Competitive satellite placement and the geography of orbital risk: evidence from the geostationary arc
Akhil Rao, Nikodem Szumilo · 2026
Read Competitive satellite placement and the geography of orbital risk: evidence from the geostationary arc by Akhil Rao, Nikodem Szumilo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-25283.txt.
Introduction
Along the geostationary ring, some longitudes are packed with satellites while others sit empty. Akhil Rao and Nikodem Szumilo explain that pattern in 2026 with a simple model of competitive entry, using the complete international registry of filings. Each slot's value depends on the population beneath it, and operators claim positions first come, first served. The model was tested both on the overall map and on predicting individual choices over time.
The model reproduced the observed spread of active satellites well, and beat a standard statistical choice model at forecasting which slots operators picked. It also predicted where inactive payloads drift, tying future debris risk to launch decisions. Today's layout proved surprisingly fair, favouring population over national income, though that fairness holds only for mature slots.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Akhil Rao, Nikodem Szumilo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.25283
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Competitive satellite placement and the geography of orbital risk: evidence from the geostationary arc Akhil Rao, Nikodem Szumilo Abstract Some orbital locations are crowded while others remain unoccupied. We explain why using the geostationary orbit as a near-ideal laboratory: a mature, one-dimensional orbit in which satellite operators compete for position under first-come first-served allocation rules. Using the complete ITU registry and a simple competitive entry model, we predict the observed distribution of active GEO satellites with R 2 = 0.64 R^{2}=0.64 . In walk-forward tests, the structural model also predicts individual slot choices out of sample better than a fitted conditional-logit discrete-choice model. Our model also predicts the distribution of inactive payloads in GEO with R 2 = 0.44 R^{2}=0.44 , showing that the geography of debris risk can be predicted when it is a function of satellite launches. Surprisingly, we find that the current satellite distribution in GEO is relatively fair: driven by population rather than income and placing satellites in economically efficient locations. However, our model shows that this is only the case for mature slots. 1 Introduction Some orbital locations are crowded while others remain empty. This is one of the most visible spatial patterns in space infrastructure, and one of the most consequential. In geostationary orbit, satellites cluster densely at some longitudes while large stretches of the same orbital ring remain lightly occupied. Understanding why this happens matters for slot allocation, spectrum coordination, and global communications coverage. It also matters for space sustainability, because debris accumulates as a result of satellite placements. If we can explain the geography of satellite deployment, we can begin to explain the geography of long-run orbital risk as well. We study this question in geostationary orbit, a near-ideal laboratory for observing competitive location choice. GEO is physically one-dimensional: each longitude corresponds to a different footprint on Earth, and the value of that footprint depends on who lives below. The observed pattern is stark. Above Asia, Europe, and the Americas, multiple operators stack satellites at the same longitude. Above the central Pacific, sub-Saharan Africa, and Central Asia, the same ring remains comparatively empty. These are high-stakes decisions, made under ITU allocation rules and involving years of coordination and hundreds of millions of dollars per satellite. Existing discussions of orbital debris usually begin after launch, with engineering models of collision, operation, disposal, and end-of-life behaviour. Those models are indispensable. But they leave open a prior question: how much of the future geography of congestion and debris is already encoded in where operators choose to locate in the first place? In GEO, that question can be tested directly. If competitive dynamics determine where active satellites concentrate, and inactive payloads accumulate where active satellites were placed, then a model of competitive entry should also contain information about the later distribution of debris. Existing models of the future orbital environment often project traffic from history rather than from a model of competitive placement—for example by repeating recent launches or extrapolating historical trends in launch traffic, explosions, and disposal practices ( 6 , 2 ) . We argue that this pattern is governed by a simple logic of sequential competitive entry. On a one-dimensional orbit, operators position satellites to maximise market share under the ITU’s first-come, first-served allocation rules. Each entrant picks the slot that offers the largest share of unclaimed demand given the positions already taken. The result is path-dependent clustering: the earliest entrants lock in the highest-demand longitudes, and later entrants pile into the same crowded arcs because even a fractional share of a large market exceeds a full share of a thin one. GEO provides an unusually clean setting in which to test this mechanism because both the allocation rules and the spatial outcome are directly observable. Using the ITU Compliance Assessment Monitor database, we show that a simple competitive entry model derived from GEO’s allocation rules—and using population as the driver of demand for satellite services—predicts the observed distribution of active satellites with R^{2}=0.64 . It reproduces the dense clusters above South and Southeast Asia, Europe, and the Americas, and the sparse coverage above the central Pacific and equatorial Africa. It also outperforms an income-based alternative: replacing population demand with GDP-weighted demand (also under competitive entry) reduces fit to R^{2}=0.11 . In walk-forward out-of-sample tests, the structural model predicts individual slot choices better than several specifications of a fitted conditional logit. In a 21-year forward simulation ( N=400 genuine new entrants, 2000–2021), the model achieves R^{2}=0.35 against a naive persistence baseline of R^{2}=0.09 , a fourfold improvement with no parameters fitted to slot-choice data. The same model also predicts the distribution of inactive payloads with R^{2}=0.44 , showing that a major orbital-risk pattern often treated as an engineering problem is partly downstream of the geography of entry itself. The paper’s contribution goes beyond validating a model. We show that the uneven geography of orbital infrastructure is predictable from economic fundamentals, population geography, and physical constraints, and that this predictive power extends to the geography of debris accumulation. We demonstrate this in GEO, where the distribution of both active satellites and inactive payloads can be predicted by a model of competitive entry with no parameters fitted to slot-choice data. The broader implication is that wherever satellite deployment generates future debris, the spatial distribution of orbital risk will partly reflect the spatial pattern of competitive entry. 2 Results 2.1 A competitive entry model of orbital location Figure 1: The sequential entry mechanism in GEO. Each satellite (top) serves the consumers (bottom) for whom it is the nearest provider. Left: an isolated satellite captures its full market. Centre: a new entrant co-locates near an incumbent, splitting the market. Right: the entrant could capture a larger share by locating in an underserved region—but the profit-maximising logic pushes it toward the demand peak instead, because moving to the periphery would allow incumbent competitors to absorb its former market share. We model the geostationary belt as a ring of 360 positions, one per degree of longitude. From each position, a satellite serves the consumers within roughly 40^{\circ} on either side---the effective commercial footprint of a GEO broadcast satellite---with each consumer’s demand going to the nearest satellite. 1 1 1 Sensitivity to \pm 45^{\circ} and \pm 60^{\circ} footprints is reported in Appendix G ; the fit is unchanged ( R^{2}=0.64 in all cases). The value of a position therefore depends on who lives within its footprint and how many competing satellites share it. Demand at each longitude is measured by gridded population ( 1 , GPWv4) . Under the ITU’s first-come, first-served system, we model entry as a profit-maximising sequential process: each new operator picks the slot that maximises its own market share given the positions already occupied. This process produces co-location—multiple satellites at the same longitude—through a simple path-dependent logic. The first entrant takes the highest-demand slot. Subsequent entrants face a trade-off: move to a less crowded but lower-demand location, or co-locate at a busy arc where demand is large enough to be shared. High-demand arcs attract entrant after entrant until the marginal gain from co-locating there falls below the payoff at the best remaining empty slot. Clustering is therefore the outcome of FCFS entry under heterogeneous demand, not