Cluster vs Field: Clear Evidence for a Morphology-Density Relation in All Environments at z ∼ 1.6 z\sim 1.6 Journal: ApJ Source Extractor ( 8 ) , Grizli ( 12 ) , GALFIT ( 62 ; 63 )
Westley Brown, Adam Muzzin, Jasleen Matharu, Gillian Wilson, Julie Nantais, Ben Forrest, Ricardo Demarco, Allison Noble, Tracy Webb · 2026
Read Cluster vs Field: Clear Evidence for a Morphology-Density Relation in All Environments at z ∼ 1.6 z\sim 1.6 Journal: ApJ Source Extractor ( 8 ) , Grizli ( 12 ) , GALFIT ( 62 ; 63 ) by Westley Brown, Adam Muzzin, Jasleen Matharu, Gillian Wilson, Julie Nantais, Ben Forrest, Ricardo Demarco, Allison Noble, Tracy Webb (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26252.txt.
Introduction
Westley Brown and colleagues compare galaxy shapes in dense clusters and in the open field, at redshift near one point six. Three clusters from the SpARCS survey anchor the cluster side. Field galaxies come from the 3D-HST survey. Sérsic index, a measure of how concentrated a galaxy's light is, sorts the galaxies into disk-like, bulge-like, and in-between forms.
Crowding already shapes galaxies at that era. As local density rises, bulge-like galaxies grow commoner and disk-like ones rarer. The trend holds in clusters and in the field alike, with matching slopes. Mass pushes the same way: higher stellar mass means a higher Sérsic index on average. Most galaxies stay disk-like until a high mass threshold, reached sooner in clusters than in the field. A morphology-density relation was already in place that far back.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Westley Brown, Adam Muzzin, Jasleen Matharu, Gillian Wilson, Julie Nantais, Ben Forrest, Ricardo Demarco, Allison Noble, Tracy Webb |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26252
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cluster vs Field: Clear Evidence for a Morphology-Density Relation in All Environments at z ∼ 1.6 z\sim 1.6 Journal: ApJ Source Extractor ( 8 ) , Grizli ( 12 ) , GALFIT ( 62 ; 63 ) Westley Brown, Adam Muzzin, Jasleen Matharu, Gillian Wilson, Julie Nantais, Ben Forrest, Ricardo Demarco, Allison Noble, Tracy Webb Abstract We explore the relationship between galaxy structure, stellar mass, and local galaxy density in three SpARCS clusters at z ∼ 1.6 z\sim 1.6 and compare with field galaxies from the 3D-HST survey. Our cluster and field data include: 1) unprecedented multiband photometry, allowing for accurate stellar mass estimates; 2) extensive slit and grism spectroscopy targeting both star-forming and quiescent galaxies, allowing for high-accuracy local density measurements; and 3) deep imaging in F160W, allowing for accurate rest-frame optical morphologies. Using Sérsic index measured in rest-frame R-band, we classify galaxies as disk-like, bulge-like, and intermediate. Our sample includes 111 cluster galaxies and 458 field galaxies with reliable Sérsic measurements. We find that a morphology-density relation is already in-place in both cluster and field galaxies at z ∼ 1.6 z\sim 1.6 , such that as local density increases, the fraction of bulge-like galaxies increases and disk-like galaxies decreases. Both samples show similar positive trends between median Sérsic index and local density. Additionally, we find a general positive relationship between Sérsic index and stellar mass. The majority of galaxies remain disk-like until reaching stellar masses above 10 10.25 M ⊙ 10^{10.25}M_{\odot} in the cluster or 10 10.8 M ⊙ 10^{10.8}M_{\odot} in the field, however, we cannot conclude whether the differences in stellar mass trends are significant. Overall, our results show clear morphology-density and morphology-mass relations in place at z ∼ 1.6 z\sim 1.6 and oppose the idea that cluster-specific processes are solely responsible the morphology-density relation. Our data further suggest that the morphology-density relation may be independent of global environment at this epoch. I Introduction Morphology is one of the most striking features we can observe about the galaxies around us. For decades, astronomers have classified morphology using the Hubble sequence, separating galaxies into early-types such as elliptical and lenticular galaxies, and late-types such as spiral galaxies. While the Hubble sequence is based purely on visual appearance, morphology has been found to correlate with a range of galaxy properties, including stellar mass ( 40 ) , size ( 79 ) , color ( 24 ; 73 ; 16 ) , star formation rates ( 13 ; 7 ) , and star formation histories ( 73 ) . Morphology is also correlated with kinematic properties of galaxies such as rotational velocity ( 33 ) , angular momentum ( 37 ) , and velocity dispersion ( 26 ) . The relationship between morphology and local or global environments can also reveal clues about galaxy evolution. By studying visual morphology in 55 galaxy clusters in the nearby universe, 27 found the first evidence of the morphology-density relation: as local galaxy density increases, there is an increase in the fractions of both elliptical and lenticular galaxies and a decrease in the fraction of spiral galaxies. This general result has been discovered across many studies and clusters (e.g. 80 and 82 at z<0.1 ; 28 , 32 , and 34 up to z\sim 0.5 ; 66 and 72 up to z\sim 1 ) with many finding that the relation appears to flatten as redshift increases. The morphology-density relation has become a fundamental part of our understanding of galaxy clusters and environmental evolution, although questions still remain about how far into the cosmic past the relation can be found. Cosmic noon ( 1<z<3 ) is an important epoch in galaxy evolution, representing the peak of star formation in the universe, and the period where early-universe protoclusters begin to transform into present-day galaxy clusters. Studies such as 76 and 30 have made progress using self-consistent methods to measure the redshift evolution of the morphology-density relation, but their work remains limited to 0.2<z<1 and 0.25<z<1 , respectively. Few studies have explored the relationship between morphology and local galaxy density at z>1 (e.g. 68 ; 49 ; 74 ), and those that have suffer drawbacks such as limited photometric filter coverage, inconsistent rest-frame wavelengths, and uncertain stellar masses. Photometry limitations and lack of galaxy spectroscopy also means that many of these studies lack accurate galaxy redshift estimates, which reduces the ability to determine cluster membership and calculate accurate local galaxy densities. Visual classification of galaxy morphology also becomes more difficult at high redshift due to lower image resolution and surface brightness dimming, leading to greater uncertainty in classifications and difficulty distinguishing elliptical and S0 galaxies (e.g. 18 ). Visual classification has been standard for many years, even adapting to large volumes of data with large-scale citizen science projects such as Galaxy Zoo (e.g. 4 ). However, automated measurements of galaxy structure have gained popularity as quantitative alternatives to manual classification. Parametric techniques such as Sérsic profile fitting ( 69 ) and bulge-disk decomposition ( 70 ) , as well as non-parametric techniques such as concentration, asymmetry, smoothness/clumpiness (CAS; 20 ), and Gini-M 20 statistics ( 1 ; 46 ) , all offer benefits over visual classification methods in terms of efficiency, classification bias, and error estimation. It is common to use these measurements as proxies for visual morphological classification by assigning traditional classifications to specified values or locations in parameter space. However, quantitative techniques also offer an opportunity to study the full distribution of galaxy structure without relying on discrete categorizations (e.g. 68 ). At high- z , these techniques could be used to help us measure changes in galaxy structure independent of the low-redshift Hubble sequence. Among other remaining gaps in our knowledge are the role of local environment (e.g. local galaxy density) compared to global environment (e.g. clusters, groups, fields). As a phenomenon, the morphology-density relation has generally been associated with galaxy clusters, due to the degeneracy between local density and clustercentric radius in relaxed clusters ( 86 ; 85 ; 31 ; 82 ) . Despite this broad association, results from studies sampling galaxies across a wider range of environments support the idea that the morphology-density relation may extend beyond the cluster environment ( 67 ; 34 ; 4 ; 76 ; 30 ) . Using galaxy samples from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS), 34 suggest that the morphology-density relation may be driven by a two different mechanisms, which act separately on local and global scales. On the star formation end, 65 suggest that local effects may be more important than large-scale environment in determining the stellar properties of galaxies at fixed morphology and stellar mass. Investigating the impact of different global environments may provide a key to understanding the physical origins of the morphology-density relation. Galaxy stellar mass is another key factor to consider. Stellar mass is strongly correlated with a wide range of galaxy properties, including morphology ( 80 ; 81 ; 18 ; 30 ) . Previous studies have also found positive correlations between stellar mass and local galaxy density ( 4 ; 55 ) , leading to questions of whether the morphology-density relation may be driven by a more fundamental relation with galaxy stellar mass. Many studies