A Circle That Won’t Return: The Fate of RR Fluxes and D-branes in Type 0A Tachyon Condensation
Ahmed Rakin Kamal · 2026
Read A Circle That Won’t Return: The Fate of RR Fluxes and D-branes in Type 0A Tachyon Condensation by Ahmed Rakin Kamal (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26280.txt.
Introduction
Ahmed Rakin Kamal follows the fate of Ramond-Ramond fluxes as a circle shrinks out of existence in string theory. Type 0A string theory carries a doubled Ramond-Ramond sector, pictured in a proposed M-theory dual as two circles joined at a point. Tachyon condensation shrinks one circle, landing the theory at type IIA. Kamal derives the balance condition a tachyon stationary point must satisfy between the two branches. A branch-odd fluctuation emerges as the tachyon's source near a symmetric background.
Collapsing branches make their fluxes homeless. An unscreened source on the shrinking circle pays a field-energy cost that blows up as the circle vanishes. Infrared screening offers one escape, through a Stückelberg-style mechanism for the relative field. Discharge is another, when a thin wall makes dumping the charge energetically favourable. Standard brane couplings identify the carrier that such a discharge would use.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ahmed Rakin Kamal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26280
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Circle That Won’t Return: The Fate of RR Fluxes and D-branes in Type 0A Tachyon Condensation Ahmed Rakin Kamal Abstract We study the closed-string tachyon and doubled Ramond–Ramond sector of type 0A in light of the proposed M-theory description on S 1 ∨ S 1 S^{1}\vee S^{1} -the wedge of two circles joined at a point. In this picture the two RR copies are associated with the two circle components, which we call branches, and tachyon condensation corresponds to shrinking one branch to the type IIA endpoint. From the type 0A equations of motion, we derive the branch-balance condition for a tachyon stationary point and identify the branch-odd RR fluctuation that sources the tachyon around a symmetric background. We then analyze the fate of the collapsing branch RR data as one branch of the wedge collapses to the type IIA endpoint. For an isolated unscreened collapsing-branch D p − D_{p}^{-} source, a Gauss-law estimate shows that the long-range RR field-energy cost scales inversely with the shrinking circle and thus becoming infinitely costly, generalizing the D 0 − D0^{-} -brane decoupling in the original wedge picture. We describe the infrared screening of the relative RR field through an effective higher-form Stückelberg mechanism and distinguish this from a possible discharge of localized relative charge. Finally, using standard Wess–Zumino couplings of D-branes, we identify an effective relative-charge carrier and derive a parametric thin-wall criterion for when such a discharge channel D p − → D p + D_{p}^{-}\to D_{p}^{+} can be energetically favored. 1 Introduction Dualities have been one of the central reasons for string theory to emerge as a leading candidate for quantum gravity. The fact that apparently different perturbative theories can describe the same physics-for example through T-duality, where compactification on a circle of radius R is equivalent to compactification on a circle of radius \alpha^{\prime}/R , or through S-duality, where a strongly coupled description is mapped to a weakly coupled one has been one of the highlights of the superstring revolution. Historically, T-duality Buscher:1987qj ; Buscher:1987sk ; Giveon:1994fu alongside strong-weak coupling duality and its unification with T-duality into U-duality led to the modern picture in which the five ten-dimensional superstring theories are apparently different limits of a single underlying theory Font:1990nt ; Sen:1994fa ; Hull:1994ys ; Witten:1995ex . Dualities have since then become both a conceptual and calculational engine of string theory: they relate strongly coupled regimes to weakly coupled descriptions, clarify the role of D-branes as Ramond-Ramond charged objects, and underlie developments such as mirror symmetry, black-hole microstate counting, holographic gauge/gravity duality, and constraints the higher-derivative corrections to classical supergravity action Polchinski:1995mt ; Candelas:1990rm ; Strominger:1996sh ; Maldacena:1997re ; Hohm:2014eba ; Hsia:2024kpi ; Wulff:2021fhr ; Aggarwal:2025lxf ; Ameri:2025bei ; Wulff:2024ips . Furthermore, dualities also seem to help in the story-telling of the early universe Brandenberger:1988aj ; Veneziano:1991ek ; Meissner:1991zj ; Agrawal:2020xek ; Sen:1991zi . The situation has been far less complete for the non-supersymmetric strings. For example, Type 0A/0B and non-supersymmetric heterotic strings have been known for a long time Dixon:1986iz ; Seiberg:1986by ; Alvarez-Gaume:1986ghj . Perturbatively, type 0A on a circle of radius R is T-dual to type 0B on a circle of radius \alpha^{\prime}/R Bergman:1999km ; Meessen:2001cq . There were also early attempts to understand type 0 strings from an eleven-dimensional point of view, for example through M-theory on antiperiodic circle Bergman:1999km . However, these ingredients did not give a duality web as rigid as the supersymmetric one. The recent proposal of Baykara, Dudas and Vafa (BDV) Baykara:2026bdv gives a sharp new picture: type 0A is described by M-theory on the quantum wedge S^{1}\vee S^{1} , where different fields probe different effective resolutions of the singular space; the doubled RR sector is branch data, and the closed-string tachyon is the branch-odd radius mode. This has led to a rapidly growing non-supersymmetric duality program relating type 0 orientifolds, heterotic theories, bosonic strings, wedge singularities and cobordism junctions Baykara:2026web ; Altavista:2026brr ; Altavista:2026edv ; Altavista:2026evd ; Dasgupta:2026maq ; Basile:2026trt . Even with these dualities, the status of non-supersymmetric strings faces a basic difficulty: the simplest examples contain a closed-string tachyon. It is useful to contrast this with the open-string tachyon, whose physical meaning is much better understood. In Sen’s picture of open-string tachyon condensation, the tachyon on an unstable D-brane or on a brane–antibrane pair parametrizes the decay of the original brane system leaving just the closed-string vacuum Sen:1998tt ; Sen:1998sm ; Witten:1998cd ; Sen:2002nu ; Sen:2004nf ; Sen:1999xm . This led to the study of brane-antibrane potentials, and also motivated the brane-antibrane inflationary scenario, where the inter-brane separation plays the role of the inflaton and the final tachyonic instability ends inflation Burgess:2001fx ; Cicoli:2024bwq ; Chakraborty:2026hob . On the other hand, closed-string tachyons are more dangerous Adams:2001sv ; Adams:2005rb , since they signal an instability of the spacetime background itself. The BDV wedge proposal gives a concrete interpretation for the type 0A closed-string tachyon: it is the relative size of the two M-theory branches, and its condensation removes one RR branch by sending the corresponding KK/D0 tower to infinite mass. In this work we analyze the BDV picture from the type 0A point of view. Type 0A contains a doubled RR sector, and in the S^{1}\vee S^{1} interpretation these two copies are naturally associated with the two branches of the wedge. We first ask how these RR fields enter the tachyon equation of motion. This gives a local condition for when the tachyon can remain at the symmetric point, and shows explicitly how an imbalance between the two RR sectors can source the tachyon. We then turn to the proposed tachyon-condensation endpoint, where one branch of the wedge shrinks and the theory becomes ordinary type IIA on the surviving circle. Since type IIA has only one RR sector, any RR flux or D-brane charge associated with the disappearing branch must have a definite low-energy fate. We therefore study the energy cost of an isolated wrong-branch D_{p}^{-} source, describe how the corresponding relative RR field may be screened in the infrared, and distinguish this from the stronger possibility of discharge, in which the localized relative charge is transferred through an additional charge-carrying channel. The goal is to isolate, within the low-energy type 0A description, the constraints that any 0A\to IIA endpoint must satisfy for the doubled RR sector and its charged branes. To summarise, our results are (a) the tachyon equation gives a local branch-balance condition and around a Q -symmetric background, the Q -odd RR perturbation sources the tachyon but not the metric/dilaton at first order. (b) The electric wrong-branch charge has energy \mathcal{E}_{-}\sim 1/R_{-} and thus gives a way to decouple wrong branch branes. (c) An infinitely massive relative RR field screens long-range relative charge and hence only one of the RR sector appears in type IIA. (d) A WZ/DBI fluxed carrier has the correct relative charge for D_{p}^{-}\to D_{p}^{+} , and if a finite-tension wall exists, the thin-wall barrier is parametrically lowered as the branch collapses and thus makes such a transition energetically favourable. 2 Type 0A Type 0A string theory may be defined directly in the RNS formulation by replacing the supersymmetric type-II GSO projection with a non-supersymmetric one Dixon:1986iz ; Seiberg:1986by .