Labels
Mark Whitmeyer · 2026
Read Labels by Mark Whitmeyer (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26064.txt.
Introduction
Mark Whitmeyer, an economist, studies labels: grades, credentials, scores, and stars. Labels do two jobs at once. They inform whoever reads them. They also give people something costly to chase. His model makes an institution commit to a classification rule first. Agents then spend effort to land on the good side of the line. A receiver sees only the public label, nothing more.
Exact certification turns out wasteful. Certifying every fine difference forces heavy signalling costs for tiny decision gains. Pooling a small interval at the bottom saves first-order costs. The information lost is only higher-order by comparison. Whitmeyer gives conditions where lower censorship, hiding the bottom distinctions, maximizes efficiency. Other conditions guarantee that every optimal classification uses finitely many categories. The design question becomes which rungs of the ladder are worth building. Fewer, coarser rungs often beat a fine ladder once chasing costs count.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mark Whitmeyer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26064
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Labels Mark Whitmeyer Abstract Labels–grades, credentials, scores, ratings, ranks–do two things. They inform receivers, and they give agents something to chase. I study optimal classification when labels must be earned through costly self-selection. I show that exact certification is inefficiently fine: pooling a small bottom interval saves first-order signaling costs while losing only higher-order decision value. I provide sufficient conditions for lower censorship to maximize efficiency as well as for every optimal classification to use finitely many categories. 1 Introduction Societies make distinctions. Students receive grades. Workers acquire credentials. Borrowers receive credit scores. Restaurants receive stars. Platforms assign badges, follower counts, and verification marks. Journals, schools, firms, and people are ranked. These accolades are informative, but they are also prizes. Once a distinction matters, agents expend resources to be on the better side of it. I study the design of such labels. The institution first commits to a deterministic classification rule: which differences will be publicly certified, disclosed, or rewarded. Agents then choose costly actions to obtain the induced labels. A receiver observes only the public label. The usual vocabulary for these institutions is informational: a grade tells us how much a student learned, a credit score tells us how likely a borrower is to repay, a star rating tells us something about quality. That language misses half of the object–a public label also gives agents something to win . It changes what the receiver believes, but it also changes what the sender wants to prove. An institution that adds one more certified category is not only adding one more message to the receiver’s information set but one more rung to the ladder that agents climb. This paper asks which rungs are worth building. A sender has a private type, which is its quantile q\in[0,1] , and type q has quality x(q) , with x increasing. The receiver has a reduced-form payoff of r in her posterior mean of the sender’s quality, for which I only assume smoothness. The sender’s preferences are monotone: higher posterior means are more valuable, so if the institution certifies that one group is better than another, it must make the better certificate costly enough that lower types do not imitate it. The design problem is to decide which distinctions are worth sustaining, not how much information to reveal in the abstract. A designer chooses a deterministic certification technology, which maps actions into public certificates. I argue that in equilibrium, a certificate is payoff-relevant through two numbers: the posterior mean M(q) attached to the certificate obtained by type q , and the least action z(q) needed to obtain that certificate. Bayes-plausibility (that beliefs are a martingale) plus incentive compatibility allow me to reduce the problem of choosing an optimal classification to a choice of a monotone partition, which I term an admissible signal. With this in hand, I next derive a simple accounting formula. For any admissible signal M , I reveal in Section 3 that the least implementation cost of M can be naturally written in terms of the “price” of a category boundary. This is the mimicry pressure at the boundary multiplied by the private prize jump across it, and this price is the basic object in the paper. A boundary may be very useful to the receiver, or almost useless; it may create a large status prize, or a small one. The formula I derive in the proposition puts those two forces in the same units. The formula also immediately points to a simple improvement over full certification. Start from the system that certifies every type exactly. Now pool a small interval at the bottom and fully certify everyone above it. The receiver loses little from this change: the types being pooled are close together, so the loss from averaging their qualities is higher order. The signaling saving is much larger. Eliminating the first certified distinction relaxes the action requirements faced by a positive mass of higher types. In Theorem 4.1 , I make this comparison precise: under smoothness and positive entry stakes, bottom pooling saves first-order signaling cost while losing only higher-order receiver value. Reassuringly, I show in Section 5 that such bottom pooling improves upon full transparency provided the receiver’s payoff is continuous in her posterior belief. This paper is not meant to rediscover the broad fact that coarse or noisy communication can be valuable. That point has already been made in many forms. Coarse certification and grading can change who seeks certification, how much quality is produced, or how much information is acquired; 1 1 1 See, e.g., 19 , 1 , 6 , 32 , 17 , 24 , 10 , 4 , 31 , and 2 . signals are themselves be sold, priced, or packaged by intermediaries; 2 2 2 As in 26 , 20 , and 9 . Also related is signaling with commitment ( 8 ) , in which a sender commits ex ante to her costly signaling. noisy or mediated messages can relax communication constraints; 3 3 3 As studied by 5 , 16 , 27 , 30 , 25 , and 28 . scores, tests, and data-use rules can be designed to blunt manipulation, falsification, or distorted incentives; 4 4 4 As in 3 , 12 ; 13 , and 7 . and rank or status disclosures can change contest effort. 5 5 5 21 , 22 , 23 , 18 , and 15 are notable examples of this line of study. Nor is my aim to show that signaling is wasteful. 6 6 6 Nor to quantify this waste, as in 14 . My question is complementary: which public distinctions should survive when the institution can choose the classification rule? Instead, I show that a robust improvement upon full certification is to erase, or blur, the bottom rung. This result also lends Theorem 4.1 a costly-certification interpretation. After pooling [0,\varepsilon] , the institution can implement the outcome as a free default label plus a certified track. Types below \varepsilon take the default. To receive any label above the default, a sender must first take an entry action that makes the cutoff type indifferent between the default label and the first certified label. 7 7 7 This resembles disclosure models, in which disclosure, testing, or certification is (exogenously) costly. ( 29 ; 10 ; 31 ) . In this sense I endogenize the 29 -like threshold: the default label and the entry action are consequences of optimal classification. The next question is whether this bottom-rung repair is actually optimal (and not just an improvement on full transparency). Section 4.1 provides conditions under which it, indeed, constitutes the whole design. A sufficient condition is that mimicry pressure L is convex in quantile, receiver value r is convex in posterior mean, and sender stakes b are weakly concave in certified quality. Since L(1)=0 , convexity of L makes mimicry pressure fall in a disciplined way, and the sender-side term works in the same direction as the receiver-side convexity. Every noninitial pooled interval can then be opened up without lowering welfare. As a result, the only pooling that may be optimal is the initial one: a free default category followed by full certification above a cutoff, viz.