Modelling convective cell occurrence in proximity to cold fronts using extreme gradient boosting
George Pacey, Stephan Pfahl, Lisa Schielicke · 2026
Read Modelling convective cell occurrence in proximity to cold fronts using extreme gradient boosting by George Pacey, Stephan Pfahl, Lisa Schielicke (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26699.txt.
Introduction
George Pacey, Stephan Pfahl, and Lisa Schielicke build a machine learning model for convective cells near cold fronts. Convective cells are the building blocks of thunderstorms. Knowing where they cluster around fronts helps weather science and forecasting. The authors trained an extreme gradient boosting model, a popular tree-based learner. Cell observations supplied the truth; weather reanalysis data supplied the predictors.
The model was judged on how well it reproduces cell frequency patterns in space and time. Regions ahead of and behind fronts were assessed separately across Germany's warm season. The optimised model showed high skill overall. It placed the peak frequency correctly near the surface front but underestimated the count there. One predictor dominated the decisions: CAPE, a measure of storm-fuelling instability. Time of day also mattered greatly for matching the daily cycle.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | George Pacey, Stephan Pfahl, Lisa Schielicke |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26699
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Modelling convective cell occurrence in proximity to cold fronts using extreme gradient boosting George Pacey, Stephan Pfahl, Lisa Schielicke Abstract Machine learning is emerging as a valuable tool for convection-related applications such as post-processing numerical weather prediction output, improving understanding of convective storm climatology and potentially improving existing convective parameterization schemes. In a rapidly developing field, it is vital to assess the strengths and limitations of machine learning approaches across different applications. Here, a probabilistic model is developed using a convective cell dataset as ground truth and predictors primarily from ERA5. The model’s ability to reproduce the convective cell climatology at different regions relative to cold fronts (i.e. post-frontal and pre-frontal) is assessed during the warm-season in Germany. The optimal number of features (predictors) is selected using a feature elimination strategy. Overall, the optimised model exhibits high skill in reproducing the spatial and temporal cell frequency at different regions relative to the front. While the highest cell frequency is correctly identified near the surface front, the model underestimates the actual cell count in this region. Feature importance analysis shows that the model depends most heavily on CAPE to make its predictions. Additionally, the time of day predictor is key for accurately capturing the diurnal cycle of convective cells on both sides of the cold front. The study highlights both the advantages and the limitations of data-driven models, offering valuable insights for future data-driven climate and weather prediction models. 1 Introduction The use of data-driven approaches has become increasingly popular in recent times. In the field of meteorology and climate, the interest has extended beyond meteorologists, also to technology companies such as NVIDIA, Google (Deep Mind) and Huawei, who have developed global data-driven weather forecasting models ( 40 , 40 ; 32 , 32 ; 7 , 7 ; 42 , 42 ). ECWMF has also developed an artificial intelligence weather prediction model (AIFS; 33 , 33 ). The models can produce realistic thermodynamic and dynamic atmospheric fields forward in time, exhibiting on par or superior skill to those produced by conventional numerical weather prediction (NWP) ( 9 , 9 ). Data-driven approaches rely on large amounts of historical data for training. During the training, the goal is to establish relationships between the predictors and the target variable(s). These relationships should also be generalisable outside of the training data. One main advantage compared to conventional NWP is that once the model is trained it is relatively inexpensive computationally to produce predictions. Most machine learning weather prediction (MLWP) approaches still utilise physics-based ERA5 reanalysis data to generate the training datasets, which of course involves using convectional NWP. Work on purely observational-based MLWP models is ongoing (e.g. 1 , 1 ; 13 , 13 ). The aforementioned models have not yet directly addressed convective phenomena on the convective-scale, but there is some evidence that they can represent convective environments (e.g. wind shear and instability) on par with NWP models ( 15 , 15 ). Atmospheric convection is associated with some of the most violent natural phenomena on earth such as lightning, hail, extreme precipitation and tornadoes. Strong events can lead to financial losses of the order 1 billion euros (e.g. 31 , 31 ; 53 , 53 ) and extreme convective precipitation events can lead to hundreds of fatalities ( 14 , 14 ). Despite advancements in the representation of convection in numerical models, models are often still associated with biases and challenges remain ( 55 , 55 ). Given the increased availability of observations, e.g. lightning detection networks, satellite imagers and crowdsourced severe weather reports, and the fundamental non-linear nature of convection, machine learning (ML) could prove to be a very useful tool to enhance understanding and prediction of convective phenomena. There is already literature on applications of data-driven approaches for convective storm prediction, most of which is regional and often applied to post-process output from conventional NWP. Random forest uses an ensemble of decision trees to make predictions and has been used to produce probabilistic forecasts of severe convective storms in the United States (e.g. 36 , 36 ; 44 , 44 ; 22 , 22 ). 34 used gradient boosting for nowcasting of thunderstorm hazards in the north-eastern United States. 43 and 3 developed Generalised Additive Models (GAMs) to estimate the probability of lightning and hail occurrence based on ERA-Interim ( 43 , 43 ) and ERA5 ( 3 , 3 ) predictors. The model developed in 3 was also adapted for use in operational forecasting in Europe ( 2 , 2 ). Likewise, 50 developed a model applicable to operational forecasting using neural networks to infer the probability of lightning by feeding in predictors from high-resolution NWP data. Some studies also suggest that machine learning based-convective trigger functions could potentially replace conventional parametrizations (e.g. 56 , 56 ; 29 , 29 ). We note that this list is by no means exhaustive due to the rapid development of the field. Aside from prediction itself, these models can also be used to understand the importance of different mechanisms (features) on determining an outcome (e.g. likelihood of convection). Building trust in these models also requires a comprehensive understanding of how they arrive at their predictions, a concept sometimes referred to as explainable artificial intelligence (XAI). With the rapid evolution of field, it is crucial to evaluate the strengths and limitations of data-driven models across various applications. One particularly interesting synoptic situation in which convection often initiates is in proximity to cold fronts (e.g. 16 , 16 ; 11 , 11 ; 30 , 30 ). This application is particularly interesting as it is known that the spatiotemporal frequency of cells in proximity to cold fronts varies substantially ( 38 , 38 ). More specifically, cells are most frequent on the warm-side of the cold front (pre-frontal) and have a weakened diurnal cycle. In contrast, cells are much less frequent on the cold-side of the front (post-frontal) and have a strong diurnal cycle. The minimum cell frequency is closely correlated with the location of the 700 hPa frontal line. The skill of data-driven model predictions, similar to NWP, is likely to depend on the specific synoptic situation. For forecasters to be able to benefit from such predictions, they should be aware of the skill variation in different synoptic situations. To this end, an extreme gradient-boosted model (XGBoost) is trained to predict the probability of cold-frontal convective cell occurrence in Germany. Gradient boosting ( 17 , 17 ) has already been extensively applied to several atmospheric science applications ranging from nowcasting to climate mitigation (e.g. 45 , 45 ; 24 , 24 and 34 , 34 ). Here, assessing the variation of skill of the data-driven model at different locations relative to the cold front is a key focus of this study. In line with previous studies, predictors are primarily obtained from data involving the use of conventional numerical models (ERA5 reanalysis data in this case). However, additional predictors that are not dependent on numerical model data, such as the time of day and latitude, are also explored. To build trust in the model outputs, feature importance techniques are also utilised. The paper is organised as follows: section 2 introduces the data and