The Colored Hofstadter Butterfly as a Many-Body Quantum Hall Phase Diagram
Giovanna Marcelli, Tadahiro Miyao, Domenico Monaco, Stefan Teufel, Marius Wesle · 2026
Read The Colored Hofstadter Butterfly as a Many-Body Quantum Hall Phase Diagram by Giovanna Marcelli, Tadahiro Miyao, Domenico Monaco, Stefan Teufel, Marius Wesle (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26256.txt.
Introduction
Giovanna Marcelli and colleagues prove that the colored Hofstadter butterfly keeps its meaning when electrons interact weakly. The butterfly is a famous fractal picture of electrons in a magnetic field. Its colors label phases by an integer tied to Hall conductivity.
Starting from a spectral gap in the non-interacting system, they build a whole region of interaction strength, chemical potential, and magnetic field where the infinite system has a unique gapped ground state. Their gap-labeling theorem says the Hall conductivity stays constant and quantized across each such region, so the butterfly's integer colors label real interacting quantum Hall phases. This holds even at field values with no repeating unit cell.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Giovanna Marcelli, Tadahiro Miyao, Domenico Monaco, Stefan Teufel, Marius Wesle |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 128 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26256
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Colored Hofstadter Butterfly as a Many-Body Quantum Hall Phase Diagram Giovanna Marcelli, Tadahiro Miyao, Domenico Monaco, Stefan Teufel, Marius Wesle Abstract We prove that the colored Hofstadter butterfly has a many-body interpretation for a broad class of weakly interacting lattice fermion systems. Starting from a spectral gap of a Hofstadter-like one-particle Hamiltonian at arbitrary magnetic flux b b , we construct an open region in the three-dimensional parameter space ( b , μ , λ ) (b,\mu,\lambda) of magnetic field, chemical potential, and interaction strength on which the infinite-volume interacting system has locally unique gapped ground states. The construction combines quasi-adiabatic continuation in the interaction strength with denominator-independent magnetic perturbation estimates, and therefore covers both commensurate and incommensurate fluxes, where no finite magnetic unit cell exists. On connected uniformly gapped regions meeting the non-interacting plane λ = 0 \lambda=0 , we prove a many-body gap-labeling theorem: the Hall conductivity appearing in the macroscopic Ohm’s law is constant and quantized, satisfying 2 π σ H ∈ ℤ 2\pi\sigma^{\mathrm{H}}\in\mathbb{Z} . Thus the integer colors of the non-interacting Hofstadter butterfly persist as Hall-conductivity labels of interacting quantum Hall phases. 1 Introduction The colored Hofstadter butterfly is the paradigmatic phase diagram of the integer quantum Hall effect for non-interacting lattice electrons with one-body Hamiltonian \mathfrak{h}^{b} in a magnetic field b at chemical potential \mu . The phases are the connected components of \{(b,\mu)\in\mathbb{R}^{2}\;|\;\mu\notin\sigma(\mathfrak{h}^{b})\}, which are open sets as the map b\mapsto\sigma(\mathfrak{h}^{b}) is continuous in the Hausdorff metric. The color of such a component encodes an integer label 2\pi\sigma^{\mathrm{H}} , which for commensurate magnetic fields b\in 2\pi\mathbb{Q} can be computed as the Chern number of a complex vector bundle. The physical meaning of \sigma^{\mathrm{H}} is the Hall conductivity within that phase. The study of these and more general models for non-interacting electrons has led to deep and beautiful mathematics, drawing from spectral analysis, topology, non-commutative geometry, number theory, and dynamical systems theory. A longstanding and in parts still open problem is whether this labeled phase diagram retains a many-body meaning. This is far from obvious as interactions destroy large parts of the structures basic to the analysis in the non-interacting case. The question is whether the gapped regions nevertheless persist for interacting systems, and whether their integer labels still give the Hall conductivity appearing in a macroscopic Ohm’s law. We prove that the answer is positive for a broad class of Hofstadter-like lattice fermion systems on the lattice \mathbb{Z}^{2} with short-range interactions. More precisely, for every (b_{0},\mu_{0}) with \mu_{0}\notin\sigma(\mathfrak{h}^{b_{0}}) , we construct an open neighborhood in the three-dimensional parameter space (b,\mu,\lambda) of magnetic field, chemical potential, and interaction strength on which the interacting system has locally unique gapped ground states. On connected uniformly gapped regions meeting the non-interacting plane \lambda=0 , the macroscopic Hall conductivity is constant and satisfies 2\pi\sigma^{\mathrm{H}}\in\mathbb{Z} . A central difficulty, and one of the technical novelties of the paper, is that the magnetic field is treated as a real parameter. The fractal structure of the Hofstadter butterfly stems from the interplay between two spatial scales and the relevant dimensionless parameter is the magnetic flux per unit cell in units of the flux quantum, namely b/(2\pi) . If b/(2\pi)=p/q\in\mathbb{Q} , the system is periodic with respect to the sublattice \mathbb{Z}\times q\mathbb{Z}\subset\mathbb{Z}^{2} , while if b/(2\pi)\notin\mathbb{Q} , no finite magnetic unit cell exists. As a consequence, for b/(2\pi)\notin\mathbb{Q} no exact periodizations of the model on finite tori exist. To overcome this difficulty, we work directly in the infinite-volume CAR algebra \mathcal{A} and obtain estimates that are uniform in the denominators of rational approximants, allowing us to pass to arbitrary fluxes. Figure 1: The colored Hofstadter butterfly as a phase diagram for interacting systems. The colors in the b - \mu plane indicate the integer gap labels of the spectral gaps of the non-interacting model, \lambda=0 , cf. [ 39 , Fig. 1] . We prove that these gapped non-interacting regions persist for sufficiently weak interactions, \lambda\neq 0 , and that the macroscopic Hall conductivity is constant throughout the corresponding interacting gapped phases. This is indicated by the local extension of the phase near (b_{0},\mu_{0},0) into the interacting region \lambda\not=0 . More concretely, we study interacting fermionic tight-binding models in a magnetic field b\in\mathbb{R} , implemented through Peierls phases; we call these systems interacting Hofstadter-like models. We first prove stability of the gapped phases of the non-interacting models under sufficiently weak interactions and then establish a gap-labeling theorem for integer quantum Hall phases in terms of Hall-conductivity gap labels. Our results give the colored Hofstadter butterfly a many-body interpretation: its gapped regions persist as interacting gapped phases, and its integer colors become macroscopic Hall-conductivity labels, see Figure 1 . In each gapped phase connected to a Bloch--Landau level gap 1 1 1 We shall refer to the spectral islands obtained by the magnetic splitting of Bloch bands as Bloch–Landau levels . This terminology reflects the semiclassical picture: near a non-degenerate extremum of a Bloch band and at small magnetic field, these islands are the lattice analogues of continuum Landau levels, with effective mass determined by the curvature of the underlying Bloch dispersion. Unlike continuum Landau levels, however, they need not be flat; in the Hofstadter problem they are spectral islands separated by magnetic gaps. of the non-interacting model, a macroscopic Ohm’s law holds with a quantized Hall conductivity ( 2\pi\sigma^{\mathrm{H}}\in\mathbb{Z} ) that is constant throughout the phase. This extends known universality results for the Hall conductivity in several directions, most notably by treating b explicitly as a continuous parameter and by identifying the gap label with the proportionality constant in Ohm’s law for macroscopic currents, rather than merely with the associated linear-response coefficient. Technically, our work builds on [ 47 ] , where we established a macroscopic Ohm’s law for gapped lattice fermion systems in infinite volume and proved invariance of the Hall conductivity under locally generated automorphic equivalence. The present paper combines this with spectral stability of weakly interacting fermions [ 21 , 28 , 23 ] and with denominator-independent approximations of magnetic Hamiltonians. For fixed b , the interacting ground state is obtained from the non-interacting one by quasi-adiabatic continuation in \lambda . The dependence on b is handled instead through magnetic perturbation theory and rational approximants, rather than by constructing an automorphic evolution in the direction of varying magnetic field. Before turning to more technical details, let us recall that the non-interacting theory underlying the Hofstadter butterfly began 50 years ago and has led to deep developments in spectral theory, topology, and noncommutative geometry. The spectral study of discrete magnetic one-body Schrödinger operators began with Hofstadter’s observation [ 32 ] that the spectrum, plotted as a function of the magnetic field, displays a fractal structure. Shortly after the discovery of the integer quantum Hall effect [ 45 ] , the TKNN formula identified the linear-response Hall conductivity at rational flux with the Chern number of a vector bundle over the magnetic Brillouin torus [ 44 , 4 , 38 ] . The colors of the Hofstadter butterfly encode these integer Hall labels [ 20 , 39 ] ; this colored version and its interpretation as a phase diagram were emphasized in [ 39 ] . For irrational flux