SINGLE OBJECT OBSERVATIONS: LARGE TELESCOPE VS. MULTIPLE SMALL TELESCOPES
S. Ben-Ami, E. O. Ofek · 2026
Read SINGLE OBJECT OBSERVATIONS: LARGE TELESCOPE VS. MULTIPLE SMALL TELESCOPES by S. Ben-Ami, E. O. Ofek (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26635.txt.
Introduction
S. Ben-Ami and E. O. Ofek compare telescope designs for observing single objects. Much large-telescope time goes to spectroscopy and brightness measurement of one target at a time. The authors ask whether one big telescope or an array of small ones delivers more science per unit cost. Their measure is survey speed divided by cost.
Several architectures are compared. Single telescopes may be limited by atmospheric blur or by their optics. Arrays combine many small telescopes either way. For single telescopes of equal collecting area, optics-limited operation wins once targets are faint enough that background light dominates. Arrays of blur-limited telescopes generally beat one blur-limited telescope for unresolved targets. A single large optics-limited telescope beats small-telescope arrays only for very faint targets. The authors caution that conclusions depend on their cost and system assumptions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | S. Ben-Ami, E. O. Ofek |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26635
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
SINGLE OBJECT OBSERVATIONS: LARGE TELESCOPE VS. MULTIPLE SMALL TELESCOPES S. Ben-Ami, E. O. Ofek Abstract A significant fraction of large-telescope observing time is devoted to single-object spectroscopy and photometry. We compare the cost-effectiveness of different telescope architectures, including single seeing- and diffraction-limited telescopes and arrays of seeing-limited or diffraction-limited telescopes. We use the survey speed per unit cost as the performance metric. For single telescopes with equal collecting area, diffraction-limited operation becomes more cost-effective once seeing-limited observations enter the background-dominated regime, typically at visible magnitudes of ∼ 20 \sim 20 . For unresolved single-object observations, arrays of seeing-limited telescopes are generally more cost-effective than a single seeing-limited telescope. When matched in survey speed, a single diffraction-limited telescope outperforms an array of small seeing-limited telescopes only for targets fainter than ∼ 20 \sim 20 – 24 24\, mag, while a single large diffraction-limited telescope becomes more cost-effective than an array of smaller diffraction-limited telescopes only for targets fainter than ∼ 26 \sim 26 – 28 28\, mag. We conclude with a discussion on aspects related to the minimum telescope size and maintenance of telescope arrays. These conclusions are sensitive to the specific assumptions and system parameters adopted for each architecture and should therefore be interpreted with appropriate caution. Our results motivate the development of telescope arrays such as MAST and LFAST and may inform the design of future optical facilities. I Introduction A large fraction of observing time on large telescopes is dedicated for single-object observations. This mainly includes seeing-dominated spectroscopy and imaging. For example, the Low Resolution and Imaging Spectrograph (LRIS; 15 ) on the Keck I telescope continues to be used for an average of more than 100 nights per year ( 5 ). The construction of additional larger telescopes is limited by the cost and complexity of such projects. Therefore, when constructing telescope systems, we would like to maximize their cost-effectiveness. The first step is to define a figure of merit that will allow us to analyze the problem. However, this figure of merit depends on our goals. For example, in 13 we analyzed the cost-effectiveness of a survey telescope. Suppose that one defines the main goal of a survey telescope as maximizing the number of targets the telescope can observe per unit of time. In that case, a reasonable figure of merit is the grasp, defined as the relative volume of space a telescope can observe, to some S/N , per unit of time. In the background-noise-dominated regime (i.e., sources fainter than magnitude 19-21, depending on sky background at the site), the grasp is given by \mathcal{G}\propto\Omega\Big(\frac{S}{N}\Big)^{-3/2}A_{\rm eff}^{3/4}B^{-3/4}\sigma^{-3/2}\frac{t_{\rm E}^{3/4}}{t_{\rm E}+t_{\rm D}}. (1) Here, \Omega is the telescope field of view (solid angle on sky), A_{\rm eff} is the effective collecting area, B is the sky background in photons per unit area, per unit time, per unit solid angle on sky, \sigma is the image quality, t_{\rm E} is the exposure time, and t_{\rm D} is the dead time - see Table 1 for a list of parameters appearing in this publication. Our analysis suggests that, for the background-noise-dominated regime, once the detector pixel drops below \sim 5\,\mu m, multiple small telescopes are more cost-effective than a single seeing-limited large telescope. Such small pixels became available only around the year 2020, and led to the construction of cost-effective survey telescopes like the Large Array Survey Telescope (LAST; 11 ; 2 ), and the planned Argus array ( 7 ). This statement is correct only for seeing-limited telescopes, whereas for a diffraction-limited survey telescope \mathcal{G}\propto A_{\rm eff}^{3/2} , and therefore larger telescopes are more cost-effective, compared to multiple small telescopes. A detailed discussion of the grasp and its limitations is presented in 13 . For the case of single-object imaging or spectroscopy, a different figure of merit is required. The figure of merit we choose to use is the survey speed, defined as the number of single sources, with flux f , that can be observed to a predefined signal-to-noise ratio \left(S/N\right) per unit of time. Since narrow-field-of-view observations can be obtained using adaptive optics, we consider the two branches of single-object observations: seeing-dominated and diffraction-limited. Here we derive the survey speed expression in the relevant regimes and use it to draw several conclusions related to the cost-effectiveness of different kinds of telescope systems. The analysis summarized in this work provides the rationale for the construction of telescope arrays for single-object spectroscopy and photometry. In recent years, several such efforts were initiated. These include: The Multi-Aperture Spectroscopic Telescope (MAST; Ben-Ami et al. in prep.; 6 ; 17 ), LFAST ( 1 ; 3 ), PolyOculus ( 4 ), and the Pan-chromatic Array for Survey Telescopes (PAST; Garrappa et al., in prep.). In § II we discuss the S/N , and in § III we analyze the impact of the detector read-noise. In § IV we derive the formulae for the survey speed. The cost-effectiveness is discussed in § V , and we conclude in § VI . II The signal-to-noise We begin by deriving the well-known signal-to-noise ratio expressions for several generic observation scenarios involving unresolved single sources. As shown below, the results depend on the transition between the source-noise-dominated and background-noise-dominated regimes; accordingly, we employ the full signal-to-noise expression rather than the limiting cases appropriate to a single dominant noise source. We neglect detector readout noise throughout this analysis, a simplification that is justified in § III . In observations, one typically differentiates between S/N for measurement processes (e.g., photometry, morphology, or astrometry) and S/N for detection processes (e.g., 20 ). Throughout the paper, we only treat the case of single target observations (spectroscopy or photometry with accuracy worse than a few millimagnitudes). Given this motivation, we are mainly interested in the S/N for measurements. The S/N for a measurement process is: (S/N)_{\rm meas}=\frac{\epsilon\alpha_{\rm f}\mathcal{R}^{-1}fA_{\rm eff}t_{\rm E}}{\sqrt{A_{\rm eff}t_{\rm E}\mathcal{R}^{-1}({\alpha_{B}\sigma^{2}}B+\epsilon\alpha_{f}f)}}. (2) Here f is the source photon flux in the desired band (e.g., units of photons cm -2 s -1 ), A_{\rm eff} is the effective collecting area in the desired band (e.g., units of cm 2 ), t_{\rm E} is the exposure time (e.g., units of seconds), B is the background in band (e.g., units of photons cm -2 s -1 arcsec -2 ). \epsilon is the Strehl ratio ( \cong 1 for seeing-limited observations). \alpha_{\rm f} is the fraction of source flux captured (e.g., in the slit), {\alpha_{\rm B}\sigma^{2}} is the effective area over which background noise is collected - see further information in the appendix, and \sigma is the standard deviation of the PSF (e.g., FWHM/2.35 for a Gaussian PSF). We provide some approximations for \alpha_{f} and \alpha_{B} in Appendix A . We also introduce \mathcal{R} , the approximate spectral resolution within the effective band. The latter scaling will be useful for evaluating the dependence of survey speed on spectral resolution. In the background-noise dominated case, or S/N for a detection process, the \epsilon\alpha_{f}f term in the denominator should be set to zero. In the case of a source-noise dominated case, B should be set to zero. In the case of diffraction-limited observations, we use the relation between the Airy disk and the aperture area (for simplicity, we write the following equations in specific units): \sigma_{\rm