Preservation of primariness under ℓ 1 \ell_{1} -, c 0 c_{0} -, and ℓ ∞ \ell_{\infty} -sums of Banach spaces
Antonio Acuaviva · 2026
Read Preservation of primariness under ℓ 1 \ell_{1} -, c 0 c_{0} -, and ℓ ∞ \ell_{\infty} -sums of Banach spaces by Antonio Acuaviva (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26417.txt.
Introduction
Antonio Acuaviva works on primariness in Banach spaces, the infinite-dimensional spaces of functional analysis. A space is primary when any split of it into two parts leaves one part shaped like the whole. This property matters for understanding how such spaces can be built and classified. Acuaviva studies sequence spaces whose entries are themselves elements of a Banach space.
He proves transfer principles for a strong form called the uniform primary factorisation property. The property passes from a space to its three classic sequence versions. The versions sum entries, let them fade to zero, or keep them bounded. The proof needs assumptions about finite cotype or about self-similarity. As applications, he recovers a known result about function spaces without a classic localisation method. He also proves primariness for a new case and for the dual of the continuous-function space.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Antonio Acuaviva |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26417
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Preservation of primariness under ℓ 1 \ell_{1} -, c 0 c_{0} -, and ℓ ∞ \ell_{\infty} -sums of Banach spaces Antonio Acuaviva Abstract . We prove transfer principles for the uniform primary factorisation property (UPFP) from a Banach space X X to the vector-valued sequence spaces ℓ 1 ( X ) \ell_{1}(X) , c 0 ( X ) c_{0}(X) and ℓ ∞ ( X ) \ell_{\infty}(X) . The hypotheses are either finite-cotype assumptions on X X or X ∗ X^{*} , or natural self-similarity assumptions on X X . Consequently, under these conditions, the resulting vector-valued sequence spaces are primary. As applications, we recover the primariness of ℓ ∞ ( L p ) \ell_{\infty}(L_{p}) for 1 ≤ p < ∞ 1\leq p<\infty without using Bourgain’s localisation method, and obtain the primariness of c 0 ( L 1 ) c_{0}(L_{1}) . We also show that ℓ 1 ( Γ , L 1 [ 0 , 1 ] ) \ell_{1}(\Gamma,L_{1}[0,1]) has the UPFP for every set Γ \Gamma , and consequently that C [ 0 , 1 ] ∗ C[0,1]^{*} has the UPFP and is primary. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 46B03; Secondary: 46B25, 46B20. 1. Introduction and organisation A Banach space is called primary if every decomposition of it as a direct sum has one summand already isomorphic to the whole space. Equivalently, whenever P\colon X\to X is a projection, at least one of the spaces PX and (I_{X}-P)X is isomorphic to X . The primariness problem for classical Banach spaces has played an important role in the isomorphic theory of Banach spaces, and many of its solutions rely on factorisation methods. A typical feature of such proofs is that they establish a stronger factorisation dichotomy for arbitrary operators. This is captured by the (uniform) primary factorisation property, abbreviated (U)PFP; see Section 2 . Roughly speaking, the PFP asks that, for every operator T\colon X\to X , the identity on X factors through either T or I_{X}-T , while the UPFP asks for uniform control of the corresponding factorisation constants. Thus (U)PFP is a natural property to explore in the study of primariness, and is often the more flexible property in permanence arguments. This point of view was used explicitly in the recent work of the present author and Kania on primariness of uncountable \ell_{p} -sums [ 3 ] ; we refer to that article for a more detailed discussion of primariness and the PFP. In this paper, we prove transfer principles showing that, under finite-cotype assumptions on X or X^{*} , or under natural self-similarity assumptions on X , the UPFP passes from X to the vector-valued sequence spaces \ell_{1}(X) , c_{0}(X) and \ell_{\infty}(X) . The proofs are surprisingly elementary and recover, by a unified method, several known primariness results for spaces of the form \ell_{\infty}(X) . Our first main results is the following. Theorem 1.1 . Let X be a Banach space with the UPFP. Suppose that at least one of the following holds: (i) The space X is self-similar, in the sense that X\simeq\ell_{p}(X) for some 1\leq p\leq\infty , or X\simeq c_{0}(X) . (ii) The dual space X^{*} has finite cotype. Then \ell_{1}(X) has the UPFP. In particular, \ell_{1}(X) is primary. We also obtain a similar conclusion in the case of c_{0} and \ell_{\infty} -sums. Theorem 1.2 . Let X be a Banach space with the UPFP. Suppose that at least one of the following holds: (i) The space X is self-similar, in the sense that X\simeq\ell_{p}(X) for some 1\leq p<\infty . (ii) The space X has finite cotype. Then both c_{0}(X) and \ell_{\infty}(X) have the UPFP. In particular, c_{0}(X) and \ell_{\infty}(X) are primary. As an immediate consequence, we recover the primariness of \ell_{\infty}(L_{p}) for 1\leq p<\infty by elementary methods. The original proofs of Wark [ 16 ] for 1<p<\infty and Müller [ 14 ] for the full range, rely on substantially more technical methods, in particular Bourgain’s localisation method. We also record the case of c_{0}(L_{1}) , which we could not find explicitly stated in the literature, although it is presumably known. Corollary 1.3 . The spaces \ell_{\infty}(L_{p}) , 1\leq p<\infty , and c_{0}(L_{1}) have the UPFP and thus are primary. Proof. By Theorem 1.2 , it is enough to note that L_{p} , 1\leq p<\infty , has the UPFP and satisfies the self-similarity condition L_{p}\simeq\ell_{p}(L_{p}) . For 1<p<\infty , the UPFP can be extracted from the primariness argument of Alspach, Enflo and Odell [ 5 ] . For p=1 , the corresponding quantitative statement can be extracted from Capon’s argument [ 6 ] , see Section 6 . It is plausible that a quantitative statement of this kind can also be extracted from Enflo’s proof, via Maurey’s exposition, of the primariness of L_{p} [ 13 ] , although we have not verified this. Therefore Theorem 1.2 applies and gives the UPFP. Primariness follows directly from the UPFP together with Pełczyński’s decomposition method. ∎ Remark 1.4 . Lechner and Speckhofer recently proved a much broader factorisation theorem for Haar system Hardy spaces [ 11 , Theorem 3.1] . In particular, their result also implies the UPFP for L_{p} , 1\leq p<\infty , and for \ell_{\infty}(L_{p}) when 1<p<\infty . The point of the corollary above is that, once the UPFP of a Banach space X is known, the passage to \ell_{\infty}(X) follows from the elementary triangular-reduction argument developed here. We also record a consequence for spaces of continuous functions on ordinal intervals. Combining our \ell_{1} -sum transfer theorem with the known factorisation properties of C(\alpha) , we obtain the remaining \ell_{1} -case in the classification of primariness of the spaces \ell_{p}(C(\alpha)) begun in [ 2 ] . Corollary 1.5 . For every ordinal \alpha , the space \ell_{1}(C(\alpha)) has the UPFP. In particular, \ell_{1}(C(\alpha)) is primary. Proof. Suppose first that C(\alpha) is not isomorphic to C(\xi\cdot n) for any uncountable regular ordinal \xi and any integer n\geq 2 . By the Alspach–Benyamini theorem [ 4 ] , in the form stated in [ 1 , Proposition 1.9] , the space C(\alpha) has the PFP; observing that the estimates in the proof are quantitative gives the UPFP. Since the ordinal interval [0,\alpha] is scattered, we have C(\alpha)^{*}\simeq\ell_{1}([0,\alpha]) . In particular, C(\alpha)^{*} has finite cotype and therefore Theorem 1.1 implies that \ell_{1}(C(\alpha)) has the UPFP. Suppose now that C(\alpha)\simeq C(\xi\cdot n) for some uncountable regular ordinal \xi and some integer n\geq 2 . Since C(\xi\cdot n) is isomorphic to the direct sum of n copies of C(\xi) , we have \ell_{1}(C(\alpha))\simeq\ell_{1}(C(\xi)) . By the first part of the proof, applied to \xi , and by the isomorphic invariance of the UPFP, \ell_{1}(C(\alpha)) has the UPFP. The primariness follows from the UPFP together with Pełczyński’s decomposition method, since \ell_{1}(C(\alpha))\simeq\ell_{1}(\ell_{1}(C(\alpha))) . ∎ Finally, although the transfer principles in Theorems 1.1 and 1.2 apply only under the stated abstract hypotheses on the summand X , the diagonal-reduction method can sometimes be implemented beyond those hypotheses by using additional structure of X . We illustrate this phenomenon for the summand L_{1}[0,1] , obtaining the following result. It generalises a previous result of the author and Kania [ 3 ] , which assumed the negation of \mathrm{CH}