A Stellar Role Reversal: Multiple Features in the Mass and Mass Ratio Distributions of Merging Binary Black Holes from Stable Mass Transfer astropy ( 13 ; 11 ; 12 ; 27 ) , Jupyter ( 72 ; 49 ) , matplotlib ( 43 ) , numpy ( 41 ) , pandas ( 62 ; 70 ) , python ( 92 ) , scipy ( 100 ; 40 ) , cosmic ( 20 ; 28 ) , legwork ( 102 ; 101 ; 23 ) , seaborn ( 105 ) , tqdm ( 29 )
Gina Chen, Katelyn Breivik, Lieke van Son · 2026
Read A Stellar Role Reversal: Multiple Features in the Mass and Mass Ratio Distributions of Merging Binary Black Holes from Stable Mass Transfer astropy ( 13 ; 11 ; 12 ; 27 ) , Jupyter ( 72 ; 49 ) , matplotlib ( 43 ) , numpy ( 41 ) , pandas ( 62 ; 70 ) , python ( 92 ) , scipy ( 100 ; 40 ) , cosmic ( 20 ; 28 ) , legwork ( 102 ; 101 ; 23 ) , seaborn ( 105 ) , tqdm ( 29 ) by Gina Chen, Katelyn Breivik, Lieke van Son (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26262.txt.
Introduction
Gina Chen, Katelyn Breivik, and Lieke van Son trace how stable mass transfer sculpts the black hole pairs that gravitational wave detectors hear merging. One formation channel has a star steadily feeding its companion before both collapse. How much of the transferred mass is kept, and when transfer stays stable, decides the final masses. Analytic reasoning and population synthesis together map those choices onto observable distributions.
Role reversal splits the population in two. Under conservative transfer, pairs whose donor and accretor swap mass ranking form one subpopulation: heavy primary black holes at near-equal mass ratios. Pairs without reversal form the other: lighter primaries at uneven ratios. Stability rules at different life stages carve the two groups into separate peaks. Each assumption about transfer physics moves the peaks around. Detectors now flying, and near-future ones, may resolve the twin peaks and read the transfer physics back out.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gina Chen, Katelyn Breivik, Lieke van Son |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26262
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Stellar Role Reversal: Multiple Features in the Mass and Mass Ratio Distributions of Merging Binary Black Holes from Stable Mass Transfer astropy ( 13 ; 11 ; 12 ; 27 ) , Jupyter ( 72 ; 49 ) , matplotlib ( 43 ) , numpy ( 41 ) , pandas ( 62 ; 70 ) , python ( 92 ) , scipy ( 100 ; 40 ) , cosmic ( 20 ; 28 ) , legwork ( 102 ; 101 ; 23 ) , seaborn ( 105 ) , tqdm ( 29 ) Gina Chen, Katelyn Breivik, Lieke van Son Abstract Observations of gravitational wave events have enabled the measurement of the merging binary black hole (BBH) mass function. This mass function encodes the physical interactions which shape the formation and evolution of BBHs. In this work we investigate how the stable mass transfer (SMT) channel of BBH formation imprints onto the BBH primary mass and mass ratio distributions. We use both an analytic framework and binary population synthesis to show how assumptions about mass transfer accretion efficiency and mass transfer stability affect the BBH mass distribution. Under the assumption of conservative mass transfer, we find that the SMT channel produces two observationally distinct subpopulations: a high primary mass, near equal mass ratio population formed through mass ratio reversal (MRR), and a low primary mass non-MRR subpopulation. The mass range where MRR occurs is determined by assumptions about binary SMT. In particular, we find that the stability criteria for mass transfer at different stellar evolutionary stages carve out complementary regions in the primary-mass–mass-ratio plane, separating the MRR and non-MRR populations into distinct peaks at high and low primary mass respectively. Our results imply that the physics of SMT creates distinct features in gravitational wave populations which current and near future gravitational wave detectors may be able to resolve. I Introduction Gravitational waves were first detected from the merger of a binary black hole (BBH) just over a decade ago ( 2 ) . Since this discovery, the catalog of observed BBH mergers has grown to contain more than 130 events ( 3 ; 4 ; 6 ; 1 ; 88 ) . A wide range of masses have been discovered, with features in the mass distribution at 10M_{\odot} and 35M_{\odot} , and features in the mass ratio distribution are beginning to be resolved ( 5 ; 89 ; 90 ) . Despite this, the origins of these BBHs are still uncertain. Many channels have been proposed for BBH formation, which can be broadly categorized into isolated formation, where the BBH progenitor forms and evolves without external influences, and dynamical formation, where gravitational interactions or accretion disk dynamics can facilitate the merger of the BBH ( 56 ; 22 , see e.g.,) . Several studies have suggested that the observed population of BBH mergers contains multiple subpopulations which could indicate contributions from different formation channels ( 108 ; 86 ; 38 ; 14 ; 79 ; 80 ; 33 ) . However, the relative rates of each channel are difficult to ascertain due to large uncertainties in stellar evolution, binary interactions, and external influences, as well as degeneracies between the measurable properties of BBHs formed across different channels ( 109 ; 26 ) . Investigating each formation channel in detail across several parameters helps build understanding about which features of the BBH population formed are distinct to that channel and how each assumption influences those properties ( 94 ; 95 ) . The stellar components in wide binaries are expected to evolve without interacting with their companion, except in the case of external interactions with the galactic tide ( 85 ) or flybys ( 63 , e.g.,) , though the BBH merger rate from this channel is sensitive to assumptions for natal kicks imparted to BHs upon formation ( 78 , e.g.,) . At the closest separations, chemically homogeneous evolution of massive stars can arise due to tidal spinup in very short orbits, preventing the expansion of each stellar component, such that a BBH can form and merge within a Hubble time ( 58 ; 30 , e.g.,) . Most massive stars form in binaries where the stellar components interact through Roche-lobe overflow ( 81 , RLOF,) . The outcome of this RLOF can remain stable or become dynamically unstable based on the response of the stellar components or the binary orbit as mass is exchanged ( 42 ; 37 ; 47 ; 59 , e.g.,) . In this work we focus on the stable mass transfer only (SMT-only) channel of BBH formation, in which all RLOF phases during a binary’s evolution remain stable ( 91 ; 46 ; 93 ; 36 ; 18 ; 68 ; 74 ; 48 , e.g.,) . This excludes the classic CE channel, in which the first mass transfer is stable but the second is unstable ( 25 , e.g.) . A key uncertainty in the SMT-only channel is the mass transfer accretion efficiency. We denote this efficiency \beta , defined as the fraction of mass lost by the donor star that is accreted by its companion, the accretor. Observations of post mass transfer systems can provide constraints on the accretion efficiency ( 97 ; 15 ; 96 , e.g.,) . A common assumption is that the accreting star rapidly spins up to critical rotation ( 69 ) and then ceases accretion ( 71 ) . This yields highly non-conservative mass transfer for all wide systems in which tides are too weak to enforce synchronization. However, studies of observed post-interaction binaries span a wide range of inferred efficiencies from strongly non-conservative ( 73 ; 67 , e.g.,) , to accretion efficiencies greater than 50\% ( 52 , e.g.) . This motivates a broad agnostic exploration of how accretion efficiency shapes the resulting BBH population from the stable mass transfer channel. This paper is structured as follows. In Section II we describe how we simulate a population of BBHs. We describe the typical SMT-only BBH formation channel in Section III . In Section IV.1 , we show that the merging population of SMT-only BBHs can be clearly divided into two subpopulations across multiple observable characteristics. We discuss boundaries on these subpopulations, how those boundaries are affected by key binary evolution parameters, and how changing these parameters affects the BBH merger rate and mass distribution in Section IV.2 . We discuss our results and summarize our conclusions in Section VI . II Simulating a BBH merger population We use the binary population synthesis code cosmic to construct a merging BBH population observable by gravitational waves. First we simulate a catalog of BBHs assuming a single-age burst of star formation on a grid of metallicities. Then we apply a cosmic star formation history (SFH) which is based on fits to the IllustrisTNG simulation to construct a cosmological population of merging BBHs. In this section, we describe each of these steps in detail. II.1 Initializing a starburst population with cosmic cosmic 1 1 1 cosmic-popsynth.github.io is an open-source, Python-based binary population synthesis code that applies fitting formulae to single star evolution simulations following 44 and the binary evolution algorithm of 45 with updated treatment of binary interactions and