Proactive Systems in HCI and AI: Concepts, Challenges, and Opportunities Conference: Graphics Interface 2026; June 9–12, 2026; Waterloo, ON, Canada Graphics Interface 2026 (GI ’26), June 9–12, 2026, Waterloo, ON, Canada CCS: Human-centered computing Natural language interfaces
Nima Zargham, Sharon Ferguson, Jaisie Sin, Cosmin Munteanu, Anastasia Kuzminykh · 2026
Read Proactive Systems in HCI and AI: Concepts, Challenges, and Opportunities Conference: Graphics Interface 2026; June 9–12, 2026; Waterloo, ON, Canada Graphics Interface 2026 (GI ’26), June 9–12, 2026, Waterloo, ON, Canada CCS: Human-centered computing Natural language interfaces by Nima Zargham, Sharon Ferguson, Jaisie Sin, Cosmin Munteanu, Anastasia Kuzminykh (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2606-25149.txt.
Introduction
Systems that act before being asked are spreading fast, from lighting that adapts to activity to robots that plan ahead. Nima Zargham and four colleagues, writing for a Graphics Interface 2026 workshop, argue that proactivity itself is still loosely defined and unevenly used across research and practice.
Simple reminders and recommendation tools are routinely labelled proactive. Their mechanisms and aims differ sharply from systems that take real initiative. Design and evaluation methods, built for reactive interaction, miss what makes proactive behaviour hard: timing, appropriateness, user control, transparency, and trust. The workshop gathers researchers and practitioners across human computer interaction and AI to give the concept a firmer footing. On shared terms, proactive systems can then be designed, compared, and judged.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nima Zargham, Sharon Ferguson, Jaisie Sin, Cosmin Munteanu, Anastasia Kuzminykh |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 15 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.25149
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Proactive Systems in HCI and AI: Concepts, Challenges, and Opportunities Conference: Graphics Interface 2026; June 9–12, 2026; Waterloo, ON, Canada Graphics Interface 2026 (GI ’26), June 9–12, 2026, Waterloo, ON, Canada CCS: Human-centered computing Natural language interfaces Nima Zargham, Sharon Ferguson, Jaisie Sin, Cosmin Munteanu, Anastasia Kuzminykh Abstract . The last few years have seen a significant rise in interest in highly autonomous and proactive systems, fueled by advances in AI. Systems that anticipate user needs, take initiative, and act without explicit user input. Such systems span a wide range of applications, from smart lighting that adapts to user activity to assistive robots that plan actions in advance to intelligent thermostats that learn routines and adjust environments proactively. Despite this breadth, the concept of proactivity remains loosely defined and inconsistently applied across research and practice. Current usage of the term often conflates fundamentally different system behaviors. For instance, simple reminders or recommendation systems are frequently labeled as proactive, even though underlying mechanisms and intentions differ significantly. This conceptual ambiguity limits our ability to systematically design, compare, and evaluate proactive systems. Moreover, existing methodologies for design and evaluation are largely rooted in reactive interaction paradigms, failing to address the unique challenges posed by proactive behavior, including timing, appropriateness, user control, transparency, and trust. This multidisciplinary workshop aims to establish a clearer and more rigorous foundation for understanding proactive systems. We bring together researchers and practitioners from Human-Computer Interaction, AI, and related fields to (1) develop a shared conceptualization of proactivity, (2) identify gaps and limitations in current design and evaluation approaches, and (3) co-create human-centered guidelines and research directions for future systems. Through interactive discussions and collaborative activities, the workshop seeks to map key challenges and opportunities, ultimately advancing robust and consistent frameworks for designing and evaluating proactive technologies. 1. Motivation & Goals In recent years, there has been a surge of interest in autonomous and proactive systems, driven by advances in artificial intelligence (AI), natural language processing (NLP), and sensing technologies. Unlike traditional reactive systems, proactive systems anticipate user needs, take initiative, and act without explicit instructions. Such systems span a wide range of applications, including smart homes ( 32 ; 33 ) , assistive robotics ( 6 ; 24 ) , in-car assistants ( 14 ) , health and wellbeing ( 19 ; 26 ) , and education ( 16 ; 15 ) . For instance, navigation systems can suggest optimal routes before congestion occurs, fitness wearables can recommend activity adjustments based on user state, and productivity tools can anticipate scheduling conflicts or suggest task priorities. Emerging AI tools such as GitHub Copilot and Google Gemini further illustrate the growing role of proactive agents in both personal and professional contexts ( 18 ) . These systems present both exciting opportunities and significant challenges ( 4 ; 23 ; 33 ) . While the potential of proactive agents is vast, ranging from increasing perceived helpfulness to improving task efficiency and calibrating trust ( 25 ; 17 ; 29 ) , there remains a critical gap in established guidelines and best practices for their human-centric design and evaluation. This starts with the description of the concept itself. Despite growing interest, the concept of proactivity remains loosely defined, conceptually imprecise, and inconsistently applied. Systems that send reminders or recommend content are often labeled proactive, even though their underlying mechanisms and intentions differ fundamentally from systems that genuinely anticipate and act on user goals. This ambiguity hampers our ability to systematically design, compare, and evaluate proactive systems. Existing design and evaluation methods are largely inherited from reactive paradigms and fail to capture critical aspects of proactive behavior, including timing, appropriateness, user control, transparency, and trust. From organizational psychology, proactivity is defined as self-initiated, future-oriented, and change-oriented behavior aimed at improving situations or preventing problems ( 7 ; 11 ) . These definitions emphasize several key characteristics, including the anticipation of future states, goal-directed action, and persistence in shaping outcomes. Notably, proactivity in this tradition is not merely about acting independently, but about intentionally influencing future conditions. However, research and practice often focus on superficial manifestations of system initiation, such as suggestions or prompts, rather than on the underlying capabilities that enable effective proactive behavior. Moreover, current evaluation methods are primarily designed for reactive systems and fall short in addressing the unique demands of proactive system interactions. Commonly used tools such as the System Usability Scale (SUS) ( 5 ) and the User Experience Questionnaire (UEQ) ( 28 ) , while often applied to proactive systems, have been validated only in reactive contexts. Consequently, they do not account for the nuances of proactive interactions, including autonomous decision-making and action execution. Aspects such as the appropriateness of interaction and the timing of proactive behavior initiation, the perceived alignment of system actions with user goals, and the user’s sense of control and consent over unsolicited system actions are often overlooked. Similarly, measures of social implications, such as perceived human-computer trust, rely on scales developed for reactive GUIs and are therefore of limited applicability ( 20 ) . For proactive systems, trust may also depend on factors such as the system’s ability to justify its actions, predictability of autonomous behavior, and the extent to which users feel comfortable delegating initiative to the system. The design of proactive systems also presents distinct challenges. Expectations of proactive behavior vary widely across application domains and user characteristics ( 22 ) . Users typically prefer to retain control, favoring initially low levels of proactivity that can increase with familiarity ( 12 ) . While early design principles, building on mixed-initiative interaction ( 13 ) , highlight qualities such as value, relevance, competence, controllability, transparency, and safety ( 30 ) , existing human-computer interaction (HCI) guidelines only marginally address proactivity ( 2 ; 18 ) . This points to a broader lack of standardized approaches for designing and evaluating proactive AI systems ( 4 ) . This multidisciplinary workshop seeks to address these conceptual and methodological gaps by bringing together researchers and practitioners from HCI, AI, and related fields. Our workshop has the following objectives: • Develop a shared conceptualization of what constitutes proactive behavior, and how it differs from related concepts such as autonomy, automation, and system-initiated interaction. • Explore the design space of proactive systems to identify key dimensions, challenges, and contextual factors that shape how proactive behavior is designed, experienced, and perceived across domains. • Establish principles, guidelines, and evaluation strategies that account for the unique challenges of proactive systems, including timing, transparency, user control, and trust. Through collaborative discussions, scenario-based activities, and interactive knowledge sharing, the workshop aims to clarify the conceptual landscape of proactivity, highlight open research questions, and map practical opportunities for designing and evaluating proactive systems. 2. Organisers The workshop is organised by leading researchers and practitioners from the fields of HCI and conversational user interfaces (CUIs). Multiple successful workshops were held between the organizers at HCI conferences, such as CHI ( 9 ) , HRI ( 21 ; 27 ) , IUI ( 18 ) , IVA ( 1 ) , CUI ( 3 ; 10 ; 8 ) , and MUM ( 31 ) . Nima Zargham is a postdoctoral researcher at the