term with the Immirzi parameter. Second, from a methodological standpoint, we follow the clean and geometrically inspired approach developed by Gotay, Nester and Hinds (GNH) in [ 20 , 21 ] to study constrained systems. This method provides an alternative to Dirac’s approach, while yielding essentially equivalent information. Finally, it offers several computational and conceptual advantages. To complete the analysis of the relevant equations in the GNH setting (and, likewise, in Dirac’s formalism), it is often useful to exploit geometric insights that clarify the structure of their solutions. In particular, to solve the equations that determine the components of the Hamiltonian vector fields, brute-force computations can always be used. However, such an approach frequently obscures the underlying structure of the solutions, making their interpretation difficult. It can also be challenging to verify the geometric consistency conditions that these vector fields must satisfy. A preliminary geometric analysis, together with the identification of the relevant symmetries, provides a clearer picture of the expected form of the Hamiltonian vector fields. This allows one to understand their structure a priori and considerably simplifies the resolution of the corresponding equations. For the present paper, the geometric insight provided by Cartan geometry (see [ 22 , 23 ] ) is especially useful and helpful. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we review the aspects of Cartan geometry that provide the geometric framework and motivation for our analysis. Section 3 introduces the action that we study in the paper, discusses its symmetries and field equations, and derives several immediate consequences for the dynamics. As we will show, a number of these features are characteristic of Carrollian systems. In Section 4 , we develop the Hamiltonian formulation of the model using the GNH method. We identify the constraint structure, solve the equations defining the

Read the complete text