Indigenizing the Drake Equation: how Indigenous methods can help us understand life in the Milky Way Galaxy Volume: 399 Journal: Oxford XIII / Indigenous Astronomy in the Space Age
Hilding R. Neilson 1 · 2026
Read Indigenizing the Drake Equation: how Indigenous methods can help us understand life in the Milky Way Galaxy Volume: 399 Journal: Oxford XIII / Indigenous Astronomy in the Space Age by Hilding R. Neilson 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26296.txt.
Introduction
Hilding Neilson rewrites the Drake Equation through Indigenous knowledge systems. The famous equation multiplies the ingredients for technological civilizations in our galaxy. Most of its factors remain unknown, and Neilson argues the usual discussion bakes in Western scientific biases. Those biases steer today's searches for biological and technological signatures. Indigenous methods, built on relational knowledge and deep time scales, frame the same question differently.
Viewed through that lens, the galaxy's life story changes shape. What counts as intelligence, communication, and a civilization's lifetime all shift. The essay reviews the equation's history alongside the assumptions SETI inherited. A dramatically different picture of life in the Milky Way follows from the Indigenous framing. The piece appears in a volume on Indigenous astronomy in the space age. Its aim is not to solve the equation but to widen who gets to define its terms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hilding R. Neilson 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26296
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Indigenizing the Drake Equation: how Indigenous methods can help us understand life in the Milky Way Galaxy Volume: 399 Journal: Oxford XIII / Indigenous Astronomy in the Space Age Hilding R. Neilson 1 Abstract The Drake Equation is a thought experiment whose purpose is to understand the ingredients necessary for life and advanced technological civilizations to exist on other worlds in our galaxy. However, beyond reflecting on life on Earth, we have no knowledge of many of these ingredients, such as the number of planets that have life, the number with intelligent life, the number with advanced civilizations, and the lifetimes of these civilizations. In this work, I will review the Drake Equation and the biases that scientists have traditionally had in discussing this equation and how it has led to the current searches of biological and technological signatures. I will discuss how the Drake Equation looks different if we consider it through the lens of Indigenous methods and sciences and how these methods would lead to a dramatically different view of life in our Galaxy. \pagerange 119–126 keywords SETI, Indignenous Methods, Technosignatures 1 Introduction Perhaps one of the biggest questions for humanity is if there is life on other worlds, but it is only in the past seventy to eighty years has academic field taken it seriously. Arguably some of the first searches for advanced civilizations was led by Dr. Frank Drake ( [ Drake, 1962 ] ) as he developed a thought experiment to predict the potential number of those civilizations that might be detectable from Earth in a search for radio emission. Since then, the field a grown dramatically thanks to new ideas and initiatives such as the SETI institute. Today, astronomers search for technosignatures to find the first evidence for advanced civilizations in the Galaxy. These searches continue to include searches for radio signals, but also optical searches ( [ Acharyya et al. 2023 , Zuckerman et al. 2023 , Zuckerman et al. 2024 ] ) for lasers and constructs such as Dyson Spheres. These searches have built on the early work of Drake and, in particular, the Drake Equation. In this work, I review the Drake Equation and consider the biases in the various terms of the Drake Equation that arise from the normative perspectives in western sciences. I then discuss Indigenous methodologies for understanding nature and the universe around us and how these methodologies can allow us to reevaluate the Drake Equation to find different conclusions. 2 The Drake Equation The Drake Equation is an exercise for considering the various ingredients and probabilities for life to exist on another world, evolve to intelligence, and to become an advanced civilization that we on Earth could potentially detect. The number of detectable civilizations in our galaxy is N=R_{*}f_{P}n_{e}f_{L}f_{I}f_{C}L. (1) The first term of the Drake Equation is the rate of star formation in the Galaxy and is R_{*}\approx 2~M_{\odot} yr -1 ( [ Elia et al. 2022 ] ), that is, we observe that there are about two Suns worth of mass are born every year. The second term f_{p} is the fraction of stars that are born that will also form planets. Thanks to the Kepler ( [ Borucki et al. 2010 ] ) and TESS surveys ( [ Ricker et al. 2016 ] ), about 20% of stars appear to host planets ( [ Zhu et al. 2018 , Bryson et al. 2021 , Boley et al. 2021 , Ment & Charbonneau, 2023 ] ). The variable n_{e} is the average number of planets in a stellar system. Our solar system hosts eight planets (or nine depending one’s feelings about Pluto, or whether the Planet Nine exists ( [ Brown et al. 2024 ] ). The remaining terms centre on the formation and evolution of life. The variable f_{L} is the fraction of planets that can support the formation of life, while the variable f_{I} is the fraction of systems that support life that will go on to evolve into intelligent life. The variable f_{C} is the fraction of systems that host intelligent life to evolve into advanced civilizations that build technologies that we might be able to detect. The final variable L is the length of time that those civilizations are detectable, either because the advanced civilization moves on from that detectable technology or the civilization ceases to exist. This one equation has motivated numerous studies and searches, but, we continue to be limited by our ability to estimate many of the terms in the Drake Equation. For instance, the presence of life has only been confirmed by western science to be on the Earth and we have yet to detect life on any other planet or satellite in the Solar System. As such, we can state that f_{L}>0 but nothing more. Likewise, there are similar issues with fractions of planets with intelligent life and with civilization. As such, attempting to compute a potential number of civilizations is largely an academic exercise and the value of the Drake Equation is reminding us of our ignorance of those terms. It should be noted, however, [ Hart, 1975 , Hart (1975)] argued that there can be no advanced civilizations in the Galaxy on the grounds that if they existed then at one of the civilizations would have visited the Earth at some point. This concept can be seen in the Drake Equation as the reduction of some of the fractions to a very small number. This view of a vary small number of civilizations continues today. 3 Indigenous Methodologies The view of the Drake Equation comes from a Western or Eurocentric view and that view creates biases in our understanding of SETI and how the astronomy considers searches for life and so-called technosignatures. Indigenous methodologies offer a different perspective on SETi because it is built on different ways of knowing and different core beliefs. The key “axioms” of Indigenous methods and Western Science are compared in Table 1 , building on the works of [ Cajete (2000) , Battiste (2013) , Lipe (2019) ] and others. Table 1: Overview of Indigenous ways of knowing versus Western Science. Western Science Indigenous Methods What is above reflects below Knowledge is objective Knowledge is relational Attempts to reduce to the smallest number of variables Considers multiple variables concurrently Knowledge is in disciplines Knowledge is (w)holistic Nature is hierarchic Nature is sacred and familial It must be noted that there is really no such thing as pan-Indigenous knowledges or methods. There can be Mi’kmaw knowledges, Salish knowledges, etc, but no pan-Indigenous methodologies. Instead, we consider that many of the different Indigenous methodologies and ways of knowing have these axioms in common. The concepts in Table 1 are significantly different from the methods of Western Science. The first concept of What is above reflects below is an acknowledgment that what is in the night sky is a reflection of the lands on which the peoples live . For instance, in Mi’kmak’i 1 1 1 The homeland of the Mi’kmaw people in what is now called eastern Canada and northeastern US and is the First Nation of the author , there is the constellation of Muin (Bear) and the Seven Bird