A one-parameter family of realizability-interior closures for odd-order kinetic moment systems

Somdeb Bandopadhyay · 2026

Read A one-parameter family of realizability-interior closures for odd-order kinetic moment systems by Somdeb Bandopadhyay (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-26032.txt.

Introduction

Somdeb Bandopadhyay works on moment closures for kinetic theory, where particle detail is compressed into averages. Closures at odd truncation order misbehave in a known way. The standard Gramian closure hugs the realizability boundary too tightly. Hyperbolicity, the property that keeps wave speeds real, comes out weak. Maxwellian equilibrium is not preserved.

Decomposition unlocks the analysis. Every odd-order closure splits into a boundary term plus a positive margin. The margin is the Schur complement of the Hankel moment matrix. An exact polynomial identity ties the margin to flux Jacobian eigenvalues. Hyperbolicity becomes a root-splitting question. A one-parameter family interpolates between two known closures. Its geometric end runs a few percent more accurate on bimodal tests. Its arithmetic end, the Morin-McDonald closure, gives the sturdiest profile. All members share an equilibrium Jacobian with a smaller spectral radius than Grad's closure, allowing larger time steps.

Catalog record

CREATORSomdeb Bandopadhyay
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE74 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26032

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A one-parameter family of realizability-interior closures for odd-order kinetic moment systems Somdeb Bandopadhyay Abstract Moment closures at odd truncation order present a fundamental difficulty: the standard Gramian closure saturates the realizability boundary, producing only weak hyperbolicity and failing to preserve Maxwellian equilibrium. We show that every odd-order closure for the one-dimensional kinetic equation decomposes into a boundary term, the Schur complement of the Hankel moment matrix, and a positive margin above it. An exact polynomial identity connects this margin to the eigenvalues of the flux Jacobian, reducing hyperbolicity to a root-splitting problem. A dimensional argument proves that no margin depending only on density, velocity, and temperature can produce a hyperbolic system for M ≥ 5 M\geq 5 . A one-parameter family C η , n C_{\eta,n} , η ∈ [ 0 , 1 ] \eta\in[0,1] , built from normalized Schur-complement ratios, reveals that the Morin-McDonald closure is the arithmetic endpoint of this decomposition. The weighted AM-GM inequality makes the accuracy-robustness tradeoff precise: the geometric endpoint ( η = 0 \eta=0 ) is 2-4% more accurate on bimodal benchmarks, while the arithmetic endpoint ( η = 1 \eta=1 , Morin-McDonald) provides the most robust hyperbolicity profile. All members share the same equilibrium Jacobian, whose spectral radius is 13% ( M = 5 M=5 ) to 29% ( M = 13 M=13 ) smaller than Grad’s closure, allowing larger CFL time steps. A linearized entropy exists at every tested order, and for a source-compatible choice of the symmetrizer weights, the BGK source dissipates it near equilibrium. A smooth nonlinear entropy exists for M = 3 M=3 but does not for M = 5 M=5 or M = 7 M=7 (certified by linear programming). The closure is validated on bimodal and Mott-Smith benchmarks, where the interpolated family achieves errors 10-40x smaller than the Gramian or Grad closures, and demonstrated in free-transport Riemann problems at M = 5 , 7 , 9 , 11 M=5,7,9,11 and BGK Riemann problems at M = 5 M=5 and 9 9 . I Introduction Moment methods approximate kinetic equations by evolving finitely many velocity moments instead of the full velocity distribution function Grad1949 ; Levermore1996 . The central difficulty is the closure problem: the evolution equation for the M th moment contains the (M+1) th moment, which must be expressed as a function of the retained moments u_{0},u_{1},\ldots,u_{M} . Classical closures include the Grad expansion around a local Maxwellian Grad1949 , which loses hyperbolicity away from equilibrium, and maximum-entropy closures Levermore1996 , which are globally hyperbolic but require iterative optimization and lack closed-form expressions for M>2 . The truncated Hamburger moment problem AkhiezerKrein ; Szego provides the mathematical framework for realizability of moment vectors on the full real line. For even truncation order M , the hyperbolic quadrature method of moments (HyQMOM) of Fox and Laurent FoxLaurent2022 provides a globally hyperbolic closure with a characteristic polynomial that factors into a product of two orthogonal polynomials with interlacing roots. The extended Gramian closure of Yilmaz, Oblapenko, and Torrilhon YilmazSIAM2026 is equivalent to HyQMOM and additionally preserves Gaussian equilibrium and gauge invariance for a specific parameter choice. For odd M , the situation is qualitatively different. The standard odd-order Gramian closure YilmazSIAM2026 produces a characteristic polynomial with n double roots, giving only weak hyperbolicity, and does not preserve Maxwellian equilibrium. The extended odd-order Gramian closure proposed in the same work was later shown by Habscheid Habscheid2026 to be non-hyperbolic. Morin and McDonald MorinMcDonald2025 constructed an odd- M closure with strong numerical evidence of hyperbolicity, using the Fox–Laurent recurrence framework with a specific choice of the recurrence coefficient \beta_{n} . Habscheid Habscheid2026 reformulated this closure in Gramian notation and proved its equilibrium preservation and gauge invariance. Separately, Pichard Pichard2020 ; Pichard2022 constructed closures by projecting moment vectors onto the boundary of the realizability domain, a different geometric approach that decomposes the vector into an equilibrium part and a singular boundary part. We show that the odd- M closure problem has a geometric structure that the constructions above use implicitly. Every odd moment closure decomposes into a boundary term, the Schur complement of the Hankel moment matrix, plus a positive margin above that boundary. An exact identity connects the margin’s moment derivatives to the characteristic polynomial of the closed flux Jacobian. The Gaussian equilibrium margin has the closed form \rho\,n!\,\theta^{n} , where \rho is the density, \theta the temperature, and n=(M+1)/2 . This framework places the Morin–McDonald closure MorinMcDonald2025 in a precise geometric context: it is the arithmetic endpoint of a one-parameter family, \eta\in[0,1] , built from normalized Schur-complement ratios. The weighted arithmetic-geometric mean inequality orders the family and explains why the Morin–McDonald closure provides the largest margin and the most robust among tested members, while the geometric endpoint ( \eta=0 ) provides the smallest margin and is slightly more accurate on the bimodal benchmark of Yilmaz et al. YilmazRGD2024 . The specific contributions are as follows: (1) We show that the gap between the Gaussian moment g_{2n} and its realizability lower bound is exactly \rho\,n!\,\theta^{n} , the squared norm of the monic Hermite polynomial under the Gaussian measure (Sec. IV ). (2) We derive an exact identity, P_{D}(\lambda)=p_{n}(\lambda)^{2}-\mathcal{D}(\lambda) , that decomposes the characteristic polynomial of any realizability-interior closure into the squared orthogonal polynomial minus the derivative polynomial of the margin, converting hyperbolicity into a polynomial root-splitting problem (Sec. V ). (3) We prove that no margin depending only on (\rho,v,\theta) can produce a hyperbolic system for M=5 : dimensional analysis fixes the equilibrium derivatives of every such margin, and the resulting characteristic polynomial has a negative \mu -root by Vieta’s formula. The same mechanism produces complex eigenvalues at M=7 and M=9 (verified numerically), explaining why closures must couple to higher-order moment features beyond the three macroscopic fields (Sec. V ). (4) We identify the Morin–McDonald closure as the arithmetic endpoint ( C_{1,n}=C_{\mathrm{MM},n} , exact identity) of a one-parameter family, \eta\in[0,1] , built from normalized Schur-complement ratios, giving it a geometric interpretation as the largest Schur-ratio margin above the realizability boundary (Sec. VII ). (5) We show that the weighted AM–GM inequality orders the family, D_{0}\leq D_{\eta}\leq D_{1} , explaining why the Morin–McDonald closure ( \eta=1 ) is the most robust member of the family, while the geometric endpoint ( \eta=0 ) provides the smallest margin and is 2–4% more accurate on the bimodal benchmark (Secs. VII – IX ). (6) We prove a Jacobian universality theorem: for closures of the form C=u_{2n}^{\min}+\gamma\,\Delta_{2n}^{\mathrm{eq}} with \gamma(G)=1 , the equilibrium Jacobian depends on the closure only through the covector \nabla\gamma\big|_{G} . The interpolated family has \eta -independent \nabla\gamma\big|_{G} matching the Morin–McDonald value, so all members share one equilibrium Jacobian (Sec. VII ). (7) We analyze the entropy structure: a linearized entropy with Vandermonde-diagonal symmetrizer exists at every tested order (through M=17 ), and for a source-compatible choice of the symmetrizer weights, the BGK source dissipates it near equilibrium (verified for M=3,5,7,9 ). A smooth nonlinear entropy exists for M=3 but does not exist for M=5 or M=7 , as certified by linear programming (Sec. VIII ). The closure family is validated on bimodal, Mott–Smith, and random-mixture benchmarks (Sec. IX ), and compared against the Gramian boundary closure and the Grad Hermite expansion closure, which

Read the complete text