A Unified Three-Stage Weighting Framework for Causal Inference and Mediation Analysis under Case–Control Sampling

Tarikul Islam, Mahbub A.H.M. Latif · 2026

Read A Unified Three-Stage Weighting Framework for Causal Inference and Mediation Analysis under Case–Control Sampling by Tarikul Islam, Mahbub A.H.M. Latif (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26543.txt.

Introduction

Tarikul Islam and Mahbub A.H.M. Latif propose a unified weighting framework for causal questions in case-control studies. Such studies compare people with a disease against people without it. They are efficient when outcomes are rare. Their backward sampling, though, distorts the outcome distribution. Most fixes need the true population prevalence, the share of people with the outcome, or estimate only total effects.

Their three-stage approach estimates prevalence first. A density-ratio method combined with outside covariate information does that job. Stage two rebuilds the target population with design weights. Stage three applies stabilised causal and mediation weights inside a marginal structural model. Mediation analysis separates an effect that flows through an intermediate factor from one that acts directly. The framework estimates total and pathway-specific effects without knowing prevalence in advance.

Catalog record

CREATORTarikul Islam, Mahbub A.H.M. Latif
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE73 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26543

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Unified Three-Stage Weighting Framework for Causal Inference and Mediation Analysis under Case–Control Sampling Tarikul Islam, Mahbub A.H.M. Latif Abstract Abstract Case–control studies are widely used in epidemiology and biomedical research because they provide substantial efficiency gains when outcomes are rare or prospective follow-up is impractical. However, retrospective outcome-dependent sampling distorts the population outcome distribution, creating fundamental challenges for causal inference. While several methods have been proposed to estimate causal effects from case–control data, most require prior knowledge of the population outcome prevalence, rely on restrictive modeling assumptions, or focus exclusively on total effects. These limitations become particularly problematic when prevalence information is unavailable and when investigators seek to understand causal mechanisms through mediation analysis. We propose a unified three-stage weighting (3S-weighting) framework for causal inference and causal mediation analysis from case–control studies. The proposed approach first estimates the unknown population outcome prevalence using density-ratio learning and label-shift correction combined with externally available covariate information. Next, prevalence-based design weights are used to reconstruct the target population distribution from the retrospective sample. Finally, stabilized causal and mediation weights are applied within a marginal structural modeling framework to estimate total and pathway-specific causal effects, including the pure direct effect, pure indirect effect, and interaction effect. The proposed methodology does not require prior knowledge of the population outcome prevalence and uses only externally available marginal covariate information. Simulation studies demonstrate that conventional analyses that ignore retrospective sampling can produce substantial bias in both total and mediation effect estimates, whereas the proposed approach consistently recovers the target population causal parameters across a range of sampling scenarios. An application to data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey further illustrates the practical implementation and utility of the proposed framework. By integrating prevalence recovery, population reconstruction, and causal weighting within a single framework, the proposed method substantially expands the scope of causal questions that can be addressed using case–control data. The framework provides a practical and theoretically grounded approach for estimating both total and mechanistic causal effects from outcome-dependent samples. Keywords : Case-control design, three-stage approach. 1 Introduction Case–control studies remain one of the most widely used observational study designs in epidemiology, public health, and biomedical research. Their enduring popularity stems from substantial gains in efficiency when outcomes are rare, disease incidence is low, or prospective follow-up is prohibitively expensive. By selecting individuals conditional on outcome status, case–control studies dramatically reduce data collection costs while retaining much of the information required to investigate disease etiology. Consequently, they have played a central role in identifying risk factors for cancer, cardiovascular disease, infectious diseases, and numerous chronic health conditions ( Cornfield, 1951 ; Miettinen, 1976 ; Breslow et al., 1980 ; Rothman et al., 2008 ; Knol et al., 2008 ; Labrecque et al., 2021 ) . More broadly, retrospective sampling designs constitute a cornerstone of modern epidemiologic research and continue to be widely employed in both resource-constrained and large-scale population studies ( Schlesselman, 1982 ; Breslow, 1996 ) . Despite their practical importance, statistical inference from case–control studies differs fundamentally from inference based on cohort or cross-sectional data. Because sampling depends on the observed outcome, the resulting data do not preserve the population outcome distribution. The observed proportion of cases is determined by design rather than by the true disease prevalence in the target population. This outcome-dependent sampling mechanism complicates estimation of population-level quantities and creates important challenges for causal inference. While certain conditional associations remain identifiable under retrospective sampling, marginal quantities that depend on the population risk distribution are generally not recoverable from the observed data without additional assumptions or external information ( Prentice and Pyke, 1979 ; Greenland, 1981 ; Robins et al., 1994 ; L. Penning de Vries and Groenwold, 2022 ) . From a missing-data perspective, retrospective sampling induces a selection mechanism that systematically distorts the outcome distribution relevant for identifying marginal causal parameters ( Robins et al., 1994 ; Hernán and Robins, 2010 ) . Historically, methodological developments for case–control studies focused primarily on estimation of odds ratios. Seminal theoretical work established that retrospective sampling preserves key likelihood relationships, allowing valid estimation of exposure effects through logistic regression without explicit modeling of the sampling mechanism ( Cornfield, 1951 ; Anderson, 1972 ; Prentice and Pyke, 1979 ) . Subsequent developments clarified the conditions under which odds ratios, incidence-density ratios, risk ratios, and absolute risks may be estimated or approximated from retrospective data ( Miettinen, 1976 ; Greenland, 1987 ; Breslow, 1996 ) . As a result, logistic regression became the dominant analytic tool for case–control studies and remains one of the most widely used models in epidemiologic research ( Hosmer Jr et al., 2013 ) . Nevertheless, routine analyses often emphasize conditional odds ratios without explicitly considering the causal estimand implied by the sampling design or its relationship to population-level intervention effects ( Knol et al., 2008 ; Labrecque et al., 2021 ) . Over the last two decades, causal inference has undergone remarkable methodological development. Within the potential outcomes framework, causal effects are typically formulated as contrasts between counterfactual outcomes under alternative treatment assignments ( Splawa-Neyman et al., 1990 ; Rubin, 1974 ; Robins, 1986 ; Robins et al., 2000 ; Hernán and Robins, 2010 ) . Under assumptions of consistency, conditional exchangeability, and positivity, population-level causal estimands such as the average treatment effect, risk difference, relative risk, and causal odds ratio can be identified from observational data and estimated using inverse probability weighting, g-computation, doubly robust estimation, targeted maximum likelihood estimation, and related semiparametric methods ( Robins et al., 2000 ; Bang and Robins, 2005 ; Van Der Laan and Rubin, 2006 ; Tsiatis, 2006 ; Imbens and Rubin, 2015 ) . These approaches are fundamentally population-based and rely on the observed sample preserving the target population distribution. Consequently, their direct application to case–control data is generally invalid because retrospective sampling distorts the marginal outcome distribution required for identification of many causal estimands ( Robins et al., 1994 ; van der Laan, 2008 ; L. Penning de Vries and Groenwold, 2022 ) . Recognizing this limitation, a growing body of literature has sought to extend modern causal inference methods to retrospective sampling designs. Early contributions demonstrated that when population outcome prevalence is known, appropriately weighted estimators can recover marginal causal risk parameters from case–control samples ( Robins et al., 1994 ; van der Laan, 2008 ; Rose and van der Laan, 2008 ) . Subsequent work introduced targeted maximum likelihood estimators, doubly robust procedures, and semiparametric efficient estimators for causal odds ratios, risk ratios, and risk differences under outcome-dependent sampling ( Rose and Van Der Laan, 2009 ; Rose and van der Laan, 2014 ; Balzer et al., 2016 ; Pearl et al., 2016 ) . More recently, formal identification analyses have clarified the assumptions under which causal effects can be recovered from case–control, case-base, survivor, and risk-set sampling schemes, thereby strengthening the theoretical foundations of causal inference under retrospective designs ( L. Penning de Vries and Groenwold, 2022 ; O’Brien et al., 2022 ) . Collectively, these developments demonstrate that retrospective sampling need not preclude causal inference, provided that the sampling process is appropriately incorporated into the identification and estimation strategy. Nevertheless, several important limitations remain. First, many

Read the complete text