Numerical thermalization in n n -D particle-in-cell simulations Preprint: AIP/123-QED

R. M. Park, C. H. Moore, S. D. Baalrud · 2026

Read Numerical thermalization in n n -D particle-in-cell simulations Preprint: AIP/123-QED by R. M. Park, C. H. Moore, S. D. Baalrud (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-25528.txt.

Introduction

Particle in cell simulations promise collisionless plasma physics, but their fat computational particles secretly collide far more than real ones do. R Park, C Moore, and S Baalrud measure that numerical thermalisation in 2026 across one, two, and three dimensional setups. The collision time is read from how fast velocity correlations decay in the simulation itself. Results are then compared with a classical kinetic theory by Okuda, Birdsall, and Langdon, varying grid spacing, plasma conditions, and dimensionality.

The old theory predicted the simulated collision times accurately in every regime tested. Particle shape softens the effect but cannot cancel the boost from heavy macroparticles. In three dimensions, reaching even the physical thermalisation time, let alone the collisionless ideal, may be impractical at resolutions that capture the shielding length. The work hands practitioners a formula for judging when numerical collisions corrupt their transport results.

Catalog record

CREATORR. M. Park, C. H. Moore, S. D. Baalrud
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.25528

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Numerical thermalization in n n -D particle-in-cell simulations Preprint: AIP/123-QED R. M. Park, C. H. Moore, S. D. Baalrud Abstract The particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation method is often understood to solve the collisionless Vlasov equation due to the finite shape of its macroparticles. In reality, it can suffer from artificially high collisionality due to the underresolution of particle number; i.e., the use of a large macroparticle weight. The degree to which particle shape effects compensate for a large macroparticle weight in 1D, 2D, and 3D is presented. The collision time is calculated from PIC simulations based on the decay rate of the velocity autocorrelation function and compared directly with the kinetic theory of Okuda, Birdsall, and Langdon. The theory is found to accurately predict the simulated collision time with varied grid spacings, plasma conditions, and simulation dimensionalities. The result is a means to predict the timescale of self-consistent Coulomb interactions in the PIC simulation and thus characterize the relevance and implications of numerical thermalization as a function of grid spacing and macroparticle weight. It is determined that reaching the physical thermalization time, let alone approximating the collisionless Vlasov limit, may often be intractable in 3D for macroparticle sizes that resolve the Debye length. I Introduction Particle-in-cell (PIC) is a popular simulation technique because it models the kinetic behavior of device-scale plasmas in a tractable way. 5 ; 16 This is possible because the introduction of a spatial grid allows for rapid solution of inter-particle forces and because each computational particle in a PIC simulation usually represents many physical particles. The interpolation of particle density to a grid gives PIC particles a finite width which is typically on the order of the Debye length. Since charge screening limits the Coulomb force in a plasma to roughly within a Debye length, it is often assumed that the inter-particle forces leading to Coulomb collisions are not resolved. It is usually expected on this basis that PIC provides a solution to the collisionless Vlasov kinetic equation as long as gradients are resolved by the grid. 52 ; 2 Collisions, if deemed necessary to include, are then implemented using a Monte Carlo collision routine. 46 ; 37 Here, we show that despite the weakening of inter-particle forces associated with grid interpolation, representing physical particles as macroparticles with an artificially scaled mass and charge amplifies these forces, and therefore numerical collisions, significantly. In higher dimensional simulations, it can be very challenging to achieve a numerical thermalization time \tau^{\text{num}} that is longer than the physical thermalization time. This presents a major impediment to achieving the correct transport in large-scale PIC simulations, particularly in 3D. These numerical collisions contribute to the wrong global evolution of the velocity distribution and thus affect principal quantities of interest (e.g., emission, breakdown, dissipation, particle loss, etc .) over timescales t\gtrsim\tau^{\text{num}} . A goal of the present work is to validate a theory for estimating \tau^{\text{num}} so that PIC users can develop constraints addressing numerical thermalization a priori . Knowledge of numerical thermalization in PIC simulations is not new. 5 ; 22 ; 6 ; 50 Hockney provided an empirical scaling for numerical collisions in 2D, 21 and this was recently elaborated on in 2D 27 and extended to 3D 26 by Jubin et al . Early work by Okuda, Birdsall 39 and Langdon 30 developed a kinetic theory of the PIC method, including a collision operator for shaped macroparticles interpolated to a grid. Here, the kinetic theory is shown to accurately predict the self-consistent Coulomb collision time in 1D, 2D and 3D PIC simulations. The primary influences on the collision time are the macroparticle shape, macroparticle weight, and the physical plasma parameter, N_{\mathrm{D}} . How these influence the overall collision time is shown to be directly related to an effective inter-particle force for PIC Coulomb interactions. The finite shape weakens and smooths the force, whereas the macroparticle weight amplifies it. By applying the kinetic theory to predict the numerical collision time, a range of common examples from previous literature are reviewed in the context of numerical thermalization. Figure 1: Characteristic regimes of the macroparticle weight and size in (a) 1D, (b) 2D, and (c) 3D. The contours obtained from kinetic theory (Eq. ( 43 )) show numerical thermalization time \tau^{\rm num} normalized by the physical thermalization time \tau^{\rm phys} . Here, the macroparticle size is half the grid width \Delta , corresponding to a top hat shape function of width \Delta=2R . Simulations with large macroparticle weights suffer from rapid numerical thermalization unless they smooth particle density gradients and forces over many Debye lengths. In this large R limit, numerical thermalization is reduced at the cost of arbitrarily weakening the mean (Vlasov) field at length scales shorter than the particle size. Eventually, further deformations to the particle shape would violate physical constraints on the spatial resolution of the grid, indicated by the purple “distorted field” region. Momentum-conserving PIC algorithms must prevent grid heating and cannot operate above R/\lambda_{\rm D}\gtrsim 1 (dotted line) unless a filter is used. The key numerical parameters influencing numerical thermalization are the shape function S\left(\bm{r}\right) , and the macroparticle weight W\equiv N_{\text{D}}/N_{\text{D}}^{\text{M}}. (1) Here, N_{\text{D}}\equiv n\lambda_{\text{D}}^{3} is the number of particles per Debye cube in the physical system being modeled, while N_{\text{D}}^{\text{M}}\equiv n^{\text{M}}\lambda_{\text{D}}^{d} is the number of macroparticles per Debye element in the d -dimensional simulation domain. In 3D N_{D}^{\textrm{M}} is the number of macroparticles per Debye cube, in 2D it is the number of macroparticles per Debye square, and in 1D the number of macroparticles per Debye length. The Debye length, \lambda_{\mathrm{\text{D}}}=\sqrt{\epsilon_{0}k_{\mathrm{B}}T/nq^{2}} , is the same in the physical and computational domains regardless of W or d . Given the same computational resources and a domain with characteristic length L>\lambda_{\mathrm{D}} , a much higher N_{\mathrm{D}}^{\textrm{M}} (and thus much lower W ) is accessible in the lower dimensions. In many codes, the weight is defined implicitly, where the user sets a physical density n\left(\bm{r}\right)\sim\left[\text{length}\right]^{-3} and number of macroparticles per grid cell N_{\mathrm{C}}^{\text{M}} . The weight is then determined from the above definitions by W=\frac{n\lambda_{\mathrm{D}}^{3}}{N_{\mathrm{C}}^{\text{M}}}\left(\frac{\Delta}{\lambda_{\mathrm{D}}}\right)^{d}, (2) where \Delta is the grid spacing. The shape function describes how each macroparticle will deposit its density onto the grid. During each field solve, the number assigned to the charge density at grid point \bm{g}\in\mathbb{Z}^{d} is \displaystyle\rho_{\bm{g}} \displaystyle=q^{\text{M}}\int\operatorname{d}\!^{d}r\ S\left(\bm{r}_{\bm{g}}-\bm{r}\right)\sum_{j}^{N}\delta^{\left(d\right)}\left(\bm{r}-\bm{r}_{j}\right) (3) \displaystyle=q^{\text{M}}\left\{S*n_{\delta}^{\text{M}}\right\}(\bm{r}_{\bm{g}}), where n_{\delta}^{\text{M}}\left(\bm{r}\right)=\sum_{j}^{N}\delta^{\left(d\right)}\left(\bm{r}-\bm{r}_{j}\right) is the microscopic distribution of macroparticles and q^{\text{M}} is their charge. This definition follows that of Birdsall & Langdon 5 and Hockney’s “assignment function shape”. 23 A summary of the weight and shape parameter space is presented in Fig. 1 . Contours for the ratio of numerical and physical collision times computed from kinetic theory 39 ; 30 show the permissible operating regime for a simple top hat shape function. The presence of a numerical collision time which is different than the physical collision time can be understood as the failure of the macroparticle to represent its physical constituents. Physical collision times can only be achieved in the region left of the black curves in the figure. In this region, numerical collisions can be made negligible, and the physical collision rate can be achieved by introducing a Monte Carlo collision routine. The effect of W in the limit of small particle

Read the complete text