Phonetic and semantic analyses of spoken corpora of Beijing and Taiwan Mandarin indicate that the neutral tone is a lexical tone

Yuxin Lu, Zhexuan Li, R.Harald Baayen · 2026

Read Phonetic and semantic analyses of spoken corpora of Beijing and Taiwan Mandarin indicate that the neutral tone is a lexical tone by Yuxin Lu, Zhexuan Li, R.Harald Baayen (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26360.txt.

Introduction

Yuxin Lu, Zhexuan Li, and R. Harald Baayen argue that Mandarin's neutral tone is a true lexical tone, not a weakened leftover. They test how the tone sounds and means in spontaneous speech corpora from Beijing and Taiwan, comparing it with the four full tones.

The neutral tone turns out to have its own pitch target, and two-syllable words carrying it show pitch shapes that depend on the first syllable, much like words with full tones. Each word also carries a signature pitch shape, partly predictable from word-meaning embeddings. Both regional varieties share the pattern, though meaning differences explain part of their divergence.

Catalog record

CREATORYuxin Lu, Zhexuan Li, R.Harald Baayen
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26360

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Phonetic and semantic analyses of spoken corpora of Beijing and Taiwan Mandarin indicate that the neutral tone is a lexical tone Yuxin Lu, Zhexuan Li, R.Harald Baayen Abstract The neutral, or floating, tone of Mandarin Chinese is a tone with an enigmatic set of properties. It has been described as a reduced tone, or as a tone that sometimes is lexically fixed, but that can also be toneless. In two-syllable words, it is found only on the second syllable, but single-syllable words can also have the neutral tone. We present a corpus-based study of the phonetic realization of the neutral tone in spontaneous conversational speech corpora of Beijing Mandarin and Taiwan Mandarin. We show that the neutral tone has its own tonal target, just as the four lexical tones of Mandarin. We also show that disyllabic words with a neutral tone have pitch contours that have a pitch component that depends on the tone on the first syllable, just as has been observed for two-syllable words with a lexical tone on the second syllable ( 11 ) . Furthermore, words with a floating tone have word-specific pitch signatures, which have also been documented for single-syllable words ( 25 ) as well as two-syllable words ( 38 ) . These word-specific pitch signatures are shown to be predictable to some extent from words’ contextualized embeddings, as previously reported for lexical tones ( 11 ; 38 ) . As there is also considerable variability in the realization of lexical tones, we propose that the neutral tone is, in fact, a lexical tone in both Taiwan Mandarin and Beijing Mandarin. We document both similarities and differences in the realization of the floating tone in these two varieties and provide evidence, using contextualized embeddings, that some of the observed differences may arise from differences in the meanings of the words as used in the two corpora. Keywords: neutral tone, floating tone, GAM, Beijing Mandarin, Taiwan Mandarin, word-specific pitch signatures, contextualized embeddings 1 Introduction The tone system of standard Mandarin Chinese comprises four “lexical” tones: a high level tone (T1), a rising tone (T2), a low dipping tone (T3), and a falling tone (T4). In addition, there is a fifth tone, the neutral tone (T5). The neutral tone is reported to approach a mid-low pitch target, with a pitch contour that is largely determined by the preceding lexical tone ( 6 ) . The phonetic realization of the neutral tone varies across regions, not only with respect to the details of how pitch is modulated, but also with respect to duration and intensity ( 33 ) . Recent studies ( 11 ; 25 ; 37 ; 38 ) have documented for unscripted conversational Taiwan Mandarin that words’ pitch contours have a word-specific component that are tied to their meanings, independently of words’ canonical tones and a wide range of prosodic factors. These studies used the generalized additive model (GAM, 51 ) to decompose empirical pitch contours into additive pitch contour components, each of which is tied to a linguistic predictor (e.g., the preceding tone, position in the sentence, or the tone of the following word). GAMs reveal strong evidence for both components tied to tone patterns and for word-specific pitch contour components. 38 investigated the pitch realization of disyllabic words with as a set exemplify all possible 20 tone patterns (the four tones T1–T4, for the first syllable, and five tones (T1–T5) for the second syllable). In their analysis, the neutral tone emerged as a tone in its own right, along with the 4 lexical tones (T1–T4). Given that the floating tone is described as highly dependent on context, this result is surprising. The present study therefore examines in further detail the pitch realization of disyllabic words in spontaneous speech, in which the first syllable bears a lexical tone and the second syllable carries a neutral tone. We address the following questions. 1. What is the nature of neutral tone? Do words with a specific initial lexical tone and a final neutral tone have a distinct pitch contour component that differs from the pitch contour components of words with other initial lexical tones? This is what 38 observed for all 20 tone patterns, four of which had a neutral tone on the second syllable. If this result is replicated for Taiwan Mandarin, and also replicates for another variety of Mandarin, namely, Beijing Mandarin, this would imply that the realization of the neutral tone depends on the preceding tone in its own way. However, dependence on the preceding tone is also observed for final lexical tones in two-syllable compounds (cf. for laboratory speech 55 ) . Therefore, if evidence for tone-pattern specific pitch components for tone-patterns with a final floating tone replicates, this would argue in favor of the floating tone being no different from a lexical tone. 2. Considerable differences have been reported for the realization of the floating tone in Taiwan Mandarin and Beijing Mandarin. Beijing Mandarin, for instance, has been reported to have a higher prevalence of neutral tones ( 10 ; 42 ) . Are these differences visible as differently-shaped pitch components for the same tone patterns (e.g., T2-T5) in Taiwan conversational speech and Beijing conversational speech? Furthermore, is there more variability in the pitch signatures for tone patterns with the neutral tone in Beijing than in Mandarin? In addition, it is possible that there is more variability in the realization of di-syllabic words with a neutral tone on the second syllable than for di-syllabic words with a lexical tone. 3. Do disyllabic words with a neutral tone exhibit word-specific pitch contour signatures not only in Taiwan Mandarin, but also in Beijing Mandarin? If so, to what extent are the pitch signatures for a specific word similar across the two dialects? One would expect there to be words with very similar pitch signatures, but for others, their pitch signatures may well be dialect-specific. 4. 11 and 38 have shown that words’ pitch signatures can be predicted from their meanings (operationalized with contextualized embeddings) with above-chance accuracy, indicating that there is some isomorphy between the phonetic space of pitch contours and the embedding space. This raises the following question: Are contextualized embeddings for Beijing conversational speech predictive for words’ tonal signatures as previously observed for Taiwan Mandarin? Given the substantial variability and greater prevalence of the neutral tone in Beijing Mandarin, this is not a trivial question. A related question is whether differences in words’ pitch signatures in Beijing and Taiwan can be traced to differences in words’ meanings in these two dialects, as gauged with contextualized embeddings. The remainder of this study is structured as follows. Section 2 provides further background on the neutral tone in Standard Mandarin, Beijing Mandarin, and Taiwan Mandarin. Section 3 introduces the speech corpora for Beijing and Taiwan and the datasets that we created from these corpora. Section 4 presents the statistical analyses of the pitch contours, using generalized additive mixed modeling. Section 4.3 reports our investigation of the relation between word-specific pitch signatures and word-specific meaning, using contextualized embeddings. Section 5 provides the general discussion. 2 The neutral tone The neutral tone occurs in unstressed syllables and is widely attested in grammatical morphemes. These include particles

Read the complete text