A Red Teaming Framework for Large Language Models: A Case Study on Faithfulness Evaluation
Abrar Alotaibi, Raed Mughus, Moataz Ahmed · 2026
Read A Red Teaming Framework for Large Language Models: A Case Study on Faithfulness Evaluation by Abrar Alotaibi, Raed Mughus, Moataz Ahmed (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-25476.txt.
Introduction
Safety testing for language models works better when the tester is itself a team of models with opposed jobs. Abrar Alotaibi, Raed Mughus, and Moataz Ahmed build such a red teaming framework in 2026. Attacker models craft ever sharper adversarial prompts, and a target model answers them. Jury models then grade the answers for accuracy and consistency. A case study aims the machinery at faithfulness, whether a response stays true to its source material and itself.
Exploitative prompts raised attack success on question answering by up to about eight percent, exposing real reliability gaps. Format limits in summarisation tasks, by contrast, measurably improved faithfulness, suggesting design choices matter more than raw model size for safety. The framework adapts across tasks and languages, from English questions to Arabic summaries, though subtle unfaithfulness without outright contradiction still slips past.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abrar Alotaibi, Raed Mughus, Moataz Ahmed |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.25476
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Red Teaming Framework for Large Language Models: A Case Study on Faithfulness Evaluation Abrar Alotaibi, Raed Mughus, Moataz Ahmed Abstract Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across a wide range of natural language processing tasks, yet their deployment in high-stakes applications has raised critical concerns regarding reliability, safety, and response trustworthiness. In this paper, we present a red teaming framework that systematically uncovers vulnerabilities in LLM outputs. Our approach employs a novel multi-role architecture comprising a target, attackers, and jury models. The attackers generate increasingly effective adversarial prompts while the jury rigorously evaluates response accuracy and consistency across tasks. In a case study, our red teaming strategy proved particularly effective at exposing unfaithfulness in LLM responses. Exploitative adversarial prompts increased the attack success rate by up to 7.9% in question-answering tasks, revealing vulnerabilities in the LLMs’ reliability. The approach successfully identifies how structural constraints in summarization tasks can significantly influence vulnerability patterns, with format limitations demonstrating measurable improvements in model faithfulness. It demonstrates that architectural design choices typically outweigh parameter scaling in determining model safety. The framework’s key strength lies in its adaptability across different evaluation tasks, from English question-answering to Arabic summarization, enabling comprehensive comparison of model vulnerabilities. While our approach excels at comparing cross-model and cross-linguistic vulnerabilities, it faces challenges in fully automating the generation of effective adversarial prompts across different languages. Moreover, our experiments also reveal limitations in detecting certain subtle forms of unfaithfulness that do not manifest as explicit factual contradictions, particularly when working across different linguistic contexts. Overall, this red teaming architecture provides both actionable insights into current LLM vulnerabilities and a scalable methodology for ongoing safety evaluation as models continue to evolve. keywords Large Language Models, Red Team Evaluation, Faithfulness Assessment, Cross-Lingual Testing, Automated Safety Testing 1 Introduction Large language models (LLMs) have transformed natural language processing (NLP), achieving unprecedented performance across tasks by leveraging transformer-based architectures trained on vast text corpora 1 ; 5 . Models such as GPT-4 and DeepSeek are increasingly integrated into real-world applications, spanning domains such as healthcare, finance, and legal services. However, their deployment at scale brings forth significant challenges concerning safety, reliability, and robustness 74 . To address these challenges, Red Teaming has become an essential practice for identifying vulnerabilities in LLMs. Originally derived from military simulations and cybersecurity, Red Teaming in this context refers to the deliberate, adversarial testing of LLMs by crafting inputs that push these systems toward generating harmful, biased, or otherwise undesirable outputs 58 . This process involves both human expertise using creative “jailbreaking” prompts and automated systems that generate large-scale test cases for systematic probing 16 . By exposing latent vulnerabilities, red teaming enables organizations to strengthen their models’ resilience before widespread deployment. Among the multifaceted risks associated with LLM vulnerabilities—including harmful content generation 20 , sensitive data exposure 7 , and system integrity compromise 16 —the issue of unfaithfulness in outputs is particularly pressing 77 . This phenomenon, where models produce plausible but fabricated information, is especially critical in question-answering and summarization tasks 19 ; 86 . We focus specifically on context-bound unfaithfulness, where the model’s response deviates from provided source material 27 . It is important to distinguish between two related but fundamentally different categories of LLM vulnerability that our framework addresses. As noted in a recent comprehensive review of LLM red teaming 27 , the landscape of LLM vulnerabilities spans a heterogeneous set of risks that are often conflated in the literature despite requiring distinct evaluation methodologies. Factual unfaithfulness refers to the generation of content that contradicts or fabricates information relative to provided source material—a concern primarily in Q&A and summarization tasks. Safety alignment failures , in contrast, involve the generation of harmful, offensive, or policy-violating content regardless of source material. While both vulnerability types benefit from adversarial red teaming, they require distinct evaluation criteria and mitigation strategies, as we detail in our task-specific experimental designs (Sections 4 – 6 ). The challenge is amplified in multilingual contexts, where models must navigate linguistic variations and cultural nuances 42 . Arabic-English language pairs pose unique challenges due to structural differences, increasing unfaithfulness risk 3 . Recent research has identified diverse attack vectors—prompt injection 45 , data poisoning 36 , model extraction 34 , and jailbreaking 46 —underscoring the need for robust multilingual evaluation frameworks 72 . 1.1 Our Contributions While existing red teaming frameworks have made significant progress, they face critical limitations in scalability, cross-linguistic evaluation, and understanding of architectural impacts on vulnerabilities. Our work addresses these gaps through: 1. Novel Multi-Role Red Teaming Architecture : A tripartite system with attacker, target, and jury LLMs operating in coordinated evaluation with strict information flow controls—advancing beyond single-role approaches. Unlike approaches that rely on a single strong LLM with carefully designed prompts, our structured multi-role design enforces component independence (preventing feedback loops that inflate attack success rates) and enables ensemble evaluation with quantitative reliability metrics—capabilities that a single-model setup cannot provide (see Section 3 for detailed justification). 2. Automated Ensemble Evaluation : Multiple LLMs with consensus mechanisms (majority voting, unanimous agreement) and quantitative inter-judge reliability metrics (Fleiss’ kappa), eliminating human evaluation bottlenecks. 3. Cross-Linguistic Vulnerability Analysis : Structured evaluation revealing Arabic processing exhibits consistently higher vulnerability rates than English across Q&A and summarization tasks. 4. Task-Adaptable, Modular Framework : The framework is modular in the sense that its core components—attacker, target, and jury—can be instantiated by any LLM, and its evaluation protocols can be adapted to diverse vulnerability types. Unified metrics effectively evaluate vulnerabilities ranging from factual unfaithfulness to harmful content generation through task-specific adaptations of the core evaluation criteria and attacker strategies, while the multi-role architecture and ensemble jury remain constant. 5. Architectural Design Observations : Empirical evidence from 24,000+ model interactions suggesting that, within the model families tested, architectural design choices appear to outweigh parameter scaling in determining model safety—a pattern warranting further investigation with controlled experiments. 6. Actionable Mitigation Strategies : Simple structural constraints (e.g., length limitations) reduce unfaithfulness by up to 30% without model retraining. This multifaceted approach provides both theoretical insights and practical deployment strategies for developing safer, more trustworthy multilingual language models across diverse applications. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews related work. Section 3 presents our red-teaming framework. Sections 4 and 5 explore unfaithfulness in Q&A and summarization tasks. Section 6 investigates harmful content generation. Section 7 synthesizes cross-task findings. Section 8 discusses validity threats. Section 9 presents conclusions, and Section 10 outlines future directions. 2 Related Work The increasing deployment of LLMs in critical applications necessitates comprehensive evaluation of their security vulnerabilities. We review relevant literature across four key areas: security and robustness, response faithfulness, attack methodologies, and identify research gaps our framework addresses. Table 1 summarizes how our approach advances beyond existing red teaming frameworks. In the following subsections, we explicitly compare and contrast our approach with each category of prior work, highlighting specific dimensions where our framework provides novel capabilities. Table 1: Comparison of LLM Red Teaming Frameworks Framework Multi-Role Automated Cross- No Human Ensemble Task- Architecture Evaluation Linguistic Labels Jury Adaptable Perez et al. 58 ✗ Partial ✗ ✗ ✗ ✗ GARAK 16 ✗ ✓ ✗ Partial ✗ ✓ AutoDAN 87 ✗